Sh. Dhari Ram And Anr v. D.T.C. And Anr

Delhi High Court · 10 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:899
Kailash Gambhir
Review Pet. 95/2008 in FAO No. 86/1991
2008:DHC:899
civil petition_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The High Court dismissed the review petition, holding that deduction for personal expenses in compensation claims depends on case facts and one-third deduction was justified.

Full Text
Translation output
Review Pet. 95/2008 in FAO No. 86/1991 HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Review Pet. 95/2008 in FAO No. 86/1991
JUDGMENT
delivered on: March 10, 2008 Sh. Dhari Ram And Anr. ....... Appellants
Through: Mr. Y.R. Sharma, Adv.
versus
D.T.C. And Anr. ..... Respondents
Through: Mr. J.S. Bhasin, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KAILASH GAMBHIR,

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may No be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to Reporter or not? No

3. Whether the judgment should be reported No in the Digest? KAILASH GAMBHIR, J. Oral: * By way of this application, the applicant seeks review of the order on the short ground that this Court has taken 2008:DHC:899 into consideration 1/3rd of the income towards personal expenses of the deceased. Counsel appearing for the applicant contends that as per the settled legal position, deduction should have been to the tune of 2/3rd of income towards personal expenses of the deceased. He has placed reliance on a judgment of the Apex Court in Donat Louis Machado & Ors vs. L. Ravindra & Ors reported in II(2000) ACC 602 (SC). I have heard counsel for the parties and have perused the record. Review is a creature of statute and the power of review can be only exercised when the ingredients of Section 114 read with Order XLVII of the Civil Procedure Code are satisfied. I do not find any force in the contention of the applicant as the Apex Court has itself held that the percentage of deduction for personal expenditure cannot be put into a straight jacket formula and the percentage of deduction towards personal expenses would depend upon facts and circumstances of the case. In this regard in Fakeerappa v. Karnataka Cement Pipe Factory, (2004) 2 SCC 473, the Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:-

“7. What would be the percentage of deduction for personal expenditure cannot be governed by any rigid rule or formula of universal application. It would depend upon circumstances of each case. The deceased undisputedly was a bachelor. Stand of the insurer is that after marriage, the contribution to the parents would have been lesser and, therefore, taking an overall view the Tribunal and the High Court were justified in fixing the deduction.
8. It has to be noted that the ages of the parents as disclosed in the claim petition were totally unbelievable. If the deceased was aged about 27 years as found at the time of postmortem and about which there is no dispute, the father and mother could not have been aged 38 years and 35 years respectively as claimed by them in the claim petition. Be that as it may, taking into account special features of the case we feel it would be appropriate to restrict the deduction for personal expenses to one-third of the monthly income. Though the multiplier adopted appears to be slightly on the higher side, the plea taken by the insurer cannot be accepted, as there was no challenge by the insurer to the fixation of the multiplier before the High Court and even in the appeal filed by the appellants before the High Court, the plea was not taken”. No grounds for review. Dismissed. March 10, 2008 KAILASH GAMBHIR, J 'raj'