Full Text
Writ Petition (Civil) No.15370/2006& CM No.12325/2006
Date of Decision: 03rd April, 2008 DARSHAN JAIN ... Petitioner through Mr. S.C. Sagar, Adv.
Mr. R.V. Sinha, Adv. for the respondent no.4.
1.Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the
Digest? GITA MITTAL, J
1. By this writ petition, the petitioner prays for a direction to the respondents to regularise the allotment of her general pool accommodation which has been effected in favour of her husband, by effecting inter change accommodation to which the petitioner would be entitled from the respondent nos.[1] & 2.
2. According to the writ petitioner, her husband was allotted quarter no.23/205, Type – IV, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi on 2nd /3rd April,
1997. Mr. M.R. Jain, the husband of the petitioner, who was working as Assistant Registrar in the Supreme Court of India, was compelled to take premature retirement/voluntary retirement on 7th February, WP(C) No.15370/2006 Page No.1 2008:DHC:1254
2006. In the meantime, the petitioner has joined the Municipal Corporation of Delhi as an Assistant Teacher as on 2nd August, 1979, promoted as TGT (English) on 1st April, 1992 and transferred to the office of the respondent no.2. As the petitioner was herself entitled to an allotment of accommodation from the respondent nos.[1] & 2, she made an application in 1992 for allotment of a quarter in the type III category which application is stated to be pending. The respondent nos.[1] & 2 have stated that the petitioner applied for a type III category flat in Siddharth Extension for which allotment, the respondents have stated that for this allotment, the petitioner is still in the waiting list.
3. After the voluntary retirement of the petitioner's husband, allotment of the said flat in his favour was cancelled by the respondent no.4 by an order passed on 11th June, 2006. His request for extension of allotment was accepted and he was permitted to occupy the flat upto 7th October, 2006. Prior to the expiry of this period, the present writ petition has been filed by the petitioner seeking a direction to the respondents to regularise the said central pool accommodation allotted to her husband in her favour. The petitioner places reliance on two office memorandums, being O.M. No.12035/4/98-Pol-II dated 20th May, 1999 and O.M.No.12035/23/2000-Pol-II dated 26th December, 2000, to urge that her request to the respondents and her prayer by way of writ petition are justified. It is further urged that the petitioner is also due for retirement shortly in October, 2008 and grave and irreparable WP(C) No.15370/2006 Page No.2 prejudice would result to the family in case this request was not accepted. The petitioner has further submitted that it was on account of compelling reasons that her husband was compelled to seek voluntary retirement and the respondent ought to take a compassionate view in the matter.
4. In addition to the above, the petitioner has cited three instances wherein the respondents have permitted an exchange of the Central General Pool accommodation against the Delhi Administration Pool and regularised allotment.
5. The writ petition has been opposed by both the Directorate of Estates of the Central Government, respondent no.4 herein as well as by the respondent nos.[1] & 2, the concerned authorities of the Government of NCT of Delhi. So far as the respondent nos.[1] & 2 are concerned, it is urged that the petitioner's application was specific and she has also sought allotment of a type III quarter restricted to e Siddharth Extension, New Delhi wherein she was on the waiting list. No other request has been made to the respondent nos.[1] & 2.
6. Mr. R.V. Sinha, learned standing counsel for the respondent no.4, has vehemently opposed the writ petition on the ground that the petitioner is not entitled or eligible for the exchange of her quarter inasmuch as she is not eligible for allotment of a General Pool Accommodation. In this behalf, reliance is placed on office memorandum no.11013(D)(21)/89-Pol.IV dated 24th August, 1990 wherein it is specifically stipulated that the Delhi Administration teachers and other posted in the school would not be eligible for WP(C) No.15370/2006 Page No.3 General Pool Accommodation. So far as the office memorandums relied upon by the petitioner are concerned, my attention is drawn to the clear stipulations therein that in order to be entitled to the regularisation of the allotment in his or her favour, the employee is required to be a government employee, eligible for accommodation from the general pool. As a result, according to the respondent, in view of the office memorandum dated 24th August, 1990, the petitioner would not be a person eligible for allotment of an accommodation from the general pool accommodation. The other ground of opposition to the writ petition is that the Delhi Government, i.e. the respondent nos.[1] & 2, have so far not offered any alternative quarter as an alternate accommodation which could be considered as an exchange towards regularisation of the flat applied by the petitioner.
7. On a consideration of the materials placed before this court, I find that the petitioner has pointed out three instances wherein the respondents have regularised allotment of general pool accommodation in favour of the employees of the Delhi Government. Copies of the information which has been obtained by the petitioner ounder the Right to Information Act, 2005 in this behalf has been placed on record. It would appear that the respondents have opposed orders dated 17th Novemebr, 2005. in this behalf, the respondents have passed an order dated 17th November, 2005 in favour of one Smt. Surekha Tehlan, Smt. Kusum Lata Gill dated 23rd February, 2006 and Mrs. Shan-E-Zehra dated 7th July, 2006 in similar WP(C) No.15370/2006 Page No.4 circumstances. These three persons were also teachers employed with the Delhi Administration. The respondents in their counter affidavit have not disputed that such excvhange/transfer regularisation has been permitted. On the contrary, the respondent no.4 has sought to explain the same by a vague assertion that the saem was considered on compassionate ground on inter exchange. 8, From the record placed before this court, there is nothing to indicate that the rspondents have considered the request of the petitioner from this aspoect. The respondent nos.[1] & 2 also have not also considered the request of the petitioner with regard to the inter pool exchange. Even according to the respondent no.4, they have not been able to place any material as to the circumstances in which no quarters/flat could have been offered for the short duration of the petitioner's services as an exchange for the general pool accommodation. In this background, I am of the considered view that the rquest of the petitioner for inter exchange of the accommodation and consequential regularisation of the allotment of the quarter in her name deserves to be re-considered. Accordingly, this writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the respondents to re-consider the request of the petitioner in view of the afore-noticed facts. The respondent shall take into consideration the fact that they have, in similar circumstances, considered such regularisation and inter exchange in respect of three other employees. The respondent nos.[1] & 2 shall also provide the requisite information to the respondent no.4 for re-consideration of the petitioner's request within WP(C) No.15370/2006 Page No.5 a period of four weeks from today. The respondent no.4 shall take a considered view in the matter and pass an appropriate orders wtihin a period of eight weeks thereafter. This writ petition and the application are disposed of in the above terms.
(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE April 03, 2008 aa