Full Text
Date of Reserve 23rd January 2008 EA No.114/2007 in Ex.P. No. 157/2006
20.02.2008 Raj Gupta Sole Proprietor of M/s Elemech Engineering ...Decree Holder
Through:Mr. Sandeep Sharma, Advocate
JUDGMENT
Through: Mr. Bhupesh Narula, Advocate JUSTICE SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not ?
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest ? ORDER: EA NO.114/2007
1. This application has been made by the Judgment Debtor for restitution of the execution petition which was disposed of as satisfied claiming that the Decree Holder had received an amount of Rs.24,348.64, which is more than the awarded amount, by misrepresentation of facts before the Court and, therefore, this amount should be got refunded to the JD and an order be passed directing the JD to pay back this amount.
2. The basis of the applicant/judgment debtor making this claim is the claim No.15 of the award. The claim No.15 of the Award reads as under:- “Claim No.15: Claimants claim Rs.1,08,000/as interest on investment of Rs.2,00,000/- for execution period @ 24% per annum. The legitimate dues of the claimants were withheld by the respondents and the claimants were deprived of the use of their money. Therefore interest EA No.114/2007 in Ex.P. No. 157/2006 Page No.1 of 4 2008:DHC:617 has to be paid to the claimants. Interest was claimed vide C-30. I award pre-suit interest on Rs.76,173.04 (Rs.23,352.00 + Rs.34,057.72 + 18,763.32) from 15.01.87 (i.e. 6 months after date of rescission) to 01.05.91 (i.e. the date before I entered upon reference). I also award 14% pendente lite interest on Rs.2,20,511.04 from 02.05.91 to 20.08.93. I also award 14% interest from the date of award till, decree or realization whichever is earlier. The total amount of interest under this claim will not exceed Rs.1,08,000/-.”
3. The claimant has claimed that the total interest payable to the claimant was Rs.1,08,000/- inclusive of future interest, pendente lite and past interest whereas the decree holder has calculated future interest @ 14% from 20.8.93 till 1.5.06 amounting to Rs.6,03,298/-. The decree holder could not have claimed this amount since under claim No.15, the Arbitrator had granted total interest limited to Rs.1,08,000/- only.
4. A perusal of award in respect of claim No.15 shows that the claimant had claimed interest of Rs.1,08,000/- as interest up to the filing of the claim before the Arbitrator. The Arbitrator awarded pre-suit interest of Rs.76,173/- from 15.1.1987 to 1.5.1991 and awarded pendente lite interest @ 14% at Rs.2,20,511 from 2.5.91 to 20.8.93. The Arbitrator also awarded 14% interest from the date of award till the decree was realized, whichever was earlier.
5. Looking into the fact that the claimant had claimed a total interest of Rs.1,08,000/- as interest on investment, the Arbitrator restricted the claim of interest by the claimant to Rs.1,08,000/-. Obviously, this restriction was in respect of pendente lite and past interest. This restriction could not have been in respect of future interest. Pendente lite EA No.114/2007 in Ex.P. No. 157/2006 Page No.2 of 4 and past interest itself amounted to more than Rs.1,08,000/-. If the Arbitrator wanted that the entire interest was to be restricted only to Rs. 1,08,000/-, he would not have awarded the future interest at all. The very fact that the Arbitrator awarded future interest @ 14%, shows that the restriction of Rs.1,08,000/- was only in respect of pendente lite and presuit interest and not on future interest. I consider that the stand taken by the JD in this application is not tenable.
6. The calculations made by the JD would show that the awarded amount was Rs.3,30,511/- whereas the decree holder calculated an award amount wrongly as Rs.3,39,313/- and the decree holder also calculated future interest on this amount. The various claims allowed by the Arbitrator are as under:- Claim No.1 - Rs.23,352 Claim No.2 - Rs.5,000 Claim No.4 - Rs.34,057.72 Claim No.6 - Rs.18,763.32 Claim No.10 & 11 - Rs.84,400/- Claim No. 15 - Rs.1,08,000/- Claim No.16 - Rs.54,938/- Claim No.17 - Rs.2,000/- Total - Rs.3,30,511.04/-
7. Thus the total award was for Rs.3,30,511.04/-. A perusal of execution would show that the decree holder wrongly stated that the awarded amount was Rs.3,39,313/-. Thus, there is a difference of Rs.8802/- in the awarded amount plus interest on this amount @ 14% has also been wrongly paid to Decree Holder and the further calculations EA No.114/2007 in Ex.P. No. 157/2006 Page No.3 of 4 of 9% on this amount has also been wrongly charged. The decree holder has, therefore, received some additional amount by not giving correct awarded amount.
8. Let the Judgment Debtor file calculations on the basis of awarded amount of Rs.3,30,511+future interest @ 14% per annum from 20.8.93 to 1.5.2006 and interest of 9% till 23.7.2006. JD would be entitled to recover the difference. Let the calculations be filed within one week.
9. With above directions, the application stands disposed of. Ex.P. No. 157/2006 List on 13th March 2008. February 20, 2008 SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA J. rd EA No.114/2007 in Ex.P. No. 157/2006 Page No.4 of 4