David Sharma & Ors. v. Delhi University & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 05 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:857
Gita Mittal
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 7393/2007
2008:DHC:857
administrative petition_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the writ petition challenging revised B.Sc. Part II results and promotion rules, upholding the university's valid relaxation of criteria and emphasizing the petitioners' concealment of material facts.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 7393/2007
JUDGMENT
reserved on : 3rd March, 2008
Date of Decision: March 5, 2008 David Sharma & Ors. ... Petitioner through: Mr. P.S. Sharma, Advocate
VERSUS
Delhi University & Ors. ....Respondents through: Mr. Anurag Mathur, Advocate for respondent no.1
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE GITA MITTAL

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? No

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? No

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?No GITA MITTAL, J

1. This writ petition has been filed by five students who have submitted that they have been admitted to the B.Sc. Life Sciences Course of different colleges of Delhi University in the academic session 2005-06. The petitioner no. 1 is a student of the Swami Shraddhanand College and the other four petitioners are students of the Shivaji College, which are affiliated to the University of Delhi. The petitioners were successful in the B.Sc. Part I and became eligible to undertake the part II examination in the year April, 2007. The petitioners have claimed that they were good students and had done well in class XII and therefore, were successful in getting admissions to these colleges. However, in the results of the B.Sc. Part II examination they have been shown as having failed.

2. The petitioners have complained that the respondents modified the 2008:DHC:857 result and allotted grace marks to different candidates arbitrarily. As a result several students have been passed and/or promoted to B.Sc. Part III whereas the petitioners have been denied the benefit of grace marks and revision in their results. Allegations of undue weightage of assessments have also been made in the writ petition.

3. On these allegations, the petitioners filed the present writ petition inter alia contending that the respondents be directed to place on record, the revised result and give details of students who have been passed as a result alongwith and to disclose reasons thereof. It has also been contended that the petitioners be declared as passed and promoted from B.Sc.Part II to B.Sc. Part III of the different colleges where they have been admitted. Alongwith the writ petition, the petitioners have annexed copy of the complete result of the candidates who undertook the B.Sc. (Life Sciences) (Programme) Part II examination held in April/May 2007 in support of their contentions.

4. The respondents have appeared in answer to the notice to show cause issued by this court. Mr. Anurag Mathur, learned counsel for respondent has contended that the respondents have notified the rules and regulations which have been titled as 'the Restructured B.Sc. Programme in Physical Sciences, Life Sciences, Applied Physical Sciences and Applied Life Sciences. These rules were notified by the executive council of the Delhi University in its meeting dated 29th April, 2005 and are effective from July, 2005. These rules contained 'the Promotion Rules'. So far as the Part II and part III examinations are concerned, the relevant promotional rules reads thus:- “2. The minimum marks required to pass the II year or III year examination in the three subjects of Science Domains shall be 36% in the aggregate of the Theory papers taken subject-wise and 36% in the Practical examination in each subject, and 36% in the Elective/Project in each year separately. The criteria will be applied separately to the University examination as well as in the total of the University examination and internal assessment.”

5. Thus a student is required to obtain 36% in the aggregate of the theory paper taken subject wise. In addition the candidate is required to secure 36% marks in the practicals. Even after adding the internal assessment the candidate should have 36% marks in the aggregate. Besides fulfilling the above criteria, the candidate is required to secure an aggregate of 36% marks after computing both the marks secured by him in the written examination as well as the internal assessment.

6. It is not disputed that the petitioners took the B.Sc. Part II examination in April/May, 2007. However, the respondents have disclosed on affidavit that there were large scale complaints and grievances from students studying in different colleges to the Vice Chancellor with regard to the difficulties faced by them. In order to consider these grievances, the Vice Chancellor constituted a committee to examine the matter. This committee made recommendations as a special case for the academic year 2006-07 when it recommended relaxation in the promotional rules for the B.Sc. Programme Part II Course. The recommendations of the Committee and the modified promotional rule 3 as placed before this court reads thus:- “Since this is the first batch of B.Sc. Programme Part II the students may be given relaxation in promotion rule (3) as a special case only for this year i.e. 2006-2007. The modified promotion rule (3) may be read as follows:- At the end of II year, a candidate who has secured pass marks (separately in Theory and Practicals in atleast one of the Science Domains and has secured 25% marks in the aggregate including the elective subject/project may be permitted to proceed to the III year class, and take subsequently the examination in the remaining subjects of II year (in which he has not secured the pass marks) along with the University examination of the III year.” These recommendations of the committee were granted approval by the Vice Chancellor.

