Full Text
Translation output
> t v» a-2
% 12.02.2008
Present. Chaudhary, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr.B.N. Gupta, Advocate for the respondent
+
*
CM No. 15977/2007 in CMfM) No. lQ37/?nn7
In view of the reasons stated in the application the same is allowed and the order dated 6.11.2007 dismissing the petition for non-prosecution is recalled.
CM(M) No.1037/2007
In this petition the petitioner tenant impugns the order dated
8.2.2007 passed by the Additional Rent Control Tribunal, Delhi in
RCA No. 94/2006. The respondent landlady has filed the eviction petition under Section 14(l){a) of the Delhi Rent Control Act and another petition under Section 14(l)(b) had also been preferred.
The defence set up by the petitioner herein was that the respondent was not the owner of the suit premises. The petitioner claimed ownership of the premises and contended that the premises had mortgaged with the respondent to secure a loan obtained by him from the respondent. The learned Additional Rent Controller came to the finding of fact that the premises had been transferred to the respondent by the petitioner by executing various documents such as registered power of attorney. Will, affidavit, agreement to
2008:DHC:5167
These are findings offacts.
The learned Additional Rent Controller, Delhi, passed an order under Section 15(1) of the Act by giving the petitioner benefit under
Section 14(2) of the Act directing him to pay or deposit rent @
Rs.2000/- per month and also requiring him to pay the same in future. However, the petition under Section 14(l)(b) of the Act was dismissed. Against that order the petitioner filed an appeal before the Rent Control Tribunal which has been dismissed by the impugned order. The Tribunal has taken aview that the petitioner herein did not raise any question of law and that the appeal under
Section 38 of the Act was maintainable only in respect of aquestion of law.
Before me, learned counsel for the petitioner argues that his client has been defrauded by the respondent. He submits thatthere was no agreement to sell etc. and that merely a loan transaction had been entered into and in pursuance thereof the property was mortgaged with the respondent. These are the questions of fact which has been determined by the learned Rent Controller. They do not raise a question of law and the petitioner is unable to show that any question of law was raised before the Tribunal which the
Tribunal has failed to appreciate. In view of the aforesaid I find no merit in the petition.
2008:DHC:5167
% 12.02.2008
Present. Chaudhary, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr.B.N. Gupta, Advocate for the respondent
+
*
CM No. 15977/2007 in CMfM) No. lQ37/?nn7
In view of the reasons stated in the application the same is allowed and the order dated 6.11.2007 dismissing the petition for non-prosecution is recalled.
CM(M) No.1037/2007
In this petition the petitioner tenant impugns the order dated
8.2.2007 passed by the Additional Rent Control Tribunal, Delhi in
RCA No. 94/2006. The respondent landlady has filed the eviction petition under Section 14(l){a) of the Delhi Rent Control Act and another petition under Section 14(l)(b) had also been preferred.
The defence set up by the petitioner herein was that the respondent was not the owner of the suit premises. The petitioner claimed ownership of the premises and contended that the premises had mortgaged with the respondent to secure a loan obtained by him from the respondent. The learned Additional Rent Controller came to the finding of fact that the premises had been transferred to the respondent by the petitioner by executing various documents such as registered power of attorney. Will, affidavit, agreement to
2008:DHC:5167
These are findings offacts.
The learned Additional Rent Controller, Delhi, passed an order under Section 15(1) of the Act by giving the petitioner benefit under
Section 14(2) of the Act directing him to pay or deposit rent @
Rs.2000/- per month and also requiring him to pay the same in future. However, the petition under Section 14(l)(b) of the Act was dismissed. Against that order the petitioner filed an appeal before the Rent Control Tribunal which has been dismissed by the impugned order. The Tribunal has taken aview that the petitioner herein did not raise any question of law and that the appeal under
Section 38 of the Act was maintainable only in respect of aquestion of law.
Before me, learned counsel for the petitioner argues that his client has been defrauded by the respondent. He submits thatthere was no agreement to sell etc. and that merely a loan transaction had been entered into and in pursuance thereof the property was mortgaged with the respondent. These are the questions of fact which has been determined by the learned Rent Controller. They do not raise a question of law and the petitioner is unable to show that any question of law was raised before the Tribunal which the
Tribunal has failed to appreciate. In view of the aforesaid I find no merit in the petition.
2008:DHC:5167
JUDGMENT