M/s Lahori Mal Anup Kumar & Co. v. Union of India

Delhi High Court · 24 Apr 2008 · 2008:DHC:1430
Pradeep Nandrajog
FAO No.267/1995
2008:DHC:1430
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court allowed the appellant's appeal, holding that the railway is liable for misdelivery despite intact wagon seals and a "said to contain" receipt, awarding compensation for the short-delivered consignment.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
FAO No.267/1995 M/s Lahori Mal Anup Kumar & Co. ........ Appellant through: Mr. M.L.Bhargava, Advocate
VERSUS
Union of India ........ Respondent through: Mr.Kumar Rajesh Singh, Advocate
RESERVED ON:
22.4.2008
Date of Decision: 24.4.2008
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Pradeep Nandrajog
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes

3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? Yes: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.

1. Since the consignment was booked on “said to contain basis”, the Railway Claims Tribunal, vide its order dated 10.7.1995 has dismissed a claim petition filed by the appellant registered as TAI.No.578/90.

2. The Tribunal has noted that the original wagon when received at the yard of destination for inspection showed that the seals were intact. It has thus been held that the FAO No.267/1995 Page No.1 of 7 2008:DHC:1430 railway authorities were not liable to recompense any money to the appellant.

3. On 29.11.1983 appellant admittedly consigned soap stone powder for delivery from Rana Pratap Nagar Station to Delhi Lahori Gate. To evidence the carriage railway receipt No.207888 was issued.

4. The railway receipt recorded loading of 378 bags of soap stone powder each weighing 50 kg. But at the place of destination 189 bags of 1 qtl. each were offered for delivery.

5. Rejecting the claim, Tribunal has noted as under:- “Thus though, the original wagon was received with seals intact, the respondent did try to see whether the consignment received was pertaining to some other party. All these facts clearly show that the consignment of 189 bags each weighing 1 quintal received in the original wagon No.NFC 15782 with seals intact was the consignment loaded by the party in the wagon.”

6. Just before recording the afore-noted finding, the learned Tribunal has noted as under:- “Since the applicant refused to take delivery of the consignment, the consignment was sent to Ambavadi, because, on a search some cloth slips stitched to the bags were found and on these slips, the name of West Coast Paper Mills, Dandali Dist. was found. The consignment remained unconnected at Ambavadi and was rebooked to the original destination station, namely Delhi Lahori Gate.”

7. A perusal of the order passed by the Tribunal shows that two facts have weighed with the Tribunal. Firstly, that FAO No.267/1995 Page No.2 of 7 the goods were consigned for delivery on “said to contain” basis i.e. loading of the goods was not witnessed by railway officers. Secondly, that the seals were intact when the consignment reached the yard of destination. Though not stated in so many words, the conclusion drawn by the Tribunal is premised on the fact that no tampering was found with the wagon during transit and hence what was received at the yard of destination was what was loaded in the wagon at the station of commencement of journey.

8. Shri M.L.Bhargava, learned counsel for the appellant urged that the Tribunal erred in not appreciating the testimony of DW-3, the witness of the railway authorities who was working as a Commercial Clerk at the relevant time. Counsel urged that testimony of DW-3 clearly established that another consignor M/s Vijay Minerals had also delivered 210 bags of soap stone powder meant for West Coast Paper Mills vide RR.No.207889 and that it was obvious that the railway authorities had delivered the consignment of the appellant to the consignee under RR.No.207889 and goods consigned vide RR.No.207889 were offered to the appellant.

9. There is prima facie merit in the submission made by Shri M.L.Bhargava, learned counsel for the appellant.

10. As noted herein above, the Tribunal has noted that FAO No.267/1995 Page No.3 of 7 on the bags containing soap stone powder which were offered for delivery to the appellant the name of West Coast Paper Mills, written on a slip, was found stitched to the bags. The Tribunal ought to have probed the matter a little further and had this been done, through the testimony of DW-3, it would have dawned on the Tribunal that M/s Vijay Minerals vide RR.No.207889 had consigned soap stone powder to West Coast Paper Mills.

