Full Text
Date of Reserve : 07.2.2008
Date of Decision: 22.02.2008 WP(C) No.667/1994
Ex. SHGO Rakesh Kumar Sharma .... Petitioner
JUDGMENT
1. Union of India
2. Chief of Army Staff
3. General Officer Commanding,
4. Commandant... Respondents Advocates who appeared in this case: For the petitioner: Mr. P.D.P. Deo, Advocate. For the respondents: Ms. Sonia Mathur, Advocate with Major S.S. Pandey. CORAM: HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE A.K. SIKRI HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE J.M. MALIK
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers No may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be Yes reported in the Digest? J.M. MALIK, J. * WP(C) No.667/1994 2008:DHC:657-DB
1. In this writ petition, the petitioner has called into question the discharge order from his service under Army Rules 13(3) item III(v). The petitioner was served with a show cause notice dated 31.3.92 from Brigadier Commandant, Delhi Cantt., on 4.4.92 which reads: “32330/Est/ME/RKS 31 March 92 MILITARY ESTABLISHMENT SHOW CAUSE NOTICE
1. It is revealed from your service docus that you have earned 3 red ink entries by committing the following offence since the time you were enrolled in Army Ordnance Corps on 9 May, 85. Your conduct indicates that you are not amenable to good order and military discipline. The details of the punishments awarded to you are as under:- No. Date of Army Act Section Punishment Offence and offence Awarded a) 27 Feb.89
AA SEC 41 (2) 02 days “DISOBEYING A LAWFUL imprisonment COMMAND GIVEN BY HIS SUPERIOR OFFICER” c) 13 Mar 92 AA SEC 63 07 days “AN ACT PREJUDICIAL imprisonment TO GOOD ORDER AND MILITARY DISCIPLINE”
2. You are hereby called upon to show cause as to why you should not be discharged from service under AR 13(3) Item III(v).
3. Your written reply is required to be submitted to the undersigned within 07 days from the receipt of this show cause notice. In case no reply is received by due date, it will be assumed that you have nothing to say in your defence and further action to discharge you locally from service will be taken. (T.J.S. GILL) Brig Commandant No.6922535 P Sep SH GD R.K. Sharma”
2. Reply was sent in response to the notice on 6.4.92. The petitioner explained that the first punishment was given only for seven days and not for 28 days. He further explained that this punishment was never awarded in reality. He admitted that punishment 1(b) detailed in show cause notice was due to fault of applicant. The petitioner had only expressed his desire to proceed on leave. He returned to the unit as per and obeyed the order of the commanding 2TB. On 23.5.92 the petitioner was discharged from Army Ordnance Corps under Army Rule 13(3) item III(v) and was struck of strength from the Army on 25.5.92. Aggrieved by the said order the petitioner has filed the present writ petition, on 4.1.94, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, wherein it is prayed that order of discharge dated 23.5.92 be quashed, the petitioner be restored to the service, he be treated as having not removed from service for all future promotions and be paid the service pay, allowances and pensionary benefits.
3. In order to embolden his case the petitioner has set up the following grounds. The petitioner was given only seven days to reply the above said show cause notice. He was not given the copies of the offences detailed in the above said show cause notice. He has also challenged the above said punishments. It is explained that the above said punishments were given illegally and due to the error of the officiating officers. Subsequently, the punishments were amended but the record was not corrected. However, the alleged offences were not grave. The respondents did not send any response to the reply sent by the petitioner.
4. The respondents have contested the present petition. It is explained that during the short span of seven years of service the petitioner was awarded four and not three punishments. The above said three punishments hardly require reiteration. The fourth punishment runs as follows: “Date of offence Army Act Section Punishment offence awarded (4) 31.3.92 63 28 days RI” It was explained that on 31.3.1992 itself before sending response to the show cause notice, the petitioner committed another offence under Section 63 of the Army Act. For this fourth offence the petitioner was awarded 28 days RI on 2.4.1992. It is explained that since the petitioner had already been served with a show cause notice, no further show cause notice was given to the petitioner in respect of this fourth red ink entry. Adverting to punishment no. 1, it is explained that petitioner was awarded 28 days RI on 27.2.1989 i.e. absenting without leave under Section 39(a) Army Act. However, after the petitioner had undergone 7 days RI the remaining period of 21 days imprisonment was remitted by the officiating commandant on 11.8.1989, in view of the fact that this was the first offence committed by the petitioner. It is pointed out that rest of the punishments were correctly awarded.
