Punjab State University Text Book Board v. Children Book Trust

Delhi High Court · 19 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:595
Pradeep Nandrajog
FAO No.9/1999
2008:DHC:595
civil appeal_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the appeal against refusal to recall an ex-parte decree, holding that summons were properly served and the appellant failed to show sufficient cause for non-appearance.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
FAO No.9/1999 # Punjab State University Text Book Board ....... Appellant
! through: Ms. Amrit Matharu, Advocate
VERSUS
$ Children Book Trust ....... Respondent ^ through: None
Date of Decision: 19.02.2008
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Pradeep Nandrajog
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Y

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Y

3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? Y: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J. (Oral)

1. Vide impugned order dated 20.10.1998 appellant's application under Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure praying that the ex-parte judgment and decree dated 10.5.1996 be recalled has been dismissed.

2. In the application filed by the appellant it was stated that on 4.10.1995 appellant's dispatch clerk received a postal docket which on opening revealed that contents thereof were only a plaint. No summons were enclosed. Appellant contacted a local lawyer who advised that since only plaint was received without summons, appellant should await receipt of FAO No.9/99 2008:DHC:595 summons. That none came. That on 27.5.1997 appellant learnt that its bank account was attached. Inquiry revealed that the attachment was issued by a learned Special Judge First Class at Chandhigarh. Further inquiry revealed that the learned Judge was executing, on transfer, a decree dated 10.5.1996 passed by Shri Lal Singh, Additional District Judge, Delhi in the suit filed by the respondent.

3. Evidence was led in the application filed by the appellant. The appellant deposed that copy of the plaint AW- 1/2 was received but without the summons. The opposite party quizzed the witness of the appellant in relation to the envelope containing the plaint for the obvious reason whenever summons are sent through post by Courts, on the envelope, not only the name of the Court but even suit number is mentioned. Appellant stated that the envelope was destroyed.

4. View taken by the learned Judge is that the Court record reveals that along with the plaint summons were enclosed and the postal envelope was duly received by the appellant as per A.D. card received back by the Court.

5. The learned Judge has disbelieved the appellant visa-vis its version that the summons were not found in the postal docket. Thus it has been held that the appellant has failed to show good cause for not appearing in the court.

6. It is urged by learned counsel for the appellant that the possibility of the Court Ahlmad preparing the summons but negligently not attaching the same with the plaint before enclosing the same in the envelope cannot be ruled out.

7. I have questioned learned counsel for the appellant as to why appellant did not contact the plaintiff whose name and address was mentioned in the plaint to find out as to in which Court the suit was filed.

8. Learned counsel for the appellant has no answer.

9. Further, the copy of the plaint received by the appellant, if not more, disclosed to the appellant that the suit was filed in the Court of the District Judge, Delhi.

10. The plaint even bears the date being 21.7.1995.

11. I have questioned the learned counsel for the appellant as to why appellant did not make endeavour to find out from the Court of the District Judge, Delhi particulars of suits filed in the month of July 1995. Indeed, there is no answer.

12. Counsel states that the appellant went by the advice of the counsel.

4,630 characters total

13. I am afraid, issues of common sense has not to be the subject matter of legal opinion.

14. To my mind, if appellant was confronted with the situation which appellant claims it was, I see no reason why appellant did not firstly write to the plaintiff seeking information of the Court in which the suit was filed. Secondly, I see no reason why appellant did not contact the Registry of the District Judge, Delhi to ascertain the Court from which the plaint was received by it.

15. I note that the plaintiff is Children's Book Trust, 4 Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi. I find that in the plaint claim is based on unpaid bills details whereof have been set out in para 2 of the plaint. I further note that in the plaint, plaintiff has made reference to exchange of letters between the parties.

16. Any person with minimum use of common sense, on reading the plaint, would have understood that Children's Book Trust was seeking to recover unpaid dues under 9 bills stated to have been raised and as disclosed in para 2 of the plaint. Any person with minimum common sense would have contacted the plaintiff to acquaint himself with the Court in which the plaint was filed.

17. I see no infirmity in the impugned order passed by the learned Trial Judge dismissing appellant's application under Order 39 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

18. The appeal is dismissed.

19. No costs.

20. TCR be returned forthwith. February 19, 2008 (PRADEEP NANDRAJOG) d.k.bainsla JUDGE