Suresh Singh v. Daya Chand & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 08 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:471
S. Ravindra Bhat
CS (OS) 49/2007
2008:DHC:471
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The court held that daughters have equal coparcenary rights under the 2005 Hindu Succession amendment, rejected adverse possession claim against a co-sharer, and decreed partition with injunction protecting possession.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CS (OS) 49/2007
Reserved on : 4th February, 2008.
Date of Decision: 8th February, 2008.
SHRI SOM NATH ..... Petitioner
Through: Mr. Suresh Singh, Advocate
VERSUS
SHRI DAYA CHAND & ORS. ..... Respondents
Through: Mr. S. Sirish Kumar for D-6
CORAM:
Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat 1 . Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
.? Yes.

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes.

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest Yes. Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat:

1. The plaintiff seeks a decree for partition of properties being Flat No. A-5/130, Janta Quarters, Janakpuri, New Delhi (hereafter “Janakpuri property”) and house No. CB-311, Naraina, Ring Road, New Delhi (hereafter “Naraina property”) by separating his 1/3 share by metes and bounds. In the alternative he seeks a declaration that he is owner in possession and has CS (OS) 49/2007 1 2008:DHC:471 perfected his title by adverse possession in respect of portion of the Naraina property. He also seeks permanent injunction to restrain first defendant from interfering with his possession in that regard.

2. According to the averments in the suit, the plaintiff and defendant Nos. 1 and 2 are brothers; defendant Nos. 3 to 5 are their sisters. All are children of late Jati Ram, who pre-deceased their mother Smt. Chawli Devi. The said Smt. Chawli Devi was in Government Service, working in the Central Ordinance Depot, Delhi Cantonment. The entire family used to live in official quarters allotted to her. It is also averred that Smt. Chawli Devi purchased the suit properties which include the Naraina propoerty, measuring approximately 160 sq. yards. All these were purchased by her with joint family funds. It is further averred that to accommodate the growing needs of the expanding family, Smt. Chawli Devi permitted second defendant to occupy the Janakpuri property.

3. In 1977, the plaintiff joined services of the Airport Authority of India and at the time of filing the suit, he was posted in the Indira Gandhi International Airport. He claims to have occupied a portion of the Naraina property in 1983 and constructed upon it to the extent of 32 sq. yards, on being asked to occupy that portion, due to a threat of dispossession. It is claimed that the mother Smt. Chawli Devi permitted him to occupy the CS (OS) 49/2007 2 premises. The plaintiff applied for LPG gas connection in 1983 and was granted it on 11.11.1988; he also secured separate electricity connection for the said premises on 18.9.1989 and was paying charges. It is claimed that the plaintiff had got consumer card No. 033802, issued on 21.3.1995 which was later replaced by No. APL 11310472, issued on 1.10.2005. He and his family members were also issued photo identity cards on 21.1.1995 by the Election Commission of India.

4. The plaintiff alleges that the other portion of the Naraina property, measuring 128 sq. yards was constructed with joint family funds and Smt. Chawli Devi permitted the first defendant to occupy that portion. He further states that the said Smt. Chawli Devi used to live with the first defendant but since he did not take care of her properly, she started living with the plaintiff; she died on 24.11.2002.

5. The plaintiff alleges that after death of Smt. Chawli Devi and in view of his likelihood of getting possession of a flat in Ever Green Cooperative Group Housing Society, the first defendant started pressurizing him and creating situations whereby he could dispossess him (ie.the plaintiff) from occupation of his portion of the Naraina, plot. The plaintiff also avers that on 4.6.2004 the first defendant did attempt to dispossess him which resulted in the police being called and both parties being subjected to proceedings CS (OS) 49/2007 3 under Section 107/151 Criminal Procedure Code. The plaintiff in the meanwhile secured possession of the society flat where his son shifted to avoid conflicts and avoid adverse impact to his career prospects. It is claimed that the first defendant was quiet for a while but again started quarreling with the plaintiff and making illegal demands, including issuing legal notice on 1.12.2005 asking the plaintiff to vacate the portion of the Naraina property in his possession. This was resisted by the plaintiff in his reply notice dated 26.12.2005. On the basis of these averments, the plaintiff seeks a decree for partition and in the alternative prays declaration as well as decree for injunction.

