Mohd. Kayum & Anr. v. State

Delhi High Court · 28 Mar 2008 · 2008:DHC:1159
P.K. Bhasin
Criminal Appeal No. 158 of 1999
2008:DHC:1159
criminal appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court acquitted appellants of attempted murder charges due to unreliable and contradictory testimony of the sole injured eyewitness and lack of corroborative evidence.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 158 OF 1999
Date of Decision: 28th March, 2008 # MOHD. KAYUM & ANR. ...Appellants
! Through: Mr. B. D. Batra, Advocate
VERSUS
$ STATE ...Respondent
Through : Mr. M.N. Dudeja, APP
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.K.BHASIN
JUDGMENT

1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?(No)

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? (No)

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the digest?(No)

JUDGMENT

P.K.BHASIN, J: By this appeal the appellants are assailing the judgment dated 27.02.1999 and order dated 05.03.1999 passed by the 2008:DHC:1159 Crl.A.No. 158/1999 2 learned Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi in Session Case NO. 55/97 whereby appellant no.2 Asif was convicted under Section 307 IPC and was awarded seven years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 5000/- with a default stipulation to further undergo one year rigorous imprisonment and appellant no.1 Kayum was convicted under Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC and was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years and fine of Rs.2000/- and to undergo further five months rigorous imprisonment in default of payment of fine.

2. Factual matrix leading to the conviction of the appellants is that on 16.07.1996 at about 12.00 noon when the complainant was working in his factory, appellant Asif, whom he knew earlier, came to his factory and called him outside the factory on the pretext of having some discussion. Appellant Asif took the complainant near the gate of Khadde Wala School where appellant Kayum was already present. Kayum asked the complainant as to why he had slapped him yesterday and that he would teach him a lesson for the same. On saying so Kayum Crl.A.No. 158/1999 3 caught hold of the complainant and Asif took out a knife from his dub and caused injuries to the complainant on the left side of his chest and also on his back. On raising of alarm by the injured the appellants-accused fled from the spot and thereafter the injured was removed to the GTB hospital by his elder brother Yunus who had also reached the spot after hearing the cries of his brother. On the basis of a rukka (Ex. PW- 13/B) FIR no. 402/96 (Ex. PW- 3/A) under Sections 307/34 IPC was registered with Seelam pur police station and investigation was carried out. During investigation blood stained shirt of injured Fujail was taken into possession vide memo (Ex. PW-9/A). On 18.7.1996 at about 8.45 p.m. a raiding party was organized comprising of Ct. Satish, Jeetpal and Head-constable Dayanand by Sub-inspector Krishan Kumar(PW-13) on receipt of secret information and the appellants-accused Mohd. Kayum and Asif were apprehended from gali no. 2, Jamaalon ka baag. On personal search of the appellant Asif one buttondar knife was recovered and in respect of that recovery a separate FIR No. 406/96 was registered under the Arms Act. As per the medical opinion, the complainant- Crl.A.No. 158/1999 4 injured PW-1 had received grievous injuries inflicted with a sharp edged weapon.

3. After completion of investigation the police charge-sheeted both the appellants and the trial Court tried them for the offence under Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC. Both the appellants had pleaded false implication. The Sessions Court after examining the evidence of the thirteen witnesses examined by the prosecution held appellant Asif guilty of the offence under Section 307 IPC and appellant Kayum under Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC. Being aggrieved by their conviction the appellants have come up in appeal.

4. Sh. B.D. Batra, learned counsel appearing for the appellants, had contended that the conviction of the appellants cannot be sustained on the sole testimony of the injured witnesscomplainant PW-1 Mohd. Fujail being totally unreliable. He further contended that the learned trial Court ought not to have relied upon the testimony of the complainant (PW-1) who himself Crl.A.No. 158/1999 5 did not support the prosecution case and was declared hostile by the learned prosecutor since the complainant had not stuck to his version as given in the FIR which was got registered at his instance wherein he had clarified that it was Asif who came to call him in the factory and when he had come out of the factory Kayum who was standing out caught hold of him and Asif inflicted injuries on his person with a knife. While in Court he gave a total contradictory version and claimed that it was accused Kayum who had stabbed him and no role was assigned to Asif at all.

