Management of M/s. A.R. Chadha & Co. (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Workman Shri Baldev Singh & Anr.

Delhi High Court · 24 Sep 2008 · 2008:DHC:719
Anil Kumar
WP(C) No.1983/2006
2008:DHC:719
labor petition_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the application under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 against the petitioner, holding that no employer-employee relationship existed to warrant payment of wages.

Full Text
Translation output
WPC No.1983/2006 HIGH COURT OF DELHI WP(C) No.1983/2006
Date of Decision: 27.02.2006 Management of M/s. A.R. Chadha
& Co. (India) Pvt. Ltd. ….… Petitioner
Through: Mr.L.K. Garg, Advocates.
VERSUS
Workman, Shri Baldev Singh & Anr. ......... Respondents
Through : Mr.S. Janani, Advocate for respondent No.1.
CORAM :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of Local papers may YES be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the reporter or not? NO

3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J. *

1. This is an application by the respondent under Section 17 B of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 claiming arrears of back wages from the date of award and wages month by month during the pendency of the writ petition on the ground that the respondent no.1/applicant is unemployed.

2. The respondent No.1 had raised an industrial dispute against the petitioner and respondent No.2, M/s.Archana Cinema Shopping 2008:DHC:719 Centre Association, Greater Kailash. The respondent No.1 had contended that he was appointed by the petitioner by an appointment letter dated 7th July, 1986 and his services were later transferred under an agreement to respondent No.2 which association was headed by Shri Basant Kumar Binani, President of the association.

3. In the claim petition, the respondent No.1 categorically asserted that his services were terminated by the President of respondent No.2 on 28th October, 1998 without any notice and without payment of his dues.

4. The claim of the respondent No.1 was contested by petitioner also, however, it was held that the respondent No.1 is liable to be reinstated with full back wages by award dated 19th November, 2004. The award was passed against the petitioner also as the petitioner had been proceeded ex parte.

5. This is no more res integra that Section 17 B is a benevolent provision and passing orders directing payment of wages last drawn is generally the rule whereas refusing to grant relief under Section 17 B is an exception. An order under Section 17 B is declined in rare cases of jurisdictional error where there is no relationship of employer and employee between the parties.

6. The respondent No.1/applicant has contended that the petitioner is the proprietor of respondent No.2. Along with the application, the appointment letter of the respondent No.1 has been produced along with the minutes of the meeting dated 23rd December, 1986 between the petitioner and Archna Cinema Shopping Centre Association, respondent No.2.

7. Perusal of the record reveals that the alleged minutes between the petitioner and respondent No.2 dated 23rd December, 1986 were not produced before the Labour Court.

8. The minutes of the meeting produced by the respondent No.1 itself negate his allegation that the petitioner is the proprietor of respondent No.2. The petitioner is a private limited company and respondent No.2 is an Association. The fact that there was meeting between the petitioner and respondent No.2 demonstrates that the two are independent entities and the allegation that the petitioner is the proprietor of respondent No.2 cannot be inferred in the facts and circumstances.

9. Learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn my attention to the statement of respondent No.1 before the Labour Court. The respondent No.1 in his deposition filed on affidavit dated 24th April, 2001 categorically deposed that though he was appointed by the petitioner on 7th July, 1986, however, his services were transferred under an agreement to respondent No.2. It is also admitted by the respondent No.1 that his services were terminated by respondent No.2. It has also been deposed by the respondent No.1 that after transfer of management to respondent No.2, he was serving as a Maintenance Officer with respondent No.2 with effect from 9th January, 1987.

