Full Text
CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA (OS) NO. 05/2008
Order Reserved on : 20th March, 2008
Date of Decision: 7th April, 2008 M/s.C.E. Construction Ltd. .....Appellant
Through : Mr. Arun Jaitley, Sr. Advocate, with Mr. Jayant K. Mehta, Advocate.
Through : Mr. Rajiv Endlaw, Advocate, with Mr. A.T. Patra and
Ms. Roopa Dayal, Advocates, for Respondent no.1.
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE ARUNA SURESH
JUDGMENT
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes
JUDGMENT
07-04-2008: MUKUL MUDGAL,J.
1. The Appellant has filed the present application for an ex parte ad interim order and the accompanying Appeal against the impugned judgment and order dated 4 th January, 2008 passed by the learned Single Judge of this CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 1 of 23 2008:DHC:1284-DB Hon'ble Court in Execution Petition No. 321/2003. By the impugned judgment, the learned Single Judge had dismissed the objections filed by the Appellant to the execution of the judgment and decree, which were to the effect that the judgment and decree dated 28 th March, 2003 in CS(OS) NO. 749/1994 had been obtained by playing fraud on the Hon'ble Court by the Respondent nos.[1] to 4.
2. The case of the appellant is as follows: - (a) The respondent no.1 filed a Suit bearing No. 749/1994 in this Court seeking specific performance of the Agreement to Sell dated 30 th April, 1993 in respect of Property No. S-23, Panchsheel Park, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as 'the suit property'). The Appellants were not made a party to these proceedings and the suit was contested by Respondent no.2 by filing its written statement stating that the Agreement to Sell dated 30 th April, 1993 was entered into by the respondent no.2 as the power of attorney holder of K.D. Somaia who had expired thereafter. Subsequently, an order CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 2 of 23 and decree dated 28 th March, 2003 came to be passed by a learned Single Judge of this Hon'ble Court recording the settlement between the parties as follows:- “Statement of the plaintiff as also of defendant No.6, Managing Director of defendant No.5 have been recorded. Application Ex.C-1 is signed by the plaintiff and its counsel. It is also supported by affidavit of the plaintiff. The application is also signed by defendants no.6 & 7 which is duly supported by an affidavit of defendant no.6. Mr. Arun Kathpalia on behalf of defendant No.2 to 4 has stated that the said defendants claim no interest in the property and have no objection to the suit being decreed in terms of Exh. C-1. Defendant No.1 is proceeded ex-parte vide order dated 1.5.1998. The suit is, accordingly, decreed in terms of Exhibit C-1. Exhibit C-1 shall form part of the decree. Parties will abide by terms as set out in Ex.C-1. The undertaking given by defendant No.6 on behalf of defendant No.5 to vacate and hand over possession of the entire first floor to the plaintiff within a month from today is accepted. The said defendant shall also deliver the remaining documents of title. Parties are left to bear their own costs. It is made clear that the mere factum of the decree being passed in terms of Ex.C-1 shall not tantamount to waiver or discharge from payment of any stamp duty or statutory levy.” (b) The decree dated 28 th March, 2003 was put into execution by the CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 3 of 23 respondent no.1 by way of Ex.P.No. 321/2003 for being put into possession of the first floor and by execution of the documents of title in his favour. The appellant filed objections to the execution petition claiming to be in possession of the first floor of the suit property. By way of the impugned judgment dated 4 th January, 2008, the objections of the appellant were dismissed and the appellant was directed to hand over the possession to the respondent no.1 within 30 days from 4 th January, 2008.
3. The learned Single Judge on 16 th May, 2007 framed the following issues:- “1. Whether the obstructionists acquired any right or interest in the suit property? If so, the date thereof? Onus on the obstructionsts.
2. Whether the decree in question was obtained in collusion between the parties to the suit and suffers from any fraud in turn affecting the rights of obstructionists? Onus on the obstructionists.
