Full Text
JUDGMENT
Through: Mr. R.N. Shrama, Adv.
Through: Mr. I.C. Mishra, Adv.
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may No be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to Reporter or not? No
3. Whether the judgment should be reported No in the Digest? KAILASH GAMBHIR, J. Oral: * The appellant, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., insurer of the offending vehicle has preferred the present appeal challenging 2008:DHC:1006 MAC990/06 the impugned order dated 02.09.2006 passed by the learned MACT. The impugned award has arisen out of the claim petition filed by respondent Nos.[1] & 2 against the appellant and respondent nos. 3 & 4, claiming compensation for the death of Shri Jitender. Brief facts which are necessary for deciding the present appeal inter alia are that respondent Nos.[1] & 2 are the legal heirs of deceased Shri Jitender, who had died on 04.06.2004. On 04.06.2004 at about 10:00 p.m. the deceased Shri Jitender, aged 19 years working as a cleaner in the truck bearing registration no. HR 55 2705 was covering the said truck with tripal when a truck bearing registration no. DL 1G 8821 was reversed by its driver Sh. Hoshiyar Singh in a negligent manner. He did not give any indication while reversing and hit Sh. Jitender & crushed him. From the accident site he was rushed to BJR Hospital, where he died. The Tribunal after taking into consideration the facts of the case as well as evidence led by the parties has passed an award in the sum of Rs.4,23,548/- along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum payable from the date of the institution of the petition MAC990/06 till the realization of the award. The said order passed by the Tribunal is now under challenge in the present appeal. I have heard learned counsel for the parties at considerable length and have perused the award. The appeal is liable to be dismissed at the admission stage itself as the very maintainability of the appeal is in dispute. The appellant never made an application and was granted leave by the tribunal to take over the defence of the owner and driver as envisaged under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act and therefore, it is debarred from challenging the impugned award so as to assail the findings of the Tribunal on the quantum of compensation. Mr. I.C. Mishra counsel appearing for the respondent has taken a preliminary objection to the very maintainability of the present appeal on the ground that the appellant cannot assail the findings of the Tribunal on the quantum of compensation as determined by the Tribunal. Counsel contends that the appellant had not taken over the defence of the owner and driver as envisaged under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act and, therefore, is debarred from challenging the impugned award so MAC990/06 as to assail the findings of the Tribunal on the quantum of compensation. The contention of counsel for the respondent is that right to file an appeal is a statutory right and the insurer can assail the findings of the Tribunal only under Section 149(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act. Counsel further contends that it is only in a case where there is collusion between the claimants and the insured, the insurer can assail the findings of the Tribunal on the grounds of quantum as well as negligence, subject however to the condition that the insurer had taken permission of the Court to take over the defence of the owner or driver as the case may be as envisaged under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act. No such permission was sought by the appellant under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act by the Tribunal and therefore, in the absence of the same, the appellant being the insurer of the offending vehicle cannot maintain the present appeal on grounds other than those available to it under Section 149(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act. Per contra Sh. R.N. Sharma counsel for the appellant vehemently disputes this position and contends that the insurer MAC990/06 cannot be rendered remedlyless especially in a case where the Tribunal has awarded an excessive amount of compensation in favour of the claimants ignoring all basic principles of law for the award of compensation. The counsel also urges that even if the appellant insurance company did not move an application to take over the defence under Section 170 but still since the insurer was allowed to cross examine the claimants on all counts as per the defences available under Section 170 of the MV Act, then it can be said that by implication the tribunal granted permission under Section 170 MV Act to the insurer. Counsel for the appellant has also placed reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court reported in 2007 (9) Scale 216, New India Assurance Company Ltd. Vs. Smt. Shanti Pathak & Ors. to contend that the Apex Court had interfered to lower down the compensation amount even in a case where the insurer had not taken any permission from the Court under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act. Counsel for the appellant also contends that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has already referred the said issue of lack of competence of the insurer to assail the findings of the Tribunal on the ground of quantum of compensation and negligence to a MAC990/06 larger Bench and, therefore, this Court may await the decision of the Supreme Court in this regard. After having given my thoughtful and conscious consideration to the issue involved in the present case, I am of the view that the issue is no more res integra as in its various pronouncements, including National Insurance Co. Ltd., Chandigarh Vs. Nicolletta Rohtagi & Ors., (2002) 7 SCC 456; National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Mastan & Anr., (2006) 2 SCC 641; etc., the Hon'ble Supreme Court has authoritatively held that in the absence of permission sought from the Court as envisaged under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act, the insurer has no right to file an appeal to challenge the quantum of compensation or finding of the Tribunal as regards the negligence or contributory negligence of offending vehicles concerned. It would be appropriate to refer Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act as under:-