Union of India v. Ashok Kumar Misra & Ors

Delhi High Court · 15 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:564-DB
A.K. Sikri; Vipin Sanghi
W.P. (C) No.4925/1999
2008:DHC:564-DB
administrative appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The High Court held that while daily wagers performing higher duties are entitled to corresponding salary, they cannot claim regularisation without following statutory recruitment rules, overruling the Tribunal's direction for regularisation.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P. (C) No.4925/1999
Dated: 15.02.2008 Union of India ......Petitioner
Through: Mr. A.K. Bhardwaj, Advocate.
VERSUS
Sh. Ashok Kumar Misra & Ors. ......Respondents
Through: Mr. S.M. Garg, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.K.SIKRI
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
JUDGMENT

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to Reporter or not? No

3. Whether the judgment should be reported No in the Digest? VIPIN SANGHI,J. (ORAL)

1. The petitioner, Union of India has challenged the order dated 28.09.1998 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (the Tribunal) in O.A. No.440/1995 filed by the respondents under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act (the Act). By the impugned order, the Tribunal has allowed the aforesaid OA and issued directions to the petitioner to pay to the respondents, salary and other allowances payable to regular Clerks/Enquiry Clerks to the respondents for the period that they have W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 1 of 11 2008:DHC:564-DB shouldered their responsibility of the higher post. A further direction was issued to the petitioners that they shall consider regularising the services of the respondents as Clerks/Enquiry Clerks against the vacancies available strictly in terms of the seniority and fulfillment of other conditions for such promotion. According to the Tribunal, though employees like Beldars and Chowkidars would have their normal promotion as Plumbers and Masons. However, the Tribunal holds that the respondents having acquired vested rights for consideration for regularisation as Clerks because they have been working in that capacity over a decade.

2. Between the years 1975 to 1983, the respondents were taken in employment as Daily Wagers as Beldars/Chowkidars. Admittedly the respondents were discharging the duties of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks till February, 1995. The respondents were paid salary due to Beldars/Chowkidars though working as Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. The respondents filed the aforesaid original application before the Tribunal contending that they were entitled to be paid the salary and allowances as admissible to Clerks/Enquiry Clerks, since they had been discharging duties as Clerks/Enquiry Clerks for over 8 to 10 years. It was also their case that they were entitled to be regularised in the posts of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks, which were being manned by them. The Tribunal, as aforesaid, has allowed this petition, which is now challenged before us by the Union of India. W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 2 of 11

3. The submission of the petitioner is that the promotion from the post of Beldar is to the post of Mate/Asstt. Painter etc. subject to the availability of vacancies and as per seniority-cumsuitability. The promotion from the post of Chowkidar is made to the post of LDC in 10% quota subject to the condition that the incumbent is matriculate and he qualifies in the examination held for promotion. The petitioner contends that in terms of OM dated 26.10.1990, there is a complete ban on engagement of casual workers for performing the duties of Group-C post. Post of Clerk/Enquiry Clerk is a Group-C post. The further submission of the petitioner is that the respondents were performing the duties of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks voluntarily and with a view to avoid the manual labour that Beldars/Chowkidars are required to perform. In the absence of any order issued by any authority requiring the respondents to work as Enquiry Clerks/Office Clerks, the respondents could not claim equal the salary as that of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. There are statutory rules prescribed for recruitment to the post of LDC, which have not been followed in respect of the respondents. No regular appointment could be made to the posts of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks except in accordance with the rules. The petitioner relies on the Constitution Bench decision of the Supreme Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka & Ors. Vs. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1. In this decision, the Supreme Court has held that unless the appointment is in terms of the relevant rules, and W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 3 of 11 after a proper selection process from amongst qualified persons, the same would not confer any right on the appointee to seek regularisation of his services. If it is a contractual appointment, the appointment comes to an end at the end of the contractual period, and if it were an engagement or appointment on daily wages or casual basis, the same would come to an end when it is discontinued. The Supreme Court in this case has also held that employees appointed as daily wagers could not be directed by the Courts to be paid wages equal to the salary and allowances that are being paid to regular employees of the cadre performing similar work in Government service from the dates from which they were respectively engaged or appointed. The petitioner has further argued that there is no provision for regularising on Group-C post. Appointment of Group-C posts is made in accordance with the statutory rules. Learned counsel for the petitioner relies on paragraphs 34 to 36 of the judgment in Umadevi (supra), wherein the Supreme Court has held that unless the appointment is in terms of the relevant rules, and after a proper competition amongst qualified persons the same would not confer any right on the appointee. The petitioner has also relied on an early decision of the Supreme Court in Union of India & Anr. Vs. Moti Lal & Ors. ATJ 1996 (1) 625, wherein the Supreme Court has held that it is not permissible to appoint a person directly as a “Mate”, as it is only a temporary post W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 4 of 11 of “Gangman” and “Keyman”. These “Gangmen” and “Keymen” can be promoted to the post of “Mate”, subject to their suitability and efficiency being tested through a trade test. In that case, the respondents had been appointed directly as Casual “Mates” and they continued as such, and by virtue of their continuance they even acquired temporary status. However, the Supreme Court held that the said temporary status itself does not entitle them to be regularised as “Mates”, since it would be contrary to the rules in force.

4. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent has relied on an Office Memorandum dated 09.09.1999. He further submits that following an arbitration award dated 31.01.1988 and recategorisation and re-clarification of the work charge established staff of CPWD, which was modified by this Court vide orders passed in CCP Nos.87/1997 and 106/1997 etc., the petitioners had re-categorised certain workmen, including work charge Beldars performing the duty of Enquiry Clerks, if they were matriculates, as “semi-skilled' and their pay scale was revised to the pay scale of LDC in CPWD. For all practical purposes, they were treated as Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. Learned counsel for the respondent also relies on the Tribunal's decision dated 05.05.1993 in the case of Ram Nath Singh Vs. Union of India, the Special Leave Petition against which, filed by the petitioner herein, has been dismissed by the Supreme Court. In Ram W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 5 of 11 Nath Singh (supra) the Tribunal had held that the petitioners therein were entitled to be considered for regularisation in accordance with the circular dated 04.07.1988. In that case as well, the petitioner herein was directed to consider the case of Ram Nath Singh and other applicants before the Tribunal for regularisation in the higher grade namely Clerk/Enquiry Clerk on the footing that they had rendered 240 service days each in two consecutive years.

5. In his rejoinder the submission of the counsel for the petitioner is that in Umadevi (supra) the Supreme Court has declared and clarified that those decisions, which run counter to the principle settled in the said decision namely Umadevi (supra), or in which directions running counter to what has been held by the Supreme Court in that decision will stand denuded of their status as precedents. Therefore, he submits that the decision of the Tribunal in Ram Nath Singh (supra), against which the Special Leave Petition was dismissed in limine cannot be relied upon by the respondents to their advantage. It is further argued that the reliance placed by the respondents on OM dated 09.09.1999 is also misplaced since on the face of it the said OM was applicable in respect of workers, who were in the rolls of CPWD on 01.01.1981 and was not applicable to any kind of daily rated workers. He submitted that so far as the respondents are concerned except respondent No.3 (Gaur Singh), respondent No.2 (Nikko Kumar) and respondent No.4 (Raj Kumar), none of the W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 6 of 11 respondents were working in CPWD as daily wagers. Even respondent Nos.2, 3 & 4 were working as on 01.01.1981 as daily wagers only. Respondent No.3 had subsequently been regularised as Chowkidar as on 01.01.1981. He further submitted that after January, 1995, none of the respondents worked as Enquiry Clerk and as on 09.09.1999, the date of issuance of the said OM, the respondents were not working as Enquiry Clerks. He also argues that the said OM does not provide for regularisation and merely provides that those who performed the work as Enquiry Clerk should be classified as semi-skilled. However, since on 09.09.1999, the respondents were not discharging duties as Enquiry Clerks, there was no question of their being classified as semi-skilled. On this aspect as well, he relied on Umadevi (supra), particularly para 5 thereof, wherein the Supreme Court has held that no government order, notification or circular can be substituted for the statutory rules framed under the authority of law.