6. In the written statement of the first defendant, the averments of the plaintiff have been generally denied. However, it is averred that the property at Janak Puri is ancestral property and the plaintiff as well as all defendants have 1/6th share each. The plaintiff's version about the circumstances whereby he occupied a portion of 32.[5] sq. yards in the Naraina plot are denied. The first defendant avers that the plaintiff has no right, title and interest and the is in permissive possession of the property as the first defendant allowed him to live there, for a short while. The plaintiff, however, did not vacate the property on one pretext or the other. The defendant also claims that the Naraina property is his self-acquired property CS (OS) 49/2007 4 and that the plaintiff is likely to secure possession of a flat in Ever Green Cooperative Group Housing Society.

7. The defendant denies the plaint averments regarding his allegedly pressurizing the plaintiff to vacate the premises at Naraina and the demands being made on his behalf through a legal notice as being incorrect.

8. This court by its order dated 29.8.2007 noticed that defendant Nos. 1 to 5 were being unrepresented on the previous two dates of hearing i.e. 12.7.2007 and 9.8.2007. Therefore, the said defendants were set down exparte. The court permitted the petitioner to file ex-parte evidence by way of an affidavit which he did, on 1.12.2007. The plaintiff was examined as PW 1 on 8.1.2008 and his affidavit was marked as Exh.PW 1/A.

9. In the affidavit which is supported by his oral testimony, the plaintiff has reiterated the contents of the plaint and deposed that all title documents of both the properties are in the power and possession of the first defendant. He further deposed that he constructed one room accomodation of 32 sq. yards in the Naraina property and later constructed another room on the first floor. According to him remaining portion of the property was constructed upon by his mother, the late Smt. Chawli Devi with joint family funds in 1988. The said late Smt. Chawli Devi lived with the first defendant in that portion. CS (OS) 49/2007 5 The plaintiff also deposed that he was in continuous and uninterrupted possession of the portion which was approximately 32 sq. yards.

10. In support of his claim for being in possession, the plaintiff marked certain documents such as Ex. PW ½, i.e. an Indane Customer Subscription Voucher issued by the Indian Oil Corporation; PW 1/3, a Bill/ Cash Memo dated 11.10.1988 issued in his favour, reflecting the premises at Naraina and PW 1/4 as well as PW 1/5 both dated 8.1.2008; they are bills issued by the erstwhile Delhi Electricity Supply Undertaking (DESU) for electricity charges paid in November and December, 1989. The plaintiff has also produced electricity bills issued by the North Delhi Power Limited dated 16.9.2006 and 19.10.2006 as PW 1/6 and PW 1/7; likewise telephone bills for different periods have been produced as PW 1/9, PW 1/10, PW 1/11 and PW 1/12. He has sought to mark photocopies of certain documents like the consumer/ration card valid for the period 2004 – 2009 and the photocopy of the identity card issued by the Election Commission; Ex. PW 1/17 is the copy of reply issued on behalf of the plaintiff to the first defendant's counsel, in reply to the latter's notice.

11. The following issues arise for consideration of this court:i ) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of partition of the suit properties or any part thereof CS (OS) 49/2007 6 and if so, what is his share; ii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a declaration that he has perfected his title by adverse possession in respect of the property being CB-311; iii ) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of permanent injunction of the claim; iv ) Relief. FINDINGS: Issue No. 1: Yes, one sixth share, in respect of the Jankpuri property. Issue No. 2: No Issue No. 3: No Issue No. 4: As indicated.

