Maninder Singh v. Jasmeet Kaur

Delhi High Court · 18 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:1024
Veena Birbal
CM(M) 364/2008
2008:DHC:1024
family petition_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the petition challenging maintenance awarded under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, holding that unsubstantiated claims of expenses cannot reduce the maintenance amount fixed for the wife.

Full Text
Translation output
CM(M) 364/2008
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Date of Decision: 18th March, 2008 CM(M) No.364/2008 & CM No.4127/2008
# MANINDER SINGH ... Petitioner ! Through: Mr. A.K. Chhabra, Advocate
VERSUS
$ JASMEET KAUR ... Respondent
Through:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE VEENA BIRBAL
JUDGMENT

1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment.

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? * Veena Birbal, J. (Oral). By the present petition, petitioner has challenged order dated 20.9.2007 passed by learned ADJ under Section 24 of H.M. Act by which maintenance @ Rs.2000/- per month been awarded to the respondent/wife from the date of maintenance application and Rs.7000/- as one time litigation expenses. Impugned order is challenged mainly on the ground that petitioner-husband is living in a rented accommodation and is paying rent of Rs.1650/-per month. He has also taken a motorcycle on loan and is paying instalment of Rs.1500/- per month towards repayment of loan. He is earning meagre 2008:DHC:1024 amount. Learned ADJ has committed illegality by not giving benefit of deduction of aforesaid amount from his income. Respondent/wife is also earning as such impugned order is liable to be set aside. Perusal of documents on record shows that the motorcycle was purchased in August 2005. Amount of loan alleged to have been taken is not stated. On being asked by the court from petitioner, who was present in person along with his counsel, petitioner informed that loan amount is over for the past few months and presently he is not paying any monthly instalment. The said fact has been concealed from the court of learned ADJ as well as from this court as the same is not stated in the present petition which is dated 17.3.2008. No details have been given as to when alleged loan was taken and how much was the monthly instalment towards its repayment. Under the circumstances, learned ADJ has rightly rejected the contention in this regard. As regards allegation of payment of rent is concerned, no document is filed before the trial court to substantiate the same. In the present petition four alleged rent receipts are filed for the months of August, 2007, September, 2007, November, 2007 & December, 2007. No reason is given as to why the same were not produced before learned ADJ. The address of alleged rented accommodation given in receipt is WZ-93, Ram Nagar, Tilak Nagar, whereas in the affidavit sworn with the present petition, petitioner has given his address as WZ-110, Ram Nagar, Near Chaukhandi Chowk, Tilak Nagar, New Delhi. No explanation has been given as to why he has given his address as WZ-110, Ram Nagar, whereas as per him he is living in a rented accommodation i.e. 93, Ram Nagar, Tilak Nagar. Learned ADJ has rightly not taken into consideration the rent amount alleged to have been paid by petitioner. Nothing has also been placed on record to substantiate alleged income of wife. It has also come on record that petitioner is also using mobile phone. Petitioner is doing the business of old spare parts. As per him his income is Rs.4500/- per month. Learned ADJ has granted maintenance @ Rs.2000/- per month to the applicantwife. In a metropolitan city like Delhi Rs.2000/- is a little amount for the survival of a person. No illegality is committed by Learned ADJ in awarding Rs. 2000/- per month as maintenance to respondent/wife. The impugned order does not call for any interference from this Court. The present petition stands dismissed with no order as to costs. Veena Birbal, J. March 18, 2008 srb