Full Text
W.P.(C) 6461/1999
SURAT SINGH ..... Petitioner
Through : Counsel
Through : Mr. N S Dalal, Advocate for respondent no.3
Mr. R S Rana, Advocate for respondent no.2
JUDGMENT
1. In 1976-80, consolidation proceedings were carried out in Village Jaunti, Delhi. The entire land was put in the common pool and thereafter repartitioned amongst the land holders under Section 21(1) of the East Punjab Holdings (Consolidation & Prevention of Fragmentation) Act, 1948 as extended to the State of Delhi. Land in Kh. nos. 45/25, 42/17/1 and 41/21/2/1 was repartitioned under Section 21(1) of the said Act in 1977-78. Petitioner and the respondents 1-2 were put in possession of their respective land in terms of the repartitioned scheme in the said 2008:DHC:642 khasras. It may be noted here that no landholder had filed any objection under Section 21(2) of the aforesaid Act.
2. By order dated 2/2/1988 i.e. after nearly 10 years, the Consolidation Officer passed an order reallocating the land after recording that the matter had been remanded back by the Financial Commissioner by his order dated 31/1/1985. It is stated in the said order that Consolidation Officer's earlier order dated 1/9/1983 was set aside. The reallocation was justified on the ground that it was difficult to allot land to the parties at their centers.
3. Against the order passed by the Consolidation Officer on 2/2/1988 an appeal was preferred before the Financial Commissioner. The said appeal was decided on 23/5/1988 after noticing the argument raised by the petitioner that under the garb of the remand order, the Consolidation Officer could not have withdrawn his land. The Financial Commissioner also noticed the other argument raised by the petitioner that the allotment was not permissible and could not have been disturbed under section 21(1) of the Act. The Financial Commissioner noticed that the Consolidation Officer has not dealt with these contentions and the order was silent and non-reasoned order, as far as these aspects were concerned. In these circumstances the Financial Commissioner remanded the matter back to the Consolidation Officer.
4. On 23rd January, 1991, the Consolidation Officer passed another order. The order records that the petitioner and the other private parties were shareholders of joint Khewat at the pre-consolidation stage. The petitioner, it was noticed, had a smaller shareholding than Mr. Ram Mehar, but Mr. Kabul Singh had yet the smallest shareholding and therefore he should be given land near his chak. Accordingly, he decided to reallocate the land allotted to Mr. Surat Singh i.e. the petitioner. It is clear from this order that reallocation of land had to be made in respect of Mr. Surat Singh, Mr. Ram Mehar and Mr. Kabul Singh. It is the contention of the petitioner that no other party or person in the village is affected by the said order.
5. Mr. Surat Singh, the petitioner filed an appeal against the order passed by Consolidation Officer before the Settlement Officer but the said appeal was adjourned sine die, whereupon the revision petition was filed by Mr. Kabul Singh before the Financial Commissioner and the same was allowed by order dated 28/2/1994, inter alia, holding that the appeal filed by Mr. Surat Singh before the Settlement Officer was not maintainable as what was challenged by Mr. Surat Singh was not an order under section 21(2) of the Act.
6. Mr. Surat Singh thereupon filed Civil Writ no.1216/1994 in this court. After examining the contentions of the parties and the fact that the matter had remained pending for nearly 10 years, the High Court directed the Financial Commissioner to himself examine the appeal filed by Mr. Surat Singh before the Settlement Officer. Certain other directions were also issued. I may note here that Mr. Surat Singh, Mr. Kabul Singh and Mr. Ram Mehar were parties to the said writ petition along with the Financial Commissioner.
7. After the directions given by the High Court, the appeal was decided by the Financial Commissioner by his order dated 16/9/1999. The said order is impugned in the present writ petition. The appellate order does not specifically deal with the contentions of the petitioner that the partition was not permissible after 10 years, in view of section 21(2) of the Act. In paragraph 9 of the impugned order it is merely recorded that the contention that the Consolidation Officer could not have reviewed his previous order was untenable as the Consolidation Officer had passed the said order pursuant to the remand order passed by the Financial Commissioner in 1988. This reasoning cannot be accepted and is contrary to the earlier order dated 23rd May, 1988 passed by the Financial Commissioner himself. While deciding the appeal on 23rd May, 1988 the Financial Commissioner had held as under: “ The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that it was not within the competence of the consolidation officer to have disturbed the allotment made under section 21(1), as such the impugned order has been sought to be reversed. The order of the consolidation officer is silent as to why and on what ground the land as in dispute taken out from the petitioner. The order must have been followed by some reasoning and justification. Rather the order of the consolidation officer is non-speaking order, as such it is not possible as to which of the records had been examined him while passing the order. There was no argument of respondent no.2.”
8. Thus the Financial Commissioner was required to examine whether fresh or re-allotment could have been made in 1988 after consolidation proceedings in respect of the khasra had already concluded under section 21(1) of the Act in the year 1977 and 1978. Reference in this regard could also be made to the judgment by Delhi High Court in 'Ram Nath Vs. The Financial Commissioner, Delhi Administration, Delhi and Anr' reported in AIR 1984 Delhi 178 wherein it has been held that once consolidation proceedings are complete under section 21(1) of the Act and no objections have been received within 15 days the matter cannot be reopened. Similar view has also been taken by a Division Bench in the case of “Ram Saroop vs. Ram Nath & Anr. reported in 38 (1989) DLT 473 DB.
9. During the course of hearing before me learned counsels for the petitioner and respondents no.2 and 3 have stated that they have been in possession of their respective lands ever since consolidation proceedings in 1977-78. It is further stated that the said parties do not want that the orders passed by the Consolidation Officer dated 2nd February, 1988 and thereafter on 21st January, 1991 should be applied to them and complied with. The parties have incurred substantial expenditure to develop the land allotted to them in 1977-78. It is stated that no other third person is adversely affected.
10. In these circumstances I allow the present writ petition inter alia holding that the parties will be bound by the order of allotment made in 1977-78 and consequently the repartition order passed on 2/2/1988 and 21/1/1991 are quashed. The order passed by the Financial Commissioner dated 16th September, 1999 is also set aside. No costs.
SANJIV KHANNA,J FEBRUARY 21, 2008 vld