Full Text
RFA 474/1998
UOI ..... Appellant
Through: Mr. Sanjay Poddar, Advocate
Through: Mr. Naresh Maan, Advocate
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SIDDHARTH MRIDUL O R D E R
17.03.2008 This appeal arises out of an order dated 3rd February, 1998 passed by the Reference Court in LAC No. 233/1982 whereby the said Court has while enhancing the amount of compensation payable to the respondent - land owners directed payment of interest under Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition
(Amendment and validation) Act, 1967 @ 6% per annum w.e.f.
24th October, 1964, subject to the condition that there is no
2008:DHC:1000-DB RFA No. 474/1998 Page No.2 of 8 overlapping in the payment of the said interest with other interest payable under the provisions of the Land Acquisition
Act. The Court has also directed that interest for the period 19th January, 1984 to 7th February, 1995 during which the proceedings were adjourned sine die by the Reference Court at the request of the land owners shall not be payable to them under Section 28 of the Land Acquisition Act. While RFA NO. 474/1998 challenges the order passed by the Reference Court to the extent interest under Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition
(Amendment and validation) Act, 1967 has been awarded, cross objections No. 782/2002 filed by the respondent - land owners challenge the order passed by the Reference Court to the extent the same has denied interest to them for the period between
19th February, 1995.
Appearing for the appellant Mr. Poddar, drew our attention to an order passed by the Supreme Court in Delhi
Colonizers vs. Union of India, Civil Appeal No. 4668/1998 disposed of on 5th December, 2001 to urge that the legal position regarding award of interest under Section 4(3) of the
RFA No. 474/1998 Page No.3 of 8 Land Acquisition (Amendment and validation) Act, 1967 stands settled by the said decision. That too was a case where the
High Court had held the land owners entitled to interest under
Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment and validation) Act, 1967, provided there was no overlapping of interest awarded under Section 28 of the Act. The Supreme
Court, declared the said view to be incorrect, in the light of an earlier decision rendered by their lordships in Mamleshwar
Prasad (d) by Lrs. & Another vs. Union of India and Others decided on 24th August, 1995. The Court declared that the claimants are entitled to interest under Section 4(3) of the Land
Acquisition (Amendment and validation) Act, 1967, in addition to other interest payable under the provisions of the Land
Acquisition Act. The Court observed as under:-
“The appellants also claimed interest under
Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment &
Validation) Act, 1967. The High Court was of the view that the appellants are entitled to interest under Section4 (3) of the Land Acquisition
(Amendment & Validation) Act, 1967, but the same shall be granted provided there is no overlapping of interest awarded under Section2 8 of the Act. This view of the High Court is not correct. In
Mamleshwar Prasad (D) by Lrs. & Anr. vs. RFA No. 474/1998 Page No.4 of 8
Union of India & Ors. decided on August 24, 1995
(Civil Appeal arising out of S.L.P. (C) NO. 10567/1985), it was held that the claimants are entitled to interest under Section 4(3) of the Land
Acquisition (Amendment and validation) Act, 1967, in addition to other interest which is payable under the provisions of the Act. Following the said decision, we direct that the appellants shall be entitled to interest under sub-section (3) of Section
4 of the Land Acquisition (Amendment and validation) Act, 1967 from the date on which the three-year period from the date of Section 4 notification expired upto the date of tender or payment of compensation awarded by the Collector for the acquisition of their land, even if any interest is paid to the appellants under any other provisions of the Act.”
In the light of the above authoritative pronouncement we have no hesitation in holding that the respondent – land owners shall be entitled to simple interest @ 6% per annum under
Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment and validation) Act, 1967 commencing from the date of expiry of three years period to be reckoned from the date of issue of the
Section 4 of the notification till the date of the tender or payment of the compensation awarded by the Land Acquisition
Collector.
That leaves us with the only other question, namely, RFA No. 474/1998 Page No.5 of 8 whether the Reference Court was justified in declining interest to the respondent-land owners for the period during which the proceedings in the reference had remained suspended/adjourned sine die. The reference Court has taken the view that since the proceedings were adjourned at the request of the land owners on a specific statement made on their behalf that they would not claim any interest during the period of stay, there was no question of awarding interest to them for that period. The legal position even in regard to the waiver of interest under Section 28 of the Land Acquisition Act by the land owners in the above circumstances stands concluded by an authoritative pronouncement of the Supreme
Court in Union of India vs. Pramod Gupta (2005) 12 SCC 1.
The Court in that case reviewed the legal position by reference to the decisions by their Lordships earlier and observed as under:-
“111. It is, therefore, not correct to contend that there cannot be any waiver of the right to claim interest. Statutory provisions are made for payment of interest with a view to compensate a party which had suffered damages owing to a positive action or inaction of the other resulting in blockade of money
RFA No. 474/1998 Page No.6 of 8 which he would otherwise have received. A party which itself represents before the court of law that it would not claim interest with a view to obtain an order of stay which would be for its own benefit, in our opinion, could not be permitted to take advantage of its own wrong. (See Sushil Kumar v.
Rakesh Kumar: (2003) 8 SCC 673 and Laxminarayan
R. Bhattad v. State of Maharashtra: (2003) 5 SCC
413).
JUDGMENT
112. Even otherwise it is now well settled that a person cannot be made to suffer owing to an action by the court (actus curiae neminem gravabit). (See Ram Chandra Singh v. Savitri Devi: (2003) 8 SCC 319 and Board of Control for Cricket in India v. Netaji Cricket Club: (2005 4 SCC 741.)
113. We, therefore, are of the view that the High Court committed a manifest error in allowing interest for the said period. In fact, Mr. Ramamoorthy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents frankly conceded that interest for the said period shall not be payable.” It is in the light of the above pronouncement, no longer open to the land owners to contend that the right to claim interest under Section 28 of the Act could not be waived. That such waiver had indeed taken place in the instant case cannot be disputed by the owners. We say so because the adjournment of the proceedings had taken place at the instance of the land owners and on a specific statement made by them to the effect RFA No. 474/1998 Page No.7 of 8 that they would not claim any interest during the period the proceedings remain suspended. In that view, therefore, the Reference Court was justified in holding that the interest for the period mentioned above was not due and recoverable from the land owners. Learned counsel for the land owners all the same argued that the land owners would be entitled to claim interest on the amount of solatium for the period excluding the period between 19th February, 1995. Mr. Poddar did not dispute that position and submitted that although the interest for the period mentioned above is not payable, the owners would be entitled to recover such interest for the rest of the period in terms of decision of the Supreme Court in Sunder vs. Union of India 93 DLT (2001) 579. In the result the order passed by the Reference Court shall stand modified to the extent that the land owners shall be entitled to interest under Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment and validation) Act, 1967 from the date the period of three years expired reckoned from the date of issue of the RFA No. 474/1998 Page No.8 of 8 preliminary notification till the date of tender/payment of compensation awarded by the Collector. Cross objections filed by the respondent–land owners, however, fail and are dismissed. No costs.
T. S. THAKUR,J
SIDDHARTH MRIDUL, J MARCH 17, 2008 ns