Full Text
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 14314/2006
Date of Decision: 30th January, 2008 Shri Rajesh Shukla ... Petitioner through: Mr. B.L. Chawla, Adv.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? GITA MITTAL, J(Oral)
1. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner seeking a direction to the respondent to implement the offer as contained in the letter dated 29th January, 2004 as purportedly extended by the letters dated 20th May, 2004, 27th July, 2005 and 19th June, 2006 and to pass on the 15% rebate mentioned therein to him. This writ petition is premised on the admitted facts that Shri S.M. Shukla was allotted the industrial shed No. I-10, DSIDC Indl. Complex, Rohtak Road, Nangloi, Delhi. The writ petition shows that these sheds were constructed under the special - 2 programme of the authorities to provide opportunities of self employment to unemployed entrepreneurs which was being implemented by the respondents. The 2008:DHC:317 petitioner has claimed that he is the nephew of the allottee Shri S.M. Shukla.
2. The original record has been placed and has been perused. It is urged that late Shri S.M. Shukla had accepted the offer of transfer of the ownership of the shed on hire purchase basis as communicated the DSIDC by a letter dated 29th January, 2004. The government had offered a scheme of 15% rebate to the allottees to make payment of the demanded amount towards the shed which benefit was available only to the original allottees and not to any transferees. The petitioner has placed reliance on the letter dated 29th January, 2004 wherein clause 4 clearly stipulates that an interim offer was being given only to the allottees who make payment of the dues payable against the shed as on 29th February, 2004. It is noteworthy that such benefit was available even to the original allottees only if they complied with and made the payments in terms of the letter dated 29th January, 2004. These offers of the DSIDC have fallen for consideration before the Division Bench of this court in the pronouncement reported at 1996 I AD (Delhi) 398 Smt. Pushplata Vs. Delhi State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd.
3. The petitioner is admittedly not the original allottee. There is -3nothing on record to show that the amount in terms of the offer dated 29th January, 2004 was paid by the original allottee to the DSIDC. Certainly the petitioner cannot claim benefit of an offer when the original allottee to whom the offer was made did not comply with the stipulated terms and conditions. In view of this discussion, the petitioner is not entitled to 15% rebate on the cost of the shed.
4. A further prayer is made that despite request of the petitioner the DSIDC is not effecting approval of right, title and interest in the subject shed in his favour. To this, I find that the respondents have stated on affidavit that the petitioner has never made a formal application in this behalf which was required to be made and considered in terms of the applicable policy and upon payment of the prescribed charges towards transfer of allotments in favour of the transferrees.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on the plea that the petitioner was inducted as a partner by Shri S.M. Shukla the original allottee and that he has been acting in all manners in respect of the subject shed. Be that as it may the fact remains that the petitioner has not put in the formal and requisite application for transfer of the allotment in his favour. Accordingly, I find no merit in this writ petition which is hereby - 4 dismissed. However the petitioner shall be at liberty to make an appropriate application for transfer of the allocation of the shed in his favour. In case the petitioner satisfies the prescribed requirements thereof, the respondents shall consider the application within four weeks of its receipt and pass appropriate orders thereon. Needless to say the petitioner shall be required to make all prescribed payments, if any due, in accordance with the policy for transfer of allotments.
(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE January 30, 2008 kr