Neera Dadhwal v. Deepak Paintal and Ors.

Delhi High Court · 04 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:365
S. Ravindra Bhat
Review Petition 418/2007
2008:DHC:365
constitutional petition_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the review petition seeking admission to the sixth semester of LLB, holding that mandatory attendance norms must be fulfilled and that the petitioner was unjustly marked absent in one exam but not entitled to promotion without meeting statutory conditions.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Review Petition 418/2007 IN
W.P.(C) 17455/2006
Reserved on January, 14th , 2007 Delivered on February 4,th
NEERA DADHWAL ..... Petitioner
Through Mr. Tarique Siddiqui, Advocate
VERSUS
DEEPAK PAINTAL AND ORS. ..... Respondents
Through Mr. J.S. Rupal, Advocate
CORAM:
Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat:
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment.?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat:

1. The Petitioner had invoked the writ jurisdiction of this Court and claims a direction to admit her the fifth semester of the LLB Course, conducted by the Delhi University. In these review proceeding, she seeks modification and recall of the judgment of this court, dated 20th

R. P. No.418/07 in W.P.(C) 17455/06 1

2. The Petitioner enrolled herself in the Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi in the year

2004. The course has six semesters and 30 subjects have to be cleared by the end of the 6th semester. A student has to clear 15 out of 20 subjects to qualify for admission to the fifth semester. The petitioner had 61% of attendance and according to Ordinance VII, of the Statutes and Ordinances the Dean/Professor in charge has the power to condone the attendance since she was working for the institution. She had alleged about not being issued a roll number to appear in the first paper; she was sent back from the institution without being allowed to give her exam. The Petitioner was issued roll number for the second examination, a few minutes of the commencement of her exams. She averred that she cleared two out of the four subjects, in which she was allowed to appear. She submitted that in the result it was shown that she has passed or qualified in 14 subjects out of 19 but actually it is 14 subjects out of 17 as the other 2 papers were disturbed by the Respondents.

3. In the main judgment, after recording the rival contentions and pleadings, the writ petition was disposed, on the basis of the following findings:

9. The undisputed case is that the petitioner had about 61 per cent attendance. The norm, stipulated by Ordinance VII 8 (a) is 66 per cent of lectures on each of the subjects as also moot courts and practical training course. Appendix II to Ordinance V (2) and VII prescribes that a law student, to be promoted to fifth semester, should have passed at least in 15 out of 20 papers.

R. P. No.418/07 in W.P.(C) 17455/06 2

Ordinance VII (8) (a) reads as follows:

“8 (a) “ The student shall be required to put in minimum attendance of 66 per cent of the lectures on each of the subjects as also at the moot courts and practical training course. ” Provided that in exceptional cases for reasons to be recorded and communicated to the Bar Council of India, the Dean of the Faculty. of Law/Professor-in-charge of the Law Centre may condone attendance short of those required by this Rule, if the student had attended 66 per cent of the lectures in the aggregate of the semester examinations. Provided further that no personal shall be deemed to have satisfied the required conditions in respect of his instructions unless, in addition to the requirements regarding attendance and other conditions, he has appeared and satisfied by his performance the Professor-in-Charge of the Law Centre in such test, written and /or oral, as may be held by him in hi discretion. The Professor-in-Charge shall have, ands shall be deemed always to have had, the power to detain a student in the same class in which he has been studying or not to sent him up for the University Examination, in case he did not appear at the t est/s aforesaid or his performance was not satisfactory. The Professor-in-Charge of the Law Centre shall have power to strike off the name of a student who is grossly irregular in attendance in spite of warning, or, when the absence of the student is for such a long period that he cannot put in requisite percentage of attendance.” Appendix II to Ordinance V (2) & VII is as follows: “A student of the First, Third, and Fifth Term will be promoted to the Second, Fourth and Sixth Term respectively, irrespective of the number of courses in which he/she has failed to pass or failed to appear in the First, Third or Fifth Term Examination: Provided that he or she has not been detained on account of shortage of attendance in First, Third or Fifth Term Examination, as the case may be.
R. P. No.418/07 in W.P.(C) 17455/06 3
Provided further that no such student shall be admitted to the Third or Fifth Term unless he/she has passed in at least five courses offered by him/her for the First and Second Term Examinations taken together in case of promotion from I year to II year and in at least fifteen courses offered by him/her; for the First, Second, Third and Fourth Term Examination taken together in case of promotion from II year to II year of the LLB course. Note:- The students eligible for admission to III/V Term must seek admission not later than two weeks from the date(s) of announcement of the results of LLB II/IV Term Annual Examinations or within one week of commencement of classes, whichever is later, failing which they will forfeit their right to be admitted to III/V Term.”

10. The petitioner's allegation is that she could not attain the 66 per cent minimum attendance criteria, as she was asked to participate in student union activities; she also attended moot courts and legal aid camps. She has relied upon certificates issued by the Legal Aid Society, of the Campus Law Centre about her active participation in legal aid programmes and also other documents showing involvement in students union activities. As far as her clearing 14 out of 17 subjects is concerned, although the allegation that she was permitted to appear late in some exams, and not permitted to appear in paper XVI (Constitutional Law – II) is denied, yet during the hearing, she produced the response of the Principal Information Officer of the Campus Law Centre under the Right to Information Act, 2005.

