Turnkey Software Projects Ltd. v. Compare Infobase Ltd.

Delhi High Court · 07 Apr 2008 · 2008:DHC:1302
Vipin Sanghi
Company Jurisdiction CP Nos. 27 & 28 of 2008
2008:DHC:1302
corporate appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court sanctioned the Scheme of Amalgamation between Turnkey Software Projects Ltd. and Compare Infobase Ltd. under Sections 391 and 394 of the Companies Act, 1956, rejecting objections regarding procedural compliance and ordering dissolution of the Transferor company from the appointed date.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
COMPANY JURISDICTION CP Nos. 27 & 28 of 2008
DATED 07.04.2008 In the matter of the Companies Act, 1956:
Scheme of Amalgamation of:
Turnkey Software Projects Ltd. ... Petitioner/Transferor
Company
WITH
Compare Infobase Ltd. ... Petitioner/Transferee
Company
Through : Mr. Ashish Makhija with Ms. Pratibha Shukla, Ms. Shweta KumariAdvocates, Ms. Manisha Tyagi, for the O.L
Mr. R.D. Kashyap, Dy. RoC VIPIN SANGHI, J. (ORAL)
JUDGMENT

1. These are two petitions under Sections 391 and 394 of the Companies Act, 1956 seeking sanction of the Scheme of Amalgamation between Turnkey Software Projects Ltd. (Petitioner/Transferor company) and Compare Infobase Ltd. (Petitioner/Transferee company). C.P.Nos27 & 28 of 2008 are filed by the Transferor and Transferee Company respectively.

2. The registered offices of both the Transferor and Transferee companies are situated at C-62, Janak Cinema Complex, Janak Puri, New Delhi - 110058, that is, within the jurisdiction of this Court.

3. The Transferor company was incorporated on 2008:DHC:1302 06.03.1992. The authorized share capital of the Transferor company is Rs.15 lacs divided into 1.[5] lacs equity shares of Rs.10/- each. The issued, subscribed and paid up equity share capital of the Transferor company is Rs.9,00,200/- divided into 90,020 equity shares of Rs.10/each.

4. The Transferee company was incorporated on 27.08.1998. The authorized share capital of the Transferee company as on 31.03.2007 was Rs.[6] crores divided into 60 lacs equity shares of Rs.10/- each. The issued, subscribed and paid-up equity share capital of the Transferee company was Rs.3,87,37,000/- divided into 37,08,000 equity shares of Rs.10/- each fully paid up and 8,28,500 equity shares of Rs.10/- each of which Rs.2/- is paid up. Thereafter the authorized share capital of the Transferee Company stands increased to Rs.[8] crores divided into 80lacs Equity shares of Rs.10/- each, while, the present issued, subscribed and paid up capital of the Transferee Company is Rs.5,92,37,000/- divided into 57,58,000 equity shares of Rs.10/- each fully paid up and 8,28,500 equity shares of Rs.10/- each of which Rs.2/- is paid up.

5. The Transferor and the Transferee companies had filed the Company Application (M) Nos. 150-151/2007, respectively, which were allowed by order dated 24th October, 2007. By the aforesaid order, the requirement of conducting statutory meetings of equity shareholders and secured creditors of the Transferor company and meeting of equity shareholders of the Transferee Company were dispensed with. However, the Court directed the statutory meeting of and unsecured creditors of the Transferee Company, to be held. The court directed the meeting of the unsecured creditors of the Transferor company to be held on 22nd December 2007, at 11 am, at C-62, Janak Cinema Complex, Janak Puri, New Delhi–110058, for the purpose of considering and, if thought fit, approving the said Scheme of Amalgamation.

6. Mr. Kirti Uppal, Advocate and Mr. Mukesh Anand, Advocate were appointed as the Chairperson and the Alternate Chairperson respectively of the meeting of unsecured creditors of the Transferor company. The required quorum was fixed as 8 unsecured creditors in number and 20% in value of the total unsecured debt. The Chairperson of the said meeting, in his report dated January 3, 2008, has reported that 9 unsecured creditors, entitled together to Rs.30,83,723/- in value of the unsecured debt, attended the meeting, either in person or through their representatives and proxy, thus satisfying the required quorum. The said Scheme was approved unanimously. The copy of the Chairperson's report has been filed on record.

