Full Text
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 5203/2007 & CM No. 9664/2007
Date of Decision: 7th March, 2008 Shri Gopal Kishan & Anr. ... Petitioner through: Mr. R.P. Bansal, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. G.N. Aggarwal, Adv.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? GITA MITTAL, J(Oral)
1. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner no. 1 as sole proprietor of M/s
V. Krishna Yarn Agencies on the averment that they are carrying on manufacturing business of cotton yarn at 2388, Teliwara, Sadar Bazar, Delhi-110006 which was a non-conforming area. Reliance is placed on a sales tax registration certificate dated 22nd June, 1979 in respect of this manufacturing business. The petitioners have submitted that in addition to these premises where manufacturing activity is carried - 2 on the petitioner was merely maintaining head office at the premises no. 4502, Dau Bazar Cloth Market, Delhi. Several documents including income tax returns, profit 2008:DHC:882 and loss account and other documents to evidence the manufacturing activity carried on this premises were deposited by the petitioner alongwith and the application dated 24th December, 1996 was submitted for allotment of an industrial plot pursuant to the relocation scheme floated by the respondents. The petitioner's grievance is that the petitioner satisfied all requirements and had duly filed affidavits also as required by the respondents. Certain defects in the application which was duly responded by the petitioner's communication dated 11th November, 1998. Further documents were also submitted. The petitioners are stated to have taken a bank loan of Rs.1,20,000/- from the Punjab & Sind Bank towards payment of the amount towards the plot.
2. It is pointed out that on the assurance that the petitioner's application was being favourably considered, the petitioner also closed down manufacturing activity in his factory located in the non-conforming area in compliance with the orders of the Apex Court.
3. Despite the above, by a letter dated 24th March, 2004 titled as “Review of Application Regarding Allotment of Industrial Plot under the Relocation Scheme”, the petitioner was required to appear before the allotment committee on the 6th April, 2004 with complete documents. This - 3 was followed by a communication dated 1st April, 2004 whereby the petitioner was informed that fresh notices/call letters were being sent for submitting documents before the committee and the petitioner should appear on 6th April, 2004. Despite submitting all documents and appearing before the committee, no intimation was received by the petitioners. The petitioner no. 1 stated to have visited the respondent's office more than a hundred times.
4. The writ petition was filed for the reason that it was only on checking on the computer site that it was shown that an allotment had been effected by the respondents in favour of the petitioner long back. The petitioner has contended that no letter of allotment was issued to the petitioner and no possession in respect of the plot given. Legal notice dated 21st February, 2005 to the respondent also did not revoke any positive response. In this background, the present writ petition seeking a modification to the respondents to allot and hand over possession of a plot of 400 sq. mtrs. to the petitioner in the conforming area in terms of the policy of relocation of industrial plots.
5. The respondents have contested the writ petition. It has been submitted that the respondents had issued a letter dated 24th March, 2007 to the petitioner to bring/produce all the original documents. It has further been submitted that on examination of the petitioner's application, - 4 his case was not recommended for allotment of the plot as the factory address as declared by the petitioner in his application form was 2388, Teliwara, Delhi-110006 which did not match with the factory address given in the sales tax registration certificate. According to the respondents, the DSIDC had thereafter written letters to the petitioner to submit the original receipts towards the depositing of the earnest money deposits so that the same can be refunded. Reliance is placed on a communication which is dated 22nd December, 2006/28th March, 2007 which has been placed on record.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the available record. I find that the averment in the counter affidavit are not supported by any record of the respondents. The petitioner has disputed issuance or receipt of any letter dated 24th March, 2007. No such letter has been placed on record. The respondents do not even state the date on which the petitioner 's case was examined or when it was decided not to recommend his application for allotment of the plot on record. It is an admitted position that no such order has been communicated to the petitioner till date.
7. On the other hand, several communications which have been placed on record which reflect that the respondents has been calling upon the petitioner only to submit documents. The petitioner has placed a large - 5 number of documents on record to manifest the correctness of its application. It has been stated that all these documents and the Central Sales Tax Registration Certificate in which the respondents have found discrepancy also notices both the premises of the petitioner, one being in the cloth market while the other is the subject premises against which the petitioner was seeking relocation.
8. In these facts, certainly the application of the petitioner could not have been rejected without proper consideration of the documents placed by the petitioner and an opportunity for explaining the position in case of any doubt in the mind of the respondents. Accordingly a direction is issued to the respondents to reconsider the application no. 35778 dated 24th December, 1996 for allotment of the plot which was submitted by the petitioner for allotment of the plot. The petitioner may place any further or additional documents in support of the application having regard to the objections taken by the respondents before the Commissioner of Industries within two weeks from today. The respondents shall give an opportunity to the petitioner or his authorised representative to clarify doubts, if any, with regard to the documents which are submitted by the petitioner. The respondents may thereafter, take a considered view and proceed in the matter as per the applicable policy. - 6 - The respondent shall communicate the date and time of hearing to the petitioner or his authorised representative by registered notice in writing. It is made clear that nothing herein contained is an expression of opinion on the merits of the petitioner's contention so far as that it was carrying on manufacturing activity in the subject premises is concerned. This writ petition and application are allowed in the above terms. Dasti to counsel for the parties.
(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE March 07, 2008 kr