3. Relief.”
4. The issues were answered in negative against the appellant in the following terms:- CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 4 of 23
5. The learned Senior counsel for the appellant Mr. Arun Jaitley submitted that the suit property bearing No.23, Panchsheel Park, New Delhi had been purchased by the respondent no.2 from the amounts due and outstanding to the Appellant in the course of their contractual relationship. All the original documents in relation to the property were deposited with the appellant soon after its purchase by the respondent no.2 in 1993. By a letter dated 28 th January, 1993, the parties had agreed on a sharing arrangement and in pursuance thereof, the appellant was put in possession of the first floor and the common areas of the suit property. The appellant has continued in peaceful, uninterrupted and unhindered possession of these CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 7 of 23 areas since 1993 as demonstrated by the Report of the Local Commissioner. The respondent no.2, to further secure the interest of the appellant had also obtained a Will and General Power of Attorney from late K.D. Somaia, the original recorded owner of the property, contemporaneously i.e. in 1993 in favour of the Managing Director of the appellant. The entirety of these facts clearly proves the interest of the appellant. He further submitted that the respondent no.1 acting in collusion with the respondents no. 2 to 4 filed a suit being CS(OS) No. 749/1994 seeking specific performance of the Agreement to Sell dated 30 th April, 1993 entered into with the respondent no.2 for the sale of the suit property. The appellant was not impleaded in these proceedings and a collusive decree dated 28.3.2003 was obtained by concealing material facts and evidence from this Hon'ble Court. This decree was a clear evidence of the conspiracy of the respondents no.1 to 4 to avoid and side step the legal rights of the appellant interalia by playing a fraud on this Court. CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 8 of 23
6. The learned counsel for the respondent no.1, Mr. Rajiv Endlaw, submitted that the appellant is merely an obstructionist to a decree. Even though it was the submission of the respondent no.1 that the objection of the appellant did not even merit any trial but the respondent no.1 did not challenge the order putting the said objections to trial in view of the same having been made time bound. The appellant however, in spite of the opportunity of trial having been granted to it has failed to make out any case whatsoever. The appellant has neither pleaded nor proved any independent title to the first floor of the house and in fact, it is the case of the appellant that it came into possession of the said first floor through the judgment debtor-respondent no.2. Having been into possession through the judgment debtor-respondent no.2, the appellant derives his rights, if any, only through the judgment debtor-respondent no.2, and cannot have rights higher than the respondent no.2. He further contended that the appellant is enjoying the use and CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 9 of 23 occupation of the first floor of the house no. S-23, Panchsheel Park, New Delhi. The appellant is enjoying the said premises without paying anything and therefore the appellant for this reason only is interested in prolonging these proceedings. The objections of the appellant remained pending for more than three years due to the dilatory tactics adopted by the appellant. Even after the learned Single Judge by the order dated May 16, 2007 framed issues and directed time bound trial, the appellant did everything possible to delay the trial. The appellant sought adjournments before the Local Commissioner appointed to record evidence. The appellant moved as many as three applications for filing additional documents and examining additional witnesses. The appellant even preferred an appeal being no. EFA(OS) No. 26/2007. The learned counsel for the respondent emphasized on the delaying tactics of the appellant and the intent of the appellant to prolong his free stay in the premises.
7. We are not inclined to go into the merits of the appeal at this stage of CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 10 of 23 the proceedings and the same is subject to the final outcome of the appeal. We are, however, of the view that prima facie the learned Single Judge had rightly observed that the appellant is merely an obstructionist to the decree. The appellant had neither pleaded nor proved any independent title to the first floor of the suit property and in fact it is the case of the appellant itself that he came into possession of the said first floor of the suit property through the judgment debtor-respondent no.2. Prima facie, the appellant would be liable to go out of the premises in execution of the decree against the judgment debtor respondent no.2 and the rights, if any, of the appellant can only be claimed against the judgment debtor i.e. respondent no.2 only.