11. In his testimony, DW-3 proved RR.No.207889 as Ex.DW-3/1. The said document Ex.DW-3/1 shows that M/s Vijay Minerals had entrusted 189 bags of soap stone powder weighing 189 tons. The consignee was West Coast Paper Mills. It is obvious that said 189 bags were offered for delivery to the appellant and since they were not the consignment of the appellant, the appellant rightly refused to take delivery.

12. The fact that the seals of the wagon were not tampered with, therefore, becomes irrelevant. It is a case where goods were mixed up.

8,687 characters total

13. Let me also clarify the position with respect to the legal import of a consignment being booked under “said to contain” railway receipt.

14. In my decision dated 31.1.2008 in FAO.No.212/1995 M/s Ram Kanwar Ram Niwas Vs. Union of India, in paras 36 to FAO No.267/1995 Page No.4 of 7 39, I had noted as under:-

36. In the decision reported as Union of India v Roop Narayan & Ors (1997)1 WLN 339 the core question which had arisen for consideration was whether consignment booked under a "said to contain" railway receipt, amounts to admission on the part of the railway administration, that the said number of articles had in fact were loaded.

37. In said regards the learned court noted the provisions of Rule 1513 of the Indian Commercial Railways Manual which reads as under:- "The outward tally book is an important and initial record of the actual loading of consignments and is likely to be referred when responsibility has to be fixed in the event of any package found missing at repacking and trans shipping points or at destination station".

38. After noting the afore-noted rule and other relevant provisions the learned court summed up as under:- “Upshot of the above discussion is, that if the railway receipt contains the "said to contain" remark, it does not amount to admission on the part of the Railway Administration that the said number of articles had in fact been loaded. But when responsibility has to be fixed in the event of any package found, missing at destination station, then examination of "outward tally book" and "Forwarding Note" is necessary. The learned Tribunal by a majority judgment, has rightly allowed the applications. In view of this, all the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the appellants, devoid of any force.”

39. Thus from the afore-noted discussion it is FAO No.267/1995 Page No.5 of 7 clear that when consignment is booked on “said to contain” basis the railways is not exonerated from its liability to pay compensation in respect of short delivery of loaded goods. The only effect of the endorsement “said to contain” is that the onus to prove that the quantity as claimed by consignor/consignee was actually loaded is on the consignor/consignee.

15. In the impugned order the Tribunal has noted an entry recorded in the loading tally book as follows: “No. 19. 24/11, NF 15782 CL”

16. The Tribunal failed to note Rule 1513 of the Indian Commercial Railways Manual which has been noted in para 37 of the decision in M/s Ram Kanwar Ram Niwas (supra).

17. Looked at from any angle it is obviously a case where the Tribunal has ignored material evidence i.e. Ex.DW- 3/1 as also the testimony of DW-3, a witness of the railway authorities.

18. The testimony of DW-3, Ex.DW-3/1 and the railway receipt of the appellant clearly establishes that 189 soap stone powder bags were booked by M/s Vijay Minerals for delivery to M/s West Coast Paper Mills named as the consignee and that the appellant had booked 378 bags of soap stone powder. Whereas each bag of the appellant weighed 50 kg., the bags consigned by M/s Vijay Minerals weighed 100 kg. each. The evidence on record conclusively establishes that the FAO No.267/1995 Page No.6 of 7 appellant's consignment was delivered to West Coast Paper Mills and the consignment meant to be delivered to West Coast Paper Mills was offered to the appellant. The appellant was fully justified in declining delivery of the consignment.

19. The appeal is allowed. Impugned order dated 10.7.1995 passed by the Tribunal is set aside. Claim petition filed by the appellant is allowed. The appellant is held entitled to receive from the railway authorities a sum of Rs.23000/- (Rs. Twenty Three Thousand) being the value of the consignment plus cost as also interest @ 6% per annum w.e.f. 15.12.1986 when the suit was filed till date of receipt of payment.

20. Before concluding I may note that initially a suit was filed and with the constitution of Railway Claims Tribunal the said suit was transferred to the Railway Claims Tribunal for decision.

21. The appellant is also held entitled to costs in the instant appeal in sum of Rs.2,000/-.

22. TCR be returned. April 24, 2008 (PRADEEP NANDRAJOG) pu JUDGE FAO No.267/1995 Page No.7 of 7