Full Text
Writ Petition (Civil) No.6835/2005
Date of Decision: 11th April, 2008 M/S M.S. BINDRA & SONS PVT. LTD.& ANR. ....Petitioners through: Mr. D.S. Narula, Adv. with
Ms. Vandana M. Bebarta, Adv & Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Adv.
1.Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the
Digest? Yes GITA MITTAL, J.
1. By this petition, the petitioners have claimed that the Punjab & Sind Bank, respondent no.1 herein, has violated the guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank of India, respondent no.2 herein under the Non-Performing Asset Scheme referred to as the NPA Scheme hereafter and has sought issuance of appropriate directions to the respondent to refund such amounts charged in excess of such scheme. WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.1 2008:DHC:1377 It is an admitted fact that the petitioners secured financial facilities from the Punjab & Sind Bank which was secured by hypothecation of the plant and machinery as well as equitable mortgage of immovable property situated at B- 54A, Greater Kailash – 1, New Delhi. On account of failure of the petitioners to comply with its contractual obligations of repayment of the final amount, the respondent no.1 filed an application for recovery of amounts before the Debut Recovery Tribunal by way of O.A. No.443/2000.
2. The parties arrived at a settlement in respect of the amounts payable by the petitioners and filed a joint application under Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts due to Banks & Financial Institutions Act, 1993. This application was filed before the Debt Recovery Tribunal on the 27th November, 2001 whereby the respondent no.1 had stated that, subject to the petitioners making payment in terms of the settlement, the bank had agreed to accept a total sum of Rs.190.29 lakhs with interest at the prime lending rate on the same with reduced balance when received by the bank on or before the 24th of October, 2002. In case the WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.2 petitioners complied with such terms, the decree would be deemed to stand satisfied. There is no dispute that the petitioner failed to make payment in terms of the settlement with the bank.
3. The petitioner has also urged that Ms. Gurbir Kaur Bindra (petitioner no.2) wife of Shri Mohinder Singh Bindra, Chairman-cum-Managing Director of the petitioner company, as guarantor had pledged her commercial flat bearing no.804, Mohandev Building, Tolstoy Market, New Delhi – 110 001 to the respondent no.1. This fact is disputed by the respondent no.1 who has urged that though Ms. Gurbir Kaur Bindra had undertaken to do so, she did not create any equitable mortgage of this commercial flat and no title deed of the commercial flat was ever deposited with the respondent no.1.
4. So far as the settlement with the respondent no.1 is concerned, it is necessary to notice the essential terms of the settlement as were accepted by the settlement committee of the respondent no.1 especially the consequences of the default based whereon the aforenoticed compromise application was filed. The same reads WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.3 as under:- “6. That you agreed to pay the additional interest at the rate of 2 per cent per annum over and above the normal agreed rate of interest with quarterly rests, in case of default in terms and conditions of the sanction and loading documents.”
5. On account of the admitted default by the petitioners, the respondent no.1 issued a notice dated 18th January, 2003 to the petitioner company and its Director under Section 13(2) of the Securitisation & Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Ordinance, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as `Ordinance') calling upon the petitioner and the respondent nos.[1] & 2 to pay an amount of Rs.9,80.23 lakhs within 60 days of the date of the issuance of the notice, failing which the bank would take measures under the provisions of Chapter III of the Ordinance.