5. On the other hand Shri M.N.Dudeja, learned Additional Public Prosecutor, supported the judgment of the trial Court and also the sentences awarded to the two appellants and submitted that there was no infirmity in the impugned judgment and prosecution case stood established despite the fact that injuredcomplainant in his initial statement to the police had ascribed role of causing injury to appellant Asif and later on in the Court assigned that role to appellant Kayum. Crl.A.No. 158/1999 6

6. After having gone through the testimony of the prosecution witnesses and particularly that of the injured-complainant (PW-1), who is the only eye-witness of the incident, I have unhesitatingly come to the conclusion that the prosecution has failed to prove its accusations against both the appellants beyond reasonable doubt. The injured witness, who is normally considered to be a truthful witness, in the present case, has turned out to be a wholly unreliable witness. As noticed already, PW-1, Mohd. Fujail, on whose complaint the case was registered, had stated in his first information statement to the police that on the day of incident at about 12.00 noon when he was working in his factory appellant Asif had come inside and took him out and brought him near Khadde Wala School where appellant-accused Kayum was already present. Both the appellants then, as per complainant’s version in FIR, started quarreling with him and Kayum caught hold of him and Asif took out a churri and stabbed him on the left side of his chest and also on the back. However, before the court the complainant deposed in his chief-examination that Crl.A.No. 158/1999 7 appellant Kayum had come inside his factory and had brought him outside the factory on the pretext of having some talks and took him to Khadde Wal School where appellant Asif was already present at the spot and then quarrel ensued between them. Kayum took out a knife and attacked him with a knife and that although he wanted to stab him on his chest but he could not do that as he(PW-1) had turned around to save himself and in that process the knife hit him on the back side and on his raising hue and cry both the accused fled away from the spot. No role was assigned to appellant Asif, who as per the FIR was the actual assailant. He also denied having lodged the FIR of the incident and claimed that the police had taken his thumb impression on some paper in the hospital. In view of his turning hostile he was cross-examined by the APP but the complainant even then maintained his version of the incident given by him in his chiefexamination. He denied that appellant Kayum had caught hold of him at the time of the incident and appellant Asif had stabbed him. On these aspects he was confronted with his first information statement to the police which he admitted to have Crl.A.No. 158/1999 8 made. It was then suggested to him that he being the friend of PW-1 had given a false statement and both had compromised the matter. Since the complainant had not claimed that he had claimed accused Asif to be the actual assailant in the FIR by some mistake his evidence cannot be said to be that of a reliable witness at all and could not be made the basis of conviction by the learned trial Court.

7. There was no other eye witness of the incident and prosecution had not sought to establish its case on any circumstantial evidence also. The testimony of these type of witnesses who give one version of the incident to the police and another version of the same incident in Court came up for consideration before the Apex Court in “State of Uttar Pradesh v. Arvind Kumer”, 2007 (6) SCALE 367 and “Ramesh Maruti Patil v. State of Maharashtra”, AIR 1994 SC 28. In both these cases the eye witnesses of the incident had changed the roles of the main assailants while deposing in Court and because of that change in version of the incident the Apex Court had declined to Crl.A.No. 158/1999 9 place any reliance upon their evidence. So, in the present case also no reliance could be placed on the evidence of the sole eye witness Mohd. Fujail despite the fact that he is an injured witness. I find it quite strange that despite the fact that the complainant has not at all supported the prosecution case the learned trial Court observed in para no. 30 of the impugned judgment that “In the present case PW-1 Mohd. Fujail has fully supported the prosecution case on each and every material particular. There is nothing on record to disbelieve his testimony.” This commendation of the complainant was absolutely unjustified.

