Kostub Investments Limited v. Reinz Talbros Limited

Delhi High Court · 31 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:321
Vipin Sanghi
Co. Appl. No.79/2008 in Co. Pet. No.222/2001
2008:DHC:321
corporate petition_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld the validity of a court-conducted auction sale by the Provisional Official Liquidator under the Companies Act, dismissing claims of undervaluation and lack of authority.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Co. Appl. No.79/2008 in Co. Pet. No.222/2001
Date of order: January 31, 2008 Kostub Investments Limited ..... Petitioner
Through: Mr.Sandeep Arya, Advocate
VERSUS
Reinz Talbros Limited ..... Respondent
Through: Mr. Bhuvan Gugnani, Adv. for the respondent/applicant
Mr.Mayank Goel, Adv. for the Official Liquidator.
Mr.A.K.Chaturvedi,Official Liquidator Mr. R.P. Aggarwal, Adv. for
Bank of Baroda.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
JUDGMENT

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? VIPIN SANGHI, J.

1. The O.L. was appointed as Provisional Liquidator in this case on 25th February 2002. This is an application filed by the Ex. Managing Director of the Company for seeking, inter-alia, the relief of setting aside the sale of the property of the Company in liquidation, which has been confirmed by this court, following the invitation of Co. Pet. No. 222/2001 2008:DHC:321 bids and consequent upon auction held in court in the presence of the Ex. Directors. Vide order dated 25.1.2007 on report 93/2006, this court appointed Mr. M.L. Gupta & Associates as the valuer of, interalia, property No.B-8, Site B, Surajpur Industrial Area, Greater Noida, UP (Surajpur Property). The valuation report made by M.L. Gupta & Associate was received by the court and taken on record and vide order dated 19.4.2007, the court directed issuance of sale proclamation considering the valuation given in the valuation report in accordance with the rules.

2. The valuation report of the valuer appointed by this Court was called for to value the company's property situated at B-8, Surajpur Industrial Area, Greater Noida, UP (Surajpur property). This was brought on record. As per this valuation report the Surajpur property was valued at Rs.5,49,64,000/-. The applicant filed CA No.666/2007 for setting aside the order dated 25.2.2002 whereby the Provisional Official Liquidator was appointed. This application was listed before the court on the judicial side on 11.7.2007. Notice was issued on the application and time was granted to the non-applicants for filing their replies. The matter was adjourned to 12th September

2007. However, no interim stay of disposal of the properties including the Surajpur property was passed by the court. On 12.7.2007 the matter was again taken in chamber. The applicant was also represented. He pointed out that he had already filed an application being CA No.666/2007 for setting aside the order dated 25.2.2002 whereby the provisional liquidator was appointed and stated that the applicant is ready to settle the claims of the creditors. The court took notice of the fact that CA 666/2006 was listed before the Court on 11.7.2007 and had been adjourned to 12.9.2007; that there was no stay of the auction of the property of the company in liquidation; that no steps had been taken by the Ex. Directors since the issuance of the sale notice on 11.5.2007, and that the offer of the ex director to deposit Rs.50 lakhs in Court allegedly due towards the principal amounts due to the creditors was refuted by the counsel for Bank of Baroda who stated that more than Rs.[7] crores was due from the company in liquidation. Thus Court did not agree to postponment of the auction since no steps have been taken by the ex director or any other person for settlement of the outstanding dues of the creditors and no details of payment and alleged proposal for settlement had been furnished by the ex director. Thereafter the Court proceeded to examine the bids that had been received. There were six bidders and open bidding was held in the Court. The highest bid of Rs.5.55 crores was given by one Pavas Chemicals Pvt. Ltd and the second highest bid was for Rs.5.52 crores given by GCG Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. The reserve price was Rs.3,29,78,400/-, that is, about 60% of the valuation done by the valuer. The secured creditor, Bank of Baroda did not dispute the reserve price and did not produce any valuation of its own. Since the highest bids of Rs.5.55 crores was higher than the reserve price the same was accepted by this Court. The earnest money deposited by the highest and the second highest bidder was retained and the highest bidder was required to make deposit of 25% of the bid amount as EMD and the balance was to be deposited within 60 days. The auction purchaser deposited the entire amount as directed on 10.9.2007 and possession was delivered to the auction purchaser on 14.9.2007. The sale was confirmed in favour of the auction purchaser on 29.11.2007. Even on that date the ex director was represented and made a statement that a proposal for settlement of dues had been sent to Bank of Baroda which was under active consideration. This statement of the ex director was disputed by the counsel for the Bank of Baroda. The applicant withdrew CA No.666/2007 on 12.9.2007. Pertinently, no liberty was sought to file any other application in respect of auction of the Surajpur Property when the said application was withdrawn.

