Bishwanath Traders and Investment Ltd v. Sh. Ajay Kumar Singh & Anr

Delhi High Court · 10 Sep 2008 · 2008:DHC:478
Anil Kumar
WP(C) No.4902/2003
2008:DHC:478
labor appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, an employer must pay full wages to a workman during pendency of proceedings challenging reinstatement if the workman is unemployed and has filed an affidavit to that effect.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
WP(C) No.4902/2003
Date of Decision: 11.02.2008
# Bishwanath Traders and Investment Ltd ….…PETITIONER
! Through: Mr.A.K. Sukhija, Advocate.
VERSUS
$ Sh.Ajay Kumar Singh & Anr. ......... RESPONDENT
^ Through : Mr.S.P. Gautam, Advocate.
CORAM :-
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of Local papers may YES be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the reporter or not? NO

3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J. (Oral) * CM No.2506/2006 in W.P(C) No.4902/2003

1. This is an application filed by the respondent no.1/workman under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 seeking direction to the petitioner to make payment of wages to the respondent no.1 as per the minimum wages with effect from the date of the award being 23rd May, 2002 till date.

2. The respondent no.1/applicant contended that he was appointed with the petitioner firm on the consolidated salary of CM No.2506/2006 in W.P(C) No.4902/2003 2008:DHC:478 Rs.1300/- per month and his services were terminated on 14th March, 1992 and that despite best of his efforts he has remained unemployed since the date of his termination. The respondent no.1 further pleaded that the factum of his unemployment was also proved during his evidence before the Labor Court and that the petitioner has failed to prove the gainful employment of the respondent no.2 during trial. In the circumstances the respondent no.2 has claimed relief under section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

3. A reply has been filed by the petitioner/non-applicant that as the applicant has not worked for over 240 days immediately preceding the date of termination with the petitioner, therefore the provisions of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 would not be applicable and once this court reaches such a conclusion then the impugned award passed by the Labor Court would be a nullity and therefore the applicant is not entitled for any relief under section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Reliance was also placed on the cross examination of the respondent no.1 during trial to contend that the applicant has not worked for 240 days with the petitioner as in terms of his own statement no wages were received by the respondent no.1 till April 1991 and after 23rd December, 1991. The petitioner further contended that the applicant is not entitled for any relief under section 17 B since there is a delay of almost two years in filing the application, as the writ petition was filed on 4th August, 2003 and the application under section 17B was filed on 5th December, 2005. Regarding the unemployment of the respondent no.1 since the date of termination of his services the petitioner contended that being a computer expert it is not possible that the applicant has remained unemployed despite his best efforts as there is no dearth of employment. The petitioner argued that the respondent has suppressed the fact of his gainful employment. It is also contended that no proper valid affidavit has been filed in terms of section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act and thus the application under section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is not maintainable.

4. Section 17 B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 comes into operation when an Award directing reinstatement of a workman is assailed in further proceedings by the employer. Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act is as under:- "17-B. Payment of full wages to workman pending proceedings in Higher Courts. - Where in any case a Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal by its award directs reinstatement of any workman and the employer prefers any proceedings against such award in a High Court or the Supreme Court, the employer shall be liable to pay such workman, during the period of pendency of such proceedings in the High Court or the Supreme Court, full wages last drawn by him, inclusive of any maintenance allowance admissible to him under any rule if the workman had not been employed in any establishment during such period and an affidavit by such workman had been filed to that effect in such court: Provided that where it is proved to the satisfaction of the High Court or the Supreme Court that such workman had been employed and had been receiving adequate remuneration during any such period or part thereof, the Court shall order that no wages hall be payable under this section for such period or part, as the case may be."

5. The statute, therefore, requires satisfaction of the following four conditions for granting relief under section under section 17B of the Act:

(i) an Award by a Labour Court, Tribunal or National

(ii) during the pendency of such proceedings, employer is required to pay full wages to the workman;

(iii) the wages stipulated under Section 17B are full wages last drawn by him, inclusive of any maintenance allowance admissible to him under any Rule;

(iv) such wages would be admissible only if the workman had not been employed in any establishment during such period and an affidavit had been filed to such effect.

