Tek Bahadur v. State

Delhi High Court · 25 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:1104
P.K. Bhasin
Criminal Appeal No. 285 of 1999
2008:DHC:1104
criminal appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court acquitted the appellant in an acid attack case due to unreliable identification evidence and failure of the prosecution to justify the arrest, emphasizing the necessity of prior Test Identification Parade and credible witness testimony.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 285 OF 1999
Date of Decision: 25th March, 2008
# TEK BAHADUR ……….Appellant
! Through:Mr.Raman Sawheny, Advocate
VERSUS
$ STATE ….....Respondent
^ Through : Mr. M.N. Dudeja, APP
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.K.BHASIN
JUDGMENT

1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?(No)

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?(No)

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the digest?(No)

JUDGMENT

P.K.BHASIN, J: By way of this appeal the appellant has taken exception to his conviction under Section 307 of the Indian Penal Code („IPC‟ in short) as also the sentence of seven years rigorous imprisonment and payment of fine of Rs.5000/- awarded by the Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi in Sessions Case No.151/1998. 2008:DHC:1104 Crl. A. No. 285/1999 2

2. Relevant facts leading to the prosecution of the appellantaccused and two others, out of whom one Bharat Bhushan died during the trial and the other one Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta was acquitted, are that PW-1 Krishan Lal used to reside at House No.72, Indira Park, Delhi along with his wife(PW-3 Radha) and daughter Seema. He was doing the job of welding from his shop in Chander Nagar. The acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta was also having a shop of building material near the shop of PW-1. PW-1 used to keep sarias etc. in the gali in front of the shop of Jagdish Kumar which used to cause inconvenience to his customers and the same was objected to by him and because of that there used to be frequent quarrels between the two. As per the further prosecution case on 7th November, 87 the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta decided to get rid of Kishan Lal by getting him killed and for that purpose he hired appellant Tek Bahadur and paid him Rs.7000/- as a reward for executing the job. That conspiracy was allegedly hatched at the shop of Jagdish Kumar on 7/11/87 and Krishan Lal has claimed that he had heard both these accused hatching that conspiracy. The appellant-accused in turn associated the deceased accused Bharat Bhushan for the Crl. A. No. 285/1999 3 accomplishment of the object of the said conspiracy. On the same day i.e. 7th November, 1987, in the evening at about 7.30 p.m. appellantaccused Tek Bahadur and the deceased accused Bharat Bhushan came to the house of PW-1 Kishan Lal who at that time was present there alongwith his wife and daughter. The two accused knocked at his door and his wife Radha opened the door. Krishan Lal also came to the door. As soon as the door was opened they saw two boys, aged about 22-23 years and one of whom boy was a pahari(accused Tek Bahadur). The pahari looking boy was having a plastic container in his hand and he threw the liquid which was there in that container on Krishan Lal, his wife and their daughter Seema who was also around that place at that time. That liquid was later on found to be Sulphuric acid. Thereafter both the accused ran away. Somebody from the neighborhood informed the police and then PW-12 Inspector Rajbir Sharma, PW-6 Constable Suresh Chand and PW-9 Constable Dayanand reached there after sometime but before that all the three injured persons had been removed to JPN hospital. PW-12 then went to JPN Hospital where the three injured had been medically examined and he collected their MLCs (Ex.PW-12/B, Ex.PW-10/A&B) which showed acid injuries on the face of all the three. Since the injured were found to be Crl. A. No. 285/1999 4 unfit for making any statement PW-12 on the basis of his own assessment of the incident got FIR (Ex.PW-8/A) registered under Sections 452/307/324 IPC. On 9.12.87 Krishan Lal gave a statement to the investigating officer (PW-12) in which he expressed suspicion that Jeeta @ Jagdish (acquitted accused) could be the person behind this incident. Jeeta had a shop of building material by the side of his shop of welding works and many a times altercation had taken place between him and Jeeta whenever iron rods etc. were kept in front of his shop. Jeeta had also extended threats to him many a times that he would teach him a good lesson.

