Full Text
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 987/2007
JUDGMENT
Through : Mr. Atulesh Kumar Anant, Advocate
Through : Mr. S.C. Dhanda, Advocate
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes GITA MITTAL, J
1. By this writ petition, the petitioner has assailed the entrance examination conducted by the Jawahar Lal Nehru University for admission in the M.Phil (Arts & Aesthetics) Course for the academic session 2006-07 as also the admissions effected to this course to six candidates.
2. So far as the case of the petitioner is concerned, he has submitted that he was a student of the school of arts of the respondent no. 1 and has completed his M.A. in Arts and Aesthetics from the JNU. Consequently, the petitioner applied and appeared in the entrance examination held on 15th May, 2006 for admission to the M.Phil (Arts & Aesthetics) course in film studies. He cleared the written examination and on 17th July, 2006 appeared in the viva examination. The final result of the examination was published on 25th July, 2006. However the petitioner's 2008:DHC:1376 name did not appear in the select list of candidates for admissions to the course. Thereafter the petitioner sought information in exercise of his rights under the Right to Information Act, 2005. On 14th August, 2006 the petitioner asked for figures whereupon he was informed of the marks secured by him.
3. The petitioner has pleaded that he is the victim of corruption, favouritism and illegal acts on the part of the respondents. The submission is that for the reason that he belongs to the scheduled castes category, the petitioner was deliberately given low marks i.e. 30 out of 70 marks in the written examination and 2 out of 30 marks in the viva examination resulting in his non-selection. The petitioner has submitted a representation to the SC/ST Cell of the said university and has contended that even the students organisation of JNU had raised the issue.
4. On 13th December, 2006, the petitioner received information in answer to his query dated 15th November, 2006 under the Right to Information Act, 2005, that out of a total of 21 students selected in the M.Phil (Arts & Aesthetics) course, four students were not eligible as they had not studied arts and aesthetics as their subjects in their M.A curriculum. A representation in this behalf was also given by the petitioner to the Vice-Chancellor on 5th January, 2007, however being dissatisfied by the actions of the respondents, necessitated the filing of the present petition.
5. I have to heard learned counsel for parstis and considered the available record.
6. So far as the eligibility is concerned, it is necessary to consider the scheme of the curriculum and the intendment of the courses conducted by the Jawahar Lal Nehru University.
7. The Jawahar Lal Nehru University, being a central university is running specialised courses including several courses which are not taught in other universities. Inasmuch as the instant case is related to the M.Phil course in the Arts & Aesthetics, it is necessary to consider the scheme of the education provided by the respondents in this course. The prospectus issued by the university for the academic session 2006-07 provides information to the candidates seeking admission to the course which is conducted by the school of Arts & Aesthetics of the university. It informs that this school is devoted to studies in history, aesthetics and critical theory of the arts from a multidisciplinary perspective and provides a unique opportunity to the students for the integrated study of the visual and performative arts of India which have been deeply interrelated in thier historical context, literary concerns and aesthetics philosophy. While the school's focus is on the range of art practices in India, the theoretical framework used for teaching also covers the western theoretical developments and refers to relevant aesthetics discourses formulated in other important cultural systems. The subjects into which the course is divided are taught by eminent scholars and teachers specialising in different arts and realted areas like anthropology, history, media and cultural studies. The courses are basically theory and history oriented but the emphasis on creativity is never lost sight of and students are encouraged to evolve their own ideas in the context of actual exposure to art works. Exposure to archival material and studio-based interactions are given pride of place in the teaching agenda.
8. The university points out, that the Jawahar Lal Nehru University is the only institution in India conducting the courses in arts and aesthetics and no other institution in India has a similar course. It is pointed out by Mr. S.C. Dhanda, learned counsel for the respondent, that the university is a central university running specialised courses which are not normally taught in other universities and its courses are designed to cater to students from not only all over India but also abroad. The respondents have compared this university to the well known Horvard university of the United States of America. The courses in arts and aesthetics are such courses which have been designed with a wide perspective and, it is pointed out, have nothing to do with the performing arts.
