M/s. Atree Associates v. Delhi Development Authority & Anr.

Delhi High Court · 14 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:534
Vipin Sanghi
C.S. (OS) No. 2715/1995
2008:DHC:534
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court set aside parts of an arbitral award due to calculation errors and remanded claims for reconsideration, affirming limited judicial interference in arbitration awards and entitlement to escalation for delays caused by the respondent.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
C.S. (OS) No. 2715/1995
JUDGMENT
reserved on: 23.07.2007
Judgment delivered on: 14.02.2008 M/s. Atree Associates. ..... Plaintiff
Through: Mr. S.K. Chandwani, Advocate
versus
Delhi Development Authority & Anr. ..... Defendants
Through: Ms. Anusuya Salwan with Ms. Monika Sharma, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to Reporter or not? No

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? VIPIN SANGHI, J.

1. By this order I propose to dispose of the above suit, filed under Section 14 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 seeking a direction to the Arbitrator to file the award dated 20.10.1995 made by the sole Arbitrator and IA No.8784/1996 (objections to the Award filed by the petitioner) and IA No.12075/1996 (objections to the Award filed by the C.S. (OS) No. 2715/1995 2008:DHC:534 respondent).

2. The Petitioner had entered into an agreement with the Respondent No.1 for, inter alia, the balance work of construction of 288 LIG houses at Motia Khan including water supply, sanitary installations and internal development. Various disputes and differences arose between the parties and the same were referred to arbitration in terms of the arbitration agreement between the parties. The learned Arbitrator has rendered his award dealing with the 20 claims raised by the petitioner. The learned Arbitrator has awarded an amount of Rs.6,90,680/- with simple interest @ 12% p.a. from the date of the award till the date of the decree or actual payment, whichever is earlier. I.A. No. 8784/1996

3. This application has been filed by the Petitioner challenging the award in so far as claim Nos.4, 6, 7 and 12 (before the Arbitrator) are concerned. The material particulars of the project were as follows: Estimated Cost Rs.20,53,894 Tender Cost Rs.48,88,268 Date of start 10.01.1987 Stipulated date of completion 09.07.1987

4. The petitioner contends that though the work was to be completed within the period of six months, the same was prolonged due to delay on part of Respondent No.1 in allowing execution of work in certain blocks only. In spite of the delays being caused by the Respondent, the Respondent withheld various amounts due to the Petitioner in respect of contractual works and extra items carried out and unjust deductions/reductions were made by the respondent. Even damages on account of losses attributable to the breach(es) of the contract by the Respondent were not paid. Escalation costs payable under clause 10-C were also refused.

5. On 5.9.2002 the petitioner had contended that there were calculation mistakes in the award as far as claim 4 & 6 were concerned. Accordingly the court had asked the respondent to check up if there were calculation mistakes. I find on record a statement signed by the counsel for the respondent dated 01.04.2003 apparently in compliance of the direction of the Court containing fresh calculations. RE: CLAIM NO.4:

6. Claim No.4 for Rs.4,90,000/- was founded upon clause 10-C of the agreement. The contention of the claimant/plaintiff was that the period of completion was six months, which was too short considering that four storied structures were to be erected. This was deliberately so fixed to deny the contractor any claim under clause 10CC. The delay in completion was attributed to the respondent DDA. Between the date of award of the work. i.e. 31.12.1986 and during its prolongation, there were statutory increases in the minimum wages of labour w.e.f. 1.5.87, 16.3.1988, 1.5.1989, 1.2.1990, 1.8.1990 and 1.2.1991. These increases had not been paid by the DDA. The Arbitrator, on the basis of letter dated 20.01.1995, which reflected levy of compensation by the DDA from 27.01.1991 till 22.03.1993 concluded that prior to 27.1.1991 no compensation for delay was levied and therefore, the contractor was entitled to claim the statutory escalation in labour rates for that period. He therefore, allowed the claim of the claimant for Rs.2,09,828.84.

