Full Text
C.M. Appl. No. 17506/2006 in C.M. (M) No. 1877-78/2006
Dated : March 12, 2008 Faken Yadav and Another. ..... Petitioners
Through: Mr. Shailender S. Dahiya, Advocate
Through: Mr. R.P. Sisodia, Mr. Avdhesh Bhakta Advocate
JUDGMENT
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to Reporter or not? No
3. Whether the judgment should be reported No in the Digest? VIPIN SANGHI, J.(ORAL) *
1. This application has been filed by the petitioner to seek modification of the order dated 6th December 2006 passed by this court in the presence of the counsel for the petitioner as well as the petitioner No.1. The petitioner had filed this petition to challenge the order dated 20th September 2006 passed by the learned Additional Rent Control Tribunal whereby the appeal filed by the petitioner tenant against the eviction order passed by the ARC had been dismissed. When this matter came up before this court on 8th C.M. Appl. No. 17506/2006 in C.M. (M) No. 1877-78/2006 2008:DHC:933 November 2006, as evidenced from the order sheet, after some hearing the petitioner did not seek to press the petition and only sought time to vacate the premises on or before 31st December 2007. The court further recorded that even otherwise, on the perusal of the impugned order the concurrent finding of fact on the issue of nonpayment of rent and sub-letting, may not be liable to be interfered with under Article 227 of the Constitution of India., and the court held that the finding of the courts below, even otherwise, are in accordance with law. Notice was issued to the respondent limited to the question of grant of time to the petitioner to vacate the tenanted premises on or before 31st December 2007 subject to furnishing of undertaking. Notice was returnable on 6th December 2006.
2. On 6th December 2006 once again the petitioner stated that he does not wish to press this petition but seeks time to vacate the tenanted premises on or before 31st December 2007. The undertaking given by the petitioner was accepted by the court with a further direction that the petitioner shall not sublet or part with possession of the same and pay the rent month by month in advance by the 7th of each month @ Rs.3000/- per month, besides electricity and water charges. It was further undertaken that the arrears of rent, electricity and water charges shall be cleared within one month from the date of the order. On this basis, the court granted time to the petitioner uptil 31st December 2007, in the presence of the parties, and the matter was disposed of.
3. Thereafter, the present application has been filed by the petitioner to say that the condition imposed upon him, requiring him to pay occupation charges at Rs.3000/- per month, should be deleted. The submission of the petitioner is that since the courts below had held that the rate of rent was not Rs.3,000/-, such a condition could not have been imposed upon him, while passing the order dated 6th December 2006. It is also argued that this application has been filed immediately after the passing of the order dated 6th December 2006, when it was realized that this condition was imposed by the court in the said order.
4. I find no merit in either of the submissions of the petitioner. The order dated 6th December 2006 was passed in the presence of the petitioner and his counsel and after hearing the counsel for the petitioner. It is well settled that once an eviction order has been passed, the tenant who continues to hold over can be required to pay the market rent. On 8th November 2006 itself, the court had heard the petitioner on merits and expressed its view that the impugned order does not call for interference by this court. Notice was issued only to consider the aspect of of grant of time uptil 31.12.2007 to the petitioner to vacate the premises. On 6th December 2006, the order was passed after hearing the parties. It was only fair that the petitioner was required to pay an amount with the court found reasonable for his continued use and occupation of the premises uptil 31st December 2007. In law the petitioner was not entitled to any such protection. The court exercised its discretion equitably by granting time to the petitioner to vacate the suit premises after nearly one year, i.e., by 31.12.2007. However, the said indulgence was not granted unconditionally. Obviously, the court had to balance the equities and therefore imposed conditions, one of which was to require the petitioner to pay the rent @ Rs.3,000/- per month. But for the said indulgence granted by the court with the consent of the respondent, the petitioner would have been liable to be evicted forthwith. The petitioner took advantage of the said order granting him time uptil 31st December 2007, which was subject to, inter-alia, the condition with regard to the payment of monthly charges of Rs.3,000/- besides electricity and water charges. Merely because application was moved soon after the passing of order dated 6th December 2006, it cannot be said that the order requiring the petitioner to pay Rs.3,000/- per month could not have been passed. Had the petitioner been so minded, and had objection to the payment of the rent at Rs.3,000/- per month, he should have vacated the premises even before 31st December 2007. I see no merit in the application. The same is dismissed.
5. Petition stands disposed of.
VIPIN SANGHI, J. March 12, 2008 P.K. BABBAR