Indu Video Films v. Delhi Financial Corporation

Delhi High Court · 14 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:539
S. Ravindra Bhat
CS(OS) 1824/1992
2008:DHC:539
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court directed the plaintiff to pay Rs. 14.5 lakhs as full settlement of a disputed loan recovery claim, adjusting interest due to delayed disbursement and sealing of premises, and ordered release of mortgage documents upon payment.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Date of Decision: February 14, 2008.
CS(OS) 1824/1992
INDU VIDEO FILMS ..... Plaintiff
Through: Plaintiff in person.
VERSUS
DELHI FINANCIAL CORPORATION ..... Defendant
Through: Mr. Sanjiv Kakra with Mr.Atul Kumar, Advocates for D-1 with Mr. A.M.
Goyal, G.M (CA)
CORAM:
MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat (Open Court)

1. The plaintiff seeks a declaration against defendant No.1 – Delhi Financial Corporation (hereinafter referred to as `DFC') declaring that it has no right to recover the principal or interest on amount advanced or on the balance amount to be released i.e., the sum of Rs.11 lacs. A consequential decree for injunction has been claimed against the DFC directing them to release the balance sanctioned amount to the plaintiff and to open the seal of the CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 1 of 12 2008:DHC:539 premises No. A-9, Okhla Industrial Area, Phase-I, New Delhi and not proceed further pursuant to the notice under Section 29 of the State Financial Corporation of India, 1952 (hereinafter referred to as `Act).

2. The plaintiff was sanctioned a term loan for purchase of machinery, for the purpose of execution of contract with the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting. The plaintiff was registered as a small scale industry. It is claimed that the plaintiff had sought financial assistance on 17.11.1986 from the DFC to the extent of Rs.34,85,000/-. He was to arrange a share capital of Rs.12 lacs and a deposit of Rs.1,35,000/-. It is further alleged that the plaintiff company arranged the share capital of Rs.13,61,000/- and deposited amounts to the tune of Rs.1,61,000/-.

3. The parties entered into a Mortgage Deed by which residential property at Malviya Nagar was secured to DFC. The parties agreed that the machinery and equipment, installed in the Okla premises were to be hypothicated. The mortgaged amount was Rs.33,20,000/- and in terms of the deal it was to be returned in 16 installments commencing from 01.08.1988; the last installment was payable on 01.05.1992.

4. The plaintiff alleges that the entire amount was not released and that even out of the sum of Rs.22,80,000/-, Rs.12,61,400/- was released to the Punjab National Bank on CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 2 of 12 26.8.1987, for the purchase of equipment from Gujarat Communications & Electronics Limited but it could be used for a considerable period. The plaintiff further alleges that on 27.08.1987 it deposited Rs.3,45,588.92 with the Gujarat Communication & Electronics Ltd. towards 25% advance for booking the equipment.

5. It is claimed that the defendant proceeded to take action under Section 29 of the Act, without notice, arbitrarily sealed the premises and took over possession on 17.07.1987 within 1½ months of its inauguration. The Punjab National Bank is alleged to have suspended further working capital on 09.12.1987 and the plaintiff at that time had availed the credit facilities only to the tune of Rs.2.[2] lacs. It is alleged that the action taken by the defendant resulted in considerable loss and the plaintiff was unable to go ahead with its business and commercial activities.

6. The plaintiff avers, in some detail about the paucity of funds and also appointment of a technical expert by DFC to look into various aspects. According to the plaintiff the said expert had recommended release of the balance sanctioned funds for purchase of the equipment. In para 30 the plaintiff has given details about its inability to purchase 22 items of equipment for which the Agreement/Mortgage Deed was entered into. On 03.10.1991 a notice was issued by the defendant threatening to take possession of the CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 3 of 12 unit. The plaintiff alleges that the defendant committed defaults right from the inception and he was, therefore, deprived of all the funds at the relevant time. Therefore, the decree for declaration and injunction has been sought for having claim.

7. In the written statement the defendant has denied the material averments. It alleges about disbursing amounts released by the Industrial Development Bank of India and the Small Industries Development Bank of India. The plaintiff had been sanctioned Rs.33.20 lacs for which a Mortgage Deed was executed. According to the defendant the plaintiff breached the agreement right from the inception and did not pay the installments in time. In these circumstances, it is claimed that a show cause notice under Section 29 was issued on 19.12.1988 itself. The defendant also avers that the plaintiff requested for deferment of the installment by one year on the condition that he undertook to remit a sum of Rs.75,000/- per month from December, 1989. It is alleged that this arrangement and terms of the agreement too was defaulted. According to the defendant the outstanding amounts due from the borrowers as on 01.11.1991, was Rs.40,93,711.46 and as on the date of filing of the written statement the total sum due exceeded Rs.46 lakhs. It, therefore, justifies the action and further state about issuance of a notice under Section 29 on 24.12.1992. The defendant filed a criminal complaint alleging that CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 4 of 12 the plaintiff was guilty of committing offences under Section 406.

