Dr. Ankit Jain & Ors. v. UOI & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 03 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:815
Sanjiv Khanna
W.P.(C) 379/2008
2008:DHC:815
administrative other Procedural

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court granted interim relief allowing MBBS graduates from both University of Delhi and I.P. University to compete proportionately for reserved Post Graduate medical seats pending final adjudication.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C) 379/2008
DR.ANKIT JAIN & ORS. ..... Petitioners
Through : Mr. R P Bansal, Sr. Adv. With Mr. Rakesh Mahajan, Mr. Prabhat Ranjan, Mr. Prashant Jain and Mr. Sheetesh Khanna, Advocates
VERSUS
UOI &ORS. ..... Respondents
Through : Mr. P P Malhotra, ASG with Mr. Rajeev Mehra and Mr. Gaurav Sharma, Advocates for UOI
Mr. A Mariarputham, Advocate for University of
Delhi Mr. G D Goel with Mr. Sanjiv Goel, Advocates for respondent no.3
Mr. Maninder Singh with Mr. T. Singh, Advocates for respondent no.4/MCI
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA O R D E R 03.03.2008
JUDGMENT

1. In spite of two Orders dated 18th January, 2008 and 22nd February, 2008, Government of India, University of Delhi and Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University (hereinafter referred to as I.P. University, for short) have not been able to resolve the controversy for distribution/allotment of seats in Post Graduate M.D/M.S. Courses.

2. Earlier, University of Delhi was the only University awarding degrees 2008:DHC:815 in Medicine and accordingly only the students from the said University were entitled to compete for 50% seats in Post Graduate Degree and Diploma in M.D./M.S. 50% seats in Post Graduate M.D./M.S. Courses were reserved for the students of the said University. Graduates in Medicine from other universities could not compete for admission to the said 50% reserved seats in Post Graduate Degree and Diploma Courses.

3. In 2003, I.P. University, which is also located in Delhi, started Graduate Courses in Medicine. First batch of students in I.P. University will be getting degrees in Medicine this year.

4. The question which arises for consideration is whether the students from I.P. University should be eligible and allowed to compete with students from University of Delhi for 50% of the said reserved seats in Post Graduate Degree and Diploma Courses. Conflicting stands have been taken with University of Delhi on the one side and I.P. University and Government of India on the other side. As per the stand taken by University of Delhi, MBBS Graduates from I.P. University are not eligible and cannot compete with MBBS Graduates from University of Delhi for admission to the said 50% reserved seats in Post Graduate Degree and Diploma courses in Delhi University affiliated colleges. It is submitted that University of Delhi is a separate Institution and in terms of the judgments of the Supreme Court, 50% of the seats can be filled up only by students who have successfully completed MBBS Course from University of Delhi. Government of India, however, feels that MBBS Graduates from I.P. University are entitled to admission to Post Graduate Degree and Diploma in M.D./M.S. under this 50% reserved quota/seats. I.P. University also contends that students from the said University are entitled to same benefits and advantages as students of University of Delhi.

5. Government of India by letter dated 26th November, 2007 informed University of Delhi that Dr.R.M.L. Hospital and Safdurjung Hospital were affiliated to University of Delhi but it had been decided to change affiliation of existing M.D./M.S. seats in these two Institutes from University of Delhi to I.P. University. It was stated in the said letter that Under-Graduate College at Safdurjung Hospital, i.e. Vardhaman Mahavir Medical College was affiliated to I.P. University and a new P.G.I.M.P.R. is being established in Dr. R.M.L. Hospital which will also be affiliated to I.P. University. University of Delhi has, however, ignored the said letter and it is stated that affiliation of Post Graduate Courses in both Hospitals with University of Delhi cannot be altered and changed without following proper procedure. MBBS students of University of Delhi have also filed a separate petition pointing out inequities in case 86 students of I.P. University are allowed right to admission to Post Graduate Courses in Vardhaman Mahavir Medical College and Dr. R.M.L. Hospital to the exclusion of the students from University of Delhi. It is stated that about 400 students every year get degree in Medicine from University of Delhi and about 900 students apply for admission to limited/reserved 50% seats in Post Gradutate courses in Medicine in University of Delhi.

6. The issues and contentions raised in the Writ Petition will have to be examined and considered in detail and depth. At this stage, this Court is concerned with the interim order that should be passed in view of the conflicting stands taken by University of Delhi, I.P. University and Government of India. I am informed that about 260 seats are available in different Post Graduate Degree and Diploma courses. About 130 reserved seats, therefore, have to be filled up by MBBS Graduates from University of Delhi.

7. I am of the opinion that the 86 students from I.P. University, just as students from University of Delhi, should also be given a fair and equitable chance for admission in M.D./M.S. courses in Delhi. About 400 students receive MBBS Degree every year from the University of Delhi. In addition, another 500 students who have cleared and obtained MBBS Degree from University of Delhi also compete and apply for admission to Post Graduate Degree and Diploma Courses in Delhi.

8. Keeping all these aspects in mind, as interim measure it is directed as under:- (i) 86 students from I.P. University will be entitled to compete for 50% reserved seats in M.D./M.S. Courses in Vardhaman Mahavir Medical College at Safdurjung Hospital to the exclusion of students from University of Delhi. I am informed that 86 students will be competing for about 25-26 seats in M.D./M.S. Course available in the said College. This means tht about 28-30% students from I.P. University will get admission to M.D./M.S. courses in the said Hospital/Institute.

(ii) MBBS students of University of Delhi, about 400 in number, will be entitled to compete and apply for admission for the balance 104 reserved seats in M.D./M.S. Courses including the seats available in Dr. R.M.L. Hospital. I am informed that there are some more seats available to University of Delhi. Thus, about 25% of the students passing out from University of Delhi this year will be entitled to admission in Post Graduate Degree and Diploma Courses in Delhi.

9. I am informed and may also note that University of Delhi is currently conducting Post Graduate courses in Dr.R.M.L. Hospital. In their letter dated 26th November, 2007 it has been stated by Government of India that a new PGIMPR is being established in Dr. R.M.L. Hospital and the same will be affiliated to I.P. University.

10. The above arrangement is applicable only for admission to Post Graduate Degree and Diploma Courses in M.D./M.S. in the year

2008. It is clarified that the observations made in this Order are tentative and not binding, and the Writ Petition will be disposed of on merits without being influenced by any observation made in this Order. List again on 5th May, 2008.

SANJIV KHANNA, J. MARCH 03, 2008 P/VKR