6. The respondents have filed an additional affidavit on 27.11.2006 disputing the stand of the petitioner that after January, 1995 they had not been discharging the duties of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. They have filed various documents along with the said affidavit to show that they had been discharging the functions of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks even thereafter and till the date of filing of the affidavit. W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 7 of 11

7. Having considered the rival submissions of the parties, we are of the view that the decision of the Tribunal cannot be sustained in the light of the decision of the Supreme Court in Umadevi (supra). It is not disputed that a post of Clerk/Enquiry Clerk is a Group-C post, whereas the post of Beldar/Chowkidar is a Group-D post. It is also not in dispute that the respondents had been engaged as daily wagers initially as Beldars/Chowkidars. Merely because they were performing the duties of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks, assuming that they can be regularized [which itself may not be the case in view of Umadevi (supra)], they certainly could not have been directed to be regularized in the higher post, which would be totally contrary to the recruitment rules. The said direction is in the teeth of the decision of the Supreme Court in Motilal (supra). The decision in Ram Nath Singh (supra) does not constitute a binding precedent for two reasons. Firstly, it is contrary to the Constitutional Bench decision of the Supreme Court in Umadevi (supra) and is, therefore, denuded of its precedent value. Secondly, it is well-settled that a dismissal of a Special Leave Petition in limine does not constitute a binding precedent. Therefore, the decision in Ram Nath Singh (supra) is not useful for our purpose. The reliance placed by the respondents on the OM dated 09.09.1999 also does not advance the respondents' case qua their claim for regularisation as Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. The said OM nowhere deals with the aspect of regularisation. W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 8 of 11 Consequently, we quash the second direction issued by the Tribunal with regard to the consideration of the case of the respondent in regularizing of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks.

8. However, since the respondents did in fact discharge duties as Clerks/Enquiry Clerks, they would be entitled to payment of salary as admissible to Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. It is the case of the respondents that they had not been paid the difference in the salary as payable to the Clerks/Enquiry Clerks and those payable to Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. There is a factual dispute as to whether the respondents have continued to discharge duties as Clerks/Enquiry Clerks after January, 1995. While it is the case of the petitioner that they have not discharged such responsibilities and duties after January, 1995, the respondents contend that they continued to discharge the same responsibility. Upto January 1995, even the petitioner does not dispute that the respondents continued to work as Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. We do not agree with the submission of the petitioner that OM dated 09.09.1999 would not be applicable to them since, according to the petitioner, they were not rendering the job of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks. A perusal of the said OM shows that “the pay of each worker in pre-revised scale will be fixed on 01.01.1973 or the date of appointment of the workers covered by these order, whichever is later and on 01.01.1986 in the new scale as per recommendations of the Fourth Pay Commission and again on W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 9 of 11 01.01.1996 in the revised scale as per recommendations of the Fifth Central Pay Commission. Arrears will however, be payable w.e.f. 01.04.1981 onwards.” Therefore, arrears were payable w.e.f. 01.04.1981, in respect of those who were in place on that day. Obviously, those who were engaged later, would get arrears from the date of their engagement. From para 5 of the OM, it is clear that the said OM is to even apply to those who have retired prior to 09.09.1999. It says that “the entire arrears of pay etc. to the beneficiary worker, who are to retire from service upto 30.09.1997 will be made in cash subject to the condition that the 5% of the gross amount of the arrears upto 28.01.1992 will go to the Prime Minister's Drought Relief Fund. All payments to the workers will be subject to standard deductions on account of Income Tax, licence fee etc. The amount deducted towards Prime Minister's Drought Relief Fund will be passed on directly to the appropriate authority for credit to the said fund.”

9. It is not for us in these proceedings to enter into this factual controversy. Therefore, for the period January 1995 onwards, it shall be open to the respondents to approach the Tribunal, in the first instance, to claim the difference in the pay on the basis that they have been discharging the duties of Clerks/Enquiry Clerks and in case the respondents do approach the Tribunal, it shall be for the Tribunal to determine this controversy and fact and arrive at a decision on the W.P. (C) No. 4925/1999 Page No. 10 of 11 basis of the aforesaid controversy. In view of our discussion, we partly allow this petition and quash the direction given by the Tribunal in sub-para (b) of para 18 of the impugned judgment, while upholding the direction given in sub-para (a) of para 18 of the impugned judgment dated 28.09.1998.

10. Parties are left to bear their respective costs.