9. In this background, the respondents point out that if the eligibility for undertaking the course of M.Phil in Arts and Aesthetics was restricted only to students who had pursued only Arts and Aesthetics in the masters programme, it would mean that the admissions to the M.Phil programme would be restricted only to students of the Jawahar Lal Nehru University which would be opposite to the basic spirit of the university.
10. The counter affidavit explains, that the course of Arts and Aesthetics is not restricted to teachings about the performing or visual arts alone but is related to the study of the history of arts, anthropology, media and other allied cultural studies. For this reason, the submission is that students coming from different streams of arts including history, anthropology, media and other allied cultural studies would be equally well equipped to undertake the course. It is in the background of its academic experties and wisdom, that the university decided that students coming from all streams of art subjects were eligible for admission to the course.
11. The prospectus issued by the respondents has indicated that the school of Arts and Aesthetics had proposed to start the M.Phil programme in Arts and Aesthetics only from the academic session 2006-07 subject to clearance by the academic Council of the University and that the research and training could be undertaken in the broad areas of arts and aesthetics.
12. So far as the M.Phil in Arts and Aesthetics was concerned, the prospectus has specified that in order to be eligible for admission to the course, the candidate was required to possess a “Masters degree in any branch of Arts and Aesthetics with at least 50% marks”. The respondents have explained that the expression 'any branch' preceding the words 'Arts and Aesthetics' clearly indicates the spirit and intendment of the eligibility condition and that the eligibility was not restricted to candidates who possessed a master's degree only in arts and aesthetics.
13. The respondents have also detailed the admission policy of the university which is stated to be guided by the proof that the respondents endeavour is to admit students with academic competence and potentiality of high quality so that its alumni are enabled to play an effective role in the process of national construction and social change in a meaningful manner. Emphasis is given on maintenance of an all India character of the university by having on its rolls such representative of all regions of the country, especially the backward areas. Efforts are undertaken to ensure that an adequate number of students from the under-privileged and socially handicapped sections of society are admitted to the university. Towards these ends, the admission process is such that there is no scope of favouritism at all.
14. To support the fairness in the admission process, it is pointed out that the entrance examination is conducted on an All India basis in 70 centres. Answer scripts of all candidates, which are received, are shuffled and awarded computer generated code numbers after removing all details and particulars of the candidates in the nature of their names, registration numbers, the centre of entrance examination etc. As such, the evaluating faculty have no knowledge about the identity of the candidates. Marks are awarded only on coded answer sheets based on the merit in the written examination. Candidates called for the viva voce examinationa re about three times the number of available seats available in each programme of study. The members of the viva voce board are not aware of the marks secured by the candidate in the written examination. The board conducting the viva voce collectively award marks strictly based on the performance of the candidates. The respondents have pointed out that the viva voce board comprises of eight teachers of their school of Arts and Aesthetics of the respondents.
15. The respondents have also explained the scheme of the viva voce. Each candidte seeking admission is required to submit a paper which is in the nature of a proposal giving details by him about the research he intends to carry out if granted admission. He then answers questions about this proposal which are put to him by the board and is required to defend the same as well as such concepts as are mentioned in the research proposal. It is only thereafter, that the marks are awarded by the board collectively. There is thus no scope of any favouritism or arbitrariness in the manner in which the viva voce is conducted or marks are awarded. Such marks are then sent to the admission branch which are merged by the computer with the written marks obtained by the candidates. The merit list which is prepared by the branch is prepared only on the basis of the secret code number. Such coded merit list is put for approval on the basis of the prescribed procedure. It is only thereafter, that the same is decoded and the names of the candidtes are revealed. The explanation rendered by the respondent university which is the expert body in the field of education cannot thus be faulted on any legally or factually tenable grounds.
16. Clearly such an exercise is an objective and mature exercise in which there is no discernible room for favouritism. Perusal of the mark list as placed on record by the petitioner would show that there are several candidates who have secured high scores in the written examination but have been awarded barely one or two marks in their viva voce examination. In the genral category, there are candidates who have secured 38 and 36 marks in the written examination but secured such low scores in the viva voce. The result of the candidates in the scheduled caste category shows that a student who had been selected for admission had secured 44 marks in the written examination whereas he could secure only two marks in the viva voce examination. As against this, there are candidates in the schedule caste category, who have secured 30 and 27 marks out of 70 in the written examination and secured 18 and 16 marks respectively in their viva voce.
