11aff01645f8c13807b794a8fd9b96ac094b1ad24b6b9a00586dab45b8603137

Delhi High Court · 18 Apr 2009 · 2008:DHC:14344
Jiv Sahai Endlaw
Tr. P. No. 18/2008
2008:DHC:14344
civil appeal_allowed

AI Summary

The court allowed transfer of a suit to be heard along with another suit involving common parties and overlapping issues to avoid conflicting judgments and ensure judicial efficiency.

Full Text
Translation output
\A
#24
%18.04.2009
Present; Mr. Sanjiv Behl,Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr.Pravir K.Jain,Advocate for the respondent.
+Tr. P. No. 18/2008
*
Petition has been filed for transfer of Suit No. 75/2005 filed by the respondent Bank against the petitioner and pending in the Court of
Sh. Chandra Bose,ADJ,Tis Hazari, Delhi to this Court, to be tried along with CS(OS) No. 787/2004 of this Court filed by the petitioner herein f. against the respondent Bank. While in the suit filed by the respondent
\
Bank and sought to be transferred to this Court, the respondent Bank seeks to recover monies stated to have been advanced as loan to the petitioner herein together with interest thereon, in the suit pending in this Court the petitioner seeks to recover damages from the respondent
Bank for breach of an agreement to lease of the property to the respondent Bank. It is the defence of the petitioner in the suit filed by the Bank that the monies advanced were not as loan but for carrying out renovation to the premises in terms ofthe agreement to lease.
The evidence in both the suits stands concluded and both the suits are ripe for hearing.
^ The respondentBank hasfiled a replyto the transfer petition and opposed the same. It is inter alia contended that except for the parties being common in the two suits, the matter for adjudication in the two suits is entirely different. Though in the reply it was also stated thatthe
2008:DHC:14344 r Ci suits were at different stages but by now it is admitted position that both the suits are ripe for hearing, the recording of the evidence therein having been completed. It is also contended by the counsel for the respondent Bank that the application has been filed belatedly and had there been commonality in the two suits, the application would have been filed much earlier.
It is found that the issues arising for consideration in the two suits are overlapping. The claim of the petitioner in the suit pending in this
Court is the defence ofthe petitioner in the suit filed by the respondent.
^, If the two suits are allowed to be adjudicated by two courts,it may lead to conflict of judgments. Since both the suits are now ripe for final hearing,the fear of the respondent Bank of delay in disposal ofthe suit filed by it for recovery of monies can be allayed by ordering the two suits to be listed for hearing on a Thursday in the near future.
Accordingly,the transfer petition is allowed.
The suit No. 75/2005 of the Court of Sh. Chandra Bose, ADJ, Tis
Hazari,Delhi stated to be listed next on 25'^ April,2009 is ordered to be transferred to this Court to be heard along with CS(OS) No. 787/2004 pending in this Court.The file be requisitioned and be listed along with
CS(OS)No.787/2004in the same Court on 23"''July, 2009.
' TheTransferPeti^nis disposed of.
JIV SAHAI ENDLAWJ
April 18,2009 rb
J
2008:DHC:14344
JUDGMENT