Sunil Gupta v. The Director of Revenue Intelligence & Anr.

Delhi High Court · 21 May 2012 · 2008:DHC:3503
H. R. Malhotra; M. L. Mehta
Bail Application No.703/2008
2008:DHC:3503
criminal appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court granted anticipatory bail to the petitioner accused of customs duty evasion due to lack of cogent evidence and later modified bail conditions following the offence's declaration as bailable by the Supreme Court.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Bail Application No.703/2008
Date of Decision: April 10. 2008 SUNIL GUPTA Petitioner
Through: Mr.S.S.Gandhi,SrAdv.with Mr.Vineet Malhotra, Advocate.
VERSUS
THE DIRECTOR OF REVENUE INTELLIGENCE & ANR. Respondents
Through: Mr. Mohan Parasaran, ASG with Mr.Satish Aggarwala, Ms.Pooja
Bhaskar and Mr.Shirish Aggarwal ,Advocates.
CORAM
HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE H.R. MALHOTRA
JUDGMENT

1. Whether the Reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporters of not? V

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? H.R. MALHOTRA./.

I. Petitioner seeks anticipatory bail as he apprehends arrest by the Directorate Revenue Intelligence-customs officials for commission of offence punishable under Section 135 of the Customs Act.

2. It is the case of the Directorate that on receipt of specific intelligence that certain importers had been indulging 2008:DHC:3503 in import of electronic goods by mis-declaration, the officials of the Directorates inteiligence examined the records of five companies, viz, M/s. Nirvana Trading Co.Deihi, M/s. Amry Trading Co.Pvt. Ltd. Deihi, M/s Gracia Internationai, Delhi, M/s.R.B.Enterprises, Navi Mumbai and M/s.Aar Jay Trading Company which revealed that these firms had misdeclared in terms of description, quantity and value to the tune of Rs.[3] crores but declared their consignments giving their values as Rs.7.07 lakhs only and that those consignments belonged to the firms owned by the petitioner. According to the Directorate the petitioner appears to the king pin who is involved in import of the electronic goods by misdeclaration in the name of the above said firms at Air Cargo Complex, Sahar, Mumbai and also seems to be the person controlling the activities of the aforesaid firms and the major beneficiary of such firms. According to the respondent, custodial interrogation is necessary to unearth the racket and reach the truth.

3. It is further the case of the Directorate that pursuant to receipt of such information one Rajaram Yadav and Ajay Sharma were arrested. Rajaram Yadav stated in his statement recorded under Section 108 of Custom Act that he was looking r import consignment of the above said firms and above said firms beionged to the petitioner.

4. On the other hand, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner urged that no sufficient evidence is available with the investigators to connect the petitioner with the aforesaid firms as according to him the petitioner has absolutely no concern with such firms. He urged that Ajay Sharma, coaccused in this case had been importing goods in the name of these firms and he admitted also while his statement was recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act where he categorically admitted that such goods were imported by him and he was prepared to pay the custom duty including penalty. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner further stated that Ajay Sharma has since been released on bail by the court of Sessions.

5. To meet the arguments of learned counsel for the petitioner, learned Additional Solicitor General urged that statement of the Rajaram Yadav was recorded under Section 108 of the Act where he categorically admitted that the consignment belonged to the petitioner. r

6. To repudiate such arguments, learned counsel for the petitioner referred to the application seeking judicial remand of co-accused Rajaram Yadav where the department Itself stated that Rajaram Yadav though admitted that he had financed the duty payment but he had not disclosed the details of the actual ^ persons who are Involved In the Import ofthe said goods by mlsdeclaratlon and therefore, according:to the petitioner. It does not lie In the mouth of the respondent to say that petitioner owned these firms.

7. My attention has also been drawn to the ball application made by the Ajay Sharma where In para 7 of the application It was stated that he had shown willingness to pay customs duty as applicable In the said five companies. He further took me to para 12 of the application where Ajay Sharma stated that he came Into contact with the foreign supplier for placing the orders for the Import In the above mentioned five firms which are In accordance with law and In case some other goods have come due to some mistake, Ajay Sharma was willing to pay customs duty as applicable. ■\

8 Learned senior counsel for the petitioner on the strength of rennand application and piso on the basis of bail application of accused Ajay Sharma submitted that the aforesaid firms did not belong to the petitioner at all and, therefore, evasion, if any, by these firms cannot be taken as evasion by the petitioner.

9. Learned Additional Solicitor General of India assisted by Mr.Satish Aggarwala to refute the arguments of learned counsel for the petitioner urged that there is ample material on record to connect the petitioner with commission of crime as during investigation it came to the notice of the department that the said firms belonged to the petitioner and on scrutiny of the petitioner's statement of account with the Standard Chartered Bank it was revealed that in the year 2005 a cheque was obtained for a sum of Rs.[2] lacs and it vyas noticed that such cheque was issued in favour of M/s.SKD Shipping Agency and on enquiry it was found that they had received the said payment i' towards Customs clearance of M/s.Rahul Industries, a proprietary firm of the petitioner.

