Mrs. Meenakshi Rai Bhatia v. M/s Ernet India & ors.

Delhi High Court · 11 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:916
Sudershan Kumar Misra
Writ Petition (Civil) No.8095/2007
2008:DHC:916
civil appeal_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that an expired offer of appointment can be validly withdrawn when the candidate fails to join within the stipulated time and declined to grant interim reliefs to keep the offer open pending resolution of disputes.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Writ Petition (Civil) No.8095/2007
Date of Decision: 11th March, 2008
Mrs.Meenakshi Rai Bhatia …..Petitioner
Through : Mr.G.D.Gupta, Senior Advocate with Mr.R.K.Saini and Mr.N.R.Sharma
VERSUS
M/s Ernet India & ors. .…Respondent
Through : Mr.Sanjay Jain, Senior Advocate with
Mr.Vakul Sharma,Ms.Sadhna Sharma and Mr.Arjun Mitra for respondent No.1
Mr.B.K.Satija for respondent No.3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDERSHAN KUMAR MISRA
JUDGMENT

1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not ? No

3. Whether the judgment should be reported No in the Digest ? SUDERSHAN KUMAR MISRA, J (Oral) CM Nos. 15280/07 & 179/2008

1. By this order I propose to dispose of these two applications filed by the petitioner at different stages of this petition. With the petition, the petitioner had filed CM No. 15280/2007. There the following reliefs were sought: “(a) appropriate orders/ directions directing the respondent No.1 to relieve the petitioner forthwith by retaining her lien so as to unable her to join service in respondent No.3 pending disposal and subject to the decision of the writ petition. (b) appropriate orders/directions directing the respondent No.3 to keep open the offer of appointment for the post of Dy. Director (Audit) given to the petitioner, pending disposal of the 2008:DHC:916

(c) pass such other further order (s) as this

Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present case and in the interest of justice.” Thereafter, on 4.1.2008 CM No.179/2008 came to be filed by the petitioner. In that application, the following reliefs were sought: “(a) Issue appropriate orders/ directions staying the operation on the letter dated 1.1.2008 (Annexure III) issued by the respondent No.3 and further restrain the respondent No.3 from offering/ appointing any other candidate to the post of Dy.Director (Audit), pending disposal of the writ petition. (b) further prepone the date of hearing from 7.4.2007 to some time in the month of January, 2008 itself for hearing and disposal of the case.

(c) pass such other further order (s) as the

Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present case and in the interest of justice.”

2. While issuing notice in the second application i.e. CM No.179/2008, I had directed respondent No.3 to maintain status quo. The counsel for respondent No.3, National Co-operative Development Corporation, states that the original offer of appointment issued to the petitioner makes it clear that in case the petitioner fails to join by the stipulated date, i.e 15 days from the date of issue of letter offering appointment, the offer of appointment shall stand automatically cancelled. He has drawn my attention to the letter dated 26.07.2007 issued by his client to the petitioner and in particular, the contents of paragraph 3 thereof where it clearly states that “if no reply is received from you or you fail to report for duty by the prescribed time limit, the offer will be treated as cancelled.” Thereafter, respondent No.3 cancelled the appointment of the petitioner by a letter of 1st January, 2008, inter alia, on the ground been filed on the record by the petitioner herself along with her application CM No.179/2008. Counsel for respondent no. 3 further states that this action of his client had been challenged by the petitioner in a substantive Writ Petition No. 986/2008. In that petition, the specific prayer of the petitioner was for, “a writ of certiorari quashing the action of the respondent, in cancelling the offer of appointment made to the petitioner, being illegal, arbitrarily, malafide, unwarranted and irregular and in violation of the rules, regulations and policies of Constitution of India and consequently the letter dated 1.01.2008”. It would appear that in that writ petition, while challenging the said order of 1.01.2008, the petitioner had also annexed a copy of the aforesaid order passed by me on 7.01.2008 in the present petition whereby respondent No.3 was directed to maintain status quo with regard to the post which was offered to the petitioner. Ultimately that writ petition was dismissed as withdrawn on 6.02.2008.

3. One of the contentions of respondent No.3 is that, in fact, there is no challenge by the petitioner to its order of 1.1.2008 in this petition and hence there can be no question of any interim directions being passed in respect of that order. In this respect, it would be necessary to note that after my aforesaid order of 7.1.2008 directing status quo in CM No. 179/2008; the petitioner approached this court in writ petition No. 986/2008 against the aforesaid impugned order dated 1.01.2008, cancelling the offer of appointment with a view to “avoid any technical hitch and difficulty”. There, it was alleged that the action of respondent No.3 in issuing the order dated 1.01.2008 was illegal and mala fide and amounts to over-reaching the court in stay being CM No. 15280/2007 was pending before the court in this writ petition, and yet they cancelled the offer of appointment in violation of the doctrine of lis pendence. For that reason, the petitioner sought quashing of the order dated 1.01.2008 by that writ.