3. Even though PW-1 Krishan Lal had expressed his suspicion against the acquitted accused Jagdish @ Jeeta on 9.11.87 the police did not take any action against him. It appears that on 14.7.88 PW-1 Krishan Lal saw appellant-accused Tek Bahadur sitting in the shop of Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta and he identified him to be that pahari boy who had thrown acid on him on 7.11.87. At that time the acquitted-accused Jagdish Kumar was also sitting at his shop. PW-1 Krishan Lal informed the police immediately and it is the prosecution case that the police rushed to the shop of accused Jagdish Kumar and arrested him and on Crl. A. No. 285/1999 5 the pointing out of PW-1 Krishan Kumar appellant-accused was also arrested from the shop of Jagdish Kumar. It also appears that appellant-accused informed the police regarding his associate who had also gone to the house of Krishan Lal on day of incident and on the basis of that information the police then arrested accused Bharat Bhushan (since deceased on 8.9.88). During the investigation period the police obtained the medical opinion regarding the nature of injuries sustained by the three victims. As per the medical opinion PW-1 Krishan Lal and his wife Radha sustained grievous injuries as a result of throwing of acid on their faces which had resulted into disfigurement of their faces. As far as their daughter is concerned, it appears that she did not sustain serious injury and so she did not get herself reexamined by the doctor in JPN Hospital even though she had been advised on the day of incident itself to come again. Therefore, the police could not get the opinion about the nature of her injury.

4. After conclusion of the investigation, the investigating agency filed a charge-sheet in the Court against appellant-accused as well as the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta and the deceased accused Bharat Bhushan @ Kaka. In due course the case was Crl. A. No. 285/1999 6 committed to the Sessions Court where the learned Additional Sessions Judge framed charge under Section 120-B IPC against all the three accused persons and under Sections 307/34 IPC also against all three of them. Appellant-accused and the deceased Bharat Bhushan were additionally charged under Section 452 read with Section 34 IPC. The prosecution had examined twelve witnesses in all including the two victims of the incident, namely PW-1 Krishan Lal and his wife PW-3 Smt. Radha. During the pendency of the trial accused Bharat Bhushan @ Kaka, as noticed already, expired and so the proceedings qua him stood abated. Appellant-accused and the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta, when examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C. denied the prosecution allegations in toto and pleaded false implication. As far as the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta is concerned he also claimed that he had made a complaint against Krishan Lal (PW-1) to the Secretary of their market association who had tried to bring about a compromise between them after making Krishan Lal realize that he was doing wrong by keeping iron rods outside the shop of Jagdish Kumar. He also claimed that on coming to know about the incident in question he had visited Krishan Lal in the hospital to enquire about his well being on the date of incident itself. Crl. A. No. 285/1999 7

5. The learned trial court after analysis of prosecution evidence came to the conclusion that the prosecution had failed to establish its case against accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta and accordingly acquitted him of all the charges vide judgment dated 11.5.1999. However, appellant-accused Tek Bahadur was held guilty for having committed the offence under Section 307 IPC and for the offences under Section 120-B and 452 IPC he was acquitted. Vide order dated 15.5.1999 the appellant-accused was awarded seven years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs.5,000/- with a default stipulation of one year‟s further rigorous imprisonment. Feeling aggrieved by the judgment of conviction and order on sentence the present appeal was filed.

6. The star prosecution witnesses in this case on whose testimony the appellant-accused was convicted are the two victims of the incident, namely, PW-1 Krishan Lal and PW-3 Smt. Radha. Both these witnesses had narrated the incident as per the prosecution story and supported each other‟s version regarding the involvement of the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta as well as the appellant- Crl. A. No. 285/1999 8 accused. However, the learned trial Court did not accept their evidence regarding the involvement of accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta. Not only the learned trial Judge rejected their evidence in respect of accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta but PW-1 Krishan Lal was severely castigated for having fabricated facts to falsely implicate the acquitted accused. Since the observation made by the learned trial Court regarding the evidence of PW-1 Krishan Lal in respect of his allegations against the acquitted accused were heavily sought to be utilized by the learned counsel for the appellant to secure his acquittal in this appeal, I would like to reproduce here itself the exact observation of the learned trial Judge. In para no.10 of his judgment the learned trial Judge observed as under:- “ On meticulous scrutiny of the testimony of Krishan Lal, it comes over the record that this witness had made improvements from his previous statement made to the police on the account that Jeeta @ Jeet Singh had given a sum of Rs.7,000/- to accused Tek Chand and Kaka for throwing acid on them. It is crystal clear that this witness had tried to add facts, which were not narrated by him before the police in his statement made under Section 161 of the Code………….As referred above the said statement was fabricated by Krishan Lal, with a psychological hatred, growing in his mind.” Then, in para no.11 of the judgment the learned trial Judge further made the following observations against PW-1 Krishan Lal Crl. A. No. 285/1999 9 “ When the testimony of Krishan Lal was considered, it became evident that on certain points this witness has fabricated facts. Admittedly the testimony of Shri Krishan Lal cannot be said to be wholly reliable.”

