Full Text
CM(M) No.1535/2007 Shri N.P. Kaushik ........ Petitioner through: Mr.Raman Duggal, Advocate
DATE OF DECISION
18.03.2008
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Y
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Y
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? Y: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.
1. Present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India lays a challenge to the order dated 28.7.2007 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Delhi whereby w.e.f. 08.03.2007 interim monthly maintenance granted to Ms. Ms.Geetika was enhanced from Rs,3500/- to Rs.11,000/-.
2. Back drop facts leading to the filing of the present petition are that on 06.03.1987 the marriage between the petitioner Shri N.P.Kaushik and the respondent Smt. Suman Kaushik was solemnized as per Hindu rites and ceremonies. On 15.1.1988 a daughter Ms.Geetika was born out of the said wedlock. CM(M) No.1535/07 2008:DHC:1011
3. Unfortunately, the marriage turned sour and the parties started living separately. Their daughter Ms.Geetika started residing with her mother i.e. the respondent.
4. In the year 1995 Ms.Geetika filed a civil suit under Section 33 CPC and Section 20 of the Hindu Adoption & Maintenance Act,1956 against her father i.e. the petitioner claiming a maintenance of Rs.2,000/- per month from him. Since Ms.Geetika was a minor the respondent being her mother was prosecuting the said suit on her behalf.
5. In the afore-noted suit, an application dated 4.10.1995 was filed by the respondent seeking interim maintenance at Rs.2,000/- per month from the petitioner. Thereafter, an application for amendment of the plaint was moved by the respondent which was allowed by the learned Trial Court vide order dated 13.9.2004. As per the amended plaint, maintenance in sum of Rs.3,500/- per month was claimed from the petitioner.
6. Consequent to the filing of the afore-noted suit, in the year 1997, the petitioner filed a divorce petition under Section 13(1)(ia)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act,1955 against the respondent.
7. During the pendency of the said divorce petition, the respondent filed an application under Sections 24 & 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act,1955 claiming interim maintenance for Ms.Geetika from the petitioner.
8. Vide order dated 28.10.1999 the learned Trial Court before whom the divorce petition was pending awarded interim maintenance in sum of Rs.3,000/- per month in favour of Ms.Geetika. The amount of interim maintenance was directed to be shared equally by the petitioner and the respondent.
9. Against the order dated 28.10.1999 passed by the learned Trial Court, a revision petition was filed before this court.
10. Vide order dated 27.11.2001 this court enhanced the amount of interim maintenance from Rs.3,000/- per to Rs.3,500/- per month. Further in order to secure the future of Ms.Geetika, this court directed the parties to invest a sum of Rs.[5] lacs in an insurance policy.
11. Pursuant to order dated 27.11.2001 passed by this court the petitioner and the respondent purchased insurance policies in the name of Ms.Geetika in sum of Rs.[3] lacs and Rs.[2] lacs respectively.
12. Thereafter, the respondent filed various applications seeking enhancement of interim maintenance granted by order dated 27.11.2001. The applications are pending adjudication.
13. On 19.9.2005, two applications were filed by the respondent in the suit by her under Section 33 CPC and Section 20 of Hindu Adoption & Maintenance Act,1956.
14. First application was under Order VII Rule 14 CPC seeking to file additional documents namely fee slips of Ms.Geetika for the Class-VI, Class-XII and B.Tech Course.
15. Second application was under Section 151 CPC seeking enhancement of interim maintenance from Rs.2,000/- per month to Rs.3,500/- per month. In the said application it was pleaded that Ms.Geetika had turned 17 years of age and that her expenses have increased to more than Rs.15,000/- per month.
16. Vide order dated 02.05.2006 both the applications were allowed. Relevant portion of the order of learned Trial Court reads under: “So for copies of fee receipts of classes are concerned the same pertains to the year 1999 and 1998 and other receipts of class XII and B- Tech pertains to the period for the year 2004 and 2005 respectively and apparently the same are beyond the original petition. It is a fact that this case has been pending since the year 1995 either because in between the judicial proceedings there were chances of compromise or during the proceedings pending before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, the proceedings in other court were under stay as compromise was in progress and in between the period the applicant progressed her academic career year after year from one class to other class. There is a situation that if the documents are permitted to be allowed it would be beyond the original plaint/application, however, considering the continuity of proceedings and in the larger interest of justice, the application is allowed to file record of fee receipts of class VI, class XII, B-Tech course subject to formal proof in evidence as well as with liberty to the respondent to raise appropriate objections, tenable under the law. x x x x Therefore, considering totality of circumstances that the applicant's mother Smt. Suman Kaushik and applicant's father Sh.N.P.Kaushik are employed gainfully and they both are required to maintain the child/ applicant Ms.Geetika during the pendency of main petition U/S 20 of the Act. Hence an interim maintenance of Rs.3,500/- is allowed to the applicant to be contributed equally by applicant's parents i.e. the mother and the father till the disposal of the main application. The applicant request for such maintenance from the date of application i.e. 19.09.1995, however, considering the facts that the applicant is getting interim maintenance w.e.f. May,1997 @ Rs.3,500/- PM from her parents in the proceedings U/S 26 r/w 24 of Hindu Marriage Act in other courts, therefore, without prejudice to her legal rights, the maintenance would be payable w.e.f. the date of order i.e. 02.05.2006. It is a settled preposition of law that an interim maintenance can be received once and there is no provision of law to claim separate interim maintenance in different proceedings, therefore, the interim maintenance @ Rs.3,500/- PM will be received by the applicant from either of the court i.e. either from the present court or from the other court where proceedings U/S 26 r/w 24 are pending, since rate of interim maintenance is Rs.3,500/-. Any observation made in the present order would not tantamount to be final opinion on the merits of the case and same is without prejudice to the rights of both parties. The applicant requests that there are expenses more than Rs.15,000/- p.m., however the interim maintenance amount cannot exceed the amount prayed in the main application.....”
17. Meanwhile Ms.Geetika attained majority and appointed the respondent as her attorney for the purposes of prosecuting the suit filed on her behalf under Section 33 CPC and Section 20 of the Hindu Adoption & Maintenance Act.
18. Pursuant to the order dated 02.05.2006, the respondent moved an application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC seeking amendment of the plaint which was allowed by the learned Trial Court vide order dated 15.5.2007. As per the amended plaint, maintenance in sum of Rs.15,000/- per month was claimed by the petitioner.
19. On 08.03.2007 another application under Section 151 CPC was filed by the respondent seeking enhancement of interim maintenance from Rs.3,500/- per month to Rs.15,000/- per month. Enhanced maintenance was claimed on the ground that the salary of the petitioner has increased, educational expenses of Ms.Geetika have increased and price index of essential commodities has gone up due to inflation.
20. Vide impugned order dated 28.07.2007 the application filed by the respondent was allowed and interim maintenance was enhanced from Rs.3,500/- per month to to Rs.11,000/- per month. Relevant portion of the order reads as under:-