5. The learned counsel for the respondent made the following submissions. Firstly, it was not necessary for the respondents to give further notice after the commission of the fourth offence. Again the mention of the fourth offence also does not find any mention either in the show cause notice or in the discharge order. Both these important documents are conspicuously silent about the fourth punishment and as such the same should not be taken into account. She stressed that the petitioner deserves the discharge order due to the three punishments detailed in the show cause notice. she explained that the procedure was complied with and the preliminary enquiry was held. It was also brought to the notice of the court that the petitioner never asked for the offence reports. She opined that the petitioner cannot pick up a conflict with the disputed questions of fact and if the petitioner had any grouse against the above said punishment he should have initiated action against the same instantaneously. She submitted that whether those punishments were rightly given or not cannot be considered in this petition. The reply filed by the petitioner clearly goes to show that some of the punishments were admitted by him to be correct. There is no inkling in his reply that the time granted in his favour was too short or he wanted to adduce evidence in support of his case. In order to bring her point home, she has cited the following cases.
6. In Ex. Sepoy Rishumuni Rai Vs. Directorate General of Sup. TP(ST-20) and Anr., 2007 (5) SLR 81, it was held: “5. In the present case since the petitioner had incurred 4 red ink entries, his case was referred to 536 ASC Bn vide ASC Records (Supply) letter NO. 6376715/T8/536/Doc-IV dated 11 May 1989, and accordingly a show cause notice dated 6.6.1989 was served on the petitioner. In reply to the aforesaid show cause notice the petitioner in terms of his petition dated 17.6.1989 requested that he be given an opportunity and be retained in service. A sympathetic view was taken and the petitioner was retained in service. That thereafter on 30.8.1989 the petitioner was again awarded a punishment under Section 39(B) of the Army Act and thereby he incurred another red ink entry making a total of 5 red ink entries. The petitioner was once again served with a show cause notice dated 10.9.1989 and in reply thereto he assured that he would improve himself and thus another opportunity be given to him. The petitioner showed absolutely no sign of improvement, and another offence was committed by him on 21.3.1990 as a result thereof he was punished under Section 63 of the Army Act. The respondents were forced to issue another show cause notice dated 28.3.1990, and thereafter orders for discharge were passed against the petitioner. Despite the show cause notices the petitioner made no effort to improve himself. By no stretch of imagination it can be stated that the respondents have not followed the due process of law or have not complied with the provisions of natural justice.”
7. In Gunner Mamraj Vs. Chief of the Army Staff & Ors, 91 (2001) DLT 652 (DB) it was held: “10. A conjoint reading of these provisions with relevant Army Instructions/Letters leaves no scope for doubt that appellant was liable to be discharged for being undesirable for retention in service and that it was for the competent Authority to adjudge his such desirability on the basis of his service record. It is not in dispute that appellant had suffered for “red ink” entries which clouded his retention in service and could be discharged in the process. His discharge could not be said to be lacking in basis or material. But his order of discharge was still required to be passed by the competent Authority.
11. Army Rule 13(3)(v) only empowers Brigade/Sub- Area Commander to pass the order of discharge but for this requires him to give show cause notice to the person concerned proposed to be discharged wherever circumstances permit. 12 x x x x
13. Appellant's other grievance that charges against him were not supported by facts and the Court Martial proceedings were vitiated for some reason, is his mere ipse dixie. It is too late in the day for him to raise such ancillary issue when he had admittedly failed to challenge all this at the relevant time. This appeal accordingly fails and is dismissed.”
8. She has also cited the judgment of Ex. L/Nk Gambhir Singh Vs. The Chief of Army Staff and Ors, WP(C) No.6014/1999 decided on 19.10.2006, wherein, it was observed: “9. The policy dated 28.12.1998 brings out various possibilities available before dealing with an individual, who is undesirable and inefficient including that in case discharge/dismissal is not warranted and that transfer will meet the case, the said individual may be transferred in his substantive rank, not recommended for further promotion and/or increments of pay until he proves his fitness for promotion or an increment of pay in his new unit. In fact it has also been recommended in the said policy that discharge from service consequent to 4 red ink entries is not a mandatory or legal requirement. The Commanding Officer was to consider the nature of offences for which red ink entries were awarded and not be harsh with the individual especially when they are about to complete the pensionable service and due consideration should be given to the length of service. The petitioner has put in 14 years 1 month and 18 days of service and there is a shortfall of about 10/12 months only.”