6. In the meantime, the Reserve Bank of India announced a fresh Non-Performing Assets Scheme (hereinafter referred to as `NPAs Scheme') on 29th January, 2003. The petitioner wrote a letter dated 12th February, 2003 to the respondent no.1 offering to sell the property and also requesting for a WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.4 consideration of its request to arrive at a One Time Settlement offer under the new NPAs Scheme. The petitioner made a formal request for consideration under the new scheme and requested the respondent no.1 for a settlement thereunder. In response to its letter, the petitioners received an intimation dated 17th February, 2003 from the respondent-bank requiring it to deposit an amount of Rs.25.00 lakhs as promised by it and also intimating that the settlement proposal in the new scheme was being prepared and forwarded to the competent authority. A cheque in the sum of Rs.25.00 lakhs was consequently deposited by the petitioner on 26th February, 2003. By a further communication of 11th March, 2003, the respondent-bank informed the petitioner that the period of the earlier sanction conveyed to the petitioner had been extended in terms of the Reserve Bank of India Revised Policy under the One Time Settlement and the petitioner was requested to deposit the said amount of Rs.25.00 lakhs. This communication was followed by an another letter dated 21st March, 2003 informing the petitioner that as per the guidelines of the scheme, the settlement amount of WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.5 Rs.190.35 lakhs was required to be paid in lump sum (maximum within 15 days) or 25% as upfront amount and balance of 75% recoverable in installments together with interest at prime lending rate (on simple basis) from the date of settlement upto the date of final payment. The petitioner is stated to have made payment of the amounts in installments and finally by a letter dated 13th September, 2003, paid the balance amount of Rs.65.35 lakhs. In this behalf, three cheques in the sums of Rs.10,00,000/-, Rs.5,00,000/- & Rs.5,00,000/- stated to have been deposited in March, 2003, have been placed on record while the final account of Rs.65.35 lakhs was deposited with the covering letter dated 13th September, 2003, which states that with this payment, the entire sum of Rs.190.65 lakhs stood deposited.
7. By a letter dated 21st November, 2003, the petitioner sought details of the amount of interest outstanding for depositing the same and finally settling the account. The petitioner unconditionally and without objection, deposited an amount of Rs.40.02 lakhs purportedly demanded by the bank by its communication of 21st November, 2003. With the WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.6 deposit, a request was made also on 27th November, 2003 for release of the property papers of the B-54A, Greater Kailash – 1, New Delhi, the property given as collateral security. This request was reiterated in a communication dated 6th February, 2004 and thereafter.
8. The correspondence placed on record by the petitioners shows that no objection whatsoever was taken to the interest demand raised by the respondent no.1 and the same was paid unconditionally without objection or protest by the petitioner. It is only on the 10th March, 2004 when the petitioner for the first time complained that excess amount of Rs.35,20,710/- had been wrongly demanded from it. The submission of the petitioner was that the respondent/bank was entitled to simple interest only with effect from 21st March, 2003 when, according to them, the bank had conveyed the settlement proposal, till 13th September, 2003 and when the petitioners claim to have made the payment, and that no other amount was payable as interest. After addressing several reminders in this behalf, the present writ petition has been filed in April, 2005.
9. The writ petition has been vehemently opposed by WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.7 Mr. Palav Saxena, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent no.1 who has contended that the submissions of the petitioners are totally contrary to the record and misconceived. Reliance has been placed on the settlement arrived at between the parties before the Debt Recovery Tribunal and the communications made by the respondent no.1 to the petitioners.
10. The respondents have enclosed a copy of a letter dated 21st March, 2003 with the counter affidavit which is stated to have been addressed by the respondent no.1 to the petitioners. As per this communication, the period for the repayment of the settlement amount had been extended upto 30th June, 2003 and the petitioner was required to pay interest at the prime lending rate w.e.f. 22nd October, 2001, which was the date of intimation of the original sanction dated 28th September, 2001. Though the respondent no.1 had disputed issuance of the hand written letter dated 21st March, 2003 enclosed by the petitioner with the writ petition, however, this court had required Mr. S.S. Kalra, senior manager of the respondent no.1 to appear and recorded his statement on 20th March, 2006. An explanation WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.8 was rendered that he was the author of the hand written letters dated 11th March, 2003 and 21st March, 2003 (enclosed with the writ petition) as well as the typed letter March, 2003 (filed with the counter affidavit). He had explained that the letter dated 21st March, 2003 with the counter affidavit was dispatched on instructions of the zonal office inasmuch as he was informed that the hand written letter dated 21st March, 2003 had not been received by the petitioners. He had further stated that the hand written letter dated 21st March, 2003 was enclosed with the typed letter dated 21st March, 2003.
