Director General of Works v. Sh. Daya Shankar Prasad

Delhi High Court · 08 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:443
Anil Kumar
CM No.8991/2007 in W.P.(C) No.12178/2006
2008:DHC:443
labor appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, a workman not gainfully employed during pendency of proceedings challenging reinstatement is entitled to full wages last drawn as subsistence allowance.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CM No.8991/2007 in W.P.(C) No.12178/2006
Date of Decision: 08.02.2008
Director General of Works ….… Petitioner
CPWD, New Delhi Through: Mr.R.N.Singh, Advocate.
VERSUS
Sh.Daya Shankar Prasad ......... Respondent
Through: Ms.Renu Verma, Advocate.
CORAM :-
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of Local papers may YES be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the reporter or not? NO

3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J. (Oral) *

1. This is an application by the respondent under Section 17B of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 read with Section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure for payment of full wages to the respondent.

2. The notice of the application was accepted by the learned counsel for the petitioner on 6th July, 2007 and four weeks time was granted to the counsel for the petitioner to file the reply. No reply to the application was filed within four weeks and till the next date of WP(C) 12178 of 2006 2008:DHC:443 hearing 22nd October, 2007. On 22nd October, 2007 when the matter was taken up, no one appeared on behalf of petitioner. The Court, however, granted four weeks time more to the petitioner to file the reply which has not been filed till today.

3. The learned counsel for the petitioner is unable to give any cogent or sufficient reason for not filing the reply since 6th July, 2007 when the notice of the application was accepted by the learned counsel for the petitioner. Consequently, there are no grounds to grant further time and the right of the petitioner to file the reply is closed.

4. The respondent/applicant has contended that award dated 23rd February, 2005 in I.D No.50/96 was given directing the petitioner to reinstate the respondent within one month from the publication of the award, however, the respondent workman was denied any back wages but was granted benefit of continuity of service. The respondent workman was also awarded interest at 12% on back wages that may accrue in view of non reinstatement.

5. Aggrieved by the award dated 23rd February, 2005 the present writ petition was filed where this Court had stayed the operation of award dated 23rd February, 2005 till further orders.

6. The respondent applicant has contended that he was entitled for reinstatement in terms of award dated 23rd February, 2005 after his termination from service with effect from 27th August, 1994, however, the respondent has not been reinstated despite the letters sent to the petitioner dated 25th April, 2005 and 20th April, 2006 seeking his reinstatement and implementation of award.

7. The respondent applicant also contended that he approached the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New Delhi for implementation of award dated 23rd February, 2005 and filed an execution petition. Despite an execution petition filed by the respondent workman neither he has been reinstated nor he has been paid back wages with 12% interest on default of petitioner to reinstate him.

8. The respondent applicant has also contended that he has not been in employment in any establishment during the period from the date of the award till the filing of the application. The respondent workman contended that he had to go to his hometown at Village Dorghat Tola Pakadihawa, Post Dhani Bazar, Tehsil Farinda, Distt.Maharaj Ganj, U.P as it was not possible for him to live in the city and in the circumstances the respondent has prayed for payment of full back wages including all allowances during the pendency of the writ petition.

9. The learned counsel for the petitioner non-applicant has contended that the respondent workman has been gainfully employed and in any case he is not in Delhi. The learned counsel has also argued on the merits of the case that the respondent is not entitled for reinstatement.

10. It is no more res integra that while deciding the applications of the workman who has been ordered to be reinstated and which order has been stayed, the merits of the case are not to be considered at the time of passing an order under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The provisions of Section 17 B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 comes into operation when an Award directing reinstatement of a workman is assailed in further proceedings. The statute requires satisfaction of the following four conditions:

(i) an Award by a Labour Court, Tribunal or National

(ii) during the pendency of such proceedings, employer is required to pay full wages to the workman;

16,827 characters total

(iii) the wages stipulated under Section 17B are full wages last drawn by him, inclusive of any maintenance allowance admissible to him under any Rule;

(iv) such wages would be admissible only if the workman had not been employed in any establishment during such period and an affidavit had been filed to such effect

