Shri Anshul Verma & Anr. v. Delhi Administration & Others

Delhi High Court · 13 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:950
Gita Mittal
Writ Petition (C) No.1832/2008
2008:DHC:950
civil petition_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court directed the respondents to accept the petitioners' marriage registration application in accordance with amended statutory rules and to update their instructions and website information accordingly.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Writ Petition (C) No.1832/2008
Date of Decision: 13th March, 2008 SHRI ANSHUL VERMA & ANR. ... Petitioners through Mr. Vishwendra Verma, Advocate
VERSUS
DELHI ADMINISTRATION & OTHERS .... Respondents through Mr. S. Sirish Kumar, Advocate for the respondent.
Mr. V.K. Tandon, Adv. for the respondent.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE GITA MITTAL.
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? GITA MITTAL, J (Oral)

1. By this writ petition, the petitioners have assailed the refusal of the respondents to accept the forms for registration of the marriage which took place on 19th April, 2006. The petitioners have contended that they approached the office of the respondents in the month of January, 2008 with regard to the registration of this marriage but the form was not accepted. Efforts were made on 25th February, 2008 with regard to the registration of this marriage with complete formalities. The petitioner no.2 is stated to have approached the respondent in person to tender the form but the same was not accepted. 2008:DHC:950 Despite requests of the learned counsel for the petitioners, who is related to the petitioner no.2, the respondents acting mala fide, misbehaved with the petitioner and counsel and did not accept the form. The petitioner has placed reliance on the information which has been posted on website by the respondents with regard to the issuance of marriage certificate.

2. The respondents have filed a short affidavit in answer to the notice to show cause repudiating the averments made by the petitioners.

3. On a consideration of the matter, I find that the respondents have submitted that as per the instructions provided on the application form for registration of marriages under Section 8 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1985, both the petitioners were required to appear in person when the form was submitted and again when the matter was placed before the Registrar of Marriage for registration of the marriage. The respondents contend that as the petitioners were not present in person, the forms could not be accepted.

4. A dispute has been raised with regard to what transpired when the forms were tendered on behalf of the petitioners. The respondents have made counter allegations against the petitioners and counsel. In view of the issue which has been raised and the nature of the matter, I do not deem it necessary to go into these allegations which are not related to the reasons which have been disclosed for non-acceptance of forms.

5. The instructions for registration of the marriage which have been placed on the printed application form issued by the respondent set out the following requirements:- “2. Application form should be duly filled in and signed by husband and wife. Both of them should appear before the Registrar of Marriage at the time of submitting the application.

4. Incomplete application forms; forms not supported by required documentary evidence and forms of applicants not within the jurisdiction of the Registrar of Marriage, East District will not be accepted.

6. Completed documents should be submitted in Room No.11 in the Personal Branch of ADM (East) by 1.00 P.M. On any working day. Registration will be done between 11.00 A.M. and 1.00 P.M. On the date given. Both the parties along with a Gazetted Officer need to be present before the Registrar, with his/her official Identity Card and stamp with designation and complete office address, on the day of Registration.” (Emphasis supplied)

6. A copy of the information which is posted by the respondents on their website relating to marriage certificate, has been placed before the court against the heading “Where to Apply”. There is thus substance in the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners that as per the information given to the petitioners, they could apply for registration of their marriage even on line. If this was the position, there would be a basic contradiction in the requirement of the person to appear in person to tender the form.

7. Learned counsel for the respondent submits that there appears to be some error in the information which has been posted on the website and he shall have the matter examined by the competent authorities and necessary corrections would be incorporated. In view of the instructions on the application form, I also deem it in the interest of justice that contents of these instructions also be informed to the public at large in an appropriate format on the website and the notice boards maintained by the respondents so that no other person faces inconvenience.

8. Learned counsel for the petitioners has also drawn my attention to the amendment effected to Rule 4 of the Delhi Hindu Marriage Registration Rules, 1956. It has been pointed out that as per this amendment which was notified on 29th September, 2005, Sub-Rule 2 of the existing Rule 4 has been substituted by the following rule:- “(2) For the purpose of identification, the proof may be in the form of a certificate containing the attested photographs of the husband and wife from any one of the following categories of persons/officers, namely:- (a) any person having PAN of Income Tax, (b) any officer/official of central or state government or Union Territory Administration or PSU/ autonomous bodies whose identity can be established.” It is, therefore, evident that so far as the identification of the applicants seeking registration of marriage is concerned, the statutory rules mandate that the identification can be effected from two categories of persons, i.e., any person having a PAN of Income Tax or any officer/official of central or State Government or Union Territories or PSU, autonomous bodies whose identity can be established. It appears that the legislature has taken into consideration the difficulties which must have been faced by the applicants who were unable to produce a gazette officer who had attended a marriage for the purposes of its registration. I find that instructions on the forms which have been issued by the respondents, have not incorporated this amendment to the statutory rules. The same also requires to be considered by the respondent and the amendment to the instructions mentioned on the rules. Accordingly, this writ petition is disposed of with the following directions:-

(i) The petitioner shall appear before the office of the concerned A.D.M. with complete application form for registration of the marriage and other formalities. Such form, if complete, shall be accepted. In case of any objection, the same shall be pointed out to the petitioner when they appear who shall remove the same and re-tender the same. The marriage of the petitioners shall be registered in accordance with law thereafter.

(ii) The respondent no.1 shall examine the amended Sub Rule

7,503 characters total

2 of the Rule 4 of the Delhi Hindu Marriage Registration Rules, 1956 made effective on 29th September, 2005 which permits the identification of the applicants by any person having PAN of Income Tax or by any officer/officials of Central or state government or Union Territory Administration or PSU/ autonomous bodies whose identity can be established. The necessary change in the instruction no.6 of the application form shall be accordingly effected by the respondent. Such consideration and action thereon shall positively be taken within a period of six weeks from today.

(iii) The respondent shall also examine the information posted on the website and effect the necessary additions/amendments which should be in consonance with the statutory provisions as also the rules, regulations and instructions issued by the respondents. Copy of this order be given dasti to counsel for the parties.

(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE March 13, 2008 aa