6. On satisfaction of the requisites as laid down under section 17B, the court is bound to grant relief to the workman in terms of the provision as laid down under section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The Court cannot go into the merits of the case/writ petition while deciding an application under section 17B of the Act as was held in 86 (2000) DLT 510=2000 (5) AD (Delhi) 413, Anil Jain v. Jagdish Chander. In para 7 of the said case, it was held as under: “7. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that respondent was never employed by the petitioner, that there was no employer-employee relation-ship between them, that the management was proceeded ex parte in the labour court due to the fault of its counsel, that the petitioner was a victim of some fraud and that the petitioner has a very good case in the writ petition and therefore the petitioner should not be directed to pay wages payable under Section 17-B. But while considering an application under Section 17-B of the I.D. Act this Court cannot go into the merits of the case in the writ petition. The application has to be considered strictly in terms of Section 17-B, irrespective of the merit of the writ petition. This Court can only consider whether the requirements mentioned in Section 17-B have been satisfied or not. If those requirements have been satisfied and if it has not been proved to the satisfaction of the Court that the workman had been employed and had been receiving adequate remuneration during the period of pendency of the writ petition, this Court has no option but to direct the employer to pay wages to the workman in terms of Section 17B, irrespective of the merit of the writ petition. As pointed out by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dena Bank Vs. Kritikumar T. Patel (supra) this Court cannot pass an order in exercise of the power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to deny to the workman the benefit granted under Section 17B of the I.D. Act, if he is entitled to such benefit in terms of the said section. The only favour that the employer can ask for is to expedite the disposal of the writ petition. Further granting relief under Section 17B of the Act and passing orders directing payment of wages last drawn, is generally the rule; refusing to grant relief under Section 17B is an exception, as the relief could be denied only in the rarest of the rare cases of jurisdictional error where there is no relationship of employer and employee between the parties.

7. The object underlying section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is to mitigate and relieve, to a certain extent, the hardship which would be caused to a workman due to delay in the implementation of an award directing reinstatement of his services on account of the challenge made to it by the employer. Section 17B recognizes a workman’s right to the bare minimum to keep the body and soul together when a challenge has been made to an Award directing his reinstatement as the statutory provisions provides no inherent right of assailing an order or an award by an industrial adjudicator by way of an appeal.

8. In the present case, by award dated 23rd May, 2002 the relief of reinstatement was granted to the workman which award has been assailed by the employer/petitioner and the operation of the same has been stayed by this Court. The workman has categorically averred in the application that he has not been employed since the date of termination of his services being 14th March, 1992 and has also filed affidavit deposing the same. Apart from bald denial the petitioner/non applicant has placed nothing on record to negate the factum of unemployment of the respondent/workman since the date of termination of their services. Merely on the presumption that there is no dearth of employment and being a computer expert the respondent no.1 could have easily got a job, the relief under section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 cannot be denied. The plea of the petitioner that the respondent has not filed a valid and proper affidavit is also unsustainable as no defect in the affidavit has been pointed out.

11,513 characters total

9. Whether the workman has worked with the petitioner for 240 days preceding the date of his termination and whether the award passed by the Labor Court is nullity and whether the provisions of Industrial disputes Act, 1947 are applicable, are issues which are to be adjudicated. Merely on the basis of submissions of the petitioner and on the ground that the petitioner has a good case on merit, the relief under section 17B cannot be denied to the workman. Also an application under Section 17B is to be disposed of expeditiously, before deciding the writ petition without going into the merits of the same. The Court while considering an application under Section 17B of the Industrial disputes Act, 1947 has only to consider whether the requisites mentioned therein have been satisfied. Adjudicating on these pleas would tantamount to deciding the petition on merits which is beyond the purview of section 17B of the Act. No limitation is provided for filing an application by the workman under secton 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Therefore the relief under section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 cannot be denied to the petitioner on the ground that the application was filed two years after the writ petition was filed by the petitioner.

10. The applicants/workmen, in the facts and circumstances, fulfills the criteria for availing the benefit under section 17B of the Act and in exercise of powers under Article 226 of the Constitution, if the requisites of Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 are satisfied, no order can be passed denying the workman the benefit of statutory provisions of Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act,

1947.

11. For the foregoing reasons, the application is allowed and the petitioner is directed to pay to the workman/applicant/respondent the last drawn wages or the minimum wages whichever is higher from the date of the award, i.e., 23rd May, 2002. Arrears of back wages or the minimum wages, whichever is higher, be paid within eight weeks. The management shall continue to pay last drawn or minimum wages, whichever is higher, by 10th of every month. The respondent is directed to file an undertaking that in case the writ petition is allowed, difference between the last drawn wages and the minimum wages shall be returned/repaid by the respondent within such time as may be given by this Court. The undertaking to this effect be filed within 2 weeks. With these directions the application is disposed of. W.P.(C) No.4902/2003 List for hearing on September 10, 2008. February 11th, 2008 ANIL KUMAR, J. 'Dev'