7. The grievance of the claimant is that the Arbitrator has disallowed the claim for Rs.66,898.16 on the basis of the statement (R-98) furnished by the Respondent wherein they had checked and verified the claims made by the claimant/contractor under clause 10C. The learned Arbitrator had ignored the errors and discrepancies committed by the said Respondent in making the calculations in R-98. The claimant has filed his detailed calculations as Annexure P-1 to the application reflecting the total amount that, according to him, should have been allowed as Rs.2,76,727.00

8. The statement dated 1.4.2003 handed over by the counsel for the respondent in pursuance to the directions issued by the court reflects that some calculation mistake has been made. It is stated that amount in respect of items No.8.6, 8.[7] and 9.[1] & 9.[2] has been omitted and if the same is included the total amount comes to Rs.2,15,883.53. Hence, calculation mistake is manifest. Due to the aforesaid error the award on claim No.4 is set aside and remanded back to the Arbitrator for checking the alleged calculation errors and discrepancies in R-98 and to recompute the amount admissible under clause 10C of the contract. RE: CLAIM NO.6

9. Claim No.6 pertains to a claim of Rs.80,000/- being the amount illegally withheld from the various running account bills due to non-sanctioning of the extra/substituted item for double scaffolding. The learned Arbitrator records that both parties agreed that extra item of double scaffolding etc had not been sanctioned. He rejected the respondents contention, that on the issue of the rates for this extra item the SE's decision was final, on the ground that the said extra item was not sanctioned and once the matter was already in arbitration, there was no question of the respondent sanctioning the same. He worked out the rate for double scaffholding at Rs.6.07 per sq. meter as opposed to the plaintiffs claim of Rs.19.56 per sq. meter, and therefore, held that over payment had been made to the plaintiff contractor and the amount of Rs.10,773/- was to be paid by the contractor. The grievance of the plaintiff is that the Arbitrator ignored the admitted rate of Rs.19.56 sq. meter in respect of the extra item of scaffholding which is to be found in exhibit R-88 and letters of Respondent No. 1 dated 21.05.1990 and 18.09.1993. It is also pointed out that while arriving at the awarded rate of Rs.6.07 per sq. meter the component of bandhani (rope) has been wrongly calculated, as instead of the schedule rate of '0.67', the Arbitrator has calculated the component at a rate of '0.067', which is an error and the award on this claim is liable to be set aside. It appears there is force in the submission of the petitioner. The Arbitrator appears to have committed a material error in calculating the component of bandhani (rope) by treating the rate per sq. meter as '0.067', though it ought to have been '0.67'. Therefore, the award is erroneous so far as Claim No. 6 is concerned, and it needs to be set aside and remanded back to the Arbitrator for recalculation. RE: CLAIM NO.7

10. Claim No.7 was made for Rs.10.50 lakhs on account of extra rate claimed from time to time due to rise in market rates due to prolongation of the contract beyond the stipulated date of completion.

11. The learned Arbitrator allowed this claim to the extent of Rs.37,355/-. The Arbitrator, while upholding the contention of the claimant that the delay was attributable to the Respondent and the claimant was entitled to increase as per clause 10-C of the contract, based his calculations on the CPWD cost index. Upto 30.11.1990, he holds nothing is payable. After providing for a reasonable increase of 10%, the learned Arbitrator worked out the increase at 33%. This increase in rates was applied in respect of 29.50% of the work, which translated to 9.735% increase. This was calculated at Rs.37,355/-.

12. The grievance of the claimant is that the Arbitrator while calculating the increase omitted the component of increase in the costs of bricks even though he specifically notes that the claimant would be entitled to an increase in the rates of the brick component before proceeding to calculate the increase. Furthermore, no reasons have been cited by the learned Arbitrator for rejecting the claim of increase for the period 15.8.1987 to 30.11.1990.

14,836 characters total

13. The grievance of the Petitioner as expressed in relation to Claim No.7 appears to be justified. The Arbitrator has disallowed the claim of increase in rates prior to 30.11.1990 on the basis that the CPWD rates did not undergo a substantial increase from 16.06.1987 onwards uptill 30.11.1990. However, on the face of the award this finding is erroneous. The learned Arbitrator has calculated the increase in the rates of various elements like sand aggregate, timber as follows: “The increase are on 16/6/87 5.97 + 8.26 + 26.11 = 40.34 This will be considered as base. From 1/11/89 5.87 + 6.77 + 28.25 1.36% = 40.89 From 30/10/89 5.57 + 7.34 + 28.67 3.07% = 41.58 From 30/11/90 6.58 + 9.80 + 41.31 = 57.69 57.69 40.34 = 43% increase”

14. This calculation shows an increase in the rates by 43%. While the Arbitrator may be right in observing that every contractor keeps some margin for increase in rates of 5 to 10%, in the present case, the increase upto 30.11.1990 worked out to 43%. It was, therefore, not proper to deny the increase in the rates upto 30.11.1990. From the aforesaid tabulation it appears that after 31.10.1989 there is a substantial jump in the rates. The base rate as on 16.06.1987 is calculated at 40.34. As on 31.10.1989 it is calculated at 41.58. However, the rate as on 30.11.1990 is calculated at 57.69. Therefore, in my view the petitioner contractor should have been allowed escalation after 31.10.1989.