10. The cross-examination of the respondent No.1 before the Labour Court is quite revealing where he has admitted that the respondent No.2 was sharing employer’s contribution after 1987 in the provident fund account. He has also admitted categorically that respondent No.2 is an Association and its members are the shopkeepers of Archana Shopping Complex. It was also deposed that respondent No.2 has his own President, Secretary, Executive Body and Management. The respondent No.1/applicant also categorically contended that petitioner is a company which is a private limited company and he had ceased to be an employee of petitioner after 9th January, 1987. The cross-examination of the respondent No.1 before the Labour court is as under:- “STATEMENT OF SHRI BALDEVA SINGH SON OF KARTAR SINGH AGED 54 YEARS R/O B-I/23 A, VISHNU GARDEN NEW DELHI-18. I tender in evidence my affidavit Ex WW1/A which bears my signatures at point A & B along with Documents Ex WW1/1 to Ex WW1/6. XXX By Shri A.K. Singla for Management. It is wrong to say that I have concealed the quantum of my salary from the Court by not mentioning the same in any of my document. It is so mentioned in my Affidavit at Para No.10 Ex WW 1/A. It is correct that I have placed photocopies & no original document is on the record. I have brought the original documents but since I have not been asked to show the originals, I have not shown. Vide Ex WW1/3 I mean the termination/retrenchment letter. I have not brought the original of the same. It is not with me. It is wrong to say that Ex WW 1/3 is not a termination/retrenchment letter. This termination letter was issued by the President of Respondent No.2. I have no other letter like permanent placement letter separately except my appointment letter Ex WW1/1. I was getting the salary in cash. The salary in cash was paid to me by the president of Respondent No.2 after 1987. It is correct that in my PF Account, it was Respondent No.2 who was sharing employer’s contribution after 1987. Respondent No.2 is an Association and its members are the shopkeepers of Archna Cinema Shopping Complex. Respondent No.2 has his own President, Secretary, Executive Body and management. I know that respondent No.1 is a company, which is a private limited company. It is correct that after 9/1/1987 I ceased to be an employee of management 1 and I became the employee of management 2.”

11. From the deposition of the respondent No.1, it is apparent and clear that he himself has admitted that the petitioner is a private limited company and respondent No.2 is an Association which are distinct and different. In view of the categorical admission on the part of respondent No.1, the allegation now made by respondent No.1 in the application that the petitioner is the proprietor of respondent No.2 is not correct nor such inference can be drawn from any of the documents produced by respondent No.1 before this Court. The respondent No.1 has also categorically admitted that even the contribution for his provident fund is made by respondent No.2.

12. The inevitable inference, in the facts and circumstances, is that there is no prima facie relationship of employer and employee between the petitioner and respondent No.1. In the circumstances, it is a rare case where this court will not have any jurisdiction to pass an order under Section 17 B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 against the petitioner as even according to the admissions made by the respondent No.1, the employer is respondent No.2 and not the petitioner.

9,398 characters total

13. Learned counsel for the petitioner has also relied on 2001 (90) FLR 67, Employer, The Management of Central Mine Planning and Design Institute Limited vs. Union of India holding that refusing to grant relief under Section 17 B is an exception. Merely because on account of Section 17 B of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, the High Court has unfettered power and jurisdiction to pass an order under Section 17 B, in case if prima facie it is established that there is no relationship of employer and employee between the parties, the power of the High Court to dismiss the application also cannot be taken away. Section 17 B also does not impose such a liability on the High court that under Article 226 of the Constitution of India such an order has to be passed even if prima facie and even according to the admissions made by the employees, it can be inferred that there is no relationship of employer and employee.

14. This cannot be disputed that in extreme cases where it is demonstrated that the award passed is either without jurisdiction or is otherwise a nullity, the court can decline to make an order in terms of Section 17 B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The case of the respondent No.1 is such in which he himself has admitted that respondent No.2 is the employer. Respondent No.1 even categorically admitted that the petitioner is a private limited company whereas respondent No.2 is an Association. The allegation now made in the application that petitioner is the proprietor of respondent No.2 is without any basis as neither any document has been produced to demonstrate this nor any such inference can be drawn from the evidence led by the respondent No.1 before the Labour Court. In the circumstances, there are no ground to pass an order under Section 17 B of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 in favour of respondent No.1 and against the petitioner directing the petitioner to pay the last drawn wages or the minimum wages whichever is higher or to continue to pay the wages during the pendency of the present writ petition. The application of the respondent No.1 under Section 17B of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is, therefore, without any merit and is liable to be dismissed. The application is, therefore, dismissed. WP(C) No.1983/2006 List for hearing on September 24, 2008. February 27th, 2008 ANIL KUMAR, J. 'Dev'