11. Mr. D.S. Narula, learned counsel for the petitioners, has vehemently urged that there is a contradiction in the hand written communication dated 21st March, 2003 and the typed letter dated 21st March, 2003. It has been urged that the additions in the typed letter enclosed with the counter affidavit, to the effect that the interest was required to be paid w.e.f. the date of intimation of the original sanction i.e. 22nd October, 2001 till repayment of the amount, cannot be imposed upon the petitioner inasmuch as by the hand written communications, the petitioners were clearly told WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.9 that they were required to pay interest only w.e.f. the date of the settlement upto the date of final payment. According to learned counsel, the settlement was arrived at only on 21st March, 2003 which was the date from which the interest on the amount of Rs.1,90,35,000/- would be charged.
12. Having heard learned counsel for the parties at length and having given my considered thought to the submissions made, I find that in the instant case, upon the default by the petitioners, the respondent-bank had approached the Debt Recovery Tribunal for recovery of its dues. The parties had arrived at a settlement which was placed before the Debt Recovery Tribunal by the joint application dated 15th November, 2001 resulting in the passing of the consent decree in favour of the respondent no.1. In terms of this decree, the petitioner was required to pay the entire amount on or before the 24th October, 2002. The petitioner has admittedly defaulted in making this payment.
13. The petitioner had been requesting for extension of the repayment period in terms of the settlement arrived at before the Debt Recovery Tribunal. Such request has been clearly and unequivocally made to the respondent no.1 by WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.10 the petitioner even in the letter dated 21st January, 2003, which was to the effect that the revised guidelines for settlement were issued by the Reserve Bank of India on 29th January, 2003. This request was pending with the bank when the petitioners approached the bank by its communication of 12th February, 2003 requesting for a consideration under this scheme.
14. I find substance in the submissions made by the learned counsel for the respondent that the petitioner was strictly not covered under the revised guidelines issued on 29th January, 2003 for compromise on the settlement of the chronic Non-Performing Assets of the public sector issued by the Reserve Bank of India (Page 44). The Reserve Bank of India had clearly stipulated that these do not cover cases of willful default, fraud or malfeasance. They also stipulate that they would cover such cases on which banks had initiated action under the Securitisation & Reconstruction of Financial Assets & Enforcement of Security Interest Ordinance Act, 2002 and cases pending before the courts, DRTs & BIFR subject to consent decree being obtained therefrom. Consequently, the instant case, which relates to WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.11 a case where the matter stood concluded by consent decree and final order passed long before the revised guidelines took effect, would not be covered under the same.
15. The view which I have taken is supported by the pronouncements of the Apex Court reported at (2005) 10 SCC 265 entitled X-Calibre Knives (P) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. State Bank of India wherein the Apex Court had clearly held that the Debt Recovery Tribunal having passed an order determining the sum payable by the borrowers to the respondent-bank and issuing a recovery certificate pursuant thereto, the bank could not be required to consider the case of the appellants under the One Time Settlement Scheme of the bank evolved in accordance with the revised guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India dated 29th January, 2003.
16. It is noteworthy that the appellant before the Apex Court was placing reliance on a letter sent by the bank stating that the dues were liable for settlement under the guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India and sought intimation of the amount required to be paid by the appellant, the court observed that this letter was issued without being aware of the stage of proceedings before the WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.12 Debt Recovery Tribunal and had rejected the contention of the appellant that the guidelines could be applied to it.
17. In this behalf, reference can also be usefully made to a pronouncement of the Division Bench of this court reported at 127 (2006) DLT 488 (DB) D.K. Gupta & Anr. Vs. Oriental Bank of Commerce wherein the court held thus:- “18. In our opinion, the court should observe judicial restraint in matters relating to loan recoveries and it should not embarrass financial institutions or banks which granted loans by over activism. Stay of such recoveries has an adverse effect on the economy. When a loan is recovered, it is advanced to set up new industrial units, but if it is not recovered, new industrial units cannot be set up. Thus non-recovery holds up the industrialization of our nation, which is a top priority for our nation. Moreover, it is well known that in our country many unscrupulous businessmen borrow money from banks or financial institutions and divert it to secret accounts, and declare their unit sick. In this way scarce financial resources of the country are siphoned off. This Court cannot approve of such malpractices.