7. From the above, it is evident that the respondents had reduced the pass criteria. So far as the second year candidate was concerned, the candidate was required to secure pass marks that is 36% marks, separately in theory and practicals, in at least one of the subjects/domains. In addition, the candidate was required to secure 25% marks in the aggregate of all subjects so as to be permitted to proceed to the 3rd year classes. Such candidates were required to subsequently take the examination in the remaining subjects of second year in which he had not secured the pass marks, that is 36% marks, alongwith the university examination of the 3rd year.

8. As a consequence of the above, the result of all candidates admitted to the B.Sc. Part II course was revised in terms of the modified rule 3 and necessary notifications were issued.

9. The respondents have made a categorical averment on affidavit that only candidates who fulfilled the modified promotional rules were notified to have qualified the B.Sc. Part II course and were promoted B.Sc. Part III course for the academic year 2007-08.

10. In this regard, it is noteworthy that Soumendu Mandal (holding the role number 8037032) has filed this writ petition as petitioner no. 5 herein. The respondents have contended that this petitioner was enrolled with the Shivaji College in the B.Sc. - Life Sciences IInd year course in the academic year 2006-07. So far as this candidate was concerned, the college originally failed to forward the internal assessment marks secured by him in one paper of the Botany subject that is paper no. 203. For this reason in the mark sheet originally issued to him by the respondents, no marks for internal assessment were reflected for said paper. Shivaji College furnished the entire assessment marks of the petitioner no. 5 herein and he was shown to have secured 11 marks out of a total of 25 marks in such internal assessment.

11. The case of the petitioner no. 5, Soumendu Mandal, was consequently re-examined upon receipt of these internal assessment marks. As a consequence, vide a notification dated 23rd January, 2007 the petitioner no. 5 has been declared as promoted to the B.Sc.(Life Sciences) Part III course with the Delhi University in the academic year 2007-08 as he fulfilled the eligibility criteria. The writ petitioners do not point out these facts. No grievance is made with regard to the revision of the marks of the petitioner no. 5 or his promotion to the next academic year.

12. The respondent were directed to place before this court a tabulation of the marks secured by the petitioners. The respondents have placed the following information with regard to the marks secured by the petitioners in the three subjects opted by them. Chemistry Botany Zoology Maximum marks Paper I (75+25) Paper II (75+25) Paper I (75+25) Paper II (75+25) Paper I (75+25) Paper II (75+25) Marks secured 21+6= 6+5= 26+3= 23+4= 30+12= 19+3= Total marks secured by the candidate in the written examination of 150 marks, conducted by the University of Delhi for each subject of study excluding Internal Assessment marks 21+6=27 out of 150 marks 26+23=49 30+19=49 Minimum marks required to qualify the written examination conducted by the University of Delhi for each (36% of 150 marks) 54 54 54 Total marks secured by the candidate out of a total of 200 marks after including Internal marks (27+11) out of 200 marks (29+27) (42+22) Minimum marks required to qualify in each after including Internal marks (36% of 200 marks 72 72 72

10,663 characters total

13. So far as Sumit Kumar petitioner no.3 is concerned, it has been pointed out that he was admitted to the old course when the role of internal assessment was not applicable. For this reason, his marks do not reflect the internal assessment marks. His marks were reduced proportionally to reflect the percentage out of 100 marks instead of 150 as is applicable under the new rules. This candidate has also failed to meet the requirements notified by the respondents in the modified rule 3 which is applicable only for the year 2006-07.

14. The petitioners have made totally vague and unsubstantiated allegations with regard to the results which have been notified by the respondents. No material to support the same has been placed on record. The petitioner no. 5 has succeeded in being promoted to the next year on an application of the modified rule 3. The respondents on affidavit have stated that on effectuating the revision on receipt of internal assessment marks and application of the modified rule 3, some of the candidates who were earlier reflected as having failed, became entitled to the benefit thereof and have been reflected as promoted.

15. Mr. Anurag Mathur, learned counsel for the Delhi University has further submitted that on an examination of the record, it appears that David Sharma, petitioner no. 1 had earlier been reflected as having secured 26 marks in the B.Sc. Paper no. II. He applied for a revaluation. When such revaluation was effectuated, his marks stand reduced to 23 in this paper. The respondents have submitted that the writ petition deserves to be dismissed on ground of concealment of these material facts. For all these reasons, there is no merit in the contentions raised by the petitioner. The allegations made by them are unsubstantiated by the material. The record of the respondent no. 1 also does not support the same. This writ petition is consequently hereby dismissed.

(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE March 5, 2008 kr