7. The Court directed the meeting of the unsecured creditors of the Transferee company to be held on 22nd December 2007, at 12.00 noon, at C-62, Janak Cinema Complex, Janak Puri, New Delhi – 110058, for the purpose of considering and, if thought fit, approving the said Scheme of Amalgamation.

8. Mr. Sidhart Mridul, Advocate and Mr. Bobby Lau, Advocate were appointed as the Chairperson and the Alternate Chairperson respectively of the meeting of unsecured creditors of the Transferee company. The required quorum was fixed as 20 unsecured creditors in number and 25% in value of the total unsecured debt. The Alternate Chairperson of the said meeting, in his report dated January 3, 2008, has reported that 30 unsecured creditors, entitled together to 10.42% in value of the unsecured debt, attended the meeting, either in person or through their representatives and proxy, as the required quorum with regard to “value” was not present, thus the meeting was adjourned by half an hour and then the persons present and voting constituted the required quorum. The said Scheme was approved unanimously. The copy of the Alternate Chairperson report has been filed on record.

9. The Court directed the meeting of the secured creditors of the Transferee company to be held on 22nd December 2007, at

11.30 am, at C-62, Janak Cinema Complex, Janak Puri, New Delhi – 110058, for the purpose of considering and, if thought fit, approving the said Scheme of Amalgamation.

10. Ms. Namita Chaudhary, Advocate and Mr. Gagan Nagpal were appointed as the Chairperson and the Alternate Chairperson respectively of the meeting of secured creditors of the Transferee company. The required quorum was fixed as 2 secured creditors in number and 15% in value of the total secured debt. The Chairperson of the said meeting, in her report dated January 3, 2008, has reported that 3 secured creditors, entitled together to 100% in value of the secured debt, thus satisfying the required quorum.

11. Vide order dated 25th January 2008, citations were directed to be published in “The Statesman” (English edition) and “Veer Arjun” (Hindi edition), in terms of Companies (Court) Rules,

1959. An affidavit dated 16th February 2008 has been filed by Mr. Sharad Poddar, Director of the petitioner companies about the publication of the citations in “The Statesman” (English) and “Veer Arjun” (Hindi) on 8th February 2008. The said publication containing the said citations were also produced along with the affidavit.

12. Notices were issued to the OL and the Regional Director (Northern Region) vide order dated 25th January 2008. Pursuant to the notice issued to the OL, a report dated 7th March 2008 has been filed by the Official Liquidator. The Official Liquidator has stated that he has sought information from the petitioner companies vide its letter no. OL/TECH/AMAL/115/492 dated 18th February 2008, upon which the requisite information was furnished by the petitioner companies.

13. The OL has stated that he has considered the accounts of petitioner companies as on 31st March 2007. The OL in its report has stated that he has not received any complaint against the Scheme of Amalgamation from any person/parties interested in the scheme in any manner whatsoever, and on the basis of information submitted by the petitioner companies. Thus it was inferred that the affairs of the petitioner companies do not appear to have been conducted in a manner prejudicial to the interest of the members, creditors, or public interest, and is well in accordance with the provisions of Section 394(1) of the Companies Act, 1956.

12,520 characters total

14. The report has been filed by Shri Dhan Raj, Regional Director (Northern Region) by an affidavit, dated 10th March 2008. Relying on Clause 9(a) of Part-III of the Scheme of Amalgamation, it was submitted that all the employees of the Transferor company shall become the employees of the Transferee company without any break or interruption in their services upon the sanctioning of the said Scheme of Amalgamation.

15. The Regional Director further submitted that on perusal of the Scheme, he did not find any mention of whether the petitioner companies have complied with the Accounting Standard-14 (Accounting for Amalgamation), issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. The Counsel for the petitioner submits that it is legally required for the petitioner to follow Accounting Standard 14 and that petitioners shall comply with the requirement of the law. Thus the objection of the Regional Director does not subsist.

