Full Text
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CRL.M.C. 831/2008 & CRL.M.A. 3151/2008(stay)
Date of order: 04th April, 2008.
DR. NARENDRA NATH ..... Petitioner
Through Mr. Sidharth Luthra, Senior Advocate with Mr. M. Pandey & Mr. Shri Singh, Advocates.
Through Ms. Mukta Gupta with Mr. Pawan Behl and Mr. Rajat Katyal, Advocates for R-1.
Ms. Radha Yadav Respondent No.2 in person.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported Yes in Digest? ORDER
1. This petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 („CrPC‟) seeks to challenge an order dated 7th March, 2006 passed by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate („MM‟), Delhi in Complaint Case NO. 366 of 2001 titled Radha Yadav v. Narendra Nath & Others and also seeks the quashing of the Complaint Case itself “along with the proceedings emanating therefrom qua the Petitioner.”
2. The facts leading to the filing of this petition are that an FIR No. 191 2008:DHC:1270 of 2001 was registered on 15th August, 2001 under Sections 147/148/149/186/332/353/427 IPC read with Section 3 of the Prevention of Public Property Act, 1984 at police station Krishna Nagar.
3. The case of the prosecution in the said FIR is that at about 8.25 pm on 15th August, 2001 an information was received through the wireless that certain people had blocked the traffic at Aggarwal Sweet Chowk Road NO. 57 and on receipt of the said information when SI Sunil Kumar proceeded to the spot, he found Smt. Radha Yadav Respondent No.2 and Shri Kant Sharma with about 30 to 35 women and about 300 persons had blocked the traffic on both sides. They were armed with hockey sticks and lathis and shouting slogans against the officials of Delhi Electricity Supply Undertaking. It is stated that when the police officials tried to pacify Respondent No.2 and Shri Kant Sharma, the crowd got aggressive and despite being asked to disburse did not do so. It is then stated that some of the ladies started pelting stones on the police vehicles and the DTC vehicles. It is stated that at about 10.15 pm under the leadership of Respondent No.2 and Shri Kant Sharma the people assembled there grappled with SI Sunil Kumar, assaulted him and started pelting stones on the police. Two persons out of the mob were caught hold of by the police and that basis the aforementioned FIR was registered.
4. In relation to the same incident of 15th August, 2001 Respondent No.2 filed a complaint giving her version and what had transpired. According to her at about 9.15 pm on that day when she along with family members and a colleague Shri Rajender Pal went to Aggarwal Sweets when she came out at about 10 pm after having dinner she noticed a huge crowd. Her neighbor Shri Vinod Sharma called her and informed her that in view of the electricity problem in the area, he and the other persons had come to make a complaint to Shri Narender Nath, the Petitioner here, who at that point of time was the Minister of Power & Education in the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi and Shri Sharma informed Respondent No.2 that the Petitioner had, instead of making arrangements for restoration of electricity, called the police. It is then stated that when Respondent No.2 went to the spot, the Petitioner here taunted and insulted her in the presence of the crowd and by stating that she was trying to portray herself as a leader, he exhorted the DCP to beat her up. It is then stated that at the instance of Shri Manoj Kumar, the DCP and Shri R.K. Sharma, the Additional DCP, Shri Ashok Tyagi the SHO tried to catch hold of her. It is stated that when the Petitioner here explained that she was a practising lawyer and that being a lady some women constable should be called, the Petitioner is supposed to have shouted “yeh saali bohat kannoon jhaad rahi hai, iska who hall karo key yeh beijjati ke karan kuch no bol sake, phir bhi na mane toh jaan se maar do”. It is further alleged that SI Sunil Kumar abused her, gave her lathi blows, caught hold of her blouse and tried to outrage her modesty. When she tried to save herself, SI Sunil Kumar snatched her Mangal Sutra, pushed her to the ground and again gave her lathi blows. Respondent No.2 states that she was taken to the clinic of Dr. Bhardwaj. The next morning she was taken to the S.D.N. Hospital, Shahdara where an MLC was prepared and she was discharged late in the evening. Thereafter she had to obtain anticipatory bail in the FIR registered against her and on 20th August, 2001 filed her complaint.
5. It is stated that on 29th August, 2001 on the basis of the complaint of Respondent No.2, the learned MM directed registration of the case and investigation by the police under Section 156(3) CrPC. The said direction was challenged by the State and that challenge was negatived in this Court as well as in the Supreme Court. FIR No. 274 of 2002 was registered and investigated by the police. On 15th October, 2003 the Inspector SIT Section of Crime Branch, Delhi Police filed a closure report or what is called an “untraced report” in the court of the learned MM.
6. On 6th December, 2005 the learned MM took up the matter and also heard the complainant i.e. Respondent No.2. A copy of the untraced report was supplied to the complainant and her preliminary submissions were heard. Thereafter the learned MM passed an order on 6th December 2005, the relevant portion of which reads as under: “At this juncture, under the law, Complainant has three courses open to her. First is that if she is not satisfied with the investigation then she can pray for further investigation in this matter. Second option is that she can straightway argue and try to make out the case on summoning of accused. The third option is that the untraced report is kept pending on record for consideration and she may proceed with her evidence on her private complaint, initially filed by her in the court. It is submitted by the learned Counsel for Complainant is well as Complainant that they would like to lead their evidence in support of their complaint. As such as prayed now, to come up for CE on 03/01/2006. The untraced report is kept pending consideration on record. Fate of the same shall be decided alongwith arguments on summoning with the complaint.”