8. During the pendency of these proceedings the entirety of the principal amount due and disbursed to the plaintiff was repaid. This fact was noticed on 29.07.1993 when the statement of the plaintiff's Managing Director was recorded, evidencing repayment of Rs.[5] lacs. On 24.09.1993 the following order was recorded:- "Learned counsel for the parties submit that payment with regard to principal amount has already been made by the plaintiff to the defendant. The premises have been desealed and have been handed over to the plaintiff. Learned counsel for the defendant submits that one vehicle has already been released to the plaintiff. Learned counsel for the plaintiff further submits that the plaintiff has disposed of the machinery and thereafter made the payment of the principal amount. Learned counsel further submits that the plaintiff undertakes not to dispose of the immovable property mortgaged in favour of the defendant- Corporation, till the disposal of the suit. It may, however, be clarified that the arrangement arrived at between the parties is without prejudice to rights and contentions of the parties. Learned counsel for the defendant also submits that the defendant-Corporation will not take any coercive steps during the pendency of this suit. Learned counsel for the parties also agree that they should be permitted to lead evidence by way of affidavits. Let the affidavits on behalf of the plaintiff be filed within three months. Courter-affidavit within two months thereafter. List the suit for further proceedings on 16th March, 1994."

9. The plaintiff has filed several affidavits pursuant to the liberty granted in the above order. Thereafter the parties were attempting to arrive at a mutually acceptable compromise. This is clear from CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 5 of 12 several orders made between 2005 and 2007. On 06.12.2007 also this Court recorded that the parties were negotiating for a compromise. This Court after considering the submissions had directed the presence of the Managing Director of the first defendant: that order was later suspended and the General Manager (Accounts) was required to be present in Court. Pursuant to that order, dated 29.01.2008, the defendant has filed an application along with certain calculations.

10. Learned counsel for the defendant relied on the calculations submitted in Court. He states that the proposal was made on the basis of a one time settlement formula which existed in 2005. That proposal acknowledged the payment of Rs.18,13,065/- by the plaintiff shown as received, the balance sum due from the plaintiff on account of the one time settlement formula by the Board of DFC is disclosed at Rs.17,79,203.99. This includes 13.5% compound interest (in accordance with the scheme) till the date the advance was declared as a doubtful non performing asset. The DFC claims to have added a simple interest from 01.08.1991 to 09.03.1992.

11. The plaintiff, on the other hand, urged that as the unit could not become operational due to the sealing and issuance of show cause notice on three occasions, which had an adverse impact on its viability and the lack of credit and working capital from the Punjab National CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 6 of 12 Bank as well as the fact that the sum of Rs.12.61 lacs was not available for the period of 14 months, the defendants cannot now seek to make a premium from their wrongs. It is submitted that in order to repay the dues the unit and the machinery was sold after seeking permission of the Court, a fact recorded in the present proceeding. In these circumstances, the plaintiff submitted that he is willing to settle the entire dispute by paying Rs.12 lacs.

12. Learned counsel for the defendant submitted that the one time settlement scheme was in vague in 2005 and applicable to the defendant till 30.11.2005; this fact was within the knowledge of the plaintiff. However, the offer of settling the entire dispute was for paying Rs. 17.[7] lacs which was not availed. Learned counsel placed reliance on the extract of the account and submitted that due credit was given to all the payments made by the plaintiff and necessary interest, which had to be duly reflected in the books. According to the account, a sum of Rs.17,42,588.32 has been shown as received towards principal and Rs.5,40,476.68 has been shown as adjusted towards the interest.

15,447 characters total

13. Counsel submitted that in terms of the agreement the plaintiff was duty bound to repay amounts in accordance with the schedule prescribed. The DFC could not be faulted although it released a sum in excess of Rs.22 lakhs by the stipulated period on 19.08.1988. In CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 7 of 12 these circumstances, there was nothing arbitrary in the action taken. Counsel submitted on instruction that although one time settlement offer was closed on 13.11.2005, having regard to the over all conspectus of facts, this Court may take an appropriate decision as to the final order to be made since the issue pertains to the rate of interest to be paid during the pendency of the proceedings.

