Full Text
Date of Decision: 07.04.2008 #Const. Durg Singh .... Petitioner
! Through: Mr. D.S.Kauntae, Advocate
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?
A.K. SIKRI, J (Oral).
The petitioner who as per the averments made in the petition itself, is
Class 8th passed from Junior High School, Shera Sabla, District Mathura, applied for and was selected to the post of cook in the Central Reserve Force. He was issued appointment letter in May 1994. At the time of joining the service, the
2008:DHC:1300-DB WP(C)No.2016/2004 Page 2 petitioner had also filled Verification Roll Form in which he had to furnish various informations as asked for in the said Form. Against column no. 12 pertaining to his involvement, if any, in a case, it was specifically asked therein as to whether he had been arrested, prosecuted, kept under dentention or bound down/fined, convicted, by a Court of law for any offence etc. This column also directed that the applicant should give information, if any case is pending against him in any
Court of law. In the form filled by the applicant, the said Column No.12 was left blank.
After the petitioner joined the service the respondent had asked for his character and antecedents verification report from the District Magistrate, Mathura as the petitioner was the resident of Mathura. On 24.6.95 a report was sent by District Magistrate duly verified by two Additional DIGs, CRPF. As per this report, the petitioner was involved in a criminal case no.106/93 under Section
452 and 324 IPC. On receipt of this report the Commandant/Respondent no. 5 decided to hold an enquiry against the petitioner. A charge-sheet was served upon him and one Mr. P.V. PILLAI, Deputy Commandant was appointed as the
Enquiry Officer. As per the charge-sheet, following charges were framed against the petitioner:
WP(C)No.2016/2004 Page 3
“That the said No.951380048 Cook Durg Singh while functioning as Cook of 91 Bn committed an act of misconduct in the discharge of his duty in his capacity as a member of the
Force u/s 11(1) of CRPF Act 1949 in that he deliberately concealed the fact regarding his involvement in Criminal Case
No.106/93 u/s 452 and 324 IPC as per verification report received from the District Magistrte, Mathura, vide letter
No.392/verification/95 for getting enlistment in CRPF.”
The Enquiry Officer gave the report holding that the aforesaid charge stood proved. On the basis of the said enquiry report, the petitioner was given the penalty of removal from service vide orders dated 19.4.1996. It was followed by a formal order passed by the Commandant on 1.5.1996 stating that the petitioner’s services were terminated from 25.4.1996. The petitioner preferred appeal thereagainst which was rejected by the Appellate Authority vide orders dated 19.9.1996. He filed Revision Petition which was also dismissed. Thereafter, present petition is preferred by the petitioner challenging the impugned order of removal as well as subsequent orders passed by the Appellate Authorities and
Revisionary Authority.
Mr. Kauntae, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner made the following submissions in support of petitioner’s case:
(a) The charge sheet was served upon the petitioner under section 11(1) of the
C.R.P.F. Act,1949 and impugned order of removal from service was also
WP(C)No.2016/2004 Page 4 passed by the respondent under the same provision, namely, Section 11(1) of the Act and Rule 27 of the C.R.P.F. Rules. His submission was that under
Section 11, only minor penalty can be imposed and thus the Disciplinary
Authority had no power to impose major penalty vide the impugned orders once the proceedings were initiated against the minor penalty proceedings.
(b) That the entire charge framed against the petitioner was misconceived inasmuch as the petitioner had not suppressed any information or given false information as the column 12 in the Verification Roll Form was left blank. From this it was sought to argue that the petitioner did not even answer this question and therefore there was no question of giving false information as is clear from the fact that the column 12 in the Verification
Roll is left blank.
(c) The last submission of learned counsel for the petitioner was that the petitioner was not much educated as he was only 8th
Class passed. It was also submitted that the petitioner was involved in the said criminal case falsely and he was even acquitted by the court of law. This information was supplied by him to the Enquiry Officer when the enquiry was pending
WP(C)No.2016/2004 Page 5 but was not taken into consideration. Moreover having regard to these facts the penalty of removal is clearly disproportionate to the charge.
Ms.Maninder Acharya, learned counsel appearing for the respondent opposed the aforesaid submissions of the counsel for the petitioner, a note whereof shall be taken while dealing with these submissions.
We now proceed to discuss the aforesaid arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner seriatim.
A. Since first submission is based on Section 11 of the Act, it would be prudent to quote this provision:
“11. Minor punishments.-
(1) The Commandant or any other authority or officer as may be prescribed, may subject to any rules made under this Act, award in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal any one or more of the following punishments to any member of the Force whom he considers to be guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty, or remissness in the discharge of any duty or of other misconduct in his capacity as a member of the Force, that is to say,- (a) Reduction in rank; (b) Fine of any amount not exceeding one month’s pay and allowances;
(c) Confinement to quarters, lines or camp for a term not exceeding one month;
(d) Confinement in the quarter-guard for not more than twenty-eight days, with or without punishment drill or extra guard, fatigue or other duty; and WP(C)No.2016/2004 Page 6 (e) Removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the Force.” No doubt, heading of Section 11 is `minor punishment’. Further punishments which are stipulated in Clauses (a) to (c) are also minor punishments. However, in the body of sub-section(1) it is clearly stated that the minor punishments prescribed therein can be given in addition to suspension or dismissal. Ms.Maninder Acharya argued that under Section 11, punishment of dismissal can be given. She referred to the Division Bench judgments of this Court, taking this view, which are as follows:
1. Order dated 6.1.2003 passed in CWP No.4329 of 2000, entitled Abbas Ali Vs. Union of India & Ors.
2. Order dated 6.12.2001 passed in CWP.No.3920 of 1999 entitled Ram Bihari Shukla Vs. Union of India & Others.
3. Order dated 6.12.2001 passed in CWP.No.4958 of 2000, entitled Khushi Ram Vs. Union of India & Ors. Mr.Kauntae on the other hand relied upon the judgment of Jammu & Kashmir High Court in the case of Angrez Singh Vs. Union of India and others WP(C)No.2016/2004 Page 7 2002(6)SLR 565 and that of Gauhati High Court judgment passed in the case of Deep Chand Vs. Union of India & Ors. 2002(3)SLR 665. In view of the judgments of this Court which have taken a specific view that under Section 11 of the CRPF Act,1949, major penalty of removal or dismissal can be given, it is not necessary even to look into the judgments of the other High Courts. It is simply because of the reason that we are bound by the judgments of our own court rendered by the Co-ordinate Benches. Learned counsel for the petitioner had, however, argued that the judgment of this Court need reconsideration and from that point of view he had cited the aforesaid judgments. In this case, we are even spared with the aforesaid exercise inasmuch as the matter stands conclusively determined and the controversy is set at rest by the Apex Court’s judgment in the case of Union of India Vs. Gulam Mohd. Bhat AIR 2005 SC 4289. The interpretation given by the Supreme Court is same as given by this High Court in the aforesaid judgments which is clear from the reading of para-5 of the judgment. It reads: “5. A bare perusal of Section 11 shows that it deals with minor punishment as compared to the major punishments prescribed in the preceding section. It lays down that the Commandant or any other authority or officer, as may be prescribed, may, WP(C)No.2016/2004 Page 8 subject to any rules made under the Act, award any one or more of the punishments to any member of the force who is found guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty, or remissness in the discharge of his duty or of other misconduct in his capacity as a member of the force. According to the High Court the only punishments which can be awarded under this Section are reduction in rank, fine, confinement to quarters and removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the force. In our opinion, the interpretation is not correct, because the section says that these punishments may be awarded in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal.“ It is thus clear that major punishment could also be given to the petitioner under Section 11 of the Act.