19. In our opinion, no one has a legal right to get rehabilitation. When a person has taken a loan he has to repay the same in accordance with the loan schedule as per the agreement between the parties. Rescheduling of the loan is in the sole discretion of the bank or the financial institution which granted the loan and the WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.13 Court cannot compel it to reschedule the loan. The matter regarding loan from financial corporations/banks is purely contractual and a party has to abide by the agreement which he has entered into.
20. A writ of mandamus can only be issued when there is a legal right with a party asking for the writ to compel the performance of some statutory duty. The petitioners have not been able to show that there is any statute or rule having the force of law which casts a duty on the respondent bank to accept the offer made by the petitioners to settle the dues. In fact, the matter is purely contractual. A Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court in M/s M.M. Accessories Vs. UPFC, 2002 (46) ALR 261 has discussed several Supreme Court decisions on the scope of a writ of mandamus, and has dismissed the writ petition praying for one time settlement of the loan, observing that no legal duty is cast on the respondents to grant the prayer. The ratio of the decision applies to this case with even greater force, because there has already been a settlement between the petitioner and the bank on 25.5.2000. It is not for this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution to keep on directing further settlements.”
18. The principles laid down by the Division Bench have to be applied in the instant case. On a consideration of the facts in their entirety, I find that the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner are based on misconstruction of the hand written communications dated 11th March, 2003 and 21st March, 2003 addressed by the senior manager to it. WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.14 There is no dispute that no fresh proposal for settlement was made by the petitioner in its letters of January & February, 2003. The petitioner had merely been seeking extension of time for effecting repayment in terms of the earlier settlement which was the subject matter of the decree by the Debt Recovery Tribunal. The letter dated 11th March, 2003 clearly indicates that it was a response in the context of the earlier sanction conveyed to the petitioner. It is not the petitioner's case that any sanction, other than the settlement arrived at before the Debt Recovery Tribunal, was in existence or had been given by any competent authority of the respondent- bank. The communication clearly informs the petitioner that the period of the earlier sanction had been extended in terms of the Reserve Bank of India revised policy on the One Time Settlement. The letter March, 2003 states that it was in furtherance of this communication dated 11th March, 2003 and reiterated that the petitioner was required to make payment of interest at the prime lending rate on simple basis from the date of the settlement upto the date of final payment. Read together, these letters clearly inform the petitioner that only WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.15 the period of the earlier settlement had been extended and it was required to make payment of interest upto the date of the final payment.
19. My attention has been drawn to a letter dated 10th August, 2002 wherein the petitioner had clearly requested the extension of the date for settlement of the amount by a period of six months i.e. upto 27th May, 2003.
20. It is not the petitioner's case that even the senior manager was the authority competent in the respondentbank to have accepted a settlement proposal or have sanctioned the same. These communications have only conveyed extension of the settlement. The only figure also conveyed is the amount of Rs.190.29 lakhs which was the subject matter of the settlement before the Debt Recovery Tribunal and no other.
21. So far as the typed letter dated 21st March, 2003 which has been enclosed by the respondent no.1 is concerned, I find no conflict between hand written communication dated 11th March, 2003 and 21st March, 2003 on the one hand or the letter dated 21 st March, 2003 as placed by the respondent before this court. WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.16
22. This view finds support even from the conduct of the petitioner. The petitioner was aware of its liability to pay the interest when it sought the quantification thereof arrived at by the letter dated 21st October, 2003 from the respondent no.1. On 27th November, 2003, the petitioner deposited the amount they demanded without protest and unconditionally. No objection was raised for several months thereafter.
23. This matter can be examined from yet another angle. The petitioner was admittedly at fault. It failed to abide by the financial discipline despite arriving at a solemn settlement before the Debt Recovery Tribunal and culminating in a consent decree. Having failed to abide with its commitment, legally all consequences of the default would flow against the petitioner in terms of the settlement arrived at before the Debt Recovery Tribunal. For the foregoing reasons, the petitioner was clearly outside the purview of the revised guidelines notified by the Reserve Bank of India. It was not entitled to any benefit thereunder.
