Full Text
CO.APP. 63/2005
Date of Decision: 29th February, 2008.
CRB CAPITAL MARKETS LTD. ..... Appellant
RESERVE BANK OF INDIA ..... Appellant
MALANPUR STEEL LTD. ..... Appellant
SECURITIES & EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA ..... Appellant
GUJARAT INDUST.INVEST.CORPN.LT ..... Appellant
Batra, Mr. Bhuvan Gugnani, Mr. Ritesh Kumar, Mr. Navpreet S. Ahluwalia, Ms. Shikha Bhardwaj, advs. for
CRB Capital Markets Ltd.
Mr. Ramesh Babu.M.R., Ms. Manisha, Mr. Srinjoy Banerjee, Ms. Swati Setia, advs. for Reserve Bank of
India.
Mr. Parag P. Tripathi, ASG. with Mr. Abhishek Kumar, Mr. Sanjay Bhatt, Ms. Vismai Rao, advs. for SEBI.
Mr. R.P. Bhatt, Sr. adv. with Mr. Chirag Shroff, Mr. Mukesh Kumar, Mr. Dattatray, Vyas, advs. for GIIC.
Mr. Susmit Pushkar, Ms. Neha Khatri, advs. for the appellants in Co.APP. 9/2006.
Mr. P.J. Mehta, adv. for IDBI Bank Ltd.
Mr. Amit S. Chadha, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Kunal Sinha, adv. for applicant in CA NO. 13223-27/2007
Mr. S.K. Luthra with Mr. Manish Tyagi, adv. for Official
Liquidator Mr. Rekha Anand, adv. for KVB.
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE VEENA BIRBAL
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Not Necessary
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Not Necessary
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Not Necessary Per Thakur, J(Oral): This appeal arises out of an order passed by a Company Court in Company Petition No. 251/2002 whereby the said Court has sanctioned a scheme for the respondent, CRB Capital Markets Limited in terms of Section 391-392 of the Companies Act, 1956. While Company Appeal No. 8/2006 has been filed by the RBI, Company Appeal No. 15/2006 has been filed by SEBI. Company Appeal No. creditor of the respondent-company. Company Appeal No. 18/2006 has been filed by GIIC who also claims to be a secured creditor but is admitted to be so only to the extent of a part of the debt due to the said corporation.
2. When these appeals came up for hearing before us on 7th December, 2007 and were argued at considerable length, learned counsel for the parties submitted that the order impugned in the appeals could be set aside as certain important aspects that arose for consideration had not been addressed in the same. While M/s Tripathi and Ramesh Babu appearing for two of the appellants pointed out certain aspects that deserved to be examined and determined by the Single Judge, learned counsel for the respondent-company suggested certain other aspects which according to them required to be similarly examined and determined. This Court had, however, left the issues that required to be determined by the Company Judge open and adjourned the appeals to enable the parties to articulate the same. For a better understanding of what transpired on 7th December, 2007, we may extract the order in extenso: “After arguing the matter at considerable length, learned counsel for the parties submit that the order passed by the learned Company Court could be set aside as certain important aspects that arise for consideration have not been addressed in the order under appeal. While M/s Tripathi and Ramesh Babu points out certain aspects that deserve to be examined and determined by learned Single Judge but have not been so examined or determined. Learned counsel appearing for respondent/company similarly suggested certain other aspects which according to him had not been examined and require determination. We do not, for the present, wish to identify the areas that arise for consideration and ought to have been examined by the learned Company Court. All that we need say is that learned counsel for could approve the scheme proposed by the company in which event this Court would examine the matter further and pass an appropriate order identifying the areas that may, on remand, be looked into and determined by the learned Single Judge while passing a fresh order. Post on 14th December, 2007.”
3. When the matter came up today, learned counsel for the RBI, in whose petition filed under Section 45 MC(1) of the RBI Act the impugned scheme has been sanctioned, has formulated four questions which according to him need to be examined by the Company Court after remand for a final and effectual adjudication of the matter in controversy. These questions are as under: i. Whether the grounds for Winding-Up of the Company under Section 45 MC(1) of the RBI Act as made out in the Winding Up Petition exists and if so to what effect? ii. Whether a Scheme under Section 391 is maintainable in a winding up petition filed by the Reserve Bank of India under Section 45 MC (1) of the Act? iii. Whether the Scheme submitted by the propounder is bonafide, fair and feasible? iv. Whether Criminal and Income Tax proceedings can be stayed while sanctioning a scheme under Section 391?