8. When despite the fact that no role whatsoever had been ascribed to appellant Asif he has been convicted substantively under Section 307 IPC by the trial Court it became a matter of anxiety to find out on what reasoning he has been convicted relying upon the evidence of hostile complainant. In this regard the submission of the Mr. Dudeja was that evidence of even a hostile witness can be relied upon to the extent it receives corroboration from other independent and reliable evidence and Crl.A.No. 158/1999 10 the learned trial Judge had found sufficient corroboration to the evidence of the complainant and had rightly relied upon his evidence. There is no doubt that evidence of a witness cannot be ignored totally just because he is declared hostile by the prosecution and that part of his evidence which is corroborated by other reliable evidence can definitely be used. However, in the present case I have not found that any part of the version of the complainant given in Court has been corroborated by any other evidence. Now, let me see what corroborative evidence has been pressed into service by the trial Court while convicting the appellants on the basis of evidence of PW-1. This is how the trial Judge has dealt with the matter in paras 22, 25 & 26 of his judgment: -

“22. It has also been argued by Ld. Counsel for accused persons that weapon of offence has not been recovered in this case. This contention of Ld. defence counsel is wrong. It has come on record that a buttondar knife was recovered from the front side pocket of the pant of the accused Asif at the time of his arrest. Further, accused in his disclosure statement has admitted that this is the same knife which was used by him at the time of causing injuries to Mohd. Fujail. The only thing is that the copy of recovery memo of knife has not been placed on this file but simply for this deficiency it cannot be said that knife i.e. weapon of offence was not
Crl.A.No. 158/1999 11 recovered from the accused and on this ground this case of prosecution cannot be thrown away.
25. The next point raised by the ld. Defence counsel is that it has not been explained as to who caused the injury to the injured. On the other hand Ld. PP has submitted that injured in his compliant ex. PW 1/A lodged to the police has clearly stated that it was accused Asif who caused injuries on his person, however, while appearing in court he has tried to save him but at the same time in crossexamination he has admitted that statement ex. PW 1/A was made by him and the same was read over to him by the police. He has also admitted that statement bears his thumb impression and thus by admitting his statement, he has corrected his earlier version.
19,022 characters total
26. In natural course, when assailant is known one, injury is fresh and the statement is recorded soon after the occurrence, there are no chances of substituting the real culprit. In this case, PW-1 in his complaint lodged to the police has ascribed injuries to accused Asif but while appearing in court he has tried to help him by stating that it was Kayum who gave injury to him. To some extent, we find corroboration from the statement of PW-4 Mohd. Yunus who saw the accused Asif with a knife in his hand. As already discussed, knife was recovered from the possession of accused Asif. Hence, all these facts goes to prove that it was accused Asif who caused injury on the person of Mohd. Fujail and none else.” This is the only discussion in the impugned judgment regarding the contentions raised on behalf of the two accused that evidence of the complainant should not be relied upon. This discussion and the findings of the learned trial Judge show that Crl.A.No. 158/1999 12 prosecution case as was projected in the FIR has been accepted despite the complainant not sticking to that version of his accepting the case of the prosecution that there was recovery of weapon of offence from the possession of appellant Asif and further because this accused had accepted in his confessional statement made before the police that he had attacked the complainant with the churri recovered from his possession at the time of his arrest and also because in the FIR he had named Asif as the assailant and Kayum to be the person who had caught hold of him at the time of the incident when Asif had assaulted him.