16. The other objection is with regard to the incorporation of the main objects of the transferor company into the main objects of the memorandum of association of the transferee company post amalgamation. The Regional Director submits that the memorandum of association of a company can be amended only after following the procedure prescribed under the relevant provisions of the Companies Act namely Section 17 by passing a special resolution by the members of the company in the general meeting and filing of relevant form with the office of the Registrar of Companies. Counsel for the petitioner The requirement of passing special resolution already stands complied with, inasmuch as, the scheme has been approved by the shareholders of both the transferor and transferee company unanimously, inasmuch as, the shareholders of both these companies have given their consent to the scheme and the meetings were dispensed with. Consequently, there is no need to hold a separate meeting in terms of Section 17 of the Act. Further the notice issued to the Registrar of Companies of the scheme is sufficient compliance of Form-22.

17. In my view there is no merit in this objection of the Regional Director since the scheme, which postulates the amendment of the main objects of the transferee company has been unanimously approved by the shareholders of both the transferor and transferee companies by way of their respective consents. In CP No.120/2007, Pallavi Copper Pipes Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Narang Metal & Engineering Works Pvt. Ltd, the Court was dealing with a somewhat similar objection with regard to the change of name. Paragraphs 9 & 10 of the said order read as follows: - “9. Referring to Para 11.[2] of the Scheme, it has been pointed out by the Regional Director that consequent upon Amalgamation the Transferee Company proposes to adopt the name of the Transferor Company. This, it is stated cannot be done without following the procedure prescribed under the Companies Act, 1956. Therefore, it is prayed that direction should be given to the Transferee Company to meet with the statutory requirement as prescribed under Companies Act, 1956.

10. Responding to the above objection, the petitioner company has placed reliance upon “You Telecom India (P) Ltd. [2007] 77 SCL 161 (BOM)”, wherein the court has held that: name of the transferee company was to be changed, and, therefore, a separate compliance with section 121 in respect of the filing of necessary forms with the Registrar of the Companies was mandatory, would not survive in view of the law laid down in, “Vasant Investment Corpn. Ltd. V. Official Liquidator, Colaba Land Mill Co. Ltd. [1981] 51 Comp Cas 20” and “PMP Auto Industries Ltd. In re [1994]

80 Comp. Cas. 289 (Bom).” The furnishing of a notice of the Registrar of the scheme as sanctioned would, in any case, constitute substantial compliance with the provisions of section 21.” Notwithstanding the above, the petitioner company has undertaken to follow the procedure prescribed in the Companies Act, 1956 for changing the name of the Transferee Company to the name of the Transferor Company.

11. Having regard to the aforementioned judgment and in view of the undertaking given by the petitioner company, the change of name as proposed is allowed. Consequent upon the petitioner following the procedure as laid down under the Companies Act, 1956, for the change of name, the Registrar of Companies shall allot the proposed name to the Transferee Company.”

18. The present matter deals with change of memorandum of association. Since procedure for change of name and any change in memorandum of association is similar, thus the rationale of the aforesaid observation is applicable to the present petition as well. This objection of the Regional Director is, therefore, rejected.

19. There is no other legal impediment to sanction of the Scheme of Amalgamation which is annexed to the petition. Consequently, sanction is hereby granted to the Scheme of Amalgamation of Transferor company with the Transferee company, under Sections 391 and 394 of the Companies Act, 1956. The Petitioner Companies will comply with the statutory requirements in accordance with law. Certified copies of this order be filed with the order will not be construed as an order granting exemption from payment of stamp duty that is payable in accordance to law. Upon sanction becoming effective from the appointed date of amalgamation, that is 1st April 2007, the Transferor company shall stand dissolved without being wound up. One set of Costs of Rs.10000/- be deposited in the Common Pool Fund of the O.L.

20. The petitions are disposed of in terms of the above order. April 7, 2008 VIPIN SANGHI, aj Judge