Agra Tourist Guide Welfare Association v. Union of India

Delhi High Court · 04 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:840
Gita Mittal
Writ Petition (Civil) No.137/2008
2008:DHC:840
administrative appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court granted interim relief permitting candidates who appeared in the tourist guide examination to work under temporary licenses pending declaration of results, balancing their livelihood rights and public interest.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Writ Petition (Civil) No.137/2008
Date of Decision: 4rd March, 2008 AGRA TOURIST GUIDE WELFARE
ASSOCIATION ... Petitioners through: Ms. Anjana Gusain, Adv. with
Ms.Fatima, Adv.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA ....Respondent through: Mr. Suresh Kait, Adv. with
Mr. Yogesh Verma, Adv. for the respondent/UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE GITA MITTAL 1.Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
?
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?
GITA MITTAL, J(Oral)

1. The writ petition has been filed by the petitioner seeking a direction to the respondent to permit the petitioners, who have duly appeared in the examination conducted as back as on 26th August, 2007, to work as temporary tourist guides till the results are declared and the selection process completed. WP (C) No.137/2008 Page No.1 2008:DHC:840

2. The petitioner is a society registered under the Society's Registration Act, 1860 in the name of Agra Tourist Guide Welfare Association and has more than 200 members, who are not holding any licence issued either by the govt. of U.P. or Department of Tourism and have been working under the interim orders passed by this Hon'ble court from time to time to take such tourists to the monuments located all over Uttar Pradesh.

3. The petitioners had applied in terms of the advertisement and also appeared for the Tourist Guide Training Examination which was held on 26th August, 2007 and was conducted by the Respondent. Because the results were not declared, some of the candidates approached the court by way of writ petition on 20th September, 2007 for the declaration of result. This writ petition was disposed of on the statement of counsel for Government that result would be declared shortly. As the result has not been declared, the petitioners have sought relief to pursue their vacation till the final selection process is concluded. WP (C) No.137/2008 Page No.2

4. Ms. Anjana Gusain, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, submits that the petitioners are at the verge of starvation on account of deprivation of only source of livelihood. It is further urged that apart from the interests of the petitioners, grave prejudice is resulting to the facilities which are made available as tourist guides to national monuments and monuments of importance for want of tourist guides for persons visiting the same. I find that this matter is pending for finalisation of the examination result since August,

2007.

5. Ms. Anjana Gusain, learned counsel for the petitioner, places reliance on the judgment dated 7th March, 2005 passed by this court in WP (C) No.4366/2001 Anuj Johari Vs. Union of India & Ors. It is pointed out that along with this writ petition, a batch of several hundred writ petitions were disposed of by the court. So far as the petitioners were concerned, the court had approved the guidelines laid down by the respondents so as to regulate the appointment and functioning of tourist guides. The respondents were given liberty to WP (C) No.137/2008 Page No.3 conduct eligibility examinations in order to assess the suitability of tourist guides. However, if they take the screening test and annual examination which is to be conducted by the respondent, pending declaration of result and finalisation of the issuance of licences, the court had granted interim protection to the petitioners. This judgment was assailed before the Apex Court and challenge thereto has been rejected.

6. I find that by an order passed on 9th January, 2007, several other writ petitions including WP (C) No.11378-425/2006 and connected matters seeking the same relief have been allowed by this court.

7. The present writ petition has been necessitated on the sole ground that despite the respondent's having held the examination as back as on 18th December, 2005 in terms of the judgment in Anuj Johari Vs. Union of India & Orgs. (Supra), the result thereof has not been declared. As a result, thirtyseven petitioners whose name and particulars have been detailed in annexure P-3 at page 60 of the paper book, have been deprived of their only source of livelihood. WP (C) No.137/2008 Page No.4

8. The petitioners have had to consequently file the present writ petition seeking a direction to the respondent to permit the petitioners who have duly appeared in the examination to be granted temporary licence to work as tourist guides as an interim measure till declaration of the result.

9. The respondents have contended that they are unable to finalise the process of declaration of result on account of certain interim orders which have been passed by the High Court of Rajasthan. The respondents have submitted that even their application seeking vacation of the interim orders have not been considered so far.

10. Pursuant to the detailed directions made by this court as back as on 7th March, 2005, the respondents actually having taken steps to implement the same by holding the examination. It is an admitted position that a large number of persons have participated and undertaken the examination conducted by the respondents.

11. The petitioners have contended that they were working as tourist guides. They have abided by the WP (C) No.137/2008 Page No.5 judgments of this court and taken the examination. However, for want of declaration of result and finalisation thereof, they are unable to provide services as tourist guides. These persons have stated that they have been working as tourist guides for a long period even prior to December, 2005 when the earlier writ petitions were decided.

12. In view of the above discussions, I find substance in the submission made by Ms. Anjana Gusain, learned counsel for the petitioner, with regard to the fact that public interest is being severely impaired inasmuch as tourist guides with knowledge and eligibility to discharge the function of tourist guides, are not available at the national monuments and other monuments of importance. As a result, not only the interests of the petitioners who seek the issuance of licences to earn their living, are deprived of the same but the interests and rights of the millions of tourists, both national and international, who visit these monuments, are adversely impacted as they are deprived of knowledgeable and experienced tourist guides to guide them around these monuments and WP (C) No.137/2008 Page No.6 provide valuable information to them. Lack of such facilities must be irreparably denying the impression of such tourists with regard to availability of such an essential facility.

13. It has been pointed out that in all the petitions which were pending prior hitherto, this court has been consistently granting interim protection to the petitioners pending their undertaking the examination and finalisation of the results and licences. On a consideration of the rival contentions, I am of the view that this writ petition deserves to be disposed of at this stage with the following directions:-

(i) The respondent shall issue temporary permits to the petitioners who have been detailed in annexure P- 3 page 60 after verification of the fact that they have participated in the examination conducted which are held on 26th August, 2007.

7,237 characters total

(ii) Temporary licences which may be issued by the respondent, shall continue till such time the respondents finalise the results of the examination held by them.

(iii) Such scrutiny and issuance of the temporary

WP (C) No.137/2008 Page No.7 licence shall be completed by the respondent within a period of four weeks from today. It is directed accordingly. This writ petition is disposed of in the above terms. Copy of this order be given dasti to counsel for the parties.

(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE March 04, 2008 aa