9. In my view, the approach of the learned trial Judge while coming to the aforesaid conclusions was not the correct approach. It appears that the learned judge has not kept in mind the well settled legal position while making the aforesaid observations in his judgment. Since the complainant had not claimed before the trial Court that it was Asif who had stabbed him and Kayum had caught hold of him at the time of stabbing it Crl.A.No. 158/1999 13 could not be said that the complainant’s version of the incident given by him in Court stood corroborated by his version in his first information statement to the police. In fact, when the public prosecutor had cross-examined him and had confronted him with his statement before the police the complainant stood completely contradicted. An FIR is not a substantive piece of evidence and its contents can be used by the prosecution either to corroborate the testimony of its maker or to contradict him if he chooses to resile from that version while deposing in Court. The accused can use the FIR to contradict its author if in Court he reiterates that version. Thus, in the present case the complainant having not stuck to his version of the incident given by him to the police in the form of his first information statement it could not be said that the complainant’s version in Court stood corroborated by whatever he had narrated in the FIR. Just because the complainant had admitted during his crossexamination by the public prosecutor that Ex. PW-1/A, which is his first information statement to the police, bore his thumb impression it could not be said, as has been observed by the Crl.A.No. 158/1999 14 learned trial Judge in para 25 of the impugned judgment, that by making that admission in the cross-examination by the public prosecutor the complainant had corrected his earlier version. The complainant never admitted that Asif had stabbed him as had been stated in the FIR. Of course, if during the cross-examination by the public prosecutor the complainant had admitted that in fact Asif had stabbed him and by mistake he had stated in his chief-examination wrongly that Kayum had stabbed him the position would have been different and in that situation only statement made by the complainant in his cross-examination by the prosecutor could have been relied upon and that too if it had received corroboration from other independent evidence which in the present case is in any case totally missing.

10. Similarly, the learned Trial Judge has wrongly sought corroboration for the prosecution case in respect of accused Asif from the fact that there was alleged recovery of weapon of offence used in the present incident from his possession. The prosecution itself never claimed that the knife which was Crl.A.No. 158/1999 15 recovered from the possession of accused Asif was the one which was used in the incident in question. As noticed already, in respect of that recovery a separate case was registered under the Arms Act and that knife was not even produced in the present case during prosecution evidence and that also shows that the prosecution never treated the recovered knife as the weapon of offence of the present incident. The learned trial Judge, however, adopted a queer approach in this regard also by observing that in the confessional statement of accused Asif he had confessed having stabbed the complainant with the knife which was recovered from him at the time of his arrest. That was wholly impermissible in law. The confessional statement could not be relied upon at all since it had not led to the discovery of anything incriminating.

11. In the afore quoted observations of the learned trial Court it also appears that corroboration to the evidence of PW-1 was sought by the learned trial Court from the testimony of PW-4 Mohd. Yunus, the brother of PW-1. Admittedly, PW-4 had not Crl.A.No. 158/1999 16 witnessed the incident and as per the prosecution case he had come to the spot only on hearing the cries of his brother Fujail. He himself has also claimed so in his evidence. All that he deposed was that when he reached the spot he had seen both the appellants present there and at that time appellant Asif was having a knife in his hand. It appears that the learned Trial Judge was looking for corroboration of whatever had been stated in the FIR ignoring the legal position that whatever is stated in FIR is not substantive evidence which can be utilized in favour of the prosecution. If whatever had been stated by PW-1 in his first information statement to the police is excluded from consideration because of PW-1 himself having not stuck to that version the evidence of PW-4 could not be utilized by the trial Court as corroborative evidence for holding the appellants guilty. In fact, even the learned prosecutor while arguing in support of the impugned judgment did not contend that the learned trial Court was justified in relying upon the confessional statement of appellant Asif as well as the contents of the FIR to hold that since that version was given by the injured soon after the incident when Crl.A.No. 158/1999 17 injuries on his person were fresh he would not have wrongly stated therein that it was Asif who had stabbed him.

12. I am therefore of the view that evidence of the sole eye witness having been held to be unreliable cannot be relied upon against any of the two accused and the prosecution cannot be said to have established its case against the appellants beyond reasonable doubt and consequently their conviction cannot be sustained. This appeal is accordingly allowed and the impugned judgment of conviction and order on sentence are set-aside and both the appellants stand acquitted. They were on bail and now their bail bonds stand cancelled and sureties discharged. P.K.BHASIN,J March 28, 2008 sh