11. While considering an application under this provision it is necessary to bear in mind that the spirit, intendment and object underlying the statutory provision of Section 17B is to mitigate and relieve, to a certain extent, the hardship resulting to a workman due to delay in the implementation of an award directing reinstatement of his services on account of the challenge laid to it by the employer. The preliminary consideration for making available such a relief to a workman is to be found in the benevolent purpose of the enactment. It recognizes a workman’s right to the bare minimum to keep body and soul together when a challenge has been laid to an Award directing his reinstatement. The statutory provisions provide no inherent right of assailing an order or an award by an industrial adjudicator by way of an appeal. The payment which is required to be made by the employer to the workman has been held to be akin to a subsistence allowance which is neither refundable nor recoverable from a workman even if the Award in his favor is set aside by the High Court. In 1999 (2) SCC 106 (para 22), Dena Bank v. Kiritikumar T. Patel the Apex Court was of the view that the object under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is only to relieve to a certain extent, the hardship that is caused to the workman due to the delay in implementation of the Award. While considering the payment which is required to be made by the employer to the workman in this behalf, the Apex Court observed as follows:

“21. As indicated earlier Section 17B has been enacted by Parliament with a view to give relief to a workman who has been ordered to be reinstated under the Award of a Labour Court or the Industrial Tribunal during the pendency of proceedings in which the said award is under challenge before the High Court or the Supreme Court. The object underlying the provision is to relieve to a certain extent the hardship that is caused to the workman due to delay in the implementation of the award. The payment which is required to be made by the employer to the workman is in the nature of subsistence allowance which would not be refundable or recoverable from the workman even if the award is set aside by the High Court or this Court. Since the payment is of such a character, Parliament thought it proper to limit it to the extent of the wages which were drawn by the workman when he was in service and when his services were terminated and therefore used the words ‘full wages last drawn’. To read these words to mean wages which would have been drawn by the workman if he had continued in service if the order terminating his services had not passed since it has been set aside by the award of the Labour Court or the Industrial Tribunal, would result in so enlarging the benefit as to comprehend the relief that has been granted under the award that is under challenge. Since the amount is not refundable or recoverable in the event of the award being set aside, it would result in the employer being required to give effect to the award during the pendency of the proceedings challenging the award before the High Court or the Supreme Court without his being able to recover he said amount in the event of the award being set aside. We are unable to construe the provisions contained in Section
17B to cast such a burden on the employer. In our opinion, therefore, the words ‘full wages last drawn’ must be given their plain and material meaning and they cannot be given the extended meaning as given by the Karnataka High Court in Visveswaraya Iron & Steel Ltd. or the Bombay High Court in Corona Sahu Co. Ltd.
22. xxxx
23. As regards the powers of the High Court and the Supreme Court under Articles 226 and 136 of the Constitution, it may be stated that Section 17B, by conferring a right on the workman to be paid the amount of full wages last drawn by him during the pendency of the proceedings involving challenge tot he award of the Labour Court, Industrial Tribunal or National Tribunal in the High Court or the Supreme Court which amount is not refundable or recoverable in the event of the award being set aside, does not in any way preclude the High Court or the Supreme Court to pas an order directing payment of a higher amount to the workman if such higher amount is considered necessary in the interest of justice. Such a direction would be dehors the provisions contained in Section 17B and while giving the direction, the Court may also give directions regarding refund or recovery of the excess amount in the event of the award being set aside. But we are unable to agree with the view of the Bombay High Court in Elpro International Ltd. that in exercise of the power under Articles 226 and 136 granted under Section 17B. The conferment of such a right under Section 17B cannot be regarded as a restriction on the powers of the High Court or the Supreme Court under Articles 226 and 136 of the Constitution.”

12. ‘Gainful employment in an establishment’ has been held by the Apex Court as not a self employment. In Rajinder Kumar Kundra v. Delhi Administration, (1984) 4 SCC 635 while considering the question relating to award of back wages, the Supreme Court noticed thus: “It was next contended on behalf of the appellant that reinstatement with full back wages be awarded to him. Mr. P.K. Jain, learned Counsel for the employer countered urging that there is evidence to show that the appellant was gainfully employed since the termination of service and therefore he was not entitled to back wages. In support of this submission Mr. Jain pointed out that the appellant in his cross-examination has admitted that during his forced absence from employment since the date of termination of his service, he was maintaining his family by helping his father-in-law Tara Chand who owns a coal depot, and that he and the members of his family lived with his father-in-law and that he had no alternative source of maintenance. If this is gainful employment, the employer can contend that the dismissed employee in order to keep his body and soul together had taken to begging and that would as well be a gainful employment. The gross perversity with which the employer had approached this case has left us stunned. If the employer after an utterly unsustainable termination order of service wants to deny back wages on the ground that the appellant and the members of his family were staying with the father-in-law of the appellant as there was no alternative source of maintenance and during this period appellant was helping his father-in-law of the appellant as there was no alternative source of maintenance and during this period appellant was helping his father-in-law Tara Chand who had a coal depot, it cannot be said that the appellant was gainfully employed. This cannot be said to be gainful employment so as to reject the claim for back wages. There is no evidence on the record to show that the appellant was gainfully employed during the period of his absence from service. Therefore, the appellant would be entitled to full back wages and all consequential benefits.”