7. Thereafter the learned MM proceeded to record the statement of the complainant and two other witnesses. On 7th March, 2006 he passed a detailed summoning order summoning the Petitioner and two other accused for the offences under Sections 119/109 read with 114/323/352/355/120 B/34 IPC. Two other accused persons were summoned under some of these and other provisions.
8. Against the aforementioned summoning order dated 7th March, 2006 the State has filed Crl. Misc. Case No. 7031 of 2006 titled State v. Radha Yadav still which is pending in this Court and listed for 1st May, 2008. The present petition has been filed by the Petitioner challenging that very order.
9. It is submitted by Mr. Sidharth Luthra, learned Senior counsel appearing for the Petitioner that once the learned MM chose to direct registration of the case and investigation by the police under Section 156(3) CrPC he had to proceed in the matter thereafter by either dropping the action after being satisfied that there was no sufficient ground for proceeding, or taking cognizance of the offence under Section 190(1)(b) on the basis of the police report and issuing process notwithstanding the closure report or take cognizance of the offence under Section 190(1) (a) on the basis of the original complaint and proceeding to examine the complainant and his witnesses under Section 200 CrPC. He submits that the order dated 6th December, 2005 indicates that the learned MM did not choose any of these courses. Instead, he opted to keep the untraced report pending consideration. This course was not open for him to adopt. Reliance was placed upon the judgments of the Supreme Court in Gopal Das v. State of Assam AIR 1961 SC 986, Minu Kumari v. State of Bihar AIR 2006 SC 1937, Abhinandan Jha v. Dinesh Mishra AIR 1968 SC 117, H.S. Bains v. State AIR 1980 SC 1883 and Dr. Kapil Garg v. State 107(2003) DLT 228. He submits that the Petitioner would be content if the matter is remanded to the learned MM at the stage the proceedings were as on 6th December, 2005 for the learned MM to consider the closure report filed by the police and to form an opinion in the manner indicated by the Supreme Court in the aforementioned judgments.
10. Respondent No.2 appeared in person and submitted that the order of the learned MM passed on 7th March, 2006 summoning the accused persons impliedly rejected the closure report filed by the police. Although she was unable to dispute the fact that the said order does not expressly refer to the closure report, she stated that she had in fact pointed out to the learned MM that the closure report was on the face of it unacceptable since it contained numerous errors and was faulty in its analysis. However, while not disputing the fact that on 6th December, 2005 the learned MM had indeed kept the untraced report “on record pending consideration”, she submits that in light of the judgment in H. S. Bains it must be construed that the learned MM had, when he proceeded to record the evidence of the complainant and her witnesses, adopted the third course as highlighted in that judgment. She also adverted the fact that the Petitioner being a person having considerable influence was interested in delaying the matter and that he has approached this Court more than two years after the passing of the summoning order. She submitted that by remanding this case to the learned MM, the proceedings would be further delayed.
11. As regards the submission about the procedure that the learned MM was expected to follow, the law has been clearly set out by the Supreme Court in the judgments referred to. In Abhinandan Jha the Supreme Court explained what the learned MM is expected to do when a closure report is submitted by the police under Section 173 CrPC in the following passages:
12. The latest judgment in Minu Kumari also reiterates the same position. In H.S. Bains the Supreme Court explained the three options available to the learned MM in situations as the present one in the following words:
13. In light of the aforementioned law, there can be no manner of doubt that in the instant case, the learned MM could not have chosen to ignore the report submitted by the police under Section 173 CrPC after having directed the registration of the case and investigation by the police under Section 156(3) CrPC. He has to either accept the report or reject it. In case he was rejecting the report he was to give reasons before deciding to proceed further in the matter by directing recording of evidence of the complainant. Unfortunately, neither the order dated 6th December, 2005 nor the summoning order dated 7th March, 2006 reflects the consideration by the learned MM of the closure report. While the former order states that “the fate of the same shall be decided along with arguments on summoning with the complaint,” the summoning order dated 7th March, 2006 does not even make a mention of the closure report.
14. The learned MM was bound to go by the procedure outlined in the CrPC and had no other option. Whatever may be the compulsions including the possible delay that might now occur remanding the case to the learned MM and requiring him to proceed in accordance with law, this Court is of the considered view that the procedure outlined in the CrPC as explained by the Supreme Court is inviolable and cannot be allowed to be bypassed. Keeping in view the fact that the complaint has been pending since August 2001 it would be in the interests of justice to direct the time bound disposal of the proceedings by the learned MM.
15. Accordingly the orders dated 6th December, 2005 and the order dated 7th March, 2006 are hereby set aside in so far as they concern the Petitioner here. It is made clear that this order does not affect the said two orders as far as they concern the other accused persons who have been summoned. The case is now remanded to the learned MM, so far as it concerns the Petitioner, for consideration of the closure report filed by the police in accordance with law and in light of the judgments of the Supreme Court. Needless to say that complainant Respondent No.2 will be heard before any order is passed by the learned MM. Thereafter the learned MM will proceed in accordance with law and pass fresh orders within a period of three months from the date of the receipt of this order.
16. The other contentions raised by the Petitioner in this petition including the non-grant of sanction for prosecuting the Petitioner here, are left open to be agitated by the Petitioner at an appropriate stage. The petition and the application are accordingly disposed of.
17. A copy of this order be sent to the concerned learned MM within five days from today.
18. A copy of this order be given dasti to learned counsel for the parties.
S. MURALIDHAR, J.