10. I have heard learned senior counsel for the petitioner and also learned Additional Solicitor General of India. In order to bring the petitioner in the net of evasion of custom duty. investigators must show some cogent evidence to connect the petitioner with evasion of duty of electronic goods imported by his firms. Except the statement of Rajaram Yadav there is hardly any evidence on record as on date from where it could be gathered that the aforesaid five firms belong to the petitioner. Even if the statement of Rajaram Yadav is presumed to be correct then too it is difficult to believe his statement as he retracted from his statement subsequently. Even otherwise, reading of the statement of Ajay Sharma co-accused and also averments made in his bail application. It is manifest that it was he who was responsible for import of electronic goods and it was he who volunteered to pay duty. Ajay Sharma did not state anywhere if these five firms ever owned by the petitioner. More so, the reply of the respondent does not say with certainty that the present petitioner is responsible for evasion of duty. Reply is evasive as everywhere in the reply, respondent used the terminology that the petitioner seems to be the king pin and seems to have evaded the duty. If at all, respondents were in possession of sufficient evidence then they should have said with certainty that it was the petitioner and petitioner only who was responsible for evasion of duty. X V

11. True, investigation is yet on but it is not a case where custodial interrogation shail be essentiai as the entire case is based on documentary evidence and the petitioner can be subjected to interrogation without being given custody to the respondent, therefore, it is a fit case where petitioner is entitled to anticipatory bail.

12. Accordingly, the petitioner is admitted to anticipatory baii. In the event of his arrest he shali be released on bail on his furnishing a personai bond in the sum of Rs.50,000/- with one surety in the iike amount to the satisfaction of the Arresting I Officer.

10,260 characters total

13. However,the petitioner shall join investigation as and when desired by the investigators and cooperate fuily with investigators and also shall not leave India without prior permission of the court and he shaii aiso surrender his passport (3^ if not yet surrender. Dasti. [H.R. MALHOTRA] APRIL 11,2008 JUDGE ps rr 'LL i I# 40 ^1'-^ + BAIL APPLN.703/2008 Through: Mr.P.Sudershan,Advocate versus THEDIRECTOR OF REVENUEINTELLIGENCE& ANR...Respondent Through: Mr.Satish Aggarwal,Advocate CORAM: HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.L. MEHTA ORDER % 10.05.2012 Bail Appln.703/2008 This is a petition under Section 438 Cr.P.C.seeking anticipatory bail. The Petitioner had filed bail application seeking anticipatory bail whereby the Court vide order dated lO"" April, 2008 granted anticipatory bail on certain conditions. Out ofthose condition,one ofthe condition was thatthe Petitioner shall not leave the country without prior permission ofthis Court and will surrender his passport ifnot already surrendered. CrI. M.A.No.1273/2012 The instant application has been filed under Section 482 CPC seeking modification ofthe aforesaid order dated lO"^ April,2008. The main ground for seeking modification is that the offence alleged against the Petitioner has now been declared bailable by the Hon'ble Supreme m Court vide order dated 30 September, 2011. It is so recorded by the Supreme Court in Para 44 of the said order. The same is not disputed by the learned counselfor the Respondent. That being the factuallegal position now,the offence for which the Petitioner was granted anticipatory bail has become bailable, the order dated 8^'' April,2008 ofanticipatory bail as also all the conditions imposed therein no longer survive.It is submitted by the counsel for the Respondentthat a show-cause notice dated 5^' April,2009 relating to the evasion ofcustom duty to the tune ofRupees Seven Hundred Twelve Crore had been issued to the petitioner by the Department.That is notthe subject matter ofthe present proceedings. The Departmentis freeto have its proceedings asregard tosaid show-cause notice. In such a situation, the Petitioner would be at liberty to take appropriate remedy of seeking bail from the concerned court. Needless to say that the aforesaid order is without prejudice to the applications filed by the parties against each other in respect of the bail order as also the alleged violation of the conditions ofbail order dated lO"^ April,2008. In view ofthe above,the Respondent is directed to return to the petitioner his Passport within one week from today. Order Dasti. M.L. MEHTA,J MAY 10,2012/dk r-. $-40 + BAIL APPLN.703/2008 Through Mr.P.Sureshan,Adv.

VERSUS

THE DERECTOR OF REVENUEINTELLIGENCE & ANR. Respondent Through Mr.Satish Aggai-wala,Adv. CORAM: HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.L.MEHTA ORDER % 21.05.2012 CrI. M.A.6286/2012 This application is for clarification oforder dated 10.05.2012 for return of his passport. It is directed that Passport ofthe petitioner be returned which is lying with the original file ofthe main case atthe earliest. The application stands disposed of. Dasti. M.L.MEHTA,J MAY 21,2012 awanish