4. On behalf of respondent-CRB Capital Markets Limited also the learned counsel appearing on its behalf filed a memo formulating the following two questions that according to it need to be examined by the Company Court after remand. i. Whether the grounds for Winding up of the Company under Section 45 MC(1) of the RBI Act as made out in the Winding Up petition exists and if so to what effect? winding up Petition filed by the Reserve Bank of India under Section 45 MC(1) of the Act?
5. Mr. Tripathi, learned ASG appearing for the SEBI, however, has added yet another question to the questions formulated on behalf of the RBI. The said question is as under: i. Whether a scheme formulated under Section 391-392 of the Company's Act could set aside the statutory orders passed by a Statutory Authority like SEBI constituted under the SEBI Act of 1992.
6. Appearing for the respondent-company, Mr. Chandhiok submitted that instead of formulating four questions as suggested by the RBI and the additional question suggested by Mr. Tripathi appearing for SEBI, the remand order could be limited to the examination of only two questions suggested by the respondentcompany and instead of setting aside the order passed by the Company Court in toto, this Court could remand the matter for consideration of those two questions only. We regret our inability to accept that submission. The submission made by Mr. Chandhiok in our opinion flies in the face of the concession which was made on behalf of the respondent-company on 7th December, 2007 by Dr. A.M. Singhvi, appearing on its behalf that the entire order passed by the Company Court could be set aside and the matter remanded back for consideration of such of the aspects as had not been examined by the Company Court while passing the impugned order. We, therefore, fail to appreciate how the respondent-company can today shift its ground and urge that the order need not be set aside and a remand order limited only for determination of the two questions proposed by the respondent be passed. This is particularly so when the questions have been addressed by the Company Court while making the impugned order. Whether or not a scheme under Section 391-392 of Companies Act was maintainable in a winding-up petition filed by the RBI under Section 45 MC(1) of the RBI Act; whether or not quasi judicial orders passed by a statutory authority like SEBI constituted under the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 could be set aside by a scheme formulated under Section 391-392 of the Companies Act; whether criminal and income tax proceedings pending against the company and its Directors could be set aside by a Company Court while sanctioning a scheme under Section 391-392 are all matters that have remained untouched by the Company Court. It was in the above circumstances that learned counsel for the respondent-company had on 7th December, 2007 agreed that the impugned order could be set aside and the above aspects that were being argued in the present appeals remitted back for examination and proper determination by the Company Court. Such being the position, there is no room for the respondent-company to wriggle out of that concession and seek a remand without the setting aside of the order passed by the Company Court. At any rate we are satisfied that the aspects that have been indicated above not having been properly determined by the Company Court require to be so determined on a remand to it. We accordingly set aside the impugned order passed by the Company Court and remit the matter back for a fresh disposal in accordance with law after addressing in particular following, among other, issues if any raised before it. i) Whether a scheme under Section 391-392 of the Companies Act is maintainable in a winding up petition filed by the RBI under Section 45 MC(1) of the RBI Act? Companies Act could set aside quasi judicial orders passed by a statutory authority like the SEBI constituted under the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992? iii) Whether criminal and income tax proceedings pending against the company and its Directors could be stayed by the Company Court while sanctioning a scheme under Section 391-392 of the Companies Act? iv) Depending upon the answers of questions 1 to 4 above whether the scheme formulated in the instant case is bonafide, feasible and fair? v) Whether grounds for winding up of the company under Section 45 MC (1) of the RBI as made out in the winding up petition exist. If so, to what effect?
7. Since the matter has remained pending before the Company Court for a long time and the same involves payments to a very large number of depositors, some of whom are senior citizens, women and people who suffer from physical infirmities, we would request the learned Company Court to expedite the disposal of the matter and pass final orders on the subject as far as possible within a period of six months from the date the parties appear before him in pursuance of this order. The appeals are disposed of with the above directions leaving the parties to bear their own costs.
8. All pending applications shall stand disposed of in terms of the above order. T.S.THAKUR, J