Full Text
Date of Reserve: 25.1.2008
Date of Order: 21.02.2008 IA Nos.12971/2006, 3489/2007, 4329/2007 and 6258/2007 in
CS(OS) No. 1639/2006 & Counter Claim No.2330/2006.
M/s. Hindustan Sanitaryware & Industries Ltd. ... Plaintiffs and another
Through: Mr.D.S. Chauhan & Ms.Ruchi Singh,Advocates
& for defendants No.1 & 2 in Counter Claim
Through:Mr.Bishwajit Bhattacharya,Sr.Advocate with
Mr.S.N.Relan for D-1 & 2 in suit & plaintiff in CC.
Mr.Manmohan,Sr.Adv. With Mr.Tejas Karia, for D-4 in CC
JUSTICE SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not ?
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest ? ORDER: IA No.12971/2006 By this application(I.A.No.12971/2006) made by defendants No.1 & 2 under Order 1 Rule 10(2) read with section 151 CPC, defendants have sought striking out the name of Ms H.A. Daruwalla as defendant No.2 for being improperly joined & not being a necessary party and to add the name of Danske Bank, Odense, Denmark as a necessary party. It is stated in the application that plaintiffs filed a suit for the recovery of Rs.20,03,220/- as damages against defendants No.1 & 2 allegedly causing delay of 34 days in affording credit for proceeds of USD 4400 remitted by defendant No.3 from Denmark to the account of plaintiff No.1. Defendant filed a written statement and also filed a Counter Claim claiming Rs.10 crores as damages alleging in the Counter Claim that plaintiffs No.1 & 2 (defendants No.1 & 2 in counter claim) have deliberately and mischievously damaged the image of defendant No.1 by making 2008:DHC:638 Euro Partner, Denmark and/or Danske Bank, Denmark. The mischievous effort on the part of plaintiffs No.1 & 2 has been to circulate defamatory averments against defendant No.1(plaintiff in the counter claim) before an International audience. The intention of plaintiffs No.1 & 2 was mala fide and it was only to defame the defendant No.1 (plaintiff in the Counter Claim) before an International audience. It is also stated that plaintiffs No.1 & 2(defendants in the counter claim) gave access to the documents containing downright false, mischievous and defamatory averments against defendant No.1(plaintiff in the Counter Claim) in Denmark to defendant No.3 and there was a collusion between the plaintiffs and common intention was to falsely pass on the blame for a delayed foreign inward remittance amounting to USD 4400 to the plaintiff and to bail out defendant No.3 and/or Denske, Denmark.
2. It is stated that Denske Bank, Denmark was a necessary party and therefore, should be impleaded as a defendant to the suit. IA No.4329/2007
3. The second application I.A. No.4329/07 under Order 1 Rule 10(2) read with section 151 CPC is by defendant No.4 i.e. for striking out the name of defendant No.4 i.e. Danske Bank, from the Counter Claim. The contention of Danske Bank is that Danske Bank was neither a necessary party nor a party against whom any relief has been claimed nor any allegations have been made against defendant No.4 in the Counter Claim. Therefore, the defendant No.4 was not a necessary party and has been wrongly impleaded as a party.
4. Brief facts relevant for the purpose of deciding these two applications are that in Suit No.1369/2006 plaintiffs filed a claim making Central Bank of India and its Chairperson & Managing Director as defendants No.1 & 2 and Managing Director, M/s Euro Partners as defendant No.3. This suit was filed for the recovery of Rs.20,03,220/- as damages against defendant No.1 and 2 i.e. Central Bank of India and its were sought on the ground that Central Bank of India had acted negligently in not remitting the amount of USD 4400 to the foreign buyer i.e. defendant No. 3 in accordance with the instructions issued by the plaintiffs. It is stated that defendant No.1 raised proforma invoice dated 20.10.2005 upon M/s Euro Partner APS for net balance of USD 4400. Defendant No.3 instructed Danske Bank, the bankers of its company to remit USD 4400 to plaintiff No.1 to be credited in the account through defendant No.1 against the invoice. The said remittance was made electronically through corresponding bank & was almost instantaneous. The remittance should reached to defendant No.1 not later than 28.10.2005. The delivery of goods was to take place to defendant No.3 only after the receipt remittance. It is stated that defendant No.1 had been negligent and did not trace the amount remitted by defendant No.3 and due to this, the plaintiffs more particularly plaintiff No.2 suffered personal humiliation, discredit ill-repute and allegations of dishonesty at the hands of defendant No.3. The plaintiff has enumerated the facts to plead that it was defendant No.1 which was solely liable for the humiliation suffered at the hands of defendant No.3 and hence the suit.
5. Defendant No.1 in turn filed counter claim as already stated.
6. It is apparent from the pleadings of the plaintiffs and defendant No.1 in the Counter Claim that plaintiffs in CS No.1639/2006 have wrongly made Chairperson & Managing Director of defendant No.1 as a party. Chairperson & Managing Director never acted in the personal capacity while corresponding to the plaintiffs. She was acting on behalf of the bank and it would be the bank and bank alone who would be liable, if proved for the damages. Only that person is a necessary party in a suit, without whose presence a substantial decree cannot be made or without whom a claim cannot be legally settled by the Court.
7. The Chairperson in this case is not a necessary party since claims against the bank can be settled in his absence as well. I, therefore, 2 for deleting the name of Ms. H.A. Daruwalla from array of parties in CS No.1639/2006. However, defendant No.1 is a necessary party since damages have been claimed from defendant No.1. I find no force in the application of defendant Nos.[1] & 2 that Danske Bank was a necessary party either in the plaint or in the Counter Claim. A plaintiff has a right to chose as to against whom he has to make the claim and what would be the nature of claim. A plaintiff can give up a part of the claim and can also give up some of the defendants. It is a liberty given to the plaintiff under law and therefore, the plaintiff cannot be compelled to make somebody as a defendant when plaintiff does not want to claim any relief from that person. It would be for the defendant in a suit to show that no case was made out against him. It is not for the defendant to show that the case was made out against some other person. I, therefore, consider that the application (I.A.No.12971/2006) made by defendants Nos.[1] & 2 in CS No.1639/06 for making Danske Bank, a necessary party is not maintainable and is hereby dismissed.
8. In the counter claim filed by defendant No.1 Bank registered as CC-2330/06, Central Bank of India has made allegations of defamation against defendants No.1 & 2(plaintiffs in suit). The contention of the Central Bank of India is that defendants No.1 & 2 wanted to bail out defendants No.3 & 4. Assuming this to be correct bailing out defendants No.3 & 4 is not an offence, neither gives any rise to claim in favour of Central Bank of India. Since Central Bank of India's counter claim is for damages because of defamation done by defendants No.1 & 2 by defamatory pleadings and circulating pleadings and documents before the International audience, and no allegations have been made against defendant No.4 in respect of any defamation or circulating any letter or document making any defamatory averments, I consider in order to decide counter claim of Central Bank of India, Danske Bank is not a necessary party. the name of Danske Bank, defendant No.4 is deleted from the array of parties in the counter claim filed by defendants.
10. Let amended memo of parties be filed by defendant No.1(plaintiff in the counter claim)and the plaintiffs in the suit. IA Nos.6258/2007 and 3489/2007 In view of allowing the application being IA No.4329/07 of defendant No.4 & defendant No.4 having been deleted from the array of parties, these applications have become infructuous and disposed of as such. CS(OS) No.1639/2006 List the suit before the Joint Registrar for admission/denial, if any and for completion of pleadings on 27th March, 2008. Thereafter it be listed before Court for framing of issues on 8th July, 2008 February 21, 2008.
SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA, J. v