15. From the award it is seen that the learned Arbitrator has observed that the contractor is entitled to increase in cost of bricks and wages of labour. However, from the calculation it is not clear whether the Arbitrator has omitted to take into account the increase in the cost of the bricks.

16. In view of the aforesaid, the award in relation to claim No.7 is set aside and the said claim is remanded back to calculate the increase in rates of the items, other than cement and steel and any other item issued from the stores, from 01.11.1989 onwards. The learned Arbitrator shall also specifically deal with the increase in the rates of bricks from 01.11.1989 onwards, to which the petitioner has been held to entitled. RE: CLAIM NO.12

17. Claim No.12 was made for Rs.8,10,000/- on account of payments claimed under clause 12A of the agreement, which states that maximum deviation in the work that can be ordered is upto 50%. The amount of any additional item not already included in the contract shall not exceed 10% of the deviation limit as per clause 12(vi) of the agreement. The overall deviation is Rs.24,44,134/- and 10% of the same comes to Rs.2,44,413. The Arbitrator found that the rates of various items, which were calculated at 55% above the quoted rates, were more or less constant till 30.11.1990. After calculating the deviation, keeping in mind the award already made on the other claims he admitted the claim of Rs.11,057/- only. The grievance of the Petitioner is that the Arbitrator ignored exhibit C-67 and wrongly took the contractor's enhancement at 149% above while dealing with this claim whereas earlier he had taken the same to be 138%.

18. As far as Claim No.12 is concerned, the reasoning adopted by the learned Arbitrator cannot be faulted with. He notes that deviation in the trade of brick works are in all items except for item in triangular shape. While discussion this claim, he observes as follows: “Claimant has demanded higher rates at 55% above quoted rates. This is brickwork and the claimant is Claim No.4 has claimed 10-C which will include elements of bricks labour etc. and its increase. The cement is issued at fixed rates. Thus elements of sand only will call for increase. As per award in Claim No.7 it will be seen that on 30/11/90 it is almost constant. At best the claimant would be entitled to get 10% which he was to absorb under 10-C i.e. 29.50 x 10% = 2.95% Therefore 374836 x 2.95% = 11057/- Respondent is to pay Rs.11,057/- against this claim to claimant.”

19. From the aforesaid, it is clear that the learned Arbitrator has taken note of the fact that the increase in the rates of bricks, labour etc. have already been considered under claim No.4. The contractor could not have asked for increase in the rates of any item twice over, once under clause 10C and again under clause 12 & 12A. However, since the date 30.11.1990 has been pushed back by me to 30.10.1989, while maintaining the basis and reasoning of the learned Arbitrator, this claim is also remanded back to the learned Arbitrator for recalculation.

20. IA No.8784/1996 is disposed off accordingly. I.A. No. 12075/1996

21. This application contains the objections raised by the Respondent No.1 against the award. Ground No. A to D are formal objections which have no substance and are therefore outrightly rejected. The arbitrator after hearing the contentions of the parties and going through the documents exhibited concluded that even upto August, 1989 the respondent were in a state of indecision as to foundation shaft for block 27, though the SE had stopped work in November, 1987. This was but an act to prevent the contractor from carrying out his contractual obligations, which saddled the claimant with increased operational cost. Once the Arbitrator has decided on merits that the delay was attributable to the Respondent, this court cannot go into that issue in these proceedings. Therefore, the objections of the respondent in relation to award in respect of claims No.4,[7] and 9 are also liable to be rejected. As far as claim No.10 and 12 are concerned, the respondent has again tried to challenge the calculations of the Arbitrator as wrong without substantiating how the Arbitrator has erred in making the calculations. These grounds are, therefore, also devoid of any merits.

22. I have also gone through the remaining objections and the award. These objections are also based on merits and seek to challenge the finding of facts of the Arbitrator and the counsel for the Respondent has not been able to point out any error apparent on the face of the record, as far as the award is sought to be challenged in these objections.

23. In view thereof I.A. No. 12075/1996 is dismissed as devoid of any merits.

24. The award is, therefore, set aside in relation to claim Nos.4, 6, 7 and 12 and the reference remanded back to the learned Arbitrator to reconsider the said claims in the light of the observations contained hereinabove. The remaining award is made a 'Rule' of the Court and a decree is passed in terms thereof. The plaintiff shall be entitled to interest @ 12% per annum on the principal amount from the date of the award till the date of actual payment. Parties are left to bear their respective costs. (VIPIN SANGHI) February 14, 2008 JUDGE P.K. BABBAR