M/s Maharani Paints (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s R.R. Automotive Components Pvt. Ltd.

Delhi High Court · 11 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:484
Vipin Sanghi
CP No. 126 of 2006
2008:DHC:484
corporate appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that admitted unpaid debts after statutory notice justify winding up under Section 433(e) of the Companies Act, 1956, dismissing the respondent's contention that the petitions were disguised recovery suits.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CP No. 126 of 2006
Date of Decision: 11.02.2008 M/s Maharani Paints (India) Pvt. Ltd. ..... Petitioner
Through: Mr. Vikas Kakkar, Advocate
VERSUS
M/s R.R. Automotive Components Pvt. Ltd. ..... Respondent
Through: Mr.Ujjwal K. Jha, Advocate AND CP No. 127 of 2006
M/s C. Dass Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. ..... Petitioner
Through: Mr. Vikas Kakkar, Advocate
VERSUS
M/s R.R. Automotive Components Pvt. Ltd. ..... Respondent
Through: Mr.Ujjwal K. Jha, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
JUDGMENT

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? VIPIN SANGHI, J.(ORAL)

1. As both these petitions under Section 433(e) read with CP Nos.126 & 127 of 2006 2008:DHC:484 Section 434 of the Companies Act, 1956 (The Act) for winding up of the respondent company are based on the similar facts. I proceed to deal with them by this common order.

2. Both the petitioner companies are carrying on the businesses of manufacture and trade in all kinds of paints, thinner, varnishes, chemicals and chemical by-products of every nature and description, compounds, intermediates, derivatives and by-products thereof. It is claimed that the respondent company approached the petitioner companies in the year 1996 and 2000 respectively to procure primer, paint etc., from the petitioner companies. It is stated that the petitioner companies supplied the goods i.e. paints, primer etc., manufactured by them, to the respondent company vide the duly received bills, details whereof have been furnished in the respective petitions. The respondent company issued “STD-4” forms and declaration in favour of the petitioner companies. The goods supplied by petitioner in C.P. No.126/2006 was to the tune of Rs.1,57,633.96 paise and by the petitioner in C.P. No.127/2006 to the tune of Rs.3,58,376.55 paise. It is claimed that the respondent company has not paid the said amounts. Vide letter dated 15.02.2006 in C.P. No.126/2006 and a letter dated 01.03.2006 in C.P. No.127/2006, respondent has categorically admitted the outstanding amount due from the petitioners. This situation is also evident from the “STD-4” Form and declaration dated 11.02.2003 and 24.03.2005, respectively, in C.P. No.126/2006 and “STD-4” From bearing Nos.139 & 140 both dated 17.02.2003 in C.P. No.127/2006.

3. The legal notices, dated 02.03.2006 at page 58 in C.P. Nos.126/2006 and page 122 in C.P.No.127/2006, respectively, under Section 434 of the Act, were also served upon the respondent and duly received by them. The acknowledgments and the notices have been filed on record of both the petitioners. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the debts are admittedly outstanding.

4. On the other hand the contention of the respondent is that the present petitions have been filed for recovery of money in the garb of a winding up petition, just to put pressure on the respondent to shell out the amounts claimed by the respective petitioners and to save the court fee payable to the exchequer. Thus they are liable to be dismissed. Further it is averred that the petitioners have contradicted themselves by claiming amounts different from the petitions from those in the accounts presented by the petitioners. Also it was submitted before me that the rate of interest claimed by the petitioners is contrary to the provisions of Interest Act.

5. I have heard the counsel for both sides and perused the documents on record and I am of the view that the present is fit case for invoking the provision of Section 433(e) of the Act on the ground that the respondent company is unable to pay its debts.

6. The respondent's contention with regard to these petitions being a mere recovery suit in the garb of a winding up petition is not good in law, as it is an established and well settled principle of law that when a company fails to pay its dues despite the statutory notice under the Act, then winding up proceedings under Section 433(e) is a perfectly good remedy. Thus. the petitioners' actions are justified and not barred by the Act.

7. Another averment made on behalf of the respondent is that the debt is not proved, but a bare perusal of documents and admission of debt by the respondent vide various documents, proves beyond doubt that the respondent company is indebted to the respondent. STD-4 Forms and “BALANCE CONFIRMATION LETTERS” categorically state that the respondent is indebted to the petitioners. These documents are not disputed or denied by the Respondent, and the admitted principal liability is of Rs.1,35,633/- in CP No.126/2006 and Rs.3,56,556 in CP No.127/2006.

8. Learned counsel for the respondent has also contended that there is a dispute with regard to the actual amount of debt and petitioners have contradicted themselves by claiming different amounts at different stages. I am not satisfied with this argument as it is now well settled that even when the exact amount of debt is disputed then also the action of winding up under Section 433(e) of the Act is a justified one. See Devendra Kumar Jain vs. Polar Forgings & Tools Ltd. ( 1993) 1 CLJ 184 (Del).

9. Furthermore, the respondent has categorically admitted in his affidavit that the respondent company is going through a major crisis for the past two years. The service of notices upon the respondent is also not disputed.

10. In view of the above observations, I am satisfied that the respondent is indebted to the petitioners and it is unable to repay its admitted debts to the petitioners. Thus, the Petitions are admitted for hearing. A combined citation shall be published in the 'Statesman' (English) and 'Jansatta' (Hindi) for 13.6.2008. The Official Liquidator attached to this Court is appointed as the provisional liquidator, who shall take charge of the assets and records of the company. The petitioners in both the petitions shall jointly take steps for getting the citations published. The O.L shall also take immediate steps as per the aforesaid directions. List on 7.7.2008.

VIPIN SANGHI (JUDGE) February 11, 2008 aj