M/s Jai Shree Electrical Store v. UOI

Delhi High Court · 28 Apr 2008 · 2008:DHC:1466
Pradeep Nandrajog
FAO No.227/1996
2008:DHC:1466
civil appeal_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the appeal, holding that an endorsed consignee must prove payment of valuable consideration with credible evidence to maintain a claim for loss of consignment.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
FAO No.227/1996 M/s Jai Shree Electrical Store ........Appellant through: Mr. M.L.Bhargava, Advocate
VERSUS
UOI ........ Respondent through: Mr. R.C.Nangia, Advocate
RESERVED ON:
24.4.2008
Date of Decision: 28.4.2008
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Pradeep Nandrajog
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes

3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? Yes: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.

1. This appeal is directed against the order dated 12.3.1996 passed by the learned Railway Claims Tribunal, Delhi.

2. The appellant M/s. Jai Shree Electric Stores filed a claim petition against the respondent claiming a compensation of Rs.18,200/-.

3. The case set up by the appellant was that on 15.12.1989 a consignment comprising of 2 packages containing PVC wire were entrusted to the respondent for transport from Delhi to Varanasi. That the consignment was booked under Parcel Way Bill (PWB) FAO No.227/1996 Page No. 1 of 6 2008:DHC:1466 No.386827. That it was the endorsed consignee of the consignment in question. That due to gross negligence and misconduct of the employees of the respondent, the respondent failed to deliver the consignment at the destination station.

4. Defence set up by the respondent was that the appellant has no locus standi to maintain the present action for the reason appellant is neither consignor nor consignee of the consignment in question.

5. After considering evidence led by the parties in light of their versions vide impugned order dated 12.3.1996 the learned Tribunal has held that the appellant has been able to establish that it was the endorsed consignee of the consignment in question but has failed to establish that it had paid valuable consideration in respect of the consignment. It has been held that an endorsed consignee can maintain an action for damages in his own right only when he has paid valuable consideration for the consignment. That since the appellant has not established that it had paid valuable consideration for the consignment it has no right to maintain the present action. The claim application filed by the appellant was thus dismissed by the Tribunal.

6. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that he does not dispute the proposition of law applied by the Tribunal that an endorsed consignee can maintain an action for damages only when it had paid valuable consideration for the consignment. Learned counsel argued that the appellant had successfully FAO No.227/1996 Page No. 2 of 6 established by leading positive evidence that it had paid valuable consideration in respect of the consignment in question.

7. Thus the controversy in the present appeal turns on the issue whether the appellant had established that it had paid valuable consideration for the consignment in question.

8. To establish that the appellant was an endorsed consignee for a valuable consideration, the appellant examined one Mr.Raj Kumar,AW-1 who claimed to be a partner of the appellant firm. He deposed that on 15.12.89 one Mr.Kaushal Kumar who was an employee in the appellant purchased the consignment in question from M/s Poonam Electricals for a sum of Rs.18,200/-. He proved a bill as Ex.A/13 to evidence the purchase. That the payment of the consignment was made by him. That after purchasing the goods Mr.Kaushal Kumar entrusted the goods to the respondent and made endorsement on the rear of the PWB in question in favour of the appellant. (Meaning thereby, that Kaushal Kumar was the consignor and the appellant was the endorsed consignee). He stated that he had also made the entries pertaining to the payment of the consignment in the cash book and ledger book of the appellant (Relevant portions of the cash book and ledger book were produced on record).

9. Learned Tribunal disbelieved the testimony of the witness of the appellant that he had made payment for purchasing the consignment on the behalf of the appellant. It has been held that the bill dated 15.12.89, Ex.A/13, purportedly issued by the M/s FAO No.227/1996 Page No. 3 of 6 Poonam Electricals is not a genuine document evidencing the sale of goods consigned. Reasons noted by the Tribunal for so disbelieving are as under:- I The bill Ex.A/13 contains the PWB number and the weight of the consignment. This is contrary to the testimony of the witness of the appellant as he had deposed that he had first purchased the consignment and then entrusted the same to the respondent. How can a document contain the details of another document which was not in existence at the time of the preparation of a document remains a mystery? II J.S.Mal, Claims Inspector, Railways, RW-1 had deposed that he was assigned the task of investigating the genuineness of the bill Ex.A/13 and he deposed that the shop 'M/s Poonam Electricals' did not exist at the address written on the bill Ex.A/13. III No documents were produced by the appellant to establish that Mr.Kaushal Kumar was an employee in the appellant firm at the relevant time. IV Neither any employee of M/s Poonam Electricals was examined nor any documents of M/s Poonam Electricals such as accounts books etc. were summoned/produced by the appellant to establish that AW-1 had purchased the consignment from M/s Poonam Electricals on behalf of the appellant. V As per the testimony of AW-1 he had made payment of the consignment in question to M/s Poonam Electricals and was present when the bill Ex.A/13 was taken personally by him. If AW-1 FAO No.227/1996 Page No. 4 of 6 who was a partner in the appellant had made the payment and the bill was taken by him, there was no reason to mention the name of Mr.Kaushal Kumar in the bill. VI Testimony of AW-1 who is an interested witness as also self-serving account books produced by the appellant does not inspire any evidence.

10. Learned counsel for the appellant had contended that the Tribunal had committed a grave error by holding that the account books produced by the appellant are self-serving documents and thus ignoring the same.

11. It is settled law that an appellate court cannot reappreciate the evidence unless the court of first instance had ignored a material evidence/circumstance or the conclusions drawn by the court of first instance from the evidence are perverse in nature.

12. Learned counsel for the appellant has not pointed any evidence/circumstance which was ignored by the Tribunal while appreciating the evidence.

6,747 characters total

13. Conclusions drawn by the Tribunal from evidence I to V noted in para 9 above are perfectly sound. Indeed the fact that in the bill Ex.RW-1/1 the PWB No. (Parcel Way Bill) was mentioned evidences that the bill was created much after the goods were entrusted to railway authorities for only then the maker of the bill referred to PWB No. on the bill.

14. I find no infirmity in the impugned order. FAO No.227/1996 Page No. 5 of 6

15. The appeal is dismissed.

16. No costs. April 28,2008 (PRADEEP NANDRAJOG) sl JUDGE FAO No.227/1996 Page No. 6 of 6