12. The pleadings in the suit and the written statement of the first defendant (as the other defendants did not file any written statement or even participate in the proceeding at any stage) disclose that the plaintiff and the first defendant both have no dispute about the nature of the Janakpuri property, and its status as a Hindu Undivided Family property. According to both of them, the said property was purchased by Smt. Chawli Devi. She CS (OS) 49/2007 7 however permitted the second defendant, the eldest son, to reside there, due to exigencies of a growing joint family. This is also deposed by the plaintiff. The plaintiff, however claims one third share in the properties, whereas the first defendant says that both of them are entitled to one sixth share each.

13. Now, the plaintiff’s claim for two thirds share in the Janakpuri property is premised on the basis that only male members of Chawli Devi’s family are entitled to the property. This however, overlooks the fact that the claim for partition has been made after 2005, i.e after the amendment to the Hindu Succession Act, which enables daughters to secure shares equal to sons in the HUF properties. Thus, Section 6, after the amendment, reads as follows: “ 6. Devolution of interest in coparcenary property:- (1) On and from the commencement of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, in a Joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshara law, the daughter of a coparcener shall, - (a) by birth become a coparcener in her own right the same manner as the son; (b) have the same rights in the coparcenary property as she would have had if she had been a son;

18,028 characters total

(c) be subject to the same liabilities in respect of the said coparcenary property as that of a son, and any reference to a Hindu Mitakshara coparcener shall be deemed to include a reference to a daughter of a coparcener: Provided that nothing contained in this sub-section shall affect or invalidate any disposition or alienation including any partition or testamentary disposition of property which had taken place before the 20th day of December, 2004. CS (OS) 49/2007 8 (2) Any property to which a female Hindu becomes entitled by virtue of sub-section (1) shall be held by her with the incidents of coparcenary ownership and shall be regarded, notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or any other law for the time being in force in, as property capable of being disposed of by her by testamentary disposition. (3) Where a Hindu dies after the commencement of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, his interest in the property of a Joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshara law, shall devolve by testamentary or intestate succession, as the case may be, under this Act and not by survivorship, and the coparcenary property shall be deemed to have been divided as if a partition had taken place and, - (a) the daughter is allotted the same share as is allotted to a son; (b) the share of the pre-deceased son or a pre-deceased daughter, as they would have got had they been alive at the time of partition, shall be allotted to the surviving child of such pre-deceased son or of such pre-deceased daughter; and

(c) the share of the pre-deceased child of a pre-deceased son or of a predeceased daughter, as such child would have got had he or she been alive at the time of the partition, shall be allotted to the child of such pre-deceased child of the pre-deceased so or a pre-deceased daughter, as the case may be. Explanation. - For the purposes of this sub-section, the interest of a Hindu Mitakshara coparcener shall be deemed to be the share in the property that would have been allotted to him if a partition of the property had taken place immediately before his death, irrespective of whether he was entitled to claim partition or not. (4) After the commencement of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, no court shall recognise any right to proceed against a son, grandson or great-grandson for the recovery of any debt due from his father, grandfather or great grandfather solely on the ground of the pious obligation under the Hindu law, of such son, grandson or great-grandson to discharge any such debt: Provided that in the case of any debt contracted before the commencement of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, nothing contained in this sub-section shall affect - (a) the right of any creditor to proceed against the son, grandson or great-grandson, as the case may be; or (b) any alienation made in respect of or in satisfaction of, any such debt, and any such right or alienation shall be enforceable under the rule of pious obligation in the CS (OS) 49/2007 9 same manner and to the same extent as it would have been enforceable as if the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 had not been enacted. Explanation. - For the purposes of clause (a), the expression "son", "grandson" or "great-grandson" shall be deemed to refer to the son, grandson or great-grandson, as the case may be, who was born or adopted prior to the commencement of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005. (5) Nothing contained in this section shall apply to a partition, which has been effected before the 20th day of December,2004 Explanation- For the purposes of this section "partition" means any partition made by execution of a deed of partition duly registered under the Registration Act, 1908 or partition effected by a decree of a court.”