3. The first submission of the applicant is that the valuation of about Rs.5.55 crore done by the valuer M/s M.L. Gupta and Associates is far below the market price. The applicant claimes that the present value of the property is about Rs.13 crores as per report made by M/s Chadha and Associates, a valuer on the panel prepared by this Court. He also states that the valuation done by M/s. M.L. Gupta & Associates is lower than even the circle rate. The next submission of the applicant is that the official liquidator was appointed as the provisional liquidator and he could not have sold the property in auction since the property did not vest in him. He could not have transferred the title to the property in favour of the auction purchaser. The third submission of the applicant is that there was a stay granted by the Allahabad High Court against the disposal of the assets of the company, i.e., the factory, including fixed assets and material in the factory without the leave of the single Judge of that Court, in Special Leave No.889/2002 titled M/s Reinz Talbros Ltd. vs. Deputy Labour Commissioner, Gautam Budh Nagar and Ors. He also relied on Allahabad Bank vs. Bengal Paper Mills Co. Limited, (1999) 4 SCC 383 to submit that the interest of the creditors is paramount and the court should ensure that the best price is fetched for the property belonging to the company that is sold by the court. He relied on Union Bank of India vs. Official Liquidator H.C. Of Calcutta, (2000) 5 SCC 274 to state that it is the obligation of the court to ensure that the valuation report brings out the market value of the property that is proposed to be sold, even if no objections are raised to such valuation.

4. Having considered the submissions of the applicant, I am of the view that this application has no merit and the same is liable to be dismissed. My reasons are as follow:

5. During the course of his arguments, learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the auction purchaser, as per the knowledge of the applicant is finalising the sale of the property at a value of about Rs.[8] crores. Firstly, there is no material whatsoever brought on record to support this statement. Moreover, this statement of the applicant itself demolishes the submission of the applicant based on the valuation report prepared by M/s Chadha and Associates. Pertinently, the auction took place about six months ago, i.e., in July 2007. It is nobody's case that property prices have since than come down. If the current market price is Rs.[8] crores, one fails to understand how it could be valued at Rs.13 crores in July, 2007. It is well known that a property sold in court auction hardly ever fetches its true market value because of the uncertainties involved in the entire transaction. Court auctions are invariably challenged by one or the other party, as in the present case. Very often, the auction purchaser get stuck with such transaction, which are neither concluded due to objections and challenges nor cancelled. Investments made by them remain unfruitful and uncertainties loom large. Therefore, while examining a plea that the price fetched in a court auction is below the market price (at which a transaction at arms length would take place), one has to consider these realities. Some amount of depreciation in the value is bound to be there when the property is sold in a court auction. Considering that even according to the applicant the market price of the Surajpur property as on date is Rs. 8 crores, when it is about to be sold by a private sale between two persons, the price at which the same was sold in a court auction over six months ago i.e. Rs.5.55 crores does not appear to be less than the reasonable value thereof at the relevant time. At this stage counsel for the applicant states that, in fact, the said property is proposed to be sold for Rs.11 crores. This submission is clearly an afterthought and has been made during the course of dictation of the order, and it only needs to be rejected. No material has been produced by the applicant in support of his aforesaid plea, and this submission only raises doubts about the sincerity and conviction with which the petitioner contends that the property was sold at a price much below the market price.