7. Prima facie, it is also pertinent to note that the appellant had come into possession of the suit property either during the pendency of the suit or thereafter when interim orders were operating against the judgment debtors 5 to 7. The original injunction order was passed on 18 th April, 1994 restraining taking over of possession by judgment debtors 6 and 7, but since CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 11 of 23 the judgment debtors 5 to 7 claimed to be in possession, the said injunction order was modified on 20 th May, 1998 to the extent that the said judgment debtors were not to part with possession or alienate the property without the leave of the court. On 25 th May, 1994, the local Commissioner appointed by the court gave his report to the effect that respondent no.2 was in possession of the entire house. The doctrine of lis pendens is applicable in the present case and in the subsequent circumstances, the claim of the appellant is subject to the ultimate decision of the pending EFA(OS) No. 5/2008.
9. In our view the respondent no.2 after contesting the suit for specific performance of the Agreement to Sell for 9 years entered into a compromise to sell the suit property to respondent no.1 on receipt of the balance consideration of Rs.1.80 crores and to execute the Sale Deed and put respondent no.1 into possession of the house. The respondent no.1 paid the balance consideration of Rs.1.80 crores in accordance with the terms of the compromise in March 2003 and the decree was passed on 28 th March, 2003 CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 12 of 23 in terms of Exhibit C-1 as mentioned herein above. Thus, it is to be noticed that the legal proceedings in this matter has been pending for the last 18 years and the respondent no.1 has been deprived of the possession of the house for which he had paid Rs.60 lacs as far back as on 30 th April, 1993 and the balance of Rs.1.80 crores in accordance with the terms of the compromise decree in March 2003. Pursuant to the order dated 5 th February, 2008 the respondent no.1 made the valuation of the letting value of the premises in question to be not less than Rs.1,25,000/- with effect from 2003 and not less than Rs.1,70,000/- with effect from 2005 and not less than Rs.2,20,000/- with effect from 2006. Since the appellant is admittedly in physical possession since at least March 2003, we do not think that at this interim stage during the pendency of this appeal, it is necessary to disturb the appellant's possession and accept the respondent's suggestion that the property be handed over to them upon payment of the current rate of Rs.2,20,000/- per month. CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 13 of 23
10. In view of the above discussion, this application for stay of the impugned order dated 4 th January, 2008 passed by the learned Single Judge cannot be granted without ensuring that use and occupation charges pursuant to the decree dated 28 th March, 2003 are secured and the pendency of this appeal does not prejudice the parties. However, we are not deciding the issue of the legality of the possession of the appellant at this stage as it is subject to the final outcome of the appeal on merits.
11. This Court passed the following order on 5 th February, 2008: - “Caveat Appl. No. 8/2008 Since the learned counsel for the respondent has put in appearance, the caveat has been rendered infructuous and accordingly stands disposed of. CM No. 1774/2008 Exemption allowed subject to all just exceptions. CM stands disposed of accordingly. EFA (OS) No. 5/2008 and 1773/2008 Issue notice. Notice accepted by the learned counsel appearing for the respondent. Reply be filed within three weeks. Rejoinder thereto, if any, within two weeks thereafter. List on 20 th March, 2008. It is open to the parties to compute the market rent CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 14 of 23 of the damages from 28 th March, 2003 upto date and file a valuation of the market rent of the premises. The execution of the Sale Deed may go on in the meanwhile, but the status quo with respect to the possession shall be maintained by the parties till the next date of hearing.”
12. Pursuant to the order dated 5 th February, 2008, the respondent no.1 computed the market rent for the damages from 28 th March, 2003 upto date and filed the valuation of the current market rent of the premises in occupation of the appellant with effect from 2003 and calculated the market rent of the disputed premises to be not less than Rs.1,25,000/- per month and with effect from 2005 not less than Rs.1,70,000/- per month and with effect from 2006 not less than Rs.2,20,000/- per month. The appellant did not file any valuation in spite of the order of this Court. The learned counsel for the respondent no.1 had even agreed to give a deposit for the compensation to the appellant at the rate at which the valuation was computed by him, provided the possession of the property was given to him during the pendency of the appeal in this Court. We have, however, not accepted the CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 15 of 23 plea of the respondent to the effect that the possession of the property may pass to the respondents.
