Full Text
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CS (OS) 2650A/1996 ANANT RAJ AGENCIES ... Petitioner
Through : Mr. Harish Malhotra, Sr.
Advocate with Mr. Rajinder Aggarwal & Ms. Namita Chaudhary, Advs.
Through : Ms. Anusuya Salwan with Ms. Monika Sharma, Advs.
21.02.2008
JUDGMENT
1. This order shall dispose of the objections filed by the DDA under Section 30 & 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 against the arbitral award dated 12.09.1996 in favour of the claimant/contractor for a total amount of Rs.10,63,438.65p together with interest on Rs.2,49,224.56p at 12% per annum w.e.f. 1st March, 1992 till the date of award and at 16% per annum on the entire award amount from the date of award CS (OS) 2650A/1996 2008:DHC:634 till payment.
2. The record of the Arbitrator was requisitioned and the same has been made available to the court. I have gone through the arbitral award as well as the arbitration proceedings conducted before the learned Arbitrator.
3. The respondent had awarded a contract to the petitioner for construction of 384 EWS houses in Block-C, Pkt. 6 to 8, Rohini, Delhi, vide Agreement No.6/EE/RPD- 4/DDA/85-86. The said contract between the parties contained an arbitration clause being clause No.25 which provide for adjudication of the disputes under the contract between the parties through the process of arbitration. In terms of the contract the work awarded by the objector to the claimant was to be completed by 8.07.1986, however the work was not completed by the time specified in the contract and the time for construction was extended from time to time. The claimant had completed the construction at the site on 30.08.1991. After the work was completed certain disputes and differences arose between the parties regarding the alleged claims made by the claimant against the objector and those disputes were referred for arbitration to the Superintending Engineer (Arbitration of DDA). The claimant/contractor had preferred four claims before the Arbitrator. The first claim was under under various heads whereas claims No.2 & 3 were on account of interest and claim No.4 was towards cost of the arbitration proceedings.
4. After hearing the parties the learned Arbitrator has made an award in the sum of Rs.10,63,438.65p under claim No.1, details whereof are given at page-26 of the Award and the same is extracted below: “UNDER CLAIM NO.1, THE FOLLOWING AMOUNTS HAVE BEEN AWARDED TO THE CLAIMANTS
1. Under agreement item No.1.[1] to 12.[6] Rs. Rs. 80,287.55
2. Under extra and substituted items from 1 to 22 Rs. 27,428.12
3. Under item No.25, 26, 28 & 29 Rs. 49,393.03
4. Recoveries found not justified Rs. 92,115.86
5. Under item No. 24 Rs.7,96,214.09
6. Under item No.27 Rs. 18,000.00 Rs. 10,63,438.65 Accordingly, I award a sum of Rs.10,63,438.65 in favour of the claimants, in full and final settlement under claim No.1”
5. As far as claims No.2 & 3 no account of interest are concerned, learned Arbitrator has awarded interest on Rs.2,49,224.56p awarded under various heads mentioned at serial Nos.1,2,3,[4] & 6 at 12% per annum w.e.f. 1.3.1992 till the date of Award and at 16% per annum on the total award amount from the date of award till the date of payment or the decree, whichever is earlier. Claim No.4 towards cost was rejected.
6. Ms. Anusuya Salwan, appearing on behalf of the DDA has assailed the impugned Award under two separate heads. She has first argued in respect of objection of the DDA against amount awarded by the Arbitrator in respect of claim made by the contractor against item No.24 mentioned at serial No.5 referred above. The amount awarded in respect of item No.24 is in respect of escalation on the cost of the building material and the labour beyond the period of contract till the date of actual completion of the work at site. Ms. Salwan has contended that the Award under this head made by the learned Arbitrator is hit by Clause 10 CC of the agreement between the parties. She has submitted that the contractor was paid escalation in terms of clause 10 CC, both for the building material as well as the cost of labour for the period beyond the date specified in the agreement for completion of the work and till the time that construction was extended and therefore the Arbitrator could not have awarded any further escalation on this account.
7. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of Objector/DDA has relied upon two Division Bench judgments of this court in Delhi Development Authority vs. K.C. Goyal & Co. - 2001 II AD (Delhi) 116 and Delhi Development Authority vs. U. Kashyap – 1998 VII AD (Delhi) 300. On the strength of these two judgments she had contended that the Award in respect of item No.24 to the tune of Rs.7,96,214.09p cannot be sustained as the said Award is contrary to the terms of the contract between the parties contained in clause 10 CC of the agreement. She has submitted that a similar award made by the Arbitrator was set aside by two separate Division Bench of this court in the aforementioned cases. A similar Award on account of escalation contrary to clause 10 CC was set aside by this court in yet another judgment in Jagat Ram Trehan & Sons Vs. Delhi Development Authority 2002 (63) DRJ 119.
8. Mr. Malhotra, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the claimant/contractor has not disputed that the payment on account of escalation in terms of clause 10 CC of the Agreement has already been made by the DDA/objector to the contractor while settling his final bill. However his contention is that the amount on account of escalation awarded by the learned Arbitrator in respect of item No.24 was over and above the amount paid to the contractor under clause 10 CC of the Agreement. This contention made on behalf of the claimant/contractor is of no consequence because once a particular formula is provided in the contract, applying some other formula and awarding the claim on account of escalation would amount to legal misconduct. Following the ratio of judgments in the aforementioned cases, I have no hesitation in holding that the amount awarded by the learned Arbitrator in respect of item No.24 on account of escalation of cost of material and labour cannot be legally justified and is therefore to be set aside. The objection of DDA/objector is with regard to the award in respect of item No.24 is, therefore, allowed.
9. Regarding the amount awarded by the learned Arbitrator in respect of other items mentioned at serial No.1,2,3,[4] & 6 at page-26 of the Award, Ms. Salwan appearing on behalf of DDA has argued that the learned Arbitrator has misconducted himself in awarding the said amounts because he has not given adequate reasons for awarding the said amounts. Ms. Salwan made an attempt to point out that the other amounts awarded under various heads as mentioned at serial No.1,2,3,[4] & 6 at page-26 of the Award were not really due and payable to the contractor and, therefore, according to her the award even in that respect is also not sustainable. This argument advanced by Ms. Salwan is of no consequence because this court while deciding objections does not sit in appeal over the judgment of the Arbitrator. The DDA/objector has appointed their own Superintending Engineer as the Sole Arbitrator for deciding the disputes and differences between the parties. The Superintending Engineer who was appointed as Sole Arbitrator by the DDA knew the functioning of the respondent and was the best person to assess the entitlement of the contractor under various heads. Even if we go into merits of each claim and at the end reach to a conclusion different to what has been arrived at by the learned Arbitrator, this court cannot substitute its opinion in place of the Arbitrator while deciding the objections against the arbitral award. Hence this court is of the opinion that there is no merit in the objections in so far as they relate to the Award in respect of other items. The Award of the learned Arbitrator in respect of items mentioned at serial No.1,2,3,[4] & 6 at page-26 of the Award is upheld. This court does not find anything unreasonable in the interest on the Award amount awarded by the learned Arbitrator in respect of claims No.2 & 3. The Award in that regard is also upheld.
10. For the foregoing reasons the objections against the arbitral Award filed by the DDA are partly allowed to the extent that the award in respect of item No.24 to the tune of Rs.7.96,214.00 is set aside. Since the objections have been filed under the old Act, the rest of the award is made Rule of the Court. The DDA/objector is given two months time for making payment of the decreetal amount to the claimant/contractor failing which, it shall be liable to pay interest at 16% p.a on the decreetal amount from the date of decree till the date of actual payment. Decree sheet be drawn accordingly. The parties are left to bear their own costs.
FEBRUARY 21, 2008 S.N. AGGARWAL, J. mb