13. Since the section itself mentions ‘employment in establishment’ self employment quite apparently is not in contemplation. Workman can be denied the benefits under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act only when it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court that the workmen have been employed and have been receiving adequate remuneration during the period of pendency of the writ petition. It is thus well settled that transient employment by the workman does not affect his entitlement to receive wages pending decision; that is to say that, the benefit of Section 17B of the Act cannot be denied merely because the workman is engaged in some activity or in some vocation to eke out his livelihood. Such relief can be denied only if it is proved that the workman is gainfully employed in some establishment and is receiving adequate and regular remuneration which is not the case with the applicant. The applicant/respondent has gone back to his native village as he did not have any means to survive and live at the place where it was directed to reinstate him and despite the award in his favor and many representations made by him, he has not been reinstated.

14. While considering an application under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, the Court cannot go into the merits of the case in the writ petitioner. It was so held in 86 (2000) DLT 510=2000 (5) AD (Delhi) 413, Anil Jain v. Jagdish Chander.

15. Whether the applicant is entitled for last drawn wages or something more. In 1970 1 SCR 51, Town Municipal, Athani v. P.O. LC Hugli & Ors. it was held by the Apex Court that a workman has a legal right to wages under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 and cannot be diverted to a remedy under Section 20 of the Minimum Wages Act for enforcing such right. In this case, the Apex Court was concerned with the power of the Act under Section 33(C)(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and the principles laid down by the Court would have a bearing on the issues raised before this Court as well. From a conspectus of the authoritative pronouncements of the Apex Court, the right of a workman to an amount equivalent to the wages notified under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 is thus, in fact, recognition of the constitutional mandate and nothing more. It is undoubtedly, the bare minimum which is required by the workman to subsist and is nothing more. Full wages last drawn can therefore only mean all the wages that have fallen due at least from the date of the Award.

16. This also cannot be disputed that granting relief under Section 17B of the Act and passing orders directing payment of wages last drawn, is generally the rule; refusing to grant relief under Section 17B is an exception, as the relief could be denied only in the rarest of the rare cases of jurisdictional error where there is no relationship between the parties.

17. The plea of the petitioner that the respondent/workman has already gone to his native village and, therefore, he is not entitled for an order under Section 17B is, therefore, without any legal basis and is not sustainable in the facts and circumstances. The learned counsel for the petitioner is unable to show any rule or any precedent that in case a workman who had been dismissed and has been directed to be reinstated, if goes to his native place as the order of reinstatement has not been implemented, the workman shall not be entitled for an order under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act,

1947.

18. What is material is whether the workman is gainfully employed in an establishment or not. The plea of the workman that he has not been gainfully employed after the date of award dated 23rd February, 2005 directing his reinstatement and he is not re-employed in any establishment remains un-rebutted and in the circumstances respondent workman has become entitled for an order under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

19. For the foregoing reasons the application is allowed. The petitioner is directed to pay the last drawn wages or minimum wages whichever is higher from 23rd February, 2005, the date of the award. Arrears of last drawn wages or minimum wages whichever is higher be paid within eight weeks. The petitioner shall continue to pay last drawn wages or minimum wages to the respondent by the 10th of every succeeding month. The respondent is also directed to file an undertaking that in case this writ petition is allowed, the respondent shall return/refund the difference of last drawn wages and minimum wages within such time as will be permitted by this Court. The undertaking be filed within four weeks. With these directions, the application is disposed of. W.P.(C) No.12178/2006 The learned counsel for the petitioner states that the amount of Rs.5000/- as litigation expenses was deposited. The counsel for the respondent states that the amount has not yet been released to the respondent. The learned counsel seeks time to file the counter affidavit. Counter affidavit be filed within eight weeks. Rejoinder, if any, within four weeks thereafter. List on 21st August, 2008. February 08th, 2008 ANIL KUMAR, J. 'k'