17. The display of the marks secured by the candidates clearly manifests the fairness of the system and I have no hesitation in rejecting the challenge laid by the petitioner on allegations of favouritism or bias. The petitioner is himself admittedly a product of the school of Arts and Aesthetics of the Jawahar Lal Nehru University. He has not been able to point out a single instance even remotely suggesting discrimination or prejudice against him. The respondents have on the other hand pointed out that the petitioner was an average student even in his master's course and had not secured high score nor had any exceptional academic achievement.
18. In an earlier writ petition being W.P.(C) No. 8043/2002 filed by one Pawan Kumar against the Jawahar Lal University & Ors., the admission procedure adopted by the Jawahar Lal Nehru University was assailed. The observations of the court in the judgment dated 31st January, 2003 in this behalf which fortify the view taken deserve to be considered in extenso and reads thus:- “Admission procedure was assailed by the petitioner. I do not find any substance in the contention. I have examined the admission procedure and policy. The admission policies adopted by the Jawaharlal Nehru University have been appreciated as one of the best practices in higher education by National Institute of Education Planning & Administration, which is evident from anenxure R-2. Care is taken by the University to ensure the fairness of admission process. There is no scope for any individual to influence the results in any manner.”
19. So far as the admissions which have been effected are concerned, I find that even if the contentions of the petitioner are accepted, it has been pointed out that out of total number of candidates who were admitted, only three seats were available towards the quota of the SC/ST candidates. In the merit list, 6 SC/ST candiates qualified in the written examination. Based on the marks secured in the written and the oral examination, out of these candidates, the petitioner has appeared at serial no. 6. The respondents have pointed out that it was in strict compliance of the prescribed admission procedure that the top 3 candidates were admitted to course. As the petitioner was not entitled to admission in the order of merit, he was not granted admission.
20. So far as the contention of the petitioner that only candidates who had undertaken the master's programme in Arts and Aesthetics, could have been admitted is concerned, the petitioner contends that out of candidates who were above the petitioner in the order of merit, Sh. Dinesh Kumar was a SC/ST candidate who had not done his masters in arts and aesthetics. The respondents point out that even if the admission given to Sh. Dinesh Kumar out of the quota of three is to to be struck down, the petitioner would still not be entitled to admission for the reason that there were other SC/ST candidates who were above the petitioner. I find that one Raj Kishore Maholoya at merit no. 4 in this category of students would thus become entitled to admission. He has not assailed the admissions.
21. In any case, in view of the explanation given by the respondent, I am unable to fault either the procedure adopted by the respondent or the admissions which have been effected by the respondents for the M.Phil arts and aesthetics course in the 2006 session.
22. There are other reasons as well on which the petitioner would be disentitled to grant of any relief in the present writ petition. The prospectus and the counter affidavit of the respondents has explained that the M.Phil course is divided into four semesters. Admittedly the 4th semester concludes in April, 2008. As such no writ directing grant of admission to the petitioner can be issued at this highly belated stage.
23. It has also been pointed out, that the entrance examination which was conducted in 70 centres spreak all over India, a total of only 68 candidates had applied to take the entrance examination and 54 candidates undertook the entrance examination from all over India. The petitioner was fully aware even at the time he undertook examination that students from various streams of arts had taken the admission test as well as the oral examination. The petitioner, a student of the Arts & Aesthetics couse was well aware that such course had been commenced only recently and was only available in the JNU. Therefore the very fact that the exam was conducted in 70 centres all over the country would show that the respondents were inviting the participation of students from the Arts specialities & Aesthetics to participate in the exam. No objectiion was taken at any time. The petitioner had participated in the selection process and has challenged the same long after he failed to secure admission. Consequently in the light of the principles laid down in (1975) 3 SCC 585; (1986) (Supp) SCC 285; (1995) 3 SCC 486' (2000) SCC (L&S) 313, (2006) 6 SCC 395, the petitioner stand estopped and is dis-entitled to from raising the challenge raised in the instant writ petition. For all these reasons I find no merit in this writ petition which is hereby dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE April 11, 2008 kr