M.S. Badgujar & Anr. v. D.D.A & Anr.

Delhi High Court · 19 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:608
Sanjiv Khanna
W.P.(C) 3690/1993
54 (1994) DLT 68 (DB)
property petition_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld the DDA's claim for interest on delayed payment of balance sale consideration and ground rent despite quashing a revised demand notice, affirming contractual liability under the original allotment terms.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C) 3690/1993
M.S.BADGUJAR & ANR. ..... Petitioners
Through : Ms. Bharti Kochhar, Advocate
VERSUS
D.D.A & ANR. ..... Respondents
Through : Ms. Sangeeta Chandra, Advocate for DDA
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA O R D E R 19.02.2008
JUDGMENT

(1) The petitioner by letter dt.18/12/1988 was allotted a shop bearing no.S- 29, CSC, Rewari Line, Delhi. The petitioner was required to deposit 25% of the reserve price of the shop amounting to Rs.34,245/- within 60 days of the issue of the said allotment letter. The petitioner was also required to submit an undertaking that he would pay balance 75% of the amount of sale 2008:DHC:608 consideration with 6% interest. The petitioner deposited Rs.34,245/- vide challan dated 11/1/1989. The terms and conditions of the allotment provides as under: “After approval of the result of draw of lots by the VC/DDA or such other officers as may be authorized by VC/DDA in this behalf the successful applicants shall be informed in writing about the shops/stalls etc. allotted to them and the successful applicants shall have to pay within 60 days from the date of issue of allotment letter 25% of the reserved price in cash or by bank draft in favour of DDA and deposit this amount in the Central Bank/State Bank of India, Vikas Sadan. The balance amount be payable in 24 equal monthly installments together with the interest @ 6% per annum. In case the applicant fails to pay the balance 75% of the reserved price on monthly installments as may be fixed within the time permitted the allotment will be cancelled and the amount deposited would be forfeited. After such cancellation VC/DDA shall be competent to make allotment of the cancelled space to any person.” (2) The term related to payment of ground rent which reads as under: “In addition to the premium for the space, the allottees shall pay ground rent for the space allotted to him @ Rs.1525/- per annum w.e.f. the date taking over of possession. the allottee shall have also to deposit the maintenance charges equal to the amount of ground rent till the services of the shopping centre are handed over to MCD. The amount of ground rent and maintenance charges is payable in advance. The rate of ground rent shall be subject to enhancement to such rate as may be decided by lessor after the period of thirty years. An interest of 10% per annum or such other rate as the DDA/lessor may in its absolute discretion decide from time to time, without prejudice to the right of re-entry under the lease shall be charged on all delayed payments. Such interest will be calculated for full fortnight or month as the case may be and not for fraction thereof.”

3. After deposit of 25% of the amount the petitioner, was handed over and given possession of the shop on 18/2/1991.

4. DDA vide letter dt.17/12/1991 revised the total sale consideration of the shop and revised demand notice was issued. The petitioner challenged the revised demand letter by way of the present writ petition which was filed in the year 1993.

5. It is admitted case of the parties that the revised demand letter cannot be sustained and upheld in view of the decision of Division Bench of this court in the case of Devender Kumar & Anr. Vs. DDA & Anr. reported in 54 (1994) DLT 68 (DB). To this extent there is no dispute now between the petitioner and the DDA as DDA has accepted the said decision and the fact that the petitioner is also entitled to benefit of the said decision. The revised demand letter dated 17/12/1991 is accordingly quashed.

6. The only dispute surviving today is whether the petitioner is liable to pay interest in terms of the Clause C[2] of the terms of allotment quoted above and in terms of allotment letter dt.18/11/1988. The terms of allotment and the allotment letter are clear that the petitioner was required to pay 75% of the balance amount with 6% interest. This payment was to be made within 24 months. Admittedly, the said balance amount as stated in letter dt.18/11/1988 was paid by the petitioner on 24/12/1997. Therefore, I feel the petitioner is liable to pay interest on the balance 75% of the sale consideration in terms of demand letter i.e. w.e.f 17/2/1989. The petitioner did not at any time dispute the total sale consideration mentioned in the letter dt.18/11/1988 and should have himself come forward and deposited the said amount, even if he was disputing the enhanced demand letter dt.17/12/1991. There is no reason and justification for not depositing 75% balance amount in terms with the letter dated 18/11/1988 and as per terms of allotment. Moreover, rate of interest which has been charged from the petitioner is 6%. The petitioner had retained the balance sale consideration of 75%, though he has been enjoying possession of the shop since 1991.

7. In these circumstances I do not find the claim of the DDA that the petitioner should pay 6% interest in accordance with the allotment letter dt.18/11/1988 and as per terms and conditions of allotment is unjustified or contrary to law. This contention of DDA is upheld.

8. It is also admitted by the petitioner that he did not pay ground rent as stipulated in the terms and conditions of allotment. Therefore, as per the said terms the petitioner is liable to pay pay 10% interest in case of delayed payment of ground rent. The petitioner is liable to pay ground rent also.

9. I find that the writ petition filed by Mr. Devender Kumar and Anr. (Supra) was allowed with costs quantified at Rs.1,000/- each. The petitioner will be also entitled to the said cost. The cost will be adjusted while making payment of interest. The interest and ground rent will be paid by the petitioner in 2 equal installments. The first installment will be paid on or before 15th March, 2008 and the second installment will be paid by 30th April, 2008. Writ petition is accordingly disposed of.

SANJIV KHANNA,J FEBRUARY 19, 2008 vld