4. On 6.02.2008, that writ petition, WP (C ) No. 986/2008, came be to be dismissed as withdrawn. Counsel for respondent No. 3 states that whilst withdrawing Writ Petition No.986/2008, no liberty was sought, or granted, permitting the petitioner to challenge the order dated 1.01.2008 in a fresh petition.

5. It appears to me that the petitioner has taken a completely obdurate approach in this matter. At the time of its initial offer, all that respondent No.3 knew was the petitioner possessed the requisite qualifications and experience for the job and, most importantly, that the petitioner's application had been duly forwarded to respondent No.3 for appointment with that organisation on the post in question. Although admittedly, the said letter stated that no vigilance case is either pending or contemplated against the petitioner, it was also clearly stated that in case she gets selected, she will be relieved as per rules of respondent No.1. Ultimately, respondent No.1 has chosen not to relieve her in view of the fact that a vigilance enquiry has come to be initiated against the petitioner and a charge sheet is also stated to have been issued to the petitioner on 5.11.2007, and an enquiry is in progress. In this connection, the stand of respondent No.1 is that after the petitioner's application seeking employment was forwarded by it to respondent No.3 on 19.10.2006; some discrepancy in the petitioner's claim for medical reimbursement lodged by the petitioner with respondent resulted in the issuance of the charge sheet and the ongoing enquiry proceedings. It is from the pleadings of the parties in this matter that respondent No.3 has learnt that in fact some vigilance enquiries are pending against the petitioner and that her previous employer has instituted disciplinary proceedings against her. It is not inconceivable that had respondent No.3 known of these facts before making the offer of employment to the petitioner, they may not have offered the appointment at all.

6. While there is no gainsaying the fact that subject to proof of the relevant facts; other civil remedies may be available to the petitioner against the respondent No.1 and 2 including, inter alia, for the petitioner having lost her chance of employment with respondent No.3, I am unable to persuade myself to direct respondent No.3 to keep the post open and unfilled till such time that her dispute with her current employer is resolved. Even if this writ petition were to be decided overnight, either party would have the option of filing further appeals and take the matter right up to the Supreme Court if so advised. This must necessarily entail considerable loss of time. I do not think it would be fair to deny respondent No.3; whose position, to my mind is akin to that of a completely innocent party in this fight between the petitioner and her employer; the services of an experienced auditor that it obviously needs. It has put respondent No.3 in a difficult position where it has to keep this post vacant for an indefinite period of time and that too only because it had chosen to offer the post to the petitioner under a given set of circumstances.

7. As I have stated, there was no certainty that respondent No.3 would have made this offer to begin with, if it had prior proceedings and also a vigilance enquiry, in her previous employment. To put it differently, if respondent No.3 were to take that decision now after full knowledge of all the facts and circumstances, there is no certainty that the offer of appointment would be held out. Furthermore, to my mind, respondent No.3 had merely made an offer of appointment to the petitioner that was valid up to a specific period. At the petitioner's request, this offer was extended for a further period. If the petitioner was unable to join for any reason within the time granted, I do not see how the petitioner can compel respondent No.3 to extend its offer any further. Respondent No.3 is clearly in a position to decline the appointment to the petitioner on two grounds. Firstly, on the ground that the petitioner has failed to join within the time granted, for the reasons not attributable to respondent No.3. Secondly, on the ground that even if it is assumed that respondent No.3 was obliged to honour its offer, the same had already expired and was no longer on the table and in view of the new facts and circumstances that have now come to the knowledge of respondent No.3, there has been a material change in the factual circumstances and it does not wish to engage the service of the petitioner, and therefore there was no question of renewing that offer or of making any fresh offer. Looking to the circumstances of this case, in my view, the petitioner has not demonstrated any unqualified right that might compel respondent NO. 3 to engage the petitioner and that too after waiting for an indefinite period. In addition the fact that even the substantive challenge to the withdrawal of the offer of respondent no. 3, that was brought by the petitioner in WP(C) No.986/2008, has been dismissed by the court orders against respondent no. 3 in both these applications, are dismissed. The order of status quo dated 7.01.2008 is also vacated.

8. With this, CM Nos.15280/07 and 179/2008 are disposed of CM No.2087/2008.

10,764 characters total

9. Mr.Saini, who appears for the petitioner states that he has received the reply of respondent No.3 only yesterday and that he wishes to file a rejoinder to the same. Let the same be filed within two weeks with an advance copy to counsel for the respondent. W.P.(C) No. 8095/2007

10. Counsel for the petitioner states that he does not wish to pursue his challenge against respondent No.2. In view of the matter, let respondent No.2 be deleted from the array of parties. Petitioner may file the amended memo of parties within one week from today.

11. Renotify on 7th April, 2008, the date already fixed. March 11, 2008 Sudershan Kumar Misra, J ib