24. This matter deserves to be considered from another aspect. The impact of acceptance of the contentions of the WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.17 petitioner by way of the present writ petition would be that the petitioner would be rewarded for the default inasmuch as it would have to be held that the petitioner was not required to pay any interest prior to March, 2003 despite its default. This cannot be the position having regard to the contract between the parties, the decree of the Debt Recovery Tribunal or in equity.
25. It requires to be noted that the Reserve Bank of India has also accepted the explanation rendered by the Punjab & Sind Bank on the complaint which was made by the petitioner to it. By a communication dated 29th November, 2004 to the Reserve Bank of India, the respondent no.1 has explained the above reasons and the interest demand. On 10th January, 2005 even the Reserve Bank of India accepted the explanation and closed the complaint made by the petitioner.
26. The instant case manifests the difficulties faced by the respondent no.1 in recovery of its dues from the petitioners. The petitioners had made the commitment not only by way of the contract but also in the settlement arrived at before the Debt Recovery Tribunal. Even the passing of the decree WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.18 on the commitment by the petitioner did not persuade the petitioner to make the payment in terms thereof and it compelled the defendant to initiate legal action in the Securitisation & Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Ordinance, 2002. Despite such conduct, the petitioner has invoked the extraordinary discretionary jurisdiction of this court under Article 226 of the Constitution by filing this misconceived writ petition.
27. In this regard, certain observations of the Apex Court in the pronouncement reported at 2004 (4) SCC 311 entitled Mardia Chemicals Limited Vs. UOI deserves to be considered in extenso and reads thus:- “Banks & financial institutions at present face considerable difficulties in recovery of dues from the clients and enforcement of security charged to them due to delay in the legal processes. A significant portion of the funds of banks and financial institutions is thus blocked in unproductive assets, the values of which keep deteriorating with the passage of time. Banks also incur substantial amounts of expenditure by way of legal charges which add to their overheads.”
28. The observations of the Supreme Court with regard to the inability of the banks to recover amounts advanced to WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.19 borrowers are as reproduced hereafter:- “34. It is also a fact that a large sum of amount remains unrecovered. Normal process of recovery of debts through Courts is lengthy and time consuming and is not suited for recovery of such dues. For financial assistance rendered to the industries by the financial institutions, financial liquidity is essential failing which there is a blockade of large sums of amounts creating circumstances which retard the economic progress followed by a large number of other consequent ill effects.”
29. The amount advanced by the respondent no.1 is really in the nature of public funds advanced for commercial gains to the borrowers as the petitioner. There is thus no equity in favour of the petitioner as well who has caused valuable judicial time to be expended on its challenge to the interest claim which is clearly without any merit. For this reason, the petitioner is liable to be burdened with punitive costs as well. The writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed with costs which are quantified at Rs.50,000/- which shall be paid to the respondent no.1 within a period of two weeks from today.
30. Before parting with the case, it is to be noticed that the WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.20 petitioner has also made a prayer for return of the documents. I find that the respondent no.1 was asserting its rights under the settlement which had been recorded before the Debt Recovery Tribunal which provided further consequences of the default and rendered the petitioner liable for payment of the full amount of the dues in terms of its contract. In this background, till such date the matter achieve a quietus, the respondent no.1 was justified in holding the title deeds.
31. So far as the title deeds of the commercial flats at Tolstoy Marg, New Delhi is concerned, the bank has stated that the same were never deposited by it. Other than a prayer, there is no averment in the writ petition even to indicate that such title deed was ever deposited with the petitioner bank. Consequently, there is no reason to disbelieve the clear statement on oath that the same were never deposited and are not with the respondent no.1. Therefore, no relief can be granted to the petitioner in reply to such a prayer. WP (C) No.6835/05 Page No.21
32. In view of the rejection of the petitioner's contentions and the amount demanded by the respondent no.1 having been paid, the respondent no.1 is directed that, subject to receipt of costs herein awarded, the respondents shall release the title deeds of the property no.B-54A, Greater Kailash I, New Delhi to the petitioner within a period of three weeks thereafter.
(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE April 11, 2008 aa