Full Text
Date of order : 30th January, 2008
KHEM CHAND ..... Petitioner
Through Mr. A.K.Goyal, Advocate.
Through Mr. K. L. Rajoria, Advocate for R-1.
Mr. Pawan Behl, APP.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in Digest? Yes ORDER:Dr. S.Muralidhar, J. (open court)
1. This petition under Section 482 CrPC seeks the quashing of Complaint Case No. 293 of 2001 tiled Kripal Singh v. Khemchand and 2008:DHC:312 Metropolitan Magistrate, Delhi (‘MM’) summoning the Petitioner here to face trial under Section 302 IPC.
2. The aforementioned complaint was filed by the complainant Kripal Singh stating that on 9th May, 2000 at about 9 pm his younger brother the deceased Shri Krishan Kumar was seen along with his wife Smt. Sushila Devi while going to the house of the present Petitioner Khem Chand, the father of Smt. Sushila Devi. It is stated that around 12 midnight Krishan Kumar was brought dead by his wife Smt. Sushila Devi in a three wheeler scooter (TSR). According to the complainant and one Shri Mir Singh who was examined as CW-3 the Petitioner also accompanied the dead body of deceased Krishan Kumar in the aforesaid TSR. It is stated that the matter was reported to the police. However as per the report filed by the police before the learned SDM it was stated that the death of Krishan Kumar was due to natural causes. Accordingly the case was closed without any further investigation.
3. It appears that in the meanwhile Smt. Sushila Devi, i.e. the wife of deceased Krishan Kumar also expired on 28th February, 2001. In regard to present complainant and he is stated to be facing trial under Sections 498A and 304 B IPC.
4. The present case would not have revived had not the complainant Kripal Singh persisted with his complaint against the Petitioner here for the offences under Section 302/506/120-B/380 IPC. The complainant was able to produce as many as six witnesses at the pre-summoning stage before the court of the learned MM to persuade him to issue summons to the Petitioner. Four of the witnesses, i.e. CW 1 Kripal Singh the complainant, CW 2 Tara Chand, CW 3 Mir Singh and CW 4 Shri Kiran Singh have consistently stated that they saw the deceased Krishan Kumar going to the house of his in-laws along with his wife at about 7 pm on 9th May, 2000. All the four witnesses have said that dead body of Krishan Kumar was brought in a TSR at 12 midnight by his wife Sushila Devi and her father Khem Chand, the Petitioner here. To this extent the complainant appears to have brought on record sufficient evidence to indicate the role and presence of the Petitioner here.
5. What is however more clinching is the evidence of CW 5 Dr. S.K. mortem report indicated that the deceased died of Aluminium Phosphide poisoning and further that the body of the deceased was having one ante mortem contact burn mark with some hot object measuring 73 cms x 6.[8] cms. The post mortem report itself was exhibited before the learned learned MM. CW 6 SI Tej Ram produced the photocopy of the final report filed by the then IO SI Kamal Prit Singh in the inquest proceedings in which SI Kamal Prit Singh is stated to have opined that it was a natural death.
6. After considering the pre-summoning evidence referred to, the learned MM formed the opinion that the circumstances showed that the present Petitioner Khem Chand and his daughter Smt. Sushila Devi had hatched a conspiracy to kill Krishan Kumar thereby committing an offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. Since Sushila Devi had already expired, the Petitioner Khem Chand was summoned to face trial for the offences under Sections 302 IPC. Significantly, summons was also issued to SI Kamal Prit Singh for facing trial for the offences under Sections 218 and 201 IPC.
7. Learned counsel for the Petitioner advanced lengthy arguments to him there is not even an iota of evidence anywhere to link the Petitioner with the alleged crime; that it is impossible that a father-in-law would want to kill his son-in-law, that there was no eye witness to the occurrence; the Forensic Science report pointing the homicidal death of the deceased could not by itself connect the Petitioner with the crime and that therefore this was an eminent case for quashing of the entire criminal proceedings against the Petitioner.
8. That apart, learned counsel for the Petitioner repeatedly referred to letters written on 15th November 1994, 16th November 1994, 14th June 1995, 1st July 1997 and 8th June 2000 by either the Petitioner here or Krishan Kumar or Smt. Sushila Devi to various authorities in which an apprehension is expressed to the life and safety of Krishan Kumar. According to learned counsel for the Petitioner this Court should examine all these letters itself and give a definite opinion in the exercise of its powers under Section 482 CrPC, and the innocence of the Petitioner in respect of the offence under Section 302 IPC.
9. This Court finds the submission of the learned counsel for the a case of homicidal death where the report of the Forensic Science Laboratory is unequivocal and indicates that the deceased had died of Aluminium Phospide poisoning, the Investigating Officer chose to close the case by labeling it as a death due to natural causes. This has undoubtedly led to a miscarriage of justice. But for the complainant Kripal Singh having persisted with his complaint, the truth would never have come to light. It is only at the stage of pre-summoning evidence that as many as six witnesses were able to be produced before the learned MM to implicate the Petitioner here for the offence under Section 302 IPC.
10. It appears for all purposes that this is a case of circumstantial evidence where evidence has been gathered not only to show that it was a homicidal death but also that the deceased was last seen with the Petitioner. At this stage when the matter is yet to go to a full-fledged trial, this Court is not supposed to examine the entire evidence that has come on record. Sufficient to say that this is hardly a case where the Court should interfere in exercise of its powers under Section 482 CrPC to quash the proceedings.
11. There is no merit in this petition and it is accordingly dismissed. The will not influence the ultimate verdict that may be reached by the trial court.
12. Before concluding, this Court would like to make a few observations and issue certain directions. During the course of hearing, the Petitioner’s counsel was asked about the progress of the matter in the trial court. He informed that there was no progress being made in the trial court. This was surprising since no stay has been granted by this Court in the present petition. It is indeed a matter of concern that the mere pendency of the present petition under Section 482 CrPC in this Court for over two years has led to the stopping of the trial for the offence under Section 302 IPC by the trial court. This Court therefore thinks it necessary to seek an explanation from the learned trial court where the matter is pending as to why the trial has not progressed. The said court will send a status report within a period of two weeks from today.
13. Further, this Court would request the District & Sessions Judge, Delhi to explore the possibility of devising a system to carefully monitor the progress of trials particularly where petitions under Section 482 CrPC are filed in this Court and no stay of trial court proceedings is granted. It is by this Court the trials get stalled till such time the records are not returned to that Court. In such event it would be important for the trial court to inform this Court that the trial is not able to proceed for this reason. This should facilitate return of the record from this court without delay. If there are already instructions issued in this regard, those should be reiterated by a fresh set of instructions.
14. The learned District & Sessions Judge, Delhi is required to send a compliance report to this Court within a period of two weeks informing the Court that the directions as contained in para 13 of this order has been issued to all concerned subordinate judges. The status report of the progress of the trial in the present case, as prepared by the concerned trial court in terms of the directions in para 12 of this order, will also be sent to this Court within a period of 15 days from today and in any event not later than 18th February,
2008.
15. List on 18th February, 2008 for compliance.
16. A certified copy of this order be sent to both the District & Sessions Judge, Delhi and the concerned trial court within five days.
S. MURALIDHAR, J.