13. In view of the long pendency of litigation and in pursuance of the order dated 5 th February, 2008 of this Court wherein liberty was granted to the parties to compute the market rent of the damages from 28 th March, 2003 upto date and file a valuation of the market rent of the premises, we deem it necessary to ourselves compute the occupation charges payable by the appellant for the continued possession of the first floor of the suit property during the pendency of the present appeal. The position of law is settled by the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Atma Ram Properties (P) Ltd. vs. Federal Motors (P) Ltd. (2005) 1 Supreme Court Case 705, where while construing Order 41 Rule 5 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, it was held as under: -
14. Order 41 Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, reads as follows: “Stay by Appellate Court – (1) An appeal shall not operate as a stay of proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except so far as the Appellate Court may order, nor shall execution of a decree be stayed by reason only of an sufficient cause order stay of execution of such decree. [explanation – An order by the Appellate Court for the stay of execution of the decree shall be effective from the date of the communication of such order to the Court of first instance, but an affidavit sworn by the appellant, based on his personal knowledge, stating that an order for the stay of execution of the decree has been made by the Appellate Court shall, pending the receipt from the Appellate Court of the order for the stay of execution or any order to the contrary, be acted upon by the Court of first instance.]” CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 20 of 23 In light of the aforementioned position of law and as directed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Atma Ram Properties (supra) it is amply clear that the Appellate court is not bound to grant an order of stay merely because an appeal has been preferred and an application for an order of stay has been made. An applicant who comes to the court for seeking a stay order must do equity for seeking equity. While granting an order of stay under Order 41 Rule 5 of the CPC the appellate court does have the jurisdiction to put the parties seeking the stay order on such terms, as would in its opinion reasonably compensate the decree holder, for the loss occasioned by the delay in the execution of the decree by the grant of stay order. The learned Single Judge in his judgment dated 16 th May 2007 had categorically held that the appellant is not entitled to the continued possession of first floor of the suit property and must hand over possession to the decree holder within a period of 30 days as the decree holder is the CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 21 of 23 owner of the property. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, this Court before passing an order of stay deems it necessary to put the applicant on such reasonable terms as would, in our opinion, reasonably compensate the decree holder for the loss occasioned by delay in the execution of the decree by grant of the stay order, in the subsequent event of the appeal being dismissed, as the case of the decree holder respondent no.1 herein stands on a higher pedestal than a successful litigant in a Suit for eviction as the Appellant is in fact an objector/obstructionist in the proceedings for execution of the decree.
15. While admitting the appeal we direct that the appellant is, therefore, liable to deposit in this Court from the date of the decree i.e. 28 th March, 2003 a sum of Rs.50,000/- per month from April 2003 to March 2004; @ Rs.60,000/- per month from April 2004 till March 2005; @ Rs.70,000/- per month from April 2005 till March 2006; @ Rs.80,000/- per month from April 2006 till March 2007; @ Rs.90,000/- per month from April 2007 per CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 22 of 23 month till March 2008 and @ Rs.1,00,000/- per month from April 2008 until further orders. Upon the deposit of the above amount due from the appellant as mesne profits/use and occupation charges with effect from March 28, 2003 to March 27, 2008, stay of the operation of the impugned judgment dated 4 th January, 2008 shall be continued. In case there is a failure to make the above deposit within the stipulated period, the interim order shall stand vacated. The amount so deposited shall be invested in a short-term fixed deposit by the Registry of this Court which shall accrue for the benefit of the successful party in the appeal.
(MUKUL MUDGAL) JUDGE (ARUNA SURESH) JUDGE April 07, 2008 sk CM No. 1773/2008 in EFA(OS) No. 5/2008 Page No. 23 of 23