9. All these arguments have left no impression upon us. The duty cast upon on the court is to winnow truth from falsehood. It must be noticed that the show cause notice served upon the petitioner is itself defective. It does not portray the correct picture. The first punishment goes to show that he was sentenced to 28 days. The counter affidavit filed by the respondent clearly reveals that the show cause notice is not correct. As per record the petitioner was punished to undergo 7 days imprisonment only. It appears that 28 days were written in respect of 7 days in order to show that the petitioner had suffered higher sentence. It is well settled that extreme step of termination of the Army man is warranted only upon evaluating all the pros and cons of a particular case. The instant case smacks of a fig leaf job. The concerned authority handled the situation in a very maladroit way. It is difficult to say in which way the wind would have blown in case the correct position was placed before the competent authority. Again second show cause notice should have been given after the commission of fourth offence. It cannot be said for sure that the competent authority did not consider the fourth punishment. The non speaking discharge order in this context is also bad in law.
10. The following case law emboldens the case of the petitioner. In Surinder Singh Sihag Vs. Union of India & Ors, 100 (2002) DLT 705, the Division Bench of this court was pleased to hold: “10. In the aforementioned situation, the respondents were bound to follow the procedures laid down in the circular letter dated 28.12.1988, the relevant provisions whereof are as under: “5. Subject to the foregoing, the procedure to be followed for dismissal or discharge of a person under AR 13 or AR 17, as the case may be, is set out below: (a) Preliminary enquiry: Before recommending, discharge or dismissal of an individual the authority concerned will ensure:
(i) That an impartial enquiry(not necessarily a
Court of Inquiry) has been made into the allegations against him and that he has had adequate opportunity of putting up his defence or explanation and / or adducing evidence in his defence.
(ii) That the allegations have been substantial and that the extreme step of termination of the individual's service is warranted on the merits of the case.”..........................................................................
(d) Action by Competent Authority – The authority competent to authorize the dismissal or discharge of the individual will consider the case in the light of what is stated in (a) above. If he is satisfied that the termination of the individual's serges is warranted, he should direct that a show cause notice be issued to the individual in accordance with AR 13 or AR 17 as the case may be. No lower authority will direct the issue of a show cause notice. The show cause notice should cover the full particulars of the cause of action against the individuals. The allegations must be specific and supported by sufficient details to enable the individual to clear understand and reply to them. A copy of the proceedings of the enquiry held in the case of.... also be afforded reasonable time to state in writing any reasons he may have to urge against the proposed dismissal or discharge........................................................................... Note:
1. As far as possible, JCO, UO and Dr. awaiting dismissal orders will not be allowed to mix with personnel.
2. Discharge from service consequent to four red ink entries is not a mandatory or legal requirements. In such case Commanding Officer must consider the nature of offences for which case red ink entry has been awarded and not to harsh with the individuals, especially when they are about to complete the pensionable service. Due consideration should be given to the long service, hard stations and difficult living conditions that the OR has been exposed to during his service, and the discharge should be ordered only when it is absolutely necessary in the interest of service. Such discharge should be approved by the next higher commander.” (Emphasis supplied)”
11. In Rajesh Kumar Vs. Union of India and others, Mil LJ (2005) Del 48, it was held that the preliminary enquiry is required to be held where the delinquent employee must be given an adequate opportunity of putting up his defence or explanation or adducing evidence in support of his case. In this case show cause notice was issued only in respect of three red ink entries whereas the respondents admittedly considered a fourth red ink entry in the final order which was not a part of the show cause notice issued to the petitioner. It was held that principles of natural justice stood violated and the discharge order was set aside. It was further held, “10. Counsel appearing for the respondents has also drawn our attention to paragraph 2 of the note below the circular where it shows that discharge from service consequent to four red ink entries is not mandatory or legal requirement. This para instead of helping the respondents, goes against the respondents as even in a case where a person has earned four red ink entries, he may not be discharged from service as all cases have to be considered by the Commanding Officer giving due weightage to the nature of offences for which the red ink entries have been awarded. It further provides that the Commanding Officer should not be too harsh with the individuals. It therefore, explicitly clear that inspite of the fact that a person has incurred four red ink entries, which is a requirement, the person may not be discharged from service in a given case where the Commanding Officer is of the opinion that the nature of the offences is not of the nature for which harsh consequences like discharge from service is called for and warranted. The petitioner shall now be reinstated in service in accordance with law with all benefits.”
12. We therefore make the rule absolute and allow this writ petition by quashing discharge order dated 23.5.1992. Consequently the petitioner shall now be reinstated in service in accordance with law with all benefits. No costs. J.M. MALIK, J. A.K. SIKRI, J. February 22, 2008 dk