Full Text
Date of Decision: 27.02.2008
Devesh Kumar & Ors. ….… Petitioners
Through: Mr.Sunil Malhotra, Advocate
Through : Ms.Jyoti Singh, Advocate
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of Local papers may YES be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not? NO
3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J. + CM No.3075/2008 in W.P.(C) No.283/1992 * Issue notice to the respondent/non-applicant. Ms.Jyoti Singh accepts notice and states that she does not want to file any reply. She, however, contends that relief claimed by the petitioners is based on different cause of action and the petitioners should file a separate writ petition. This is an application by the petitioners under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking amendment to the writ petition. 2008:DHC:717 The petitioners/applicant contended that in their petition seeking they have sought quashing of orders of cancellation of panel formed in September, 1988 of the Junior Engineer (Electrical). They have also sought a direction to the respondent to form a fresh panel of Junior Engineers (Electrical) and appoint no other person against the post of Junior Engineer and for a writ of mandamus directing the respondent to appoint the petitioners as Junior Engineer (Electrical) before appointing any other candidate to the said post. The petitioners contended that court passed an order dated 22nd October, 1992 directing the respondent that no fresh appointment be made to the post of Junior Engineer (Electrical), however, the respondent was given liberty to appoint the petitioners. This interim order was confirmed by order dated 22nd January, 1993. The application of the respondent to modify the interim order dated 21st April, 1993 was partly allowed and the respondent were directed to keep four vacancies for the petitioners. The petitioners asserted that out of four of them, three were departmental candidates and one was from outside. The respondent, therefore, appointed petitioners on the basis of select panel as Junior Engineer (Electrical) on ad hoc basis for a period of six months and thereafter, the respondent has continued the services of the petitioners by extending the ad hoc appointments for six months from time to time for the last 14 years. The petitioners stated that they have completed 14 years and are still continuing on ad hoc basis without any break in service after being duly selected in accordance with rules. The petitioners’ grievance is that they are 40 to 50 years of age, however, they have not been regularized and they are entitled for regularization from the date of their ad hoc appointment to the post of JE (Electrical). In view of the pendency of the writ petition for a considerable period and the petitioners continuing to work as Junior Engineer (Electrical), the petitioners want to amend the writ petition and want to incorporate paras 5 to 8 and grounds A and B and consequently prayer 3A to the writ petition also and therefore, the present application for amendment has been filed. No reply to the application has been filed by the respondent. Learned counsel for the respondent states that amendment sought shall change the nature of the reliefs sought by the petitioners. The power to allow the amendment is wide and can be exercised at any stage of the proceedings in the interests of justice on the basis of guidelines laid down in various precedents. Though the amendment cannot be claimed as a matter of right and under all circumstances but the Courts while deciding such prayer do not adopt a hyper technical approach. The purpose and object of Order 6 Rule 17 is to allow either party to alter or amend his pleading in such manner and on such terms as may be just. Amendments are allowed in the pleadings to avoid uncalled for multiplicity of litigation. This is not disputed that the court can take note of subsequent events. The petitioners are seeking relief on the basis of subsequent events which have occurred during the pendency of the writ petition as on account of interim order passed by this court, the petitioners were appointed as ad hoc Junior Engineers and have continued as Junior Engineers for the last many years. Normal rule is that in any litigation the right and obligation of the parties are adjudicated upon as they obtained at the commencement of the lis. But this too is subject to an exception. Where subsequent events of facts or law which have a material bearing on the entitlement of the parties to relief or on aspects which depend on the molding of the relief occurs, the Court is not precluded from taking note of the subsequent events of facts and to mold the relief accordingly. In Pasupuleti Venkateshwarlu vs. Motor and General Traders, (1975) 1 SCC 770 at page 773 para 4 the Apex Court had held as under:-
4. We feel the submissions devoid of substance. First about the jurisdiction and propriety vis-a-vis circumstances which come into being subsequent to the commencement of the proceedings. It is basic to our processual jurisprudence that the right to relief must be judged to exist as on the date a suitor institutes the legal proceeding. Equally clear is the principle that procedure is the handmaid and not the mistress of the judicial process. If a fact, arising after the lis has come to court and has a fundamental impact on the right to relief or the manner of moulding it, is brought diligently to the notice of the tribunal, it cannot blink at it or be blind to events which stultify or render inept the decreetal remedy. Equity justifies bending the rules of procedure, where no specific provision or fairplay is violated, with a view to promote substantial justice — subject, of course, to the absence of other disentitling factors or just circumstances. Nor can we contemplate any limitation on this power to take note of updated facts to confine it to the trial court. If the litigation pends, the power exists, absent other special circumstances repelling resort to that course in law or justice. Rulings on this point are legion, even as situations for applications of this equitable rule are myriad. We affirm the proposition that for making the right or remedy claimed by the party just and meaningful as also legally and factually in accord with the current realities, the Court can, and in many cases must, take cautious cognizance of events and developments subsequent to the institution of the proceeding provided the rules of fairness to both sides are scrupulously obeyed. On both occasions the High Court, in revision, correctly took this view. The later recovery of another accommodation by the landlord, during the pendency of the case, has as the High Court twice pointed out, a material bearing on the right to evict, in view of the inhibition written into Section 10(3)(iii) itself. We are not disposed to disturb this approach in law or finding of fact. Taking these facts into consideration, it is apparent that the amendment sought by the petitioners is relevant for determination of real controversies between the parties and is based on the fact that the petitioners are continuing on ad-hoc basis for the last 14 years and their term is being extended on six monthly basis. It is also true that at the time of adjudication of the application for amendment by a party who takes a particular plea, normally the validity and correctness of the plea is not to be determined so as to allow or disallow the amendment sought by a party. In the said facts and circumstances, I do not find any embargo in allowing the application for amendment of the petition by the petitioners. The application is, therefore, liable to be allowed and the petitioners are entitled to amend the petition incorporating the paras, ground and reliefs as detailed therein. For the foregoing reasons the application for amendment of the writ petition is allowed. The petitioners are allowed to amend the writ petition in order to incorporate amendments as detailed in the application subject to a cost of Rs.5000/- payable by petitioners to the respondent. Amended writ petition be filed. W.P.(C) No.283/1992 Amended writ petition dated 22nd February, 2008 already filed is taken on record. The learned counsel for the respondent seeks time to file additional counter affidavit. Additional counter affidavit be filed within eight weeks. Rejoinder, if any, within four weeks thereafter. List on 9th July, 2008. February 27th, 2008 ANIL KUMAR, J. 'K/Dev'