14. Apart from the above legal provision, the plaintiff has not led any evidence showing that the Janakpuri or the Naraina properties were purchased out of joint family funds. Indeed as far as the Naraina property is concerned, the plaintiff has not been able to show any material, save his telephone, electricity bills and document relating to gas connection as well as copies of the ration card and election identity card in support of his claim. These documents at best dislose prima facie possession, no more. It is not even certain as to who owns the properties. The defendant had filed some copies of documents such as agreement to sell, power of attorney, etc favouring Chawli Devi which were not marked in evidence. Even they show that the Naraina plot was notified for acquisition under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act. In the above circumstances, the plaintiff is entitled only to a one sixth share in the Janakpuri property. CS (OS) 49/2007 10 Issue No. 2 and 3:

15. These issues can be considered conveniently. The second relief claimed by the plaintiff, is an alternative claim; it is a declaration that he has perfected title by adverse possession of the portion occupied by him, in the Naraina property. Any claim based on adverse possession of immovable property should successfully establish three elements; they were described by the Supreme Court, in In S. M. Karim v. Bibi Sakina (AIR 1964 SC 1254) in the following terms: "Adverse possession must be adequate in continuity, in publicity and extent and a plea is required at the least to show when possession becomes adverse so that the starting point of limitation against the party affected can be found." It is one of the cardinal rules that adverse possession is asserted against the owner. It cannot be set up against a co-sharer (see Mohammed Ali –vs- Jagadish Kalita 2004 (1) SCC 271 and Janaki Pandyani –vs- Ganeshwar Panda 2001 (10) SCC 434). The plaintiff has not established his claim regarding continuous hostile possession as against the defendant. The production of some bills issued in the late nineteen eighties, and two electricity bills issued in 2006, after the disputes arose between him and the first defendant, is not sufficient to return a finding of continuous and uninterrupted hostile possession. Besides, the ownership of the Naraina plot itself has not be shown. Even if it were assumed that the plaintiff established long and continuous possession, his CS (OS) 49/2007 11 claim, as appearing in the plaint is that the property belonged to the joint family and that the first defendant was a co-sharer, in possession of a different portion. This is a self-defeating averment, since there can be no adverse possession as between co-sharers. The issue has to be accordingly answered in the negative, against the plaintiff.

16. The plaintiff cannot claim a permanent injunction against the first defendant in respect of the Naraina property, because he has nowhere disclosed exclusive, uninterrupted and continuous possession of the portion of that property as alleged, independently of his averments. Yet, the pleadings of the defendant show that he does not deny the plaintiff’s occupation; he however characterizes it as permissive possession. While the true ownership of the property is a unclear and perhaps not discernable as it belongs to neither party, what can be gathered is that the first defendant admits to the plaintiff’s current possession. In these circumstances, the only relief that the plaintiff can be entitled to is an injunction against the first defendant not to disturb his occupation, except in accordance with law. However, this order cannot purport to bind the real owner or any public authority having title to the property. Such a party has not been impleaded in these proceedings; the decree will not bind it. CS (OS) 49/2007 12 Issue No. 4

17. In view of the above findings, the plaintiff is entitled to a preliminary decree declaring that he is entitled to one sixth share in the property bearing No. A-5/130, Janta Quarters, Janakpuri, New Delhi. All the defendants are likewise entitled to one sixth share each in the said property. The plaintiff is also entitled ot a decree of permanent injunction restraining the first defendant from dispossessing him from his occupation of the 32.[5] square yards of premises being CB-311, Naraina, Ring Road, New Delhi, save and except in accordance with law.

18. The suit is decreed in the above terms. No costs. DATED: (S. RAVINDRA BHAT) 8th February, 2008 JUDGE