Full Text
Date of Decision: 02.04.2008
Sh.Bhagat Singh ….… Petitioner
Through: Mr. Manmohan Singh Vohra, Advocate.
Through: Mr.J.S. Bhasin, Advocate
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of Local papers may YES be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not? NO
3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J. (Oral)
1. The petitioner seeks benefits under the Pension Scheme dated 27th November, 1992 after seeking voluntary retirement under the Voluntary Retirement Scheme in December, 1994. 2008:DHC:1237
2. The petitioner was employed by the respondent Corporation as conductor in 1977. His badge number was 10712 and pay token number was 23398. A scheme for pension of the employees of the respondent was issued pursuant to office order dated 27th November,
1992. The scheme was applicable to the existing employees including those who retired on or after 4th August, 1981. Under the scheme the employees were given option to opt for the scheme within 30 days from the date of issue of order dated 27th November, 1992. Clause 9 of the Scheme categorically contemplated that in case any employee of DTC does not opt or exercises an option which is incomplete or conditional or ambiguous, such an employee shall be deemed to have opted the pension scheme benefits. Clause 9 of the scheme is as under:- “Clause 9: If any of the employee of DTC, who does not exercises any option within the prescribed period of 30 days quit service or dies without exercising an option on whose option is incomplete or conditional or ambiguous. He shall be deemed to have opted the Pension Scheme Benefits.”
3. The scheme for pension in 1992 was not somehow implemented for sometime and later on another scheme for voluntary retirement dated 31st March, 1993 of employees of Delhi Transport Corporation was promulgated. On availing the voluntary retirement scheme an employee was entitled for balance of his PF account; encashment of refused leave and accumulated earned leave; gratuity as per the payment of Gratuity Act; three months notice pay; exgratia payment equivalent to 1½ month basic pay plus dearness allowance for each completed of service; expenses for travelling by the entitled class for the employee with his family to a place where the employee intended to settle and Pensionary benefits as per office order no. 16 dated 27.11.1992. However by another letter dated 5th December, 1994 it was categorically stipulated that no pensionary benefits under the Pension Scheme would be given to the employees who will seek voluntary retirement under the Voluntary Retirement Scheme.
4. The petitioner on consideration of the Voluntary Retirement Scheme applied on 9th December, 1994. However before he applied for the Voluntary Retirement Scheme, the respondent had already issued a letter dated 5th December, 1994 categorically stipulating that no pensionary benefits under the Pension Scheme would be given to the employees who would apply for the voluntary retirement under the Voluntary Retirement Scheme.
5. On receiving the application of the petitioner for voluntary retirement on 9th December, 1994 his request was processed and the petitioner was retired from 31st December, 1994 and was paid full dues by way of three cheques.
6. After availing the Voluntary Retirement Scheme in 1994 the petitioner in 1999 almost after five years sent a notice through the counsel alleging that the petitioner had signed on the dotted lines on the form for voluntary retirement in a mechanical manner and without understanding the implementation of the consequence thereof and thereafter the petitioner had applied for withdrawal of the letter of voluntary retirement under the Voluntary Retirement Scheme but no action was taken. It was also contended that the Voluntary Retirement Scheme was availed on the belief that DTC was being closed down as it was running into losses and the person taking voluntary retirement could be given pension as per their entitlement if they were 40 years of age or had put in atleast 10 years of service with the respondent. The petitioner, however, admitted that he had availed the cheques for Rs.5200/- on 28th January, 1995, Rs.98,968.10/- on 2nd January, 1995 and Rs.74545.57/- on 4th July, 1995 and in the circumstances it was claimed that the petitioner be granted pension under the pension scheme of 1992. The petitioner also asserted that he is a poor man and is not doing any job and has to support a large family comprising of four school going children besides his wife and he has been passing through very hard times and is in a state of penury. In the circumstances it was also contended that not granting the pension is illegal, contrary to settled laws of the land and is in violation of fundamental rights granted to the petitioner under the Constitution of India. As the petitioner was not granted pension under the scheme of 1992 he filed the present petition on the same grounds.
7. The Respondent/Corporation has contested the petition on the ground that the petitioner sought voluntary retirement after understanding the circular dated 3rd March, 1993 and letter/circular dated 5th December, 1994. A copy of the letter dated 5th December, 1994 has also been produced by the respondent/Corporation. The allegation that the petitioner had asked for the return of his application for voluntary retirement was not admitted. It has been contended that no such written or oral request was made to the respondent. The allegation that petitioner was intimated that he will also be paid pension was also not admitted. It has been contended that after availing voluntary retirement, the petitioner is not entitled for pension.
8. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. This is not disputed that the petitioner had not opted for the pension scheme of
1992. Though the counsel for the petitioner has not argued that there is deemed acceptance of the pension scheme under clause 9 but even if, there is a deemed acceptance of the pension scheme under clause 9, on opting for voluntary retirement the petitioner became disentitled to claim the benefit under the pension scheme of
1992. Non applicability of 1992 scheme for pension in case of an employee taking the voluntary retirement was also categorically communicated by letter dated 5th December, 1994 which fact has not be disputed by the petitioner. This also cannot be disputed that the petitioner had applied or voluntary retirement after the letter dated 5th December 1994 on 9th December, 1994.
9. Another admitted fact is that the petitioner had availed the benefits under the voluntary retirement scheme by taking the amounts by two cheques in January, 1995 and another cheque in July, 1995. The amounts received by the petitioner in 1995 were not returned by him as under the scheme for the pension, some of the amounts could not be availed by him. From 1995 till 1999, the petitioner did not take any steps to refund the amounts under the voluntary retirement scheme and claim pension under the pension scheme. Though the petitioner has alleged that he had sought return of his application seeking voluntary retirement, however, this plea is very vague. Nothing has been produced by the petitioner to show that he made such a request in writing. There are no particular even for the oral request allegedly made by him as he has not disclosed as to whom the oral request was made and when in fact such an oral request was made by him. In the circumstances, it cannot be believed that the petitioner made such a request. It appears to be an afterthought. Had the petitioner made any request for withdrawal of his option for voluntary retirement, he would not have been waited for five years after he allegedly made the request for withdrawal from the voluntary retirement scheme.
10. Once the petitioner had sought voluntary retirement, he is not entitled for pension under the scheme for pension of 1992. The learned counsel for the respondent has relied on a judgment of the single Judge of this Court in Civil Writ Petition No.686/2000 titled as DTC Retired Employee‟ Association & Others v. Delhi Transport Corporation dated 26th February, 2002 and the decision of the Division Bench in LPA No.330/2002 titled DTC Retired Employees‟ Association & Others v. Delhi Transport Corporation whereby the letters patent appeal filed against the order dated 26th February, 2002 was dismissed by the Division Bench on 17th April, 2002. A Special Leave Petition was filed against the order dated 17th April, 2002 which was also dismissed by the Supreme Court in SLP (C) No.16135/2002 by order dated 2nd September, 2002.
11. This Court in „DTC Retired Employees‟ Association (supra) had considered the question “Whether employees of DTC who had opted for the pension scheme 1992 and later withdrew from the same are entitled to once again be covered under the pension scheme as per their request subsequently”. Relying on the judgment of the Supreme Court in DTC Retired Employees‟ and Others, etc. (supra), it was held that the employees who had withdrawn from the Scheme of Pension of 1992 later could not be granted benefit nor they could be permitted to resile from their plea. The learned single Judge in its judgment dated 26th February, 2002 had held that after withdrawing from the Pension Scheme, an employee of the Corporation was not entitled for benefit under the Pension Scheme. The said judgment of the Single Judge was affirmed by the Division Bench in LPA No.330/2002 by order dated 17th April, 2002 and a Special Leave Petition filed against the said order was also dismissed by order dated 2nd September, 2002.
12. The petitioner had not opted to avail pension scheme. Later on, the petitioner opted for the voluntary retirement scheme and availed all the retiral benefits also. It has already been held that the petitioner did not seek withdrawal from the voluntary retirement scheme and his plea to this effect has been disbelieved. Consequently the petitioner will not be entitled for benefit under the pension scheme of 1992. An employee who had not opted for the pension scheme and who had later on opted for voluntary retirement scheme, cannot be allowed to opt for the pension scheme of 1992. Financial exigencies cannot be a ground for the petitioner to first not to opt for the pension scheme and seek voluntary retirement in another scheme and later on to seek the benefits under the pension scheme. Therefore the petitioner is not entitled for any of the reliefs sought in this petition on any of the grounds raised by him. Consequently, there are no grounds to allow the petitioner to rejoin the Pension Scheme dated 27th November, 1992 and direct the respondent to extend the benefit of Pension Scheme to the petitioner. The writ petition, therefore, is without any merit and it is dismissed. However, considering the facts and circumstances, the parties are left to bear their own costs. April 2nd, 2008. ANIL KUMAR, J. ‘Dev’