13,535 characters total

11. The petitioner had sought information about the seating plan for students attempting in all the subjects of the fourth semester; Constitutional Law, paper- XVI was the subject of examination on 01.05.06. The seating plan for room No. 26 indicated that 55 students had attempted the examination. The petitioner's role number i.e. 60856, did not find mention in that examination hall; indeed it does not find mention in any other examination hall for that paper. What has, therefore, been established is that the petitioner lost the opportunity to appear in one paper. She was admittedly marked “absent” in that paper. To that extent, her grievance of not being permitted to appear in all the papers

R. P. No.418/07 in W.P.(C) 17455/06 4 seems well founded. As regards the complaint that she was permitted to appear but later on in some other subjects, there is no evidence to establish that. Similarly, in the representations addressed by her on 17.10.06 and later, she has not complained that attendance was wrongly withheld. In these circumstances, the only grievance which can be considered by the Court is whether the respondents acted with justification in proceeding to detain her at the end of the fourth semester examination.

12. After the filing of this writ petition, this Court had permitted the petitioner to appear in the fifth semester (Suppl.) examinations conducted in May-June, 2007. The Court had also directed that the results would not be declared till further orders and that no special equities would arise in her favour by the permission to appear in the examinations

13. The above facts and attendant circumstances would disclose that the petitioner fell marginally short of minimum attendance requirement spelt out by the Ordinance. There is some documentary evidence in support of her claim that a claim of having participated in legal aid camps and cocurricular activities of the students' union. Apparently, the respondents have not given credit for it; in any case, the petitioner fell short of attendance by nine classes. At the same time, she was also not permitted to appear in all the examinations – the response to the query made by her under the Right to Information Act, indicated that her role number was not included in the seating plan for that examination on 01.05.06. In these circumstances, the respondents' action in marking her absent cannot be justified. I am, therefore, of the considered opinion that the petitioner's results for the fifth semester examination should be declared forthwith. However, this cannot automatically mean that all attendance requirements have to be give a go by. She was not admitted to the 6 th semester examination. She approached this Court on 21.10.06 and was unable to secure an interim order. In these circumstances, although this Court has got wide powers under Article 226 of the Constitution, such powers should be exercised with circumspection having regard to the express statutory conditions and the attendant circumstances. In this case, the issue is one of attendance norms. If this Court, at this stage

R. P. No.418/07 in W.P.(C) 17455/06 5 were to permit the petitioner to appear in the 6 th semester without having been admitted to it, it would be violating the attendance requirements and all other conditions.

14. In the above circumstances, following directions are issued:

1. The Faculty of Law, namely, the third respondent shall declare the results of the fifth semester examination (Suppl.) in which the petitioner appeared, within a week from today;

2. The petitioner shall admitted to the fifth semester. It shall be open to her to appear in the examinations/tests conducted by the respondents in respect of the subjects which she has not cleared in accordance with the Ordinance and statutes;

3. The petitioner shall be permitted to make up the deficiency of attendance if any in the fifth semester and shall be admitted to the 6 th semester at the end of the present term, in January, 2008. Thereafter, subject to her fulfilling the attendance norms and other conditions, she shall be permitted to appear in the 6 th semester examinations. The petition is disposed off in terms of the above directions. No costs.”

5. The limited review sought by the petitioner now is that the court should correct direction Para 14 (2) so as to clarify that the petitioner should be admitted to the sixth semester, instead of the fifth semester. It is contended that this is necessary, because the respondents have now declared the fifth semester examination, which showed that she secured 240 out of 500 marks in the III term and 260 out of 500 marks, in the fifth term. The petitioners also adverts to her approaching the Division Bench of this court, in an appeal, which was rejected and later,

R. P. No.418/07 in W.P.(C) 17455/06 6 appealing to the Supreme Court, by special leave. The Supreme Court permitted her to withdraw the petition and file the present review petition.

6. The review petition is opposed by the respondent; its counsel alleges that the petitioner did not disclose to the Supreme Court, that she was permitted to appear in the fifth semester examination without granting equities. He relied on the order of 4th May, 2007, whereby this court had allowed her to appear in the fifth semester examination, without creation of any special equities. He also submitted that a similar request for correction of the order was made through an application, i.e CM 12294/2007, after delivery of judgment; after some hearing, it was permitted to be withdrawn, on 5th September, 2007.

7. This court has carefully considered the pleadings in the writ petition as well as the main judgment, and the subsequent order, dated 5th September 2007. The findings disclose that the court was conscious about the restricted nature of the right to appear in the fifth semester examination; it was not to create any special equities. After analyzing all the relevant ordinances and statutes, the court noted that attendance norms have to be fulfilled for each semester. The legitimate grievance on which directions were issued was the respondents action in not permitting the petitioner to appear in one paper. However, the court consciously held that no inference could be drawn about her having attended fifth semester, or fulfilled the norms in that regard:

R. P. No.418/07 in W.P.(C) 17455/06 7 “However, this cannot automatically mean that all attendance requirements have to be give a go by. She was not admitted to the 6 th semester examination. She approached this Court on 21.10.06 and was unable to secure an interim order. In these circumstances, although this Court has got wide powers under Article 226 of the Constitution, such powers should be exercised with circumspection having regard to the express statutory conditions and the attendant circumstances. In this case, the issue is one of attendance norms. If this Court, at this stage were to permit the petitioner to appear in the 6 th semester without having been admitted to it, it would be violating the attendance requirements and all other conditions.” In the above background, the petitioner was permitted admission in the fifth semester, and not in the sixth semester. There is no material to suggest that she fulfilled the attendance norms for the sixth semester, and had attended the requisite number of classes in the fifth semester. In the absence of any such material, the court cannot view the main judgment, sitting in review jurisdiction, as an appellate forum.

8. In the above circumstance, no case for review has been made out. The review petition is accordingly dismissed. Dasti under the signature of the Court Master. DATED: 4th February, 2008 (S. RAVINDRA BHAT) JUDGE