Full Text
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 3523/2000
Date of Decision: 7th April, 2008.
M/s Mahajan Polishers ... Petitioner through: Mr. U.S. Chaudhary, Adv.
Mr. Vibhu Shankar, Adv. for the respondent/MCD
Mr. Ajay Raghav and Mr. Rajesh Mahajan, Adv. for the respondent no.4/DSIDC
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? GITA MITTAL, J(Oral)
1. By this petition the petitioner has assailed the authority of the respondent to process the petitioner's application for the purposes of allotment of an alternative industrial plot under the relocation scheme of the respondents whereby the respondents proposed to relocate eligible polluting units in an industrial area in terms of the orders of the Apex Court. The petitioner has claimed that he was running a steel utensil - 2 polishing unit in the premises located at K-107, Krishna Park Extension, new Delhi- 2008:DHC:1305 110018 since the year 1977 and on a valid factory licence granted by the MCD in this respect bearing no. 30686 CEM/WZ/AD/77/89/140 since the year 1979. According to the petitioner, the same was renewed by the factory licence department of the MCD up to the period 31st March, 1991. Inasmuch as thereafter, even upon making an application with the MCD for renewal, the licence was not being renewed by the MCD, the petitioner made an application on 28th March, 1996 for allotment of an alternative industrial plot to the respondents in lieu of non-renewal of the license and to renew the license till the alternative plot is allotted. No communication or allotment was informed to the petitioner. However vide a letter dated 5.5.2000, he learnt that the respondent no. 3 had not accepted the petitioner's application no. 33153 for allotment of an industrial plot under the 'relocation scheme' for the reason, among others, that the petitioner was not possessing a valid municipal corporation licence up to 1995. The submission of the petitioner is that the petitioner had applied for renewal of the licence granted to him, however the same was not being renewed by the MCD. Consequently, the petitioner prayed that his application be granted and the decision taken by the respondents be reviewed. However, the same did not result in any favourable action. Thereafter, on 5th of July, 2000 the petitioner was informed through a news - 3 article in the 'Times of India' that allotment of plots under the Relocation Scheme to the eligible water polluting units would be done though a draw of lots to 60 held on 8th July, 2000. However, upon visiting the concerned office, the petitioner was surprised to note that its unit was not included in the list of eligible units. The petitioner has consequently filed the present writ petition seeking setting aside of the rejection and directions to include the name of the petitioner in the list of eligible water polluting units for the purposes of allotment of the industrial plot under the said relocation scheme.
2. The respondents have opposed the writ petition primarily on the ground that the rejection of the petitioner's application is not on the sole ground that he did not possess a valid industrial licence but on the ground that the petitioner failed to submit any evidence in terms of the guidelines of the respondents which could evidence the fact that the petitioner was running a polluting industrial unit prior to 19th April, 1996 which would have entitle him to allotment of an alternative plot. The respondent nos. 1 and 2 have further submitted that the respondents had decided to give another hearing to the petitioner and for this reason the petitioner had been requested by the letter dated 16th November, 2000 to file the required documents on 30th November, 2000. However upon repeated requests of the petitioner, the hearing before the Appellate Committee was adjourned - 4 from 11th April, 2001 to 30th May, 2001 but the petitioner failed to appear before the Appeal committee on the said date. In the interest of justice, another opportunity was given for producing the requisite record and the next date of hearing the case was fixed on 11th July, 2001. Inspite of ample opportunity given to the petitioner for submitting the requisite documents to prove that the unit of the applicant was in existence prior to 19th April, 1996, the petitioner failed to submit the same on 11th July, 2001. In these circumstances, the allotment of the industrial plot to the petitioner was rejected.
3. The respondents have drawn my attention to the communication dated 18th July, 2000 made by the petitioner requesting the respondents to review its decision and seeking allotment of the alternative plot. It has been pointed out that in support of his contention that the petitioner was conducting his business at the subject premises from 1979, the petitioner had placed before the respondents not only the correspondence exchanged with the Municipal Corporation of Delhi requesting renewal of the licence but also records of the income tax returns filed by the petitioner during the period 1st April, 1995 to 31st March, 1996 as well as thereafter. Copy of these returns have been placed before this court. The petitioner has also placed before this court the photocopies of electricity bills issued by the Delhi Electricity Supply Undertaking towards electricity consumption - 5 between the period 6th October, 1996 till June, 1996 and even thereafter. Reliance has been placed also on a certificate dated 18th May, 2001 purporting to have been issued by an official of the Delhi Vidyut Board certifying that an electricity connection bearing
4. During the course of hearing, this court had required the respondents to produce the record of the case. The same has been perused and inspection thereof has been permitted to the petitioner. It is an admitted fact, that such documents were submitted by the petitioner alongwith his representation dated 18th July, 2000 and are available on the records. The petitioner has also placed the income tax returns commencing for the financial year 1992-93 till 1995-96 on record.
5. In view of the stand which has been taken in the counter affidavit, it is apparent that these documents which were certainly relevant in the context of the guidelines framed by the respondent towards consideration of the application for allotment of an alternative plot have not been considered by the respondents while considering eligibility of the petitioner. Certainly such documents had a bearing on the matter. Such - 6 material records were not considered even by the Appeals Committee of the respondents. In this view of the matter, these documents would support the petitioner's contention and would manifest that the business was being run by the petitioner in the subject premises. It is also an admitted fact, that documents in the nature of income tax returns and electricity bills have not been taken into consideration by the respondents while considering the applications for allotment of alternative plots. It would therefore appear that the petitioner's application has been wrongfully rejected.
6. In this view of the matter this writ petition is allowed. The order rejecting the petitioner's application for allotment of industrial plot/flat in the relocation scheme of the respondents is hereby set aside and quashed. Accordingly, the respondents shall consider the matter and make appropriate orders on a consideration of the documents on the petitioner's application for allotting a plot within a period of six weeks from today. The writ petition is allowed in the above terms. Dasti to parties.
(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE April 07, 2008 kr