Indrani Ghosh v. Maya Rani Saha

Delhi High Court · 22 Feb 2008 · 2008:DHC:652
Pradeep Nandrajog
FAO No.321-22/2006
2008:DHC:652
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court allowed the appeal and granted an interim injunction restraining alienation of disputed property pending partition suit, holding that prima facie doubts about the will's authenticity justified preserving the status quo.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
FAO No.321-22/2006 # Smt. Manjula Saha ....... Appellant
! through: Mr. J.P.Sengh, Advocate Mr. S.K.Bahaduri, Advocate
Ms. Indrani Ghosh, Advocate
VERSUS
$ Smt. Maya Rani Saha ....... Respondent ^ through: None
Date of Decision: 22.02.2008
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Pradeep Nandrajog
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Y

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Y

3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? Y: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J. (Oral)

1. Matter was called for the first time at around 12:00 noon. At the passover round it has been called for the second time at 1:00 PM. None appears for the respondent.

2. The appellant is aggrieved by the fact that vide impugned order dated 10.10.2006 their application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC praying for a restraint order against the defendants from creating third party interest in the suit FAO No.321/06 2008:DHC:652 property, pending adjudication of the suit has been dismissed.

3. Appellants are the plaintiffs. The defendants are their mother and their bother.

4. During the pendency of the present appeal the mother expired. The three siblings, being already on record, this fact was noted in the order dated 23.8.2007.

5. Case of the appellants was that the suit property bearing No.H-1491, C.R.Park, New Delhi was the property acquired by their father Sh. G.N.Saha from ancestral funds. The daughters claimed partition in view of the amended provisions of the Hindu Succession Act.

6. Defence was predicated by relying upon a will stated to have been executed by Sh. G.N.Saha on 29.1.1999. It was stated that the property was the self-acquired property of Sh. G.N.Saha.

7. Declining injunction learned Trial Judge has recorded, pertaining to the will, that on the face of it it appears to be genuine.

8. On the issue of source of funds, learned Trial Judge has held that prima facie material evidence that G.N.Saha acquired the property from his own funds.

9. It is urged by learned counsel for the appellant that Sh. G.N.Saha died on 1.2.1999. Counsel urges that this fact is itself sufficient to cast a serious doubt on the due execution of the stated will dated 29.1.1999. Counsel further urges that there was documentary evidence placed before the Trial Judge that a few days prior to his death, G.N.Saha being unwell, was admitted in a hospital.

10. Unfortunately, due to non representation from the side of the respondents this court does not have the benefit of the view of the respondent.

11. Suffice would it be to state that at the interim stage a court has to consider prima facie case and not to evaluate evidence to return conclusive findings for the reason there is no evidence strictly so called before the court. Documents placed before the court are to be proved in accordance with law. Witnesses of the parties have to testify and subject themselves to cross examination.

12. The circumstance of the will being dated 29.1.1999 and the deceased having died 2 days thereafter and the fact that a few days prior to the execution of the will the deceased was hospitalized, do prima facie cast a doubt whether the deceased was in a testamentary state of mind on 29.1.1999.

4,982 characters total

13. I fail to understand as to how a prima facie finding pertaining to the authenticity of the will could be rendered by recording that on the face of it the will appears to be genuine.

14. Probably the learned Trial Judge has been guided by his judicial experience of daughters being generally deprived of immovable property in India.

15. These kinds of presumptions cannot be generalized for the reason this court has come across enlightening parents who have given equal share of their wealth to their daughters.

16. In a suit for partition the ordinary rule is to secure the property to be available for partition if claim succeeds unless there are compelling circumstances brought on record justifying non grant of an interim injunction. In the instant case I find no circumstance brought out justifying departure from the normal rule of granting interim injunctions.

17. Appeal is allowed.

18. Impugned order dated 10.10.2006 is set aside.

19. Appellant's application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC is allowed.

20. It is directed that till suit filed by the appellants is disposed of, the respondent would not transfer, alienate, encumber or part with possession of the suit property bearing municipal No. H-1491, C.R.Park, New Delhi. Noting that a part of the suit property is tenanted, permitting respondent to realize rent, I direct the respondent to maintain an account of the rent realized and money spent on the upkeep of the property. If the tenant vacates the tenanted premises said fact would be disclosed to the learned Trial Judge. Rent at which new tenant is sought to be inducted would be indicated and after taking permission of the court it would be permissible for the respondent to induct a new tenant, but in respect of the portion already in occupation of the tenant.

21. When the order was concluded Sh. Sanjay Aggarwal Advocate entered the court on behalf of the respondent.

22. The contents of the order have been verbally told to learned counsel for the respondent.

23. No costs. February 22, 2008 (PRADEEP NANDRAJOG) mm JUDGE