6. His further grievance is that the Court while confirming the sale ignored the fact that CA No.666/2007 was also pending. By urging these submission, the applicant is in fact seeking a review of the order dated 12.7.2007 passed in chambers, whereby the Court had, in the presence of the applicant, accepted the highest bid of Rs.5.55 crores and confirmed the sale. In my view, if the applicant had any grievance with the said order whereby the court proceeded to auction the Surajpur Property and confirm the sale, the correct thing to do was to challenge the said order. I am not hearing a review of that order, and cannot go behind the said order.

7. The submission that the valuation done by M/s M.L. Gupta and Associates was even below the circle rate is also of no avail for the aforesaid reasons. The property has been put to auction in open Court in the presence of the applicant, and even the secured creditor, whose dues are more than the amount at which the property has been sold has also accepted the valuation and not questioned the sale. I, therefore, reject this submission as well.

8. The submission that the provisional liquidator is not entitled to sell the property of the company is also misplaced in view of the express provisions contained in Section 450 of the Companies Act, 1956. The said Section states that the official liquidator may be appointed as the provisional liquidator and that he shall have the same powers as an official liquidator, provided that the Court may limit or restrict his powers by the order appointing him, or by any subsequent order. Section 457 of the Act specifically empowers the liquidator, with the sanction of the Court, to sell the immovable and movable property and auctionable claims of the company by public auction or private contract, with power to transfer the whole or part thereof to any person or body corporate, or to sell the same in parcels. In the present case, the Court had directed issuance of the sale proclamation and it is in pursuance thereof that the official liquidator, acting as the provisional liquidator, has put the property to auction. In fact the auction was held in the Court amongst the bidders who had given their bids in response to the advertisement. No limitation was put on the powers and authority of the official liquidator to deal with the property of the company in liquidation either in the order dated 25.2.2002, or in any other subsequent order of the court. On the contrary, the court directed and approved the sale of the Surajpur Property. Therefore, reliance placed by the applicant in support of the aforesaid submission on the decision of the Madras High Court in Sri Chamundi Theatre Mysore Talkies Ltd. vs. S. Chandrasekara Rao 45 Comp. Cases 60 is of no avail. The facts of the present case are materially different from the case cited by the applicant.

9. So far as the stay granted by the Allahabad High Court in Special Appeal No.889/2002 is concerned, the applicant has failed to state and substantiate that the said order was ever communicated to the official liquidator or to this Court. Pertinently this order, though passed on 23.8.2002 was not brought to the notice of this Court even when the applicant had filed CA No.666/2007. The official liquidator is not even a party in those proceedings. Consequently it cannot be said that the sale of the property has taken place in violation of the Court order since its communication was as important, as the fact that it had been passed.

10. Reliance placed by the applicant on the decision in Allahbad Bank (supra) and Union Bank of India (supra) as also on Lica (P) (No.1) v. Official Liquidator, (2000) 6 SCC 79 are misplaced in the facts of this case. As aforesaid the Court while confirming the sale, records its satisfaction that the property had been sold at the best price that it could fetch on the relevant date and no cogent material has been placed on record for the court to conclude that the sale in court auction was below the market price of the property on the relevant date. In my view, since there was no procedural infirmity in the process of sale, and no case of fraud etc. has been made out, merely because with the passage of time the price of the property has gone up, its sale cannot be set aside by the court, particularly when it appears to have been sold on the prevailing market price on the relevant date.

11. Accordingly I reject this application with cost of Rs.10,000/-. 50% of the cost be paid to the secured creditor, that is, Bank of Baroda and 50% to the Common Pool Fund of the official liquidator. Cost be paid within a week. January 31, 2008 VIPIN SANGHI, J. aj/P.K. BABBAR