14. It is evident from the above narration of facts and discussion that the parties agreed to the terms whereby a sum of Rs.33 lacs was payable to the plaintiff. It is not in dispute that of the entire sum of Rs.33 lacs for which the repayment schedule was made only 6 installments were disbursed. The total sum actually disbursed i.e. Rs.22,80,000/- was paid to the plaintiff in the following terms:- (1) 11.08.1987 - 1,94,000/- (2) 26.08.1987 - 12,61,400/ (PNB)14months disbursed later (3) 29.07.1987 - 2,10,200/- (4) 26.02.1988 - 3,65,895/- (5) 13.07.1988 - 1,68,505/- (6) 01.08.1988 - 80,000/-

15. It has not been disputed that the sum of Rs.12,61,400/- was not made available by the DFC to the plaintiff. That was deposited with the Punjab National Bank which apparently made the amount available to the plaintiff after 14 months from the date of its being CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 8 of 12 kept in its account i.e. 26.08.1987. There is nothing in the Mortgage Deed indicating that the amount would not be made available to the plaintiff but could be disbursed to the bank, to be released later. In the circumstances, what emerges is that at the relevant time,i.e., till August 1988 or so the plaintiff was, in fact, able to secure only a sum of Rs.10 lacs. However, in terms of the obligations cast upon him in the Mortgage Deed the repayment schedule became operative and also the interest has started ticking as agreed by the parties i.e. 17.5% compoundable with quarterly installment rests. If one takes into account the further circumstance that the plaintiffs' unit was sealed admittedly on three occasions before the suit was filed, his plight is understandable.

16. As noticed earlier, the plaintiff sold the unit and repaid the entire amount. Therefore, the narrow question which this court has to deal with in the present case is the rate of interest and the amount to be paid to the defendant. The defendant, no doubt, had indicated at one stage that if the plaintiff was willing to accept a one time settlement, it would settle the entire dispute for Rs.17.79 lacs. That offer apparently existed only upto 30.11.2005. The plaintiff, on the other hand, was willing to accept the offer but wanted to pay only Rs.12 lacs.

17. Now it is clear that at one stage the defendant was willing to CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 9 of 12 settle the dispute, the plaintiff too wanted to settle it. The only difference between the two was to the extent of Rs.5,57 lacs. On the account submitted by the defendant in support of the application (i.e. I.A. No. 1741/2008) the details of the principal and interest accruing on the advance has been disclosed. According to this statement, the total amount repaid by the plaintiff works out to Rs.22,83,065/-. This has been submitted by the defendant in the following manner:- (1) Principal - Rs.17,2,588.32 (2) Interest - Rs.5,40,476.68

18. The parties are agreed that lump sum amounts were deposited by the plaintiff. The defendant cannot be entirely blamed in splitting the amount received and reflecting part of them towards interests yet in the peculiar circumstance of this case such accrual in the opinion of the Court resulted in prejudice of the plaintiff. The plaintiff had requested for postponement of the repayment schedule and said that it should commence from 1989.

19. In the final extract of the accounts enclosed as Annexure – B, to the application the amount received has been shown as Rs.18,13,065/-. This figure varies with the figure mentioned in the detailed statement which is Rs.22,83,065/-. Therefore, the matter can be resolved by giving due credit to the repayment made as if the same were adjusted against the principal amount. In view of these CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 10 of 12 circumstances and peculiar facts, the Court, while not commenting on the calculations, is of the opinion that to suitably reduce the liability of the plaintiff, the defendant cannot be compelled to accept Rs.12 lacs which is now being offered. In the circumstances, having regard to the above factors, the plaintiff should be granted relief upon paying the sum of Rs.14.[5] lakhs. The defendant in my opinion should accept the same and reflect that the liabilities of the plaintiff are closed.

20. In view of the above discussion, the suit is decreed in the following terms:- (1) The plaintiff shall pay to defendant No.1 a sum of Rs.14.[5] lakhs in full and final settlement of the disputes which are subject matters of this suit within a period of three months. In such event, the amount so paid shall be deemed to be in full settlement of the defendant's entitlement, and are declared to be so. (2) In case, the plaintiff defaults in paying amounts as indicated in direction (1) above, the defendants are free to take action in accordance with law and enforce their rights under the Mortgage Deed, for recovery of the above amount, with interest at 12% per annum. CS(OS) No. 1824/1992 Page No. 11 of 12 (3) The defendant shall upon receipt of the amounts as directed by this Court, release the title deeds in accordance with law and other terms of the mortgaged deed lying with it to the plaintiff. The suit is decreed in the above terms.

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J