7. However, even after making the aforesaid observations regarding the testimony of PW-1 Krishan Lal the learned trial Court came to the conclusion that the testimony of Krishan Lal fell in the category of evidence of a partially reliable witness whose evidence could be relied upon in respect of the other accused if it was corroborated by other independent evidence. Thereafter, the learned trial Judge after examining the evidence of PW-3 Smt. Radha, the other victim of the incident and the wife of PW-1 Krishan Lal, came to the conclusion that the evidence of PW-1 Krishan Lal was fully corroborated by the evidence of his wife as far as the involvement of appellant-accused Tek Bahadur was concerned. The testimony of PW-

3 Radha was found to be wholly reliable. Holding so, the learned trial Court held the case against the appellant-accused fully established for the offence under Section 307 IPC. Crl. A. No. 285/1999 10

8. It was submitted by Shri Raman Sawhney, learned counsel for the appellant that the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside for two strong reasons. The first reason was that the prosecution had not conducted any Test Identification Parade after the arrest of appellantaccused to have his identify fixed as one of the culprits and in the absence of prior Test Identification Parade the identification of appellant-accused for the first time in Court by PW-1 Krishan Lal and his wife PW-3 Smt. Radha was valueless and based upon dock identification alone. The appellant-accused could not have been held guilty. In support of the submission that absence of prior Test Identification Parade in the present case was fatal for the prosecution learned counsel placed reliance upon a few decisions of the Apex Court reported as 1999 (3) SCC 54, “Vijayan v. State of Kerala”, 1979 (3) SCC 319, “Kanan & Ors. v. State of Kerala”, AIR 1998 SC 1922, “Shaikh Umar Ahmed Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra”, 2004 SCC (Crl.) 185, “Devinder Singh & Anr. v. State of Himachal Pradesh”, 2004 SCC (Crl.) 93, “Joseph v. State of Kerala” and 2006 (1) SCC 600, “D. Gopalakrishnan v. Sadanand Naik & Ors.”. The other reason put forth by the learned counsel for the appellant for securing the acquittal of the appellant was that the learned trial Judge himself having severely Crl. A. No. 285/1999 11 castigated the star witness Krishan Lal for his fabricating facts to secure conviction of the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar@ Jeeta could not have held the appellant-accused guilty relying upon his evidence. It was also contended by Mr. Sawhney that nowhere from the prosecution evidence it gets established as to how and on what basis the appellant-accused came to be arrested for his involvement in the present incident and in the absence of any evidence to that effect also the entire prosecution case against him also should have been viewed with suspicion and considered by the trial court to be highly doubtful.

9. Per contra, learned Additional Public Prosecutor supported the conviction of the appellant by the trial Court and submitted that there being no infirmity with the reasoning given by the trial Court regarding the involvement of appellant-accused no interference is called for in this appeal. Regarding the absence of Test Identification Parade the submission of learned Prosecutor was that Test Identification Parade was not conducted in this case since the appellant-accused was apprehended at the instance of victim himself, namely, PW-1 Krishan Crl. A. No. 285/1999 12 Lal and further that even though PW-1 Krishan Lal had during his crossexamination on behalf of accused Bharat Bhushan (since deceased) had denied having got the appellant-accused Tek Bahadur and the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta arrested but despite that the prosecution allegation against the appellant-accused had stood fully established from the evidence of the two victims of the incident which according to him was in fact wholly reliable even in respect of acquitted accused. Mr. Dudeja also contended that even though the State had not filed any appeal against the acquittal of accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta this Court can still disagree with the observations of learned trial Court to the effect that PW-1 Krishan Lal had fabricated facts to implicate acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta and come to an independent conclusion that the evidence of PW-1 Krishan Lal was wholly reliable and he had not fabricated any facts to falsely implicate any one. Mr. Dudeja also cited one judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court reported as AIR 1998 SC 1376 “George & Ors. Vs. State of Kerala & Anr.” to seek support for his submission that non-holding of Test Identification Parade even in respect of accused who is a stranger for the eye-witnesses of an incident is not always fatal for the Crl. A. No. 285/1999 13 prosecution. Mr. Dudeja drew my special attention to the following observation of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in this judgment.:-

“25. That brings us to the question whether the ground canvassed by the trial Court for rejection of her evidence regarding identification of the appellants, whom she, admittedly, did not know from before, as the assailants are improper or not. So far as the first ground is concerned, law is well settled that identification of an accused in Court is the substantive evidence of the person identifying and his earlier identification in a T.I. parade corroborates the same. In other words, want of evidence of earlier identification in a T.I. parade does not affect the admissibility of the evidence of identification in court.”
21,762 characters total

10. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the rival submissions and with those submissions in mind I have examined the prosecution evidence also and on an independent analysis thereof I find myself in full agreement with the learned counsel for the appellant that this accused also deserves to be acquitted. In these kind of cases where there is a murderous attack on somebody by a total stranger the most crucial aspect which needs to be examined by a criminal Court is as to how the person who has been sent up for trial was picked up by the police and booked for the crime. If the prosecution fails to bring any cogent evidence on record during the trial to justify the arrest itself of the accused the entire prosecution becomes suspect. In the Crl. A. No. 285/1999 14 present case, as noticed already, the appellant-accused, as per the prosecution case, was arrested at the instance of the victim of the incident, namely, PW-1 Krishan Lal on 14/07/88 i.e. after about eight months of the incident when he happened to see the appellantaccused sitting at the shop of the acquitted accused. PW-1 had informed the police and then both these accused were arrested on 14/07/88 at the instance of PW-1. That was, however, the position during the investigation stage and when the stage came during the trial in Court for the prosecution to establish the factum of arrest of the appellant-accused on the pointing of PW-1 this witness flatly refused to accept that. When he was being cross-examined he categorically claimed that he had not seen the appellant-accused and the acquitted accused arrested and had in fact seen the appellant-accused at the police station after the incident. Even the investigating officer has not deposed as to how he could arrest the appellant-accused and at whose instance. He has simply stated during his evidence that he arrested the appellant-accused and the acquitted accused. In the absence of any evidence justifying the very arrest of the appellant-accused his involvement in the incident definitely becomes doubtful. Unfortunately, the learned trial Court did not address itself to this aspect of the matter Crl. A. No. 285/1999 15 which should have been done and this crucial question as to how and on what basis the prosecution was able to justify the arrest of accused Tek Bahadur from the evidence of its witnesses should have been answered. Even during the course of hearing in this appeal learned Prosecutor while defending the impugned judgment could not point out any evidence which could show that the appellant‟s arrest was on some basis. His main contention was that this deficiency in the prosecution evidence was not fatal in view of the reliable and trustworthy evidence of the two victims of the incident and their evidence had been rightly accepted by the trial Court in respect of the appellant-accused. However, I am unable to persuade myself to accept this submission of the learned prosecutor. The prosecution cannot succeed simply on the basis of identification evidence of the victim of some incident without establishing as to how the accused who was a total stranger to the victim came to be arrested. The police just cannot pick up anybody from the street and prosecute him for some crime.

11. There is another reason also for doubting the genuineness of the arrest of the appellant-accused in this case. As noticed already, the Crl. A. No. 285/1999 16 prosecution case is that the appellant-accused and the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta were both arrested together on 14.07.88. As also noticed already, two days after the incident PW-1 Krishan Lal had expressed his suspicion against the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar @ Jeeta who was having a shop near the shop of PW-1. The police, however, did not arrest Jagdish Kumar for about eight months and there is no reason forthcoming for that delay and there is also no explanation as to what prompted the police to arrest him all of a sudden on 14.07.88. Thus, for this reason also the prosecution case becomes doubtful even in respect of the involvement of the appellantaccused.

12. I am also unable to agree with the submission of the learned prosecutor that PW-1 Krishan Lal was a wholly reliable witness. Although the learned trial Court has found him to be partly reliable and because of that reason his testimony has been relied upon for convicting the appellant-accused but in my view considering the fact that he has been found by the trial Court itself to have fabricated facts to falsely rope in the acquitted accused Jagdish Kumar and that he had Crl. A. No. 285/1999 17 disowned even the factum of arrest of the appellant-accused on his pointing out he definitely is a wholly unreliable witness and no reliance whatsoever could have been placed on his testimony.

13. PW-1 Krishan Lal having been held to be wholly unreliable witness and his having denied to have got arrested the appellantaccused and there being no other evidence whatsoever adduced by the prosecution to justify his arrest even the evidence of PW-3 Smt. Radha, the other victim of the incident who also identified the appellantaccused as the culprit who had thrown acid on her, cannot be of any help to the prosecution case. She also did not know the appellantaccused before the incident and in the absence of prior test identification parade her identifying the appellant-accused in Court after about eight months of the incident does not inspire any confidence and more particularly when she herself stated during her cross-examination that the accused persons had switched off the light in connivance with the DESU officials and further that even the street light was not there at the time of the incident in their street and if her evidence is also excluded from consideration there remains nothing in Crl. A. No. 285/1999 18 the prosecution evidence on the basis of which the conviction of the appellant can be maintained.

14. In view of the foregoing, this appeal is allowed and the impugned judgment to the extent it holds the appellant-accused guilty is set-aside and consequently the appellant-accused stands